Added: 3 years ago
From: laaabama
Views: 68,715
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (93)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is my favorite song of all times, i always ask myself why Martina don't record this song, no other will never perform this song like her, besides of course Tammy,.. i still waiting for that cd, please..

  • Comment removed

  • I remember watching this on TV. I'm a huge rock music fan, but I actually like some country. :)

  • That was AMAZING ! NO ONE has does this ANY better since Tammy then Martina, NO ONE ! Sorry, it's fantastic, love, LOVE Martina's voice !

  • Girl, the hottest eyes on earth! Man!

  • Carrie uses a vocalizer and alway s has even with her star rise band ..... DOH

  • TRULY not a bad word you can say about Martina, she is the ORIGINAL powerhouse of Country Music & still proven to be unbeaten. Among the many things to love about Martina is her genuine personality and how much she truly appreciates the great women of Country Music than came before her. NO ONE sings a tribute like this woman. She is a legend herself who broke many barriers down for the women of "todays" country music.

  • @Sam7svu Can you two not argue? Seriously. Carrie Underwood and Martina McBride are both outstanding vocalists. They have both made history in Country Music and they are both very current powerhouse females in the genre. Carrie and Martina do not need to be compared.. they really are incomparable. They are both extremely talented and easily the two most talented women in the format. I have heard them both live, and they both sound just as good live as on albums. Both deserve every award.

  • @92Lyss Who am I arguing with? No one. Giving praise to Martina, no where did I mention Carrie. Carrie isn't in this video so why would anyone mention her??

  • My favorite tribute...

  • Also, do you not know how CRAZY well Carrie's past tour (2010) did? So much so that they needed to ADD a bunch of dates since they were all selling out so quickly? When was the last time that Martina had to do that? LOL, so much for Carrie's "15 minutes expiring." I knew you were getting desperate from your "bride of chucky" comment, but now I see that you've moved on to completely talking out of your ass. Carrie achieved more in 2010 than Martina has in the past decade. #Delusional

  • @mellynumerounoo Yeah - I read the reviews by critics which usually complained about her pitchy vocals and the unclarity in her vocal delivery of the lyrics. Martina has sold out many times in the same venues - and again you cannot compare a 20 year career to a 3 year career. I am not desperate as you are the one making personal attacks. Carrie will never achieve more than Martina - as Martina has had way more firsts and groundbreaking impact on music - its in the history books.

  • @mewc402 3 year career? Wow. Not only are you embarrassingly unfamiliar with some of the most common idiomatic expressions in the English language, you're also terribly bad at math. This is now going on year 6 for Carrie, and she STILL got an additional 3 #1s under her belt just from last year. Try again. I see that playing "make believe" is the only way that you can muster up any chance of"winning" these arguments in your own delusional little mind. You just keep digging the hole for yourself.

  • @mewc402 Nope, actually the first "personal attack" was launched by YOU. In describing Carrie's ability to easily hit a particular note that Martina struggles with, I referred to it as "child's play," and you stooped down to a 4th-grader mentality and said what you did. Not only do you have all of your facts wrong, you're just such an overly tacky and immature debater that you can't even tailor your bullshit assertions in any way that could make them appear even remotely valid. You're a joke.

  • @mellynumerounoo Can you two not argue? Seriously. Carrie Underwood and Martina McBride are both outstanding vocalists. They have both made history in Country Music and they are both very current powerhouse females in the genre. Carrie and Martina do not need to be compared.. they really are incomparable. They are both extremely talented and easily the two most talented women in the format. I have heard them both live, and they both sound just as good live as on albums. Both deserve every award.

  • @mewc402 Your comments are starting to reek of desperation now. Resorting to ad hominem attacks, "she could play the next bride of Chucky"? LMAO. If I wanted to get personal with Martina, I could have mentioned that triple chin she gets from opening her mouth so damn wide to hit a high note that she practically has to unhinge her freaking jaw. Looks painful. Also, Carrie's lowest note is actually lower than Martina's. Martina's is an Eb3. Carrie's is a D3. Clearly you know NOTHING about notes.

  • @mellynumerounoo Her karaoke version of Martina's groundbreaking music. Carrie's music is unforgettable melodically and lyrically. I never commented on CU appearance. Again - you mentioned CHILD'S PLAY not me - it relates to her less than stellar acting not her looks. But since you mentioned it - she has no upper lip and bad veneers on her teeth. Anyone can sound good in the studio including CU with a good engineer and autotune - You don't know the range of Martina's ability - impossible.

  • @mewc402 Martina's music is anything but groundbreaking, and sadly she hasn't actually written any of the songs that had the great impact in her career. LOL @ you attributing Carrie's sounding good in the studio to "a good engineer and autotune"...right, that's why 9/10 critics who've seen Carrie when she's in tip-top shape (hell, even when she's SICK) point out that she's one of the few singers in this day and age that actually sound just as good if not BETTER than they do on record.

