Added: 3 years ago
From: dilshan34
Views: 51,998
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (242)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • While he had a good enough voice i don't think he was strong enough to go through. He prob would have made it as far as bootcamp but then would have got sent home.

  • O shit, he got a new t-shirt!

  • That was so sad. 3 years of work on attitude image and voice gone to waste. I teared a bit. I can't imagine what he felt.

  • I think Simon influenced Cheryl a lot in her decision. She says at 3:45 that she 'really likes him' and then says that he isn't good enough. She is also looking at Simon when he asks her for the decision. I think Simon was harsh.

  • Cheryl is hottttt! Her accent is sexy!

  • Cheryl is so sexxxxxy!

  • Did he come back after 2008?

  • I actually feel sorry for him I was about to cry had tears in my eyes

  • compassion is you put yourself in the other

  • His voice was very good. Better than mine totally. But I agree with Simon and Cheryl, it would have hurt even more for him if they put him through

  • Comment removed

  • Don't forget the tie!

  • why didnt they give him a chance?

  • he didn't talk about next round. he should be given a chance

     i'll categorize cheryl' voice in dog's

  • i lave cheryl

  • This proves that being a judge is not easy, because you have to put your emotions aside to be able to be objective; which is very very hard to do.

  • Cheryl is so beautiful...... :O

  • Cheryl is so beautiful...... :O

  • hehehe! trying to convince a woman with a "please", she was about to say yes but when she heard that got the perfect excuse :-D Loser.

  • Cheryl is such a good judge! I love the fact that she didn't just give him the pity vote.

  • lol - Simon takes so much crap from a lot of these contestants 0:38

  • Any guy will gave him a small chance

  • he needed a chance,

    

  • she just looked like she ran over a dog she looked so sad.

  • lol craig armstrongs soundtrack from layer cake

  • @someoneON I knew I recognized it! Love that movie!

  • I think this guy deserves a chance !

    But Cheryl is still incredibly beautiful!!!!!

  • thats why i think paula would be a good judge! when she was drunk it was yes, when she had a hangover it was a yes, when she was clean it was a no... THATS WHY SHE ALWAYS SAID YES!

  • Wat cheryl talkin about like she can sing i would put her in my dogs voice catogeory and yet shes a singer she cnt sing live for shit

  • @solid786snake Now that's a little harsh, I've heard her sing live and granted she's not the greatest out there but she can sing live, i think she actually took a Heart song on and nailed it, i can't remember if it was Alone but she nailed it i do remember that

  • I wanna know the song of the 3:09 pls tell me!!!!!!

  • @SerdaruIonutOