Added: 4 years ago
From: inTheFade26
Views: 158,915
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (224)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • WOW HOW COULD PEOPLE DISLIKE FOO FIGHTERS

    DAVE JUST MARRY ME YOU ARE PERFECT

  • Great band, great song!

    

  • ♥'

  • 5 people are out

  • VIBRAPHONE.

    that is all.

  • 4:03

  • This video has been selected by the channel as one of the best Music videos on YouTube and was added to the channel's playlist accordingly. Thanks for sharing.

    Regards,

    bestofYTchannel

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I stopped playing video games just to listen to this song. Holy crap, I love this song, it's so beautiful and haunting.

  • I was'nt there!

  • @Stealth7551 the sad sad truth..

  • as ever great tune

  • just wow....you gotta love this music!

  • What he said. V

  • Amazing.

  • Dave > rest of the world

  • What's beautiful about Foo Fighters is that you can connect and feel somethin' in every song.

  • Epic..... !!

  • @ ww3pl This is taken from the Double dvd set 'HYDE PARK/SKIN AND BONES'

  • From what gig is this video? Where I can buy a DVD/Blu-Ray?

  • @ww3pl Skin an bones tour, you can prolly buy it online or music/dvd stores

  • I'm totally addicted to this song! <3

  • I feel that way about my brother's son. He's gonna be born in like a week or something, but I already feel connected to him. sometimes I feel like he's the only thing that's connecting me with the world and he's the only reason I should stay alive. And that's just weird. :p

  • 2:07, listen to guitar carefully :)

  • amico...

  • my favorite foo fighters song

  • The vibes suit this song so well.

  • They need to tour more.

  • @lazaros11 You're a nutcase

  • This song makes me think of my little girl. It brings a tear to my eye. Absolute poetry.

  • 5 persone non hanno capito un cazzo della musica! LOL

  • Wow is that a xylophone? I like the guitar chords on this song. What a lovely band. I like Dave's lyrics ;-)

  • @michanita It's a vibraphone. :)

  • Thats what I call music!!

    FF 4 eva!!

  • ... so amzing

  • Yeahh ....

  • has someone actuallly found another live version of this song

  • @BlueOnionGroup Nope :( and i doubt there is since it's an acoustic song but who knows... they ply my hero acoustic now sooo

  • 5 people need new ears

  • I just LOVE this song ................

  • great song!

  • This video has been selected by the channel as one of best Music videos on YouTube and was added to the channel's playlist accordingly. Thanks for sharing.

    Regards,

    bestofYTchannel

  • the live version is so much better. It gives me chills when i listen to it~

  • Awesome....

  • love this song its so soothing

  • Wow!!! Wish i could have been there

  • dave grohl is a badass.. one of my favorite artists... and his guitars are all badass.. my god.. look at em.. perfection.

  • Five stars and favorited. This is definitely one I want to learn.

  • Dave Grohl is one talented mofo.

  • this song is also hackin easy :)

  • unbelievable.

  • Look how intimate this is, it's wonderful how everyone can just stay silent and listen to amazing music. Wish I had been there !

  • Poetry. I feel sorry for the folks who don't appreciate this band. I really do.

  • @BBCater AMEN.

  • I saw them live Dec. '06 when they headlined K-rOQ's almost acoustic xmas. Too bad I had to hear hours of lame bands like 30 sec. to Mars and papa roach, but Foo Fighters were more than worth it in the end............Oh, and Incubus rocked da house it that night too!

  • holy fuck, The Foos and Incubus at the same show? I'm fucking jealous.

  • It's so great how a band so usually heavy can just sit down and do things acoustically and stripped, it show that they have major variety and diversity which is what what many bands sometimes lack. 10/10

  • The whole Skin and Bones concert DVD is incredible

  • This is how the second disc of in your honor should of sounded, the recordings lack the energy , emotion and fullness of these live version counterparts

  • OMG.........they fucking rock!!!!!!

  • The BEST band out there in DECADES - no question. Wow - just awesome stuff.

  • I was there!

  • *Looks at your username" O.O

  • yeah!!

  • @ireallyamjoeking lucky bastard, i envy you

  • @ireallyamjoeking i'm green of envy! ;)

  • @ireallyamjoeking I envy you soooo much! *__*

  • @ireallyamjoeking ....... I was too but in SD....But still very BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!

  • in your honor is the best foo fighters cd

  • I love this! This is on Skin and bones CD and DVD

  • ftmfw

  • its vibraphone dude they are way cooler than marimbas

  • no its not a marimba or glock

    Drew Hester the percussionist is playing a vibraphone or (set of vibes)

  • Are you theeeeeeeeeeeeeere? Grohl  ubijaaaaa

  • ...maybe a glockenspiel?

