When You Believe - Lani & Charice vs Rachelle Ann & Sarah

[tmdduqrns]

I believe Charice sang much better when she sang with so hyang. Lani failed to support Charice's voice. rather messed each others' character up since they have similar voice colors. I felt uncomfortable when Charice made thicker tone than usual. She could've made much clearer voice. :(

[bhebesha]

I don't want to compare..but I really LOVE Sarah & Rachelle VERSION, it was PERFECT...

Their VOICE were really AMAZING...DUET kung DUET...the BLENDING were PERFECT...

[matalinongkritiko]

sintunado naman si charice sa 1:27 to 1:29.//

dapat kasi hindi masyado nagpapasikat si charice na gusto sapawan si lani.//may dapat pa bang patunayan si lani?sinadya ni lani na hinaan ang boses niya kasi yun ang nire require ng isang duet performance.akala kasi ni charice siya lang mag- isa kaya yun sigaW ng sigaw.//gustong manapaw

[mikesalazar45]

@matalinongkritiko obviously bata pa siya diyan. hindi pa niya kayang icontrol yung voice niya masyado. husga ka lang kasi ng husga

[tinkerbelle808]

hanga ako sa apat na singers na yan.. bsta dto po sa kntang ito mas binigyan lng ni charice at lanie ng power ang knta, todo bigayyy as in...un nga lng wlang blending at nsapawan c lanie,pero ung version nila so powerful naaangat pwet ko sa taas ng boses nila hehehe.wla ako masabi mgagaling d best. kina sarah at rachel hndi nila nilabas ang powerful voices nila d2, relax lng ang pgknta nila,pati ako na nkikinig e narerelax sa smooth ng dating ng voices at blendingm gnda ng pgkaknta malinis..

[tinkerbelle808]

uuhhmmm, ky lanie at charice,ok din nmn, at alm din natin na tlgang my mga powerful voices ang mga eto at biritera,pero ung version nila d2,dko po maxado gs2 kc po hndi na naririnig boses ni lanie, nasapawan ni charice,tpos wlang blending and harmony,hndi nagbalance,ang importnte po kc pag my kaduet pakinggan nyo ang isat isa,pkiramdaman po at ikontrol ang voice pra swak at malinis pakinggan..pro dko po cnsabi na d cla mgaling..magaling po cla,, mga idols kopo nga yan cla po.. ty po. peace!!

[tinkerbelle808]

AAHHHMMM..sakin mas ok ang version nila sarah at rachel kc may blending at harmony,hndi cla ngpapasikatan sa isat isa,tamang timpla, ang lakas ng voice nila tamang timpla,galing ng volume control nila at vocal dynamics,kya d nila gano nilagyan ng power kc ginawa nila soft ung version nila..kc kng pareho nilang iPOwer ung voice nila pareho hndi na mgnda pkinggan, tama lng po ginawa balance, at alm din nmn ntin na my powerful voice din cla kinontrol lng nila d2 pra smooth pakinggan, hehehhe

[MrBesprenko]

walang boses si LANIE dto amp ahah may magling version nila sarah geronimo may blending pa

[MrBesprenko]

walang boses si LANIE dto amp ahah

[lhiz646]

wala na bang ibabanat ang boses ni sarah at rachel??? dinig lang sa butas ng pwit nila kanta eh.. pay pakanta kanta pa kc ng matataas na notes eh.. walang power,,walang harmony. nd ko rin gusto si cha at lani,walang blending.. taz,nd mganda ang dating... but if need ko pumili,,cha at lani pa rin cguro.

[reinaabeja100]

Me fascina muchas gracias.

[123buffylover]

charice and so hyang's version was the best

[alvindindo]

parang nasal ang boses ni charice dito...