  • she is in a class of her own and certainly belongs with the great country female country legends she is one

  • Martina BLEW that song out of the water!!!!

  • Now THIS is what I call country music !!!! This brought tears to my eyes, it was so beautiful ! All I can say is : WOW !!!

  • Only Martina could sound better than Tammy!

  • Tammy would have loved Martina paying tribute to this song!!

  • Es una excelente versión. Pero hallo más intensa la de Carrie.

  • She is the only artist who should have performed this, since Tammy has passed.

  • There will NEVER be another Martina... ever. She is golden.

  • Comment removed

  • I love this version of this song. She totally rocks!! And I love Martina's hair this way too. :)

  • Still 1 of the purist voices I've ever heard. She's in the top 5 for best female singer of all time.

  • go martina! awesome tribute to tammy! rock on!..

  • Beautiful, the Singer and the Song! Nobody does it better than Martina.

  • Martina is one of those very few that sound just as great in person as they do on a recording. Martina can really hit those notes. She absolutely belongs among the ranks of Dolly, Loretta, Tammy, Reba, Connie, Kitty, and the many other legendary women of country.

  • @wildwesternman Definitely - but Miss McBride is in another class vocally from those women you mentioned

  • Wow! Great song and rendition. 

  • What a sweety

  • AMAZING! Gotta love Martina McBride

  • Great job by the industries best female voice of today. Martina ranks right up there with Tammy, Loretta and Patsy. She is much better than the hip hoppers and the rap crapers! She is talented, country and adorable. She is at the pinnacle and what many strive to be. Love ya Martina!

  • @RealDare2 ...Absolutely...couldn't have said it any better myself..

  • I'm not a big McBride fan - but she sure kicks ass on this song. It's hard to duplicate the great Tammy Wynette - but this ain't bad at all.

  • She has a great voice... Better than Tammy's.

  • shes the shit!!

  • Hey people! She did really good, so stop arguinning and enjoy the video. ( I know I spelt arguinning wrong but o well) haha

  • I am a big fan of some of the classic country singers - but in some cases somebody comes along that does it even better than the original; and this is the case on this one - I just think it is ironic that is happens to be with her singing the "#1 Country Song of all time". I'd be willing to bet from the ovation that some others would agree. The picked the right person for the tribute.

  • Outstanding vocal - the best rendition I've ever heard of this song, outside of Tammy!

  • Carrie is probably my favourite but i have to say i think Martina is a better singer. Love them both though! Martina does so great on this.

  • Martina is the best female country singer, period. Better than Loretta, Reba, etc. Maybe even Patsy Cline. I even like this version better than Tammy's because she doesn't punctuate the words, just lets the song flow.

  • She is the best who are you to judge you dont know anything about music

  • yeah

  • i agree volleyballchick!! haha, nobody can beat martina, i love volleyball too!! i play back row =)

  • Don't take anything personally, Carrie- NOBODY can EVER beat Martina! Even when they do have as much experience as her!

  • @volleyballchick15luv; Except maybe Tammy!

  • @volleyballchick15luv there are/were better singers than martina

  • In my opinion... Martina McBride has an especial voice... She sings in natural way, simple but beautiful... She is a true artist... She doesn`t compare with Carrie Underwood... Martina is much better than her... I´m a musician... I know of this... Greetings from Perú.... Juan Carlos

  • Your not clearly listen to both you are clearly a moron

  • Comment removed

  • LOL. Martina has a much better technique than Carrie, but no doubt, Carrie can belt out higher notes than her. I agree that Martina is a better overall singer, though.

  • Why is a comment that states a simple FACT thumbed down?? lmao.

  • great song and impressive performance.

  • Best tribute version, Martina is the best vocalist I have ever heard. She is the only one I know of that can sing ANYTHING and have it sound so amazing. She can go from Journey's songs to Garth Brooks songs and every one is done to perfection. Martina is the true entertainer of every year! Talent like that is hard to come by these days.

  • I'm a Carrie fan, but face the truth.  Martina outsang her.

  • @bigbird88 Isn't it concensus, even within the country artist community, that Miss McBride is the ultimate voice in country music ! takes a backseat to no one when it comes to singing- You better be pretty damn good if just want to take the stage with her~

  • @roselandalvin well said, well said.

  • @bigbird88 Of course Martina outsang her...Martina didn't have a sinus infection when she did her version lol. Carrie's done other performances of this song on tour that were AT LEAST as good as Martina's.

  • @mellynumerounoo This is the excuse given by fans of Carrie regarding every performance. Is she permanently sick or what? Even when Martina is sick she can stay in tune and control of her voice. Let's face the facts. Carrie has a pitchy voice. Her voice lacks depth, warmth, tonal quality and control. She is a product of American Idol & the recording studio. I cringe when I think of the recent performance with Steven Tyler. Her voice was weak and tiny compared to his on "Walk this way".

