Miley Cyrus on American Idol Gives Back 2008

[mileybeiber]

luv it 

[TheZorba8]

ive not heard this song in like a year

[AliceBeatrizBarros]

let´s go miley! love u!!!

[TotallyJadeable]

prefer the soundtrack version...

[DanaLAstyle]

WOW SHE IS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!

[ais12341000]

this is actually a good video

[naNAricG]

ok seriously watch this song but when shes performing @ rock in rio.... like WOW this girl grew up!!!

[117holly]

shes being milay??? why do u say it like dat???

[GlubschiixD]

on american idol she sings always good.... see you again.. then the climb... and when I look at you

[GlubschiixD]

@cadycute what?! people saying that she sings live good on american idol and on other shows she sounds terrible and then I said she sings always good on american idol...

[utterbullspit]

Miley wouldn't make it past the first stage of Idol.

[f0cusen]

@utterbullspit Dude you can't be serious? she has an amazing and powerful voice and if you are not a fan don't watch this video just to write negative stuff. Listen to her now on her gyspy heart tour singing "stay" or "landslide" her low notes are amazing.

[wersdfxcvtt]

287 people didn't wanna be seen again

[XxAshley59xX]

she sucks live -_-

[lupe7411]

From 1:02 To 1:07 MIley Has A Wedgie!! XD

[spilledthecrackers]

what the heck is she doing?

freaky

[crystalbgood]

@smashonab y is it that when someone doesnt like a singer, ppl like u think its cus they sing better than us...i cant sing for shit, but i love carrie underwood, and she sings a hell of a lot better than miley

[ItalianVampire64]

thats weird... i remember wen this was on tv i thought she did just awful! but now i think its not bad. huh. i guess tastes change. then again, i was young and stupid and preferred studio versions. thats probably why i didnt like it.

[vandaspiwak]

luv ya? miley,awesome song!!! beauiful voice:) She had great tracks, my mother am anticipating for her undebuted songs to be featured in ReciveCyrusSongs[.]tk

[sanjuanagrammont]

love this song!!!!!!!!? Miley Cyrus had great songs, I am anticipating for her unrealeased soundtracks to be featured in ReciveMCyrusMp3[dot]tk

[miaclozza]

I love this song and I agree with rebeckarocks,? I realy prefere this Miley! She has great tracks, I am anticipating for her undebuted songs to be featured in ObtainMileySongs(dot)tk

[aliasspy47]

ok i can deal with her voice, even if she has a cold..but the dance moves... just to all over the place for my liking.

[michaeljackson6789]

i dont like her now acting all crazy like one of her video called I CANT BE TAMED

[mariapapa81]

2 3 4!!

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

she said it herself.. "i might not sing like Beyonce, but i go there and give my best, i don't go there and lip sync and lie to my fans"

MILEY ROCKS

[zanessarocks4e2g]

She was sick... and she still sings like this:) I mean like it really isn't that bad it's not off key or anything so what are you talking about? at least she's devoted and blablabla LOVE MILEY(L)

[AceFrolic720]

Sure she sounds horrible .. but she's SICK! look at all the hate comments here..

don't u guys hav other stuff to do.. i guess NOT. n if u ask me.. then i find that LAMER than this singing.. SPRED LOVE NOT HATE.... it's cuz of ppl like you that v can't have peace in the world.. i like Miley.. she's unusual..

[08Identity08]

she sounds like she has a cold....

[JAYMELEEDAVIS]

She doesn't even sound bad. I think she's got alot of talent and so much potential, especially for her age. She's obviously sick but she still gets up on stage and performs for her fans.

[AlexH2906]

I wish she would just leave out all these dumb moves.....and start singing.....she can sing, I heard her do it.....

[djalemmers]

♥Put ur hand on ur mouth

2.Wish into ur hand

3.Put ur hand in ur heart for five seconds

4.Put this comment on three videos

5.Tomorrow you will have the best day of your LIFE it really works

[OrangeHighTopGRL]

She is HORRIBLE!!!! OMG!!!! She looks like she's spazzing out on stage!! Btw all of those immature Miley wanna be's , just because she's sick , doen't mean she can't be good.

[FilipeRSantos1]

@OrangeHighTopGRL shes awsome even sick, u dont see the truth

[jc100hung]

@OrangeHighTopGRL hahaha lol ur soooooooo rite

[BekahT2038]

oh please stop...just stop...please

[BlackpandaG]

u can tell that she is a little sick in this

[NewMO0n90210]

Shes a pretty good singer.