[miumi2011]

parang pilit na pnapalaki ni charice yng boses nya. mas natural voice nya sa kantang "pyramid"

[tnuocca10]

mali b ko pro prang ung mga high notes ni charice d2 prng mga flat... meron bng pdeng mag explain... xe un higher higher nya dn dun s i believe prng mbaba din ang kuha...pkisgot po s mga mrunong s music...thnx

[john18824]

@tnuocca10 no offend me po ahh,,, kc po pag kenompare po natin ung present ngayun saka noon,, malaki na po ang pinagbago,,, malamang po kung maulit ito,, baka hindi na po gaya nito,,

[rowena824]

idol ko rin c lani..she's very professional..galing nilang dalawa,..charice ang miss lani!!mabuhay!

[losiadalin20]

no dynamics? i think mas nakaka angat cna lani at charice..kasi they are the best in the world....e yng dalawa? best of wat? philippines? mas maraming singer sa pilipinas indi lng cla...

[sophmore90]

Charice would destroy if she sang it today! She sang this song, what, when she was 15 years old. Most of these women are in there 20's. Charice is not even 20 yet, and she has already surpassed these ladies. Don't get me wrong, these ladies have beautiful voices, Charice's is just a few levels higher.

[charicesunshine]

My lucky ears hear 4 great voices

[mrjhojho92]

charice and lani have no dynamics... wahaha they are good in nature but.... till what?/till where??

i'll go with sarah and rachel...

[sselevol23]

ang CHAKA ni CHARICE!!!BANSOT!!!FEELING!!

[charisseLMB]

@sselevol23

excuse me?do u hear urself?

di ak makapaniwala n tlga may taong nag iisip tulad m ng gnyan...utak-dilis!

mahiya k s srili m ui...eh kaw?ano n achieved m s life m?hanggang tingin k nlng ky cha...

mamatay k s inggit hehehe...kung ak sau PAKAIN M NLNG PUTAY NANAY M S ASO!

[chocolatemontero]

@sselevol23 kahit chaka sa palagay mo... saan c charice ngaun? nagkkmal na dollars.. ikaw? puro ka panera. dapat sau sa m.

[mikobbyko]

dko nrinig ung boses ni lani..nsapawan ni charice

[millikam0811]

obviously shin and sarah's did a great rendition of the duet!!they owned it nailed it and rocked it!!!goosebumps!!!:)))))))))))

[millikam0811]

no comparisons...all singers are uniquely great!!!please change!!nakakahiya kayo!makikita ng mga foreign people na makakanuod nito how filipinos create arguments on who's the best in this the best in that!!come on!!wala nabang taong mababago pa yung mga ganyang ugali ng karamihan saten??ano ba?!magbago naman...

[nahnahfaith1018]

mas maganda ang kina sarah geronimo....

[deli238]

kamangha mngha ang boses ng bata na ito ay walang iba kundi si charice luv u cha.

[renbiendalla]

Charice and Sarah are both talented singers.. And I adore them both! I don't think that it is right for the people to compare them because they are entirely different individual...

[bretsarah0803]

charice cannot justify when she sang puro biret kya nga ...

d2 plang d ng tugma spaw ksi si charice... haha... gus2 nia xa lgi bida...

[pinaygemstone]

@bretsarah0803 ignorante halata wla kang alam hehehe

[deli238]

@bretsarah0803 hahaha nkktawa ka inday u're such an ignorante ewww cannot justify u n sarah ngongo flop prinses hahaha,, toink.

[MrLabyo]

as Charice matures...she gets better everyday....meron ba silang US Billboard200?

[deli238]

@MrLabyo meron po sila us quiapo porn board hahaha..

[aban357]

@deli238 wahahahahahahahahahah tang ina

[blackshadow122186]

@MrLabyo wala.. ^_^

[rpaduag]

Lani I cant hear you!!!!

[kirkfranz]

marami ngang napanalunan si sarah at sold out ang concert niya before na di pa sikat si charice pero ngayon siguradong langawin at lamukin siya dahil namamayagpag na si charice worldwide star!

