snowy white nails the guitar solo in these piece! following david gilmour is no easy thing but i like how he added his touch to the solo and how he interpreted it while still remaining true to the original vibe.
Can't understand why some people only have bad things to say about someone's vision and creativity? If you don't like something, just click on to something else? Usually the person saying how bad something is, might be a jealous that they lack the talent to create something this good? So before you make fun of someones talent, remember that once said you can't take it back and leave yourself open to everyone else to comment about you?
@mr10169michael so well said sir! even if one doesn't like or understand a creation by another individual at least try to appreciate the effort put into making it. btw, roger water's is one of my favorite philosophers.
One of the greatest bands that will ever be. Pure genius and people who say there ahead of there time, sure thats true but there music will be relevant to any time period
So far ahead of it's time, and yet still manages to epitomize the present. Before NIN wrote Hurt, Pink Floyd had already captured the mood with One of my Turns.
not the best pink floyd album ever and not the best pink floyd song ever, however this is the song that ties the first act with the second act. if of course you ever watched the movie The Wall.
C'mon people... the chick at the beginning is classic! It's Jerry Hall, formerly missus Mick Jagger, former girlfriend of Bryan Ferry before that, classic rock chick in other words!
The chick at the beginning was annoying. But she had a cool dress. The rest was awesome, I especially liked the scene where he destroyed the apartment.
THE BEST was jones beach newyork, i went there about 5 maybe 6 years ago , great time , best ever to tell the truth , im off to watch roger on the 12th may earls court this year , GONNA BE ANOTHER GREAT TIME , CHEERS FOR POSTING UR TUNES AND HAVING GREAT TASTE IN MUSIC , AND THANKS TO ROGER FOR LETTING ME HAVE SOMETHING GREAT TO LOOK FORWARD TO , love ya forever , i was also at the live8 concert , best in the world , them together again , ROGER AND FLOYDY FOREVER X
@JimTheUmp roger waters is pink floyd he wrote over 90 % percent of all there songs and i understand gilmours awesome guitar playing but if u had to go back intime and start pink floyd it could be donewith out david gilmour but not vice versa
@lumix1444 Are you fucking daft?...........I guess you never listened to albums before DSoTM. Because Waters only started really writing lyrics at Dark Side and after. Saucerful of Secrets, Atom Heart Mother, More, Obscured by Clouds, Ummagumma, Meddle. All the music on those albums are written mostly by Gilmour not Waters. So believe me it isn't Waters by himself it is the band as a whole. Even the albums of DSoTM and after the music was co written by David Roger AND Richard. So get your facts.
@KissTheSky321 I think you are the daft one. Roger was writing lyrics way before Dark Side; it's just from Dark Side onwards he wrote all of the lyrics. Plus how can you say all the music was written mostly by Gilmour before Dark Side?? Look at the song writing credits to albums like Saucerful, More and Obscured and you will see Waters has more than any other band member. I suggest you get YOUR facts straight!
TI AMO
pinksoneband 2 months ago
WAO.
leonseru 4 months ago
snowy white nails the guitar solo in these piece! following david gilmour is no easy thing but i like how he added his touch to the solo and how he interpreted it while still remaining true to the original vibe.
drmr4hm 4 months ago
I wish to be in this show :s
victorhbji 4 months ago
the fuckin chills i have right now wanna cry
asus3571 6 months ago
YAH WANNA TAKE A BAAAAAAAAAAAAAATHHH?
and all the people: "yeeeeeeeeeahhhH!!" lol
RosarioNahu 7 months ago
Can't understand why some people only have bad things to say about someone's vision and creativity? If you don't like something, just click on to something else? Usually the person saying how bad something is, might be a jealous that they lack the talent to create something this good? So before you make fun of someones talent, remember that once said you can't take it back and leave yourself open to everyone else to comment about you?
mr10169michael 9 months ago
@mr10169michael so well said sir! even if one doesn't like or understand a creation by another individual at least try to appreciate the effort put into making it. btw, roger water's is one of my favorite philosophers.
drmr4hm 4 months ago
Bitch, shut up I'm watching the amazing adventures of Nigger the dog!