  • probably one of the top five musicians of our generation no doubt

    ROCK ON dave hes never let me down

  • personally, hes #1 but undoubtedly in the top 5 man

  • holy shittt

    sounds like the recording.....Foo Fighters are amazing!!!!

  • gosh.. this song is so amazing. :)

  • Can anyone confirm that the Black Gibson Guitar is infact the Elvis Presley J-200 Model, cause i've been wanting to buy this guitar ever since i saw this DVD

  • Comment removed

  • wat!! daves vocals owns live.. even when he has a cold. but thats my opinion.

  • nope technicality doesn't make a song,...love does.

  • a-freakin-men : )

  • The studio verswion isnt good as live! Never! This version is much better than the studio version.

  • I was there, August 31, 2006 at the Pantages. One of the greatest concerts I've ever been to. I will cherish that night for the rest of my life.

  • Daves vocals live never live up to the records

  • This Song is my favorite foo fighter song. theres just something about it that got me hooked and never let me go.... It's Awsome

  • Hands Down One Of The Best Bands You Could EVER See Live...... This song is VERY DEEP!!!!!!!! If you ever get the chance to see the FOO FIGHTERS ..... DO SO... You wont Regret it ! !! ! This I Promise you. FOOFAN4EVER

  • Agreed! Fantastic performers...great music. This song on skin and bones is better thatn on in your homor

  • Absolutely incredible performance of one of the best band in the worlds amazing songs

  • Isn't it terrible that after looking at the first page of comments of a FOO FIGHTERS video, there was none about the performance? That is sad, come on guys comment on the greatest band alive!

  • fuck you

  • who cares about technicality. if the music is good its good and if it sucks it sucks. Just because your a talented guitarist it doesn't mean your a talented musician.

    If its a great song and theres lots of skill involved, more power to you, but technicality doesn't make the song

  • haha people are stupid who waste there time complaining with someone they have never seen or met. this is such a song the guitar part is great and the song speaks volumes great

  • you need to lay off the drugs, son.. better yet - don't..as you set a fine example of why people shouldn't be taking them..

    shit and I thought the whale and the rino were female? how does that make me gay then?..a zoophil perhaps..but you were the one who FIRST mentioned being fucked in the ass, so what does that tell us about you, hm? ;) but don't worry..there's no shame in that.. be what you gotta be, man..I mean boy..(meaning: a brainfucked little junkie buttfucking son of a son of a bitch)

  • now for the last time (just trying to get that through your thick skull to reach the vacuum that is inside of it..perhaps eventually you'll grow some brains too?hmm).. The ONLY time i posted was to say there is NO best guitarist.. or are you too fucking dumb to READ (or to find the "previous" button)?!? Now shut the fuck up allready or else you'll just keep on making even a bigger fucktard out of yourself (wonder if that's even possible though..)!

    ps: Ok I will say it.. "hi to your mum for me"

  • @inTheFade26 Nice attempt to sound smart. You should make your comments elsewhere. You said nothing about this song. Stop breathing our air.

  • @inTheFade26 No need to get so wound up over some troll

  • @inTheFade26 Dont blame anyones personality on drugs, drugs dont change people, people use it as an excuse to change.Drugs do amazing things for the world, they just get hard press. For example take the foo fighters above, stoners. I love their music, the entire red hot chili peppers, all junkies in their own right. Does it make them bad people? Pink Floyd? Do i need to go on? Just keep ill informed mass media views to yourself. You're both pathetic. Enjoy the music comfortable and warm.

  • damn kids today.. no manners at all! :(

    now listen here homefuck! just to put things in perspective ( = to show how incredibly fucking stupid you are).. you somehow "accused" me of saying Dave was the best guitarist.. problem is it was my first fuckin post on that subject where all I said was that there is no "best ever".. do you see now what a fuckin stupid moronic dimwitted imbecilic retarded little punkass dumbfuck you are being?.. no wait, you're too dumb to get it..

    anyhow - love u too!

  • shit.. I wouldn't wanna be misleading you or something..

    what I meant was.. I love U2 (they're great live!)

    as for you..you're still a daft prick.. ('til you start coming to your senses.. apparently that's hard for you.. now go pencil-trick yourself..)

    oh and as always.. hugs&kisses!**

  • love the chimes

  • lol.. sure, you can always suggest (I just won't listen :D).. btw, you were talking to a "dude" = one person.. not "all those who mentioned..".. so basically..you're full of shit!:) now, may I suggest you get fucked by a rhino and a whale (at the same time) and (if you don't make it)then get resurrected every 2minutes (you are Lazaros afterall:D)) just so you can get fucked by a rhino and a whale again.. and again.. and again.. and again..('til you stop making and writing nonsense..) LUV xoxo:*

  • Ok...it's alright evrey1 sayin he's a simple guitarist...but on his first album, he played drums, bass, guitar, sang and recorded, THEN put a band to it to go on tour with. Can any of YOU do that???