[UKISSMEMariah92]

I think Charice and Lani are better singers individually, but Sarah and Rachelle did a better cover cause I think it's more original, cause I didn't hear Nippy and Mimi, I heard Sarah and Rachelle,... Damn!! Filipino are great singers, I wish I'd be Filipino in my next life,..

[75216367]

charice u rock

[lovepeacer13]

charice and lani is strong and powerful but rachelle and sarah's is sweet and soul-lke song,

but hey isn't that supposed 2 b d purpose?? sweet and gentle, its for Mrs. Aquino after all...

[whatever894]

yuck..charice sucks here...i say even if iyoure a very different singer from Mariah..you have to justify her song...even if you made it as yours...

[easyee28]

sarah and shin!!!

love u sarah!

[sOlidShinFan]

mxado NmaN n oByUz.....

xempre shin @ sarah.

[xrichellebordonesx]

c rachelle nanalo sa maraming international e c sarah sa pilipinas lang nag kakaawards.. votings pa labanan.... tinatadtad nya sariling votes nya, tama bang iboto ang sarili... wew walng kwenta fans mo sarah...... jologs kayu......

[mrjhojho92]

@xrichellebordonesx hoy nanalo rin c sarah sa ibang bansa at sya ang pinakamaraming awards sa mga singer,,.. sya ang my pinakamaraming concerts no sold-out here and abroad..>>.

[pacute234]

Sarah sucks Charice rulez :D

[naespyre25]

^_^

[mkazakshtan]

Pareho silang panget can't even sing the right note....mga baluga. lol

[hatpayp]

but given the same situation like rachel & sarah had nung kinanata nila ito i'm sure charice and lani would do equally good or better. (pra saan pa, they are recognized internationally). each performances varies on the situation and emotion they give. sarah and rachel had done a good job giving a tribute to d late Cory A.

[hatpayp]

it's not proper 2 compare ths, althou same song cla pro mlaking factor ung situation. sarah & shin- ngblend cla, ang light at soothing ng atake lalu ni shin. kac nga it was a tribute 2 d late Cory A. khit dmit nila ngcomplment, well prepared & well rehearsed. sa case nmn nila lani & cha, i think nung time na 2 binigyn cla ng recognition as int'l performr at naisipan lng bigla 2 hav a duet. obvious n binibagy ni lani un moment k cha kaya tuloy mukhng nanapaw c cha. khit dmit nila ndi tugma.

[sOlidShinFan]

rachelle ann go and sarah geronimo ang mgaling ndi cla ngtalbugan..........,bgayan lng kYa ang kNaLabasan mGanda

lot of Rnb........

[finally020809]

nakakahiya ang video na to for charice and lani kc pareho silang may experience na sa taste of Hollywood. mas maganda ang naging performance nina rachel and sarah dito kahit local singers lang cla doing several concerts abroad hindi lang sa US.

[musicheals091]

4:03 struggling

[gemmeboy]

SARAH GERONIMO IS THE BEST!!!!!

[DijMolay]

i love them all but my fave part is sarah's and rachelle's part.

[wilbert015]

haizzzzzzzz,,,mas maganda ang kina sarah and rachelle,,,,nagjejelly....

[panicatthediscofever]

wow.. ..

why the fuck are you bashing your own filipino artist? arent you supposed to be cheering for them and be proud you have these great singerss?...

.it made me think, why charice got popular in other foreign countries than in her own. country, ..

OTHER FOREIGN PEOPLE APPRECIATE's THE TALENT CHARICE POSSESS.

WHILE YOU GUYS ALL DO WAS BASH AND SHIT. .

[ymaoj06]

agree.

[CrUeTxEoo7]

you freakin' pack of charice haters should learn how to appreciate your own kind...you guys should really learn how to respect your own kind coz if you dont..what more to yourselves..plus..yu really should learn to not compare ones voice to another coz they are different..way to much different..they're both good..they just have their own specialty...