[657angel]

its like mommy i wanna be like her haahahhaahaha this was the turning point from teen pop sensation to wanna be paramore rocker girl look at her at 1:30 shes like haveing sez from 2:11 to 2:18

[LisaHoward0226]

she stunk because she had a sore throat

WATCH DA NEWS!

[smileyfan16]

Her voice has gotten so much better since then!!!!

[xgirlxify]

omg she has gotten soo much better since then

[sharinganWS]

lol simon must be laughing hard inside..... i bet he cried tears because of her voice..... really horrible.....

[JenniferSilvaOday]

@sharinganWS well, you're right her voice sucks but why is she singing in "Everybody Hurts" for haiti? it was arranged by Siomon...

[michealjnikhil]

@JenniferSilvaOday dude,u suck,if miley wud hv cm on axn or hbo,u wud spend all day long lisening 2 her songs,get it,just coz she came on disney,her repu fell down,but once,try to listen widout thinking she's da hannah star,or miley....u'll like it

[JenniferSilvaOday]

@michealjnikhil dude, i like her :S i don't look at her like "Hanna Montana" i look at her like Miley Cyrus, i was just saying that i don't like her voice live, and i said "why is she singing in "Everybody Hurts" for haiti? it was arranged by Siomon... " to shut that sharinganWS up...

[michealjnikhil]

@JenniferSilvaOday

[xxxWarriorGoddessxxx]

She can't sing worth SHIIIIIIT!

[nikkiacebedo]

dont denai it!!!!! u all know u just started hating miley since she did that scandal thing. . u can say stuff a bout that coz its true but if its about singing u know that she is amazing u jst cant admit it she is an amazing singer. .she did some bad things but that dosent change her voice. . !!!

[braidengodfrey1]

Shes a horible singer when she cant sync the somg to a better voice

[kimberlilymagda]

From her voice you could tell she has a cold.

[chely452]

from 2:23 and till like 2:25 she looks cock-eyed or drunk or somethin lol hahaha

[Pupsy03]

is she dunk or something?

[Pupsy03]

she sounds sick

[lexishank]

terrible

[videokingkling08]

BOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She stinks!!!!!!

[missKAWAIIx]

of all people why did american idol choose MILEY CYRUS to be a mentor ?

[lliizziiee1992]

@missKAWAIIx i have the exact same question!!

[ohyouloveit]

there must be poo on her finger tips from 1:30 on...

[Greeb17]

@ohyouloveit HAHAHAHA THATS SOOOOOO FUNNNNNYYYYYYYYYYY

[wholelifetolive]

@ohyouloveit that is the coolest thing EVER. Your are my HERO

[cocok76]

@ohyouloveit lolol wow im soooo glad you FOUND THAT!!!

[pealovesq]

@ohyouloveit - wow. what a stupid thing to say.

[iReimu]

@ohyouloveit lol

you comment made me crack up

I'm still laughing right now XD

[BlueandPinkAngelz]

i always wondered if a voice of singer is real or not because sometimes the records fix their voice and make them sound good

[luna1222cool]

she sing awesome :)

[homeslice341]

she sucks

[DianaLmh]

She's kinda pathetic. LOL

[littlejohn65868]

she is the worst singer i have ever heard. Utterly ATROCIOUS! American Idol should be ashame that they let her on the show!!

[m22n11b2]

shes sooooo much better now live :)

[msalice111]

i cant belive i went 2 1 of her preformances but i was all the way in de bck i had 2 use bunoculirs 2 see her tht sucked butt

[love0bueno]

i love her .

[RockBandGirl129]

thisis wen she not a slut, long pants a shirt tat covers, but now shes a slut short short pants n a cut tshirt

[MileyRayFan790]

no one truly has a very good singing voice bcuz no one is perfect, but she has a really good vioce!

[FreakSquad121212]

her choreogrophy is wayyy better than her singin...which is y ppl. watch her...cUse he "performances" are kool

[maeandeloise]

she sounds pretty bad, but this song is pretty tweeked originally so it will never sound the same live

[BekahT2038]

1:24 - 1:30 what kinda awkward strut stomp thing was that?! She sounded like she was singing through her nose. awkward 2! 3! 4! ....what was GOOD about this performance?

[MissMileysFan1]

I like her live performances ^^

[JojoStar14]

very bad... he can imagine what the judges are thinking of that perfomance XD

[4everASugarAddict]

she looks like she has a wedgie and shes trying to get it out....

[robert98padrinao]

0:48-0:50 i liked what she did th3re with "when u looked in my eyes" so cool

[Ericsimagination]

Hahahahahahha EPIC FAIL.

[is2477]

that was not a cold its just that her mics usually discise her voice and they arent alowed to tweek the mics on American idol DUH!