McFudge93 10 months ago
G-damn......listen to that voice.
UfilthyFAGrag 1 year ago
3:01-3:20 i want to do that
pinkfloyd257 1 year ago
@pinkfloyd257 3:13 - 3:16 I want to do THAT!
gertjeeeh 8 months ago
@gertjeeeh lol you play guitar?
pinkfloydLIB1990 8 months ago
jerry hall playing her very self?
MoveOverCasanova 1 year ago
is it me or does he mess up the lyrics at 6:37
pinkfloyd257 1 year ago
@pinkfloyd257 Oh wow - he does!
Belgarath98 7 months ago
Jerry Hall's acting here is so cheesy. In fact, this whole gig was cheesy. Sinead O'Connor... Brian Adams... Cyndi Lauper???!?!? Horrible!
rumblefishism 1 year ago
That bitch in the begining grates at my ears, but the actual song is fucking great, especially here.
I fucking ADORE that synth tone.
TheElusiveBirdMan 1 year ago
this is amazing!
Navohk 1 year ago
The piano in this song is... flawless.
CzechGuardian 1 year ago
just like in the movie >:-)-
pffan1000 1 year ago
the chick at the beginning is NOT funny
krollaostmedburger 1 year ago
Roger Live In Europe 2011 !
damsdams 1 year ago 4
tHIS IS CLOSE TO MY FAV pf BIT EVAH!
AntiTraci 1 year ago
por dio!!! los gritos de esa mina!!!!
piberocker 1 year ago
best vocalist ever
daaaaaaaamn i love you roger
tachku1986 1 year ago
perfection!!! wudn xpect anyting else from roger
MrChewbacca1978 1 year ago
"I have grown older anyou have grown colder and nothing is very much fun anymore..." so fucking apocalyptically true and genius
MaghoxFr 1 year ago 3
@MaghoxFr
Day after day, love turns grey
Like the skin of a dying man
Night after night, we pretend it's all right
Spot On!
larryoduncan 1 year ago 13
Waters trashing a hotel room -- nice! Echoes of the WYWH tour ...
apacolipps 1 year ago
hahahaha! that chick just made my day...
xxkewldudexx 1 year ago
Every century has it's highest artistic expression . This a milestone !!
franzmattioli 2 years ago
look how many fucking people there are!
xfactor5492 2 years ago
Holy fuck the intro is wretched.
Anjohl 2 years ago 7
u.u tipa dalla voce gallinosa U_U
VeronicaFloyd 2 years ago
Pretty elaborate way of performing this live, Roger just never settles for anything less!
kenakuma 2 years ago
Awesome! Thanx for the post :)
DSky2001 2 years ago
Rogers voice is amazing in this performance! what happened to it afterwards! seemed to go down the pan
GeezaGooderz 2 years ago
I think in this song he can put a lot of agression en frustration in.. it can bring the best up in a human.. further he's a genius :)
sandermatthijs 2 years ago 2
Jerry Hall Mick Jaggers EX
poodle720 2 years ago
JUST AMAZING !!!!!
kapesa1 2 years ago
fucking love this song but whoever this lady is she's fucking annoying, any other way you can POSSIBLY over do it?
miiwii93 2 years ago
I agree, but I think thats also kinda the point
tsup77 2 years ago
yeah i know that but i mean how come the lady on the album wasnt even close to be as annoying?
miiwii93 2 years ago
Idk, I feel like the album girl was annoying too, but more shallow
tsup77 2 years ago
This one is doing "too much". The one on the album never seemed that annoying to me.
Anyway :) Roger's performance here is astonishing as always. Genuine man.
labitajojo 2 years ago
Love the part where he stands up and has 200K in the crowd cheering. What an unbelievable feeling that must be.
rlkavan 2 years ago 2
One of the greatest bands that will ever be. Pure genius and people who say there ahead of there time, sure thats true but there music will be relevant to any time period
7jimmyjames 2 years ago
This song is a response by Roger to a fight he had with his wife...