[cjay321990]

mas mgnda kla sarah and shin.

wla sapawan ska feel na feel ung kanta..

c cha ee nananapaw k lani..

sumabit pa xa sa 1:29.. d q lam kung na out of tune xa or wat.. mxado kc xa nananapaw..

d na npncn c lani..

mas gs2 q tlga ung kla shin and sarah kc ndi cla nagsapawan ska ndi showdown ang gnwa nla kundi duet..

[princeOFsfamsc]

pareparehas naman sila magagaling kaso lang hula ko mas na practice ung kay sarah and rachel kaya mas maganda kasi sa ibang bansa naka base si lani si charice naman palabas labas ng pinas both busy... btw VERY GOOD for both

[socialitte]

Sarah pang local..si charice pang global..ang layo......... charice my lalabas na USA album.... search FINGERPRINT-charice.....patiki m ni charice sa USA album nya....hhahahha...si Sarah..hangang STar records lng......gumising kau..support charice......mas malayo marating nya....si Sarah..hangang ASaP nlng yan at pa movie movie........ganun naman talga ka eh..pag la-os na sa singing career sa pelikula na babagsak para may kita...at kahit pano kiligin ang mga fans sa mga ka partner nya..aminin!

[newton]

hoi zaldy tanga kba.. ang pinaguusapan blending ng boses ndi ung lugar n npuntahan.. i agree nellerule.. ahm.. lhat kc cla idol ko..

but charice is overpowering the voice of her partner whnever she sings.. kea gnun..

sna maaus ng manager nia ung attitude n gnun n charice..

bestofluck s knlng lhat..

[neLLeruLeZ21]

rachelle and sarah....cuz ngblend ang mga voices nla...

si charice nananapaw kac...paring galit... im not against her... pero sana isipin nyang may kasama sya at mging professional sya... mas maayos kung ngcomplement ang voices nila ni lani...

charice, wag ka nmng mangaway... nxt tym ha!!!

[frostybryan]

sarah's and shin version much better

[zaldy1987]

oi grave nyo naman laitin si charice bkit ung mga idol nyo nkarating naba sa hollywood bka hanggang us lang cla.hahahahaha and beside bka nga di cla kilala ni opra bka pag nkita cla nung tao bka layuan cla at d cla kilala..

[marygrace27]

ay nako si lani mukhang bakla hahahah!!!

[abbelle008]

kawawa nman si lani...sinapawan ni Charice...

tsk...tsk...tsk...

[abbelle008]

naiinis ako sa nose ni lani...pero i like her voice...very powerful...but I like Sarah even better...mas magand syemps ung version nina Sarah and Rachelle...their voices really complements with each other...

[thopeng23]

Rachelle and sarah.. i like lani also!

[fanatic100806]

charice wag ka makipag aaway kumanta ka ...

rachelle and sarah ... love you version.... yan ang wala sapawan di katulda ng iba dyn ....

[babes0205]

sarah congatulations sa platinum award ng just me album mo and good luck sa the next one concert mo

[gurlash09]

sarah and rachelle version parang mga chuwawa girls! nyahahahaha!

[fanatic100806]

ikaw hayop ka...

[blackfish24]

shut up you brute

just watch and listen...

if you hated Sarah thats alright... she doesn't like you either :)

and don't waste your time viewing any of her videos no more... she doesn't need your reviews either :)

[babes0205]

masmganda po ung kina sarah..gudluck sa the next one concert mo

[biritbaby]

super ganda nung kay sarah and shin!

[martianlinz16]

sarah and rachelle is the best..c charice everytime na kumknta parang nkkpg away..

[fanatic100806]

korek ... paano para mapancin cia ewan ko ba bakit pa ginawan cia ng tribute sa asap

[frostybryan]

Im looking forward that sarah and rachelle will make there songs,that they will sing together in one album like mariah and whitney,I wish.

[frostybryan]

mas feel q ung kay sarah and shin mas kaka kilabot ang tono i feel the song commingfrom there heart

[AteReginedBEST]

you want a reliable reason why Sarah and Rachelle Ann's version is better?