[iARELiLY]

She looks like she's having a spazz attack.

[thebearjew1996]

@iARELiLY ohhh thts wht i was thinking :P

[kokym8]

i think she was sick here cuz her voice tells that !

[deathiswaitin]

her voice is always like that, it the auto-tune that ur listening to when u play her music

[kokym8]

@deathiswaitin

no it's not always like this go and watch the wonderworld tour videos she sings live so good !

[ThePaulaAbdulfan]

1:25 - 1:32 WTF?!

[NMVK3]

haha same here WTF !!! :o

[harleydavidson130]

@ThePaulaAbdulfan at 1:30 , she grapped her own ass. lolness!

[ChadKroeger500]

good perfomance

i am impressed

[Saphire0718]

lol she did good for her nose being stuffed.....lolz

[Basandar43]

@Saphire0718 her nose stuffed? her voice is always harsh like that. She doesn't have a good voice. She is just lucky. That's it.

[Saphire0718]

@Basandar43 lol yeah i guess you could say that haha

[ChocoChipsProduction]

i <3 miley shes so awesome and i love all her songs

[SlayerGod999]

very ok

[EnvyChann]

Omg...a bad cold...

[D1G1TALhikari]

i think simon should've put some input on this xD

a big issue that the american idol judges have is with the singers inability to act their own age - which honestly shouldn't be hard.

can we have miley who is sixteen-ish actually act look/act like a 16 yr old? having fun with songs...and not putting on pounds of makeup would be nice

[twilightfan5873992]

when she is live she sounds lyk she is on crack or pot

[attitudelarhh]

wao she even have back dances

[henriquezeitoum2]

nossa eu ahco ela muito gata!!!

By:Brazil

[harsh2krytiseyez]

...i'm so glad she gained weight. she's scary skinny here. 0.o i miss this miley. *tear* lmfao.

[lynpaul38]

For all you people who say u hate miley y r u watching this vid??

[SpecialEdwerd]

@lynpaul38 Because I'm hoping that simon is going to rip her a new asshole when I get to the end.

[DarylLaiTV]

she's pretty talented for her age.

[Christina918273645]

Um...guys stop arguing. It's kind of simple. If you hate Miley, everyone knows that you are just trying to make your life less boring by stirring up drama. Why don't you do something better with your time then look up people you hate. If you like Miley you have the right to defend her on her own videos

[Jened0998]

Thanks so much for saying that Christina918273645.. I've been trying to tell that to everyone ... I hope you guys learned something from her... Or, just because she suck at singing, forget the lyrics, not good at dancing you would make fun of her..

[Ander185olds]

my ears hurt

[starfire35fan]

I agree, she tried too hard. she doesn't sound good at all

[sonikcadet]

youre the best miley

[GozziiPGirl]

Miley cyrus is so so sos so pretty! soo talented and a great singer! she sings soo good here! shes my idol i lvoe her!

[jemkls]

Why is she singing this song on Idol gives back? Something more appropriate would have been atleast better!

[Reemo093]

oh shes so eww here

[zacefronforever14]

she is sooo nasty.

gross!

[ViVAlAhSkiTZ0]

Gotta admit, she tried too hard.

[KathyJohnnyTV]

yea she def sounds sick here... but i dont care shes the best ;)

[TheFearOfOne]

She doesnt sound good here x-x Good thing the judges wasnt able to say their opinion on how she sang.

[jamiewrightrocks]

in an interview she said that she got the flu just a couple days after this performance. so maybe she was a lil sick here.

[jigglypuffsmom]

She should watch the Aristocats. Very valuable lessons in that movie, especially in the song 'Scales and Arpeggios': "Bring the music ringing from your chest and not your nose!" Then she'd be decent.

[recniabsal]

Or Eminem.

[recniabsal]

You know who I wanna see on American Idol? Fred Durst. That'd be tight.

[skipperrox99]

simon probably has earplugs in.

[ScottObenshain]

She doesnt have a very good voice. Very nasaly. If she would stop singing through her nose, she'd be okay

[theoneandonlykatiev]

i like miley cyrus songs, but she is kind of promiscuious in every performance that i see her live in. it just makes me sad.

[PooPixxie]

I love Miley <3

[hercia06]

Divaa. *-------------*

[mariehairy]

wow this was a really good performance

[ABCproductionsBFF]

wow. right at 1:29 or 1:30 she grabbed her butt.

[mileyraycyrusfan411]

People, people, people. It's called choreography. It's when someone else makes up a dance that you HAVE to do. That's called a choreographer.

[Zincura]

Don't fuck with MileyrayCyrusfan411, shit that name is serious LOL. Just leave Miley alone on here.