NightClubKing 2 years ago 2
Wanna take a ba-a-a-th?
Rafmanne 2 years ago
So far ahead of it's time, and yet still manages to epitomize the present. Before NIN wrote Hurt, Pink Floyd had already captured the mood with One of my Turns.
EnviousDominous 2 years ago
Man I love this guy.
garvess 2 years ago
there goes gilmours strat
golf520man 2 years ago
Passei minha adolescência ouvindo está música....
Pink Floyd is my life........
s2 Fabio e Jal s2.......
Te Amoooooooooooooooooooooooooo0
08do07de1984 2 years ago
quien es la mina?
Scirius13 2 years ago
La ex mujer de mick Jagger, no me acuerdo como se llama.
Frlecube 2 years ago
jerry hall
sebafloyd1 2 years ago
It's Jerry Hall - yes the former Mrs. Jagger (current at the time)
DonohoFlanker 1 year ago
@Frlecube JERRY HALL??
cheminwey 1 year ago
@Frlecube jerry hall
MrTGSB 1 year ago
@Frlecube
Con razon es la ex....
thedorkfish60 3 months ago
fantastic
masterm01 3 years ago
he should have trashed that room
other than that its great
terenceokane 3 years ago
what with his one hand
rudeawakening5 2 years ago
good point
still, i cant hear that song without thinkin about a room being destroyed
terenceokane 2 years ago
by god, hes still got it but then again hes always had it and always will have it. Whatever it is
hodgepodge1 3 years ago
That chick as you call her is Jerry Hall. Its invited guests to perform the wall not original singers...ya noddy
petnzme01 3 years ago
excellent, but somebody tell that chick to shut up. She doesen't even sound hot like the album one.
TheElusiveBirdMan 3 years ago
not the best pink floyd album ever and not the best pink floyd song ever, however this is the song that ties the first act with the second act. if of course you ever watched the movie The Wall.
dave18469 3 years ago
buena cansion me encanta arriba roger eres el mejor pink flod arriba
bucktoto 3 years ago
this song is just plain brilliant...
arkhforever 3 years ago
My heart and Pink Floyd's music are one and the same.... thank you for uploading this video.
tseekr379 3 years ago 3
Thanks Roger
nakarada 3 years ago
my favorite pink floyd's song
salvadorap 3 years ago 3
magnificent...
pink72floyd 3 years ago 3
Love this song! Glad I finally get to see it live!
RogerFloyd1981 3 years ago
that women sucks eggs...
BlowoutBob 3 years ago 5
No, she used to suck Eggs!!!
That is Jerry Hall, The Ex-wife of Mick Jagger. Therein lies the "Irony'you Meathead!
fig8slomo 3 years ago
No wonder she sucks, just like Mick Jagger as a singer.
TheElusiveBirdMan 3 years ago
don't dream too much about items, prohibited to you, BirdMan.
nevertheless if she sucks...
ToshibaConsumer 3 years ago
What do you mean "items"?
TheElusiveBirdMan 3 years ago
Best album ever made
ggizzer 3 years ago 6
Nah. Not even Pink Floyd's best. Still great though.
TheCameraEye1989 3 years ago 5
just awesome 5 stars
smuge123 3 years ago
C'mon people... the chick at the beginning is classic! It's Jerry Hall, formerly missus Mick Jagger, former girlfriend of Bryan Ferry before that, classic rock chick in other words!
Zepster77 4 years ago
The chick at the beginning was annoying. But she had a cool dress. The rest was awesome, I especially liked the scene where he destroyed the apartment.
darkempress1066 4 years ago
she's supposed to be annoying.
she's doing all that vain talking while you are in a deep moment of introspection, and you couldn't care less about a word she says...
that's the spirit of the beginning of the song.