First of all, Sarah and Shin's arrangement is different, secondly, they have more preparation and mastered the piece because they recorded it before singing it live! On the other hand, Charice and Lani's was based from the orinal arrangement since they only have few hours to rehearse. What do you think if Cha and Lani would use Sarah and Shin's arrangement? who would sound better?

[AteReginedBEST]

We know for a fact that Lani is a vocal genius that could easily blend her voice whoever she sings with, with a nice arrangement Sarah and Shin's will be left behind...if we're talking about "flaws" Sarah committed a lot of flaws in the high parts!!!

[fanatic100806]

flaws... mo muka mo

[jamelandi]

lam mu khit poh ung arrangement nung kay sarah and shin ung gamitin nila kung ganyan cla kumanta magsa2pawan lng sila!

and ung kay sarah and shin original version nila regine and lani un!

kya maganda tlga!

mala whitney and mariah!

d2 kay charice and lani pareho whitney kya parang nagsapawan cla!

[twinkyscarlet]

most DEFINITELY sarah's and rachelle's version was better. the best.

[28shioren]

woohoooooo,,

sarah at shin aku..

sarah geronimo and rachelle ann go are the best..

[iluvcharice]

both versions were good naman though i noticed na my mga sablay si charice,1:29-1:31 saka 1:45..peace!!

[cheche0527]

ung kay lani at charice, di nagblend ng maayos ung boses nila kc ayw mgpasapaw ni charice. ung kay rachelle and sarah, kumbaga, may teamwork, kaya mganda at msarap pakinggan.

[bretsarah0803]

@cheche0527 ate tma sinbi mue ... prng bgang laki ng voice ni charice ... hehe... d bgay...

[gstsby]

bakit laging ipit ang mukha ni Sarah tuwing umaawit, parang namimilipit,

[usagichan020]

mukha rin nman ni charice ahh..pra ngang itlog ehh ang bilog kay lani nman prang kabayo sa sobrang papabanat

[joonala8]

Galgal !!! Zip it you piece of shit !

[usagichan020]

oh ano na offend ka?

bkit die hard fan ka nila hahahahha

just stating the truth here biatch

[fanatic100806]

wala wala ... sa vewrsion ni sarah and rachelle yung kay lani at charice... mas may puso ... ang version ng poprincessat ultimatechampion take it from mS, kris Aquino... "nakakakilabot ... ibang kalasi ang ranged ng voice ni rachelle ann at sarah g.

yun lang thank you ...

[shinsolid]

tama si hallestorm!

[hallestorm]

both duets are great.. Charice and lani's version is d same as the original.. nothing new but superb.. but in sarah and rahcelle's.. new version and they gave justice to the song.. charice didn't hit the high note properly at 1:29-1:31.. listen carefully.. luv both but stil prefer sarah and rachelle's.. anyway mero powers to all of them..

[khookhtz2]

charice and lani

[fokfokfuta]

kitang kita nman ang kay lani at charice ay powerful at pang standing ovation tlaga, ang kila rachel at sarah, wlang effort, try mong pkanta kay lani at charice yan chicken, kay sarah at rachel kya, pig. ang mag react mamatay bukas kc kukulamin ko.

[fanatic100806]

ikaw ang baboy kasama ng lani at charice mo,,, sikat lang sa ibang bansa pero dito hinid

si sarahrachelle sikat kahit saan... hayop ka ...

[joonala8]

Galgal !!!

[fanatic100806]

gago ... mamatay kana

[joonala8]

Piece of shit ! Why don't u make a finger & stick it to your ass ! fuckin' idiot !!!

[fanatic100806]

thnak bussterd.

[m1vin]

for the version and arramngement paaalo si sarh and rachelle ann...but i just love lani misalucha...the 4 singers are really good...

[ChariceMix]

Lani & Charice Better

[TrUpNaY28]

DEFINITELY SARAH AND RACHELLE ANN's version is WAYYYY better.. No questions asked!

[bretsarah0803]

@TrUpNaY28 tammmaaaah!...