  • Wow, awesome!

  • W(hat)TF are you talking and W(ho)TF are you talking to?! (no really, I'm curious who started this whole "best fuckin guitarist" bullshit debate..) anyway - fuck the guitarists! Dave Grohl is a fuckin drummer! ..and a bloody briliant one, might I add.. so better start discussing "best drummer ever" bullshit debate.. on the other hand.. hmmm.. don't..

    Music forever

  • watch him play razor. awsome fukin musician

  • wow seriously it was this guys oppinion that dave grohl was the best guitarist. in my oppinion hes a great musician and i admire him, and hes my favorite, so are you gonna flame me? i dont care if slash is better that grohl at guitar, i just love dave grohl. go away you fucking metal heads, i hate metal, but hey its what you like right? so idk if you like it, just leave this kid alone.

  • WTF is wrong with you people? WTF are you/we even discussing this? There's no such thing as "best ever...something"! There are only opinions based on our own perspectives.. I'm sure whoever said Dave's "the best ever" meant in terms of writting skills (as in being able to write good songs)and..that's all! It's crystal clear he didn't mean it literally - fuck! He's not even a fuckin guitarist FFS - he's a fuckin drummer! So please, pretty please, with sugar on top - STFU with the "best ever"! :*

  • doesn't really matter who is the best guitar player in the world or if the best guitar players are from metal. what difference does it make? can't understand these comments... only music is important.

    and over and out is fucking amazing...

  • how the hell can you even say gilmour is the best guitarist ever? you can't deny his talent, but compared to the greats in metal, jazz, blues, flamenco etc. he can't compete. plus, floyd is just music you fall asleep too. you're a complete dumbass trolling this stupid video and responding to everyones opinion. get a life and listen to some music of substance. then maybe you'll actually know what it takes to actually play the guitar. and recoginize talent. gilmour my ass.

  • dave grohl THE BEST GUITARIST? JAJAJAJA must be a really bad joke, every metal guitarist is far way better IN ALL ASPECTS than this guy , except for the singing

  • well Dave wrote metal on Probot too :P

  • this shit blows the only reason i came here is because i heard someone say dave grol is the best guitarist ever, are you out of ur fucking mind fuckin douche cunt

  • Dave Grohl is probably one of the worst and simplest guitarists ever. It's like saying Kurt Cobain is one of the best guitarists, they are both ok writers, but terrible musicians.

  • Dave Grohl the best guitarist? i think not. people need to broaden(Spelling??) their horizon in musicianship. heres some people that are the quintessence of guitar playing: alex skolnick(testament), marty frieman(cacaphony and megadeth), joe satriani, steve vai, michael romeo(symphony x), jason becker, john 5(marilyn manson, rob zombie and solo albums), paul gilbert, rusty cooley, chris broderick, and tony mcalpine.

  • i have no idea why you people are talking about who is better or not, you like the music or you dont like it, every musician makes music in his or her way. the ones that enjoy of it, listens to it, you dont listen to it just to fight against each other. so enjoy of it or dont.

  • so playing the three same power chords in one song makes you a a good guitarist?

    let's see dave play like john petrucci, mustaine, skolnick, dimebag, laiho, synester gates etc. etc.

    METAL RULES!! HORNS UP!!

  • you're a douche. this is just one song. He's not just a great guitarist, he's a wicked singer. plus all the guys you mentioned are nobody compared to dave Gilmour, and that opinion is shared by critics of music through the century, not some punk ass skin heads

  • You have no idea what are you saying, havent you?

    Do look up who those guitarists are and dont talk yust something to look smart, because you actually seems redicoular whit your comment.

  • I look what? I cant understand what you're saying. Try typing in english, that'll help. Once again, David Gilmour. Best guitarist ever.

  • Ok i am sorry that my english is not good, i am not from english speeking country. What i ment to say was that none of the guitarists mentioned above are skin heads either punks soo

    you should learn few things about music.

  • I didn't refer to the guitarists themselves, but rather the people who listen to them. And again, my opinion hasn't changed. They are not the best.

  • out of all those guys named there, the only that can even be mentioned in an adjacent sentence would be dimebag. A good guitar player isn't defined by how many notes he can hit and how fast he can hit them, but I guess thats how you rank them

  • It is a bit late but anywhay, i am wasnt talking about ranking i was refering to you saying that everybody is either punk or skinhead. O and yust one thing go to music academy and ask somewhone how important is to be quick and acurate at playing an instrument.