[MrGibby95]

what a slut

[MizzGigi4ever]

she sounds sick. i went to her wonderworld concert and she was just an amazing performer.

[TheJohnybegood]

shes 16

[mzdelz12]

what is mileys sog genre?

pop? rock? rap? what kind

[jade14xx]

pop

[MrGibby95]

shit

[mileyraycyrusfan411]

Pop, and country.

[goldmaedchen91]

Thanks for the Answer ; )

[goldmaedchen91]

she is very beautiful :)

How old is she?

[michalsonn]

She is 17

[jessicabrain19]

Why are people leaving mean comments???!!She is a young, talented girl who is damn good at what she does:)

ILoveMiley!!!!

[Ngelcanfly]

I thought American Idol is a place that looks for talented people, not inviting people who can't sing like Miley to perform.

[BrownEyeLady]

whats going on she sings great live:)

In the CD they re-makew her voice, and it doesnt sound natural at all!! LIve much better:)

[SUNNYFULWIDER1]

yea... miley was 'sick'! everytime she sings live she's 'sick' right? yea... if she really is sick, then i'm megan fox.

[iloveyoubaby3195]

Miley is so good at performing.

She may not be the best "live singer"

but she has a great voice.

She can perform better than anyone.

I love her! She's incredibly talented.

[kajain007]

Yea..ur totaly rite..

she change her voice when live singing~

Sometimes her live singing's good

but sometimes its very awful ..

I Love MILEY!!!!

[LoboAscuridad]

So hot at 0:52 to 0:56

LOL xD

[JeffIsMyHarDylicious]

Its funny how they showed only her top shot when she was humping the floor,Kinda like they did when she was dancing on the icecream cart pole on fox''s awards show..

[mileyraycyrusfan411]

What? That doesn't make sense.

[JeffIsMyHarDylicious]

What didnt make sense about it? The bit at 2:10-2:15 the camera zooms out when mileys is trying to hump/dancie sexy in the floor with her legs open which would have been an automatic crotch shot,like they accidentaly showed at 1:29 when it looks like she snaps her pelvis to the camera..(Thats the focus in the shot)and that whole dancing part was akwardly inappropiate with thetwitching,touching herself/butt and trying to do some head banging rocker moves?

[mileyraycyrusfan411]

Actually the camera was just right there...they couldn't very well easily have moved it...

[mileyraycyrusfan411]

Also, why wouldn't they show her head in the 2:10 thing?

[jessicacandylips]

i like her but not in this show

[Broadwaystar1234567]

why is it that whenever she sings live she is always "sick"?

[phillip11625]

that is every stupid miley cyrus fans excuse. i dont understand why people worship this girl her dad sucked at singing country and she sucks at singing too. people miley cyrus is not god quit worshiping her..

[dolmation1]

at least she sing LIVE unlike britney spears..

[Ngelcanfly]

That's because Britney dances like crazy. You can't pull it off at the same time if you have to dance like her.

[theaterkanin]

then she shouldn't dance like that...

[mileyraycyrusfan411]

1.) She isn't always sick.

2.) She has a condition.

3.) When you sing all the time, you lose your voice...

[Broadwaystar1234567]

But you dint lose your voice is you sing right. and what is her condition?

[mileyraycyrusfan411]

That's not true for one. Yeah, singing right helps, but you can still lose your voice easily. She has a heart condition.

[Broadwaystar1234567]

Oh i didnt know she had a heart condition.

[TheUjay]

that is scary. it must be very hard for her to sing live.

[ClamVersion]

You just gave three good reasons for why she is a horrible singer, i'm sorry but it's true.

[kidphresh19]

@ClamVersion if shes a horrible singer why do you listen common sense :[

[jigglypuffsmom]

Then she shouldn't sing all the time. :) Take it from someone who knows. I've lost my voice from singing too much before, and I learned when I should stop. She's a superstar now, she can tell people when she doesn't want to sing.

[Miley709]

she had strep at this performance so she did pretty good compared to other sick singers!!!

[anniep94]

not really

[mrsLALAcolorfullAbby]

omg look what sees doing with her arm behind her at 1:28

[mileyraycyrusfan411]

What do you mean? What's she doing?

[elegg111]

2 3 4!! that was stupid

[crystalcook02]

she sounds like she's doing karaoke drunk!!!!!

[shivey94]

She went way too out of breath and screwed her singing, but like her shoes...

[mileyraycyrusfan411]

She was not that out of breath. You try running around, moving around, and singing at the same time. It's kinda hard.

[phillip11625]

wow this bitch seriously cant sing.. wayyyyy to overated. booooooooooo get the fuck off the stage.. haha