SickDream 3 years ago 13
Ohhh and in this version they exaggerated the annoyance. The girl in the album version wasn't nearly as obnoxious. XD
darkempress1066 3 years ago 2
that's right...
plus the girl in the album version sounds sexy.
this one sounds just plain dumb
SickDream 3 years ago 4
@ SickDream: This one IS just plain dumb, lol.
Jerry Hall (the groupie) was, in fact, criticized for her performance and I can see why.
Madroxxide17 3 years ago
This is true.
TheCameraEye1989 3 years ago 2
This is true.
TheCameraEye1989 3 years ago
Amen to that
tseekr379 3 years ago
I've said this before and i'll say it again, Roger waters is a freaking living legend who we are so lucky to have in our era.. just amazing 5/5
hefforda 4 years ago 6
you've got always something to say, man!
there is nothing to say
simply fantastic
bardauil 4 years ago
The Best
Xboxliv3 4 years ago
Rog...mate, you are the best
PiinkFloyd4ever 4 years ago
Roger Waters is the Best.
HashFloyd 4 years ago 2
she's hot! lol
salatatabaa 4 years ago 3
"bestest" :) great english man. by the way great video
salatatabaa 4 years ago
man that chick bugs me!!!! it sounded cool on the album but this brakes my balls.
Morttinen 4 years ago 2
agreed, bad acting! but the show is sweet
Dogma216 4 years ago 2
Agreed! I went down to germany to see this fucker, and that dumb southern American chick ruined the whole thing for me.
JasonLicklider 4 years ago
Jerry Hall is dreadful! Not just different from the original, she was in her own right aweful. The rest was brilliant as is usual for Mr Waters.
AndyPVale 4 years ago
IM GONNA BE THERE EARLS COURT 12TH MAY
daza1234567 4 years ago
THE BEST was jones beach newyork, i went there about 5 maybe 6 years ago , great time , best ever to tell the truth , im off to watch roger on the 12th may earls court this year , GONNA BE ANOTHER GREAT TIME , CHEERS FOR POSTING UR TUNES AND HAVING GREAT TASTE IN MUSIC , AND THANKS TO ROGER FOR LETTING ME HAVE SOMETHING GREAT TO LOOK FORWARD TO , love ya forever , i was also at the live8 concert , best in the world , them together again , ROGER AND FLOYDY FOREVER X
daza1234567 4 years ago
think you'll find this WAs Berlin, coz i was there with me dad, was fantastic. I'm goin to see him perform darkside of the moon in may, can wait.
liverpool, england.
nelzi80 5 years ago
Excellent performance!
Shift19 5 years ago
This is Roger Waters without Pink Floyd, and it's in Potsdam and not Berlin. Otherwise, great clip. I remember this show just after the wall fell.
JimTheUmp 5 years ago
Hi! It´s Berlin .. i have the full dvd and i extracted my self from it.
Frlecube 5 years ago
yup... its berlin... best concert EVA
AubThaMan 5 years ago
lol
postdamer platz is a place in berlin
oberon79 4 years ago
@JimTheUmp roger waters is pink floyd he wrote over 90 % percent of all there songs and i understand gilmours awesome guitar playing but if u had to go back intime and start pink floyd it could be donewith out david gilmour but not vice versa
lumix1444 1 year ago
@lumix1444 Are you fucking daft?...........I guess you never listened to albums before DSoTM. Because Waters only started really writing lyrics at Dark Side and after. Saucerful of Secrets, Atom Heart Mother, More, Obscured by Clouds, Ummagumma, Meddle. All the music on those albums are written mostly by Gilmour not Waters. So believe me it isn't Waters by himself it is the band as a whole. Even the albums of DSoTM and after the music was co written by David Roger AND Richard. So get your facts.
KissTheSky321 1 year ago
@KissTheSky321 I think you are the daft one. Roger was writing lyrics way before Dark Side; it's just from Dark Side onwards he wrote all of the lyrics. Plus how can you say all the music was written mostly by Gilmour before Dark Side?? Look at the song writing credits to albums like Saucerful, More and Obscured and you will see Waters has more than any other band member. I suggest you get YOUR facts straight!
xfilian1 1 year ago 2