  • but that´s a matter of opinion

    some say they care more bout there feelings and not about perfect technique

    I think that´s okay as well

  • Dave grohl is about as good a guitarist as noel gallagher is!!

    He doesn't even remotely compare to ANY metal guitarist.

  • yet again Dave has written metal

    and it's not all about being fast whatsoever it's about feeling and connecting with an audience, I'm sure if Dave wanted he could easily write fast songs, but that's not what he's about

  • this guitarist blows.

    foo fighters blows.

    his voice is annoying.

    listen to some real music

    like megadeth,metallica,slayer,test­ament,and fall out boy.

    ........lol

    just kidding fall out boy blows too

  • Right, so this sin't real music. Well thats the biggest load of crap i have heard a srimp like u say.

    Why u on this page is its crap?

    And too correct u this is real music its not fake. All u ''Metal heads'' clame u aren't fake and u don't pose, yet u are. To prove my point i bet ur sitting at ur computer dressed like a drone, with proper long hair, possibly them stupid large black earings in to make urself distant from the noraml guy, while doing so it makes u a poser as well. ur all the same.

  • actually, you are completely wrong about.

    yeah i have long hair but it doesnt even

    pass my shoulders, i wear vans zoo york,

    and i have no piercings at all.

    so your perception of my drone like appearence to try and be diiferent from the "average" person is wrong.

    i think the metal-head look is gay as fuck.

  • u right we are normal persons the 85%

  • As much as I respect Dave Grohl and enjoy Foo Fighters. He is not the greatest. I agree with all the Metalheads below. Alex Skolnick (Testament), John Petrucci (Dream Theater), Herman Li (DragonForce), Kerry King (Slayer)and we can go on and on.

  • How is Kerry King such a great guitarist? Hannemann is twice as good.

  • I agree with Skolnick and Petrucci, but Herman Li is a terrible and poser guitarist. And as much as I love Slayer, Kerry King can't solo to save his life.

  • Dave Grohl inst the greatest guitarrist alive or ever or whatever, why?

    because he can't do speed picking, he cant do a solo with tapping, he can bearly solo a song, thats why and to be a the greatest guitarrist he must not only be a great compositor, he must have an amazing hability for soloing. so if you think that hes the greatest ever you shouldnt have listen dream theater or even pink floyd...

    those are guitarrist, those are compositors, those are musician...

  • this guitarist blows cock

  • Well, with these words coming out of your cock-blowing mouth from a cock-blowing master expert such as yourself (well I would assume so, given the perverse nature of your way of thinking), you almost had me fooled there for a while.. BUT (and I'm not talkin' double "T" here) come to think of it.. nah! Now stop sharing your twisted sick fucked-up fantasies of yours with the rest of us, 'cause no one cares really.. Hugs and kisses! (but please - cheeks only!)

  • apparantly all the time it took you to write this makes just as much of a pervert. (Take notes, i managed to call you a pervert ,yet I managed to not include one peverted word in my writing)

    .... Dumbass!

  • seriously people... anyone that thinks Dave Grohl is the greates guitar player alive is a moron. You need to listen to people like Alex Skolnick (Testament), John Petrucci (Dream Theater), Marty Friedman (Cacophony and Megadeth), Joe Satriani, Steve Vai, Paul Gilbert, and John 5

  • come on guys dave grohl isnt the best guitar player ever he isnt even near guys like dave mustaine, james hetfield, slash,SRV,Hendrix,Page,david Gilmour etc etc etc etc

    he s a great songwriter and a amazing musician but he isnt a great guitar player lets face it!!

    and to the guy saying he made tour with led zeppelin...LZ broke up in 1980 with the death of the great john bonham!! page and john paul jones did play with dave but they arent LZ...

  • the most emotional performance of the most emotional song i know

  • i think its the skin and bones. :) omg i get goosebumps when i hear this song <3

  • Damn, this is great! Thet foo's are the best! Can you please tell me the name of the concert DVD macdben? I definetely want to have it :D

  • Skin and Bones - its the live dvd and theres an album of it :)

  • yeahhh! grohl awesome!!!! sorry :D

  • Grohl is an awesome singer! this is one of his best!

  • mother fuck... dave grolh is awesome! great song!

  • grohl* and yes he is

  • Awesome song! <3

  • Ive got this concert on DVD, and honestly i never get tired of it

  • Awesome!!! I truly love this!!!

  • Great song!!

    Grohl is really awesome.One of the most talented man in Rock!

  • I"ve seen a few bands in thru the years n the foo fighers or so talented!!

  • OK. That's your opinion and I respect it, but, sincerely, this is the first time I have heard such a thing.

    I still think he's fucking brilliant at everything he does.