  • @mewc402 -wrong answer buzzer- I've heard Martina crack and go out of tune SEVERAL times, even when NOT being sick. In fact, she almost always goes out of tune at some point during "Where Would You Be," especially in the last chorus when the key changes and she needs to belt those C#s (which is a very EASY note for Carrie, mind you). and actually yes, Carrie DOES have chronic issues with her sinuses. Her mother mentioned this back in 2005 on a special.

  • @mellynumerounoo Huh? Martina rarely goes out of tune more importantly she does have her "mommy" make public escuses for her. In addition, Martina's catalog of music and the back to back performances of Where Would You Be, Broken Wing, Whatever You Say and Independence Day could not be performed by any other singer today. Yes, I do agree with you Carrrie has chronic issues with her vocals and absolutely lacks any lower register thus her performances are flat & limited to inaudible upper noise

  • @mewc402 "Weak and tiny"? LMFAO. That's because they practically turned her mic off once he came out. Any idiot could have told you that. You know what the proof is in? The fact that when they were singing together into the SAME mic, his voice was completely inaudible. Why is it that when the playing field was leveled to where both of their voices were evenly amped, she drowned him out? You've obviously seen very few Carrie performances for you to NOT know that that girl has a huge voice.

  • @mellynumerounoo There is probably good reason they turned down her mic - she is incapable of singing in tune! Face the fact! Her singing is undecipherable. Believe me - I have suffered through many CU performances and the butchering of many great songs. The positive thing is her 15 minutes of fame have expired. Her long career of 3 years is winding down as she makes appearances in "B" movies and sells make-up on TV. I am sure they will rehire her as a server at Chilli's back in Oklahoma.

  • @mewc402 Right, they turned her mic down "because she can't sing in tune" yet awarded her the "Female Vocalist Of The Year" award 3 consecutive years in a row. You're really grasping at straws right now and it's hilarious to watch. The petty "bride of chucky" comment wasn't enough. & her 15 minutes have expired? Then why did she achieve 3 more number 1s just last year? Did Martina even get ONE? lmao. You're a joke. It's obvious now that you just have a personal axe to grind.

  • @mellynumerounoo You should be smart enough to know awards mean nothing. They have become nothing more than paying off the right people and record sales. Talent, work ethic, longevity, & being a good entertainer no longer have anything to do with it. You brought up "CHILDS PLAY". Sorry that her career is on the downswing. CU has had a three year career - Martina a 20 year career - there is no comparison. Without Martina - there would be no Carrie. She was only noticed because of her karoke

  • @mewc402 Once again, you're talking out of your ass. Do me a favor and post one of these reviews in which the critic complained of "pitchy vocals." I can guarantee you that for every ONE negative review that you post, I can post 20 outstanding reviews. Once again, it's MORE than apparent that your assessment is anything but objective and that you have a personal axe to grind at her expense. Oh, and in case your dumbass didn't know: "child's play" is also a figure of speech--not just a movie.

  • @mewc402 I'll concede that Martina does indeed project her voice better and has a much better vocal TECHNIQUE than Carrie. However, Carrie has far more natural ability, both in terms of vocal range and vocal flexibility. Even with better technique, Martina starts straining quite a lot on D5. Sometimes when she belts the final "man you OUUUUUUUUUUUUUGHTA see her" in "Broken Wing," it sounds like one of her lungs is going to home flying out of her mouth. For Carrie, a D5 is CHILD'S PLAY.

  • @mellynumerounoo At least we agree on one thing - Martina projects her voice better and has better vocal technique than Carrie. I would continue to argue Martina has better tonal quality to her voice. Carrie may be able to sing higher but her range is more limited. She cannot sing the low notes at all. I also agree that sometimes it does sound like Martina might loose a lung. However, the closest thing that Carrie has to CHILD'S PLAY is looking like she could play the next bride of CHUCKY.

  • Comment removed

  • She's the best.  Wow! Awesome!!

  • WOW! That Last Part Was UNBELIEVABLE! Martina Is TOTALLY AWESOME!

  • Carrie Underbite? Smoke some more crack....Underbite isnt even worthy enough to adjusts Martina's microphone!

  • LMFAO, underbit?? you just HATIN'.

  • This woman is in a league of her own!! :)

  • Martina McBride can sing any song and make it her own. Because why else is she compared to the Celine Dion and 4x CMA Female Vocalist She sure beat Carrie Underwood and Carrie Idolizes this hot country queen.. I mean who wouldnt with a million dollar angelic voice like hers and the beauty that can knock any boy or man off there feet.... damn she sure has a voice!

  • Tammy Wynette is fucking amazing, Martina is probably the best to sing this as a tribute to Tammy. (:

  • Agreed! Martina's is my favorite cover of this song.

  • amazing is the only word for this performance

    martina is an amazing singer

  • SHE ROCKED THIS!

  • Martina does a great job with this song but noone can compare to Tammy! She sang it with such ease and such....heart everyone else can only help to imitate!

  • She did a damn good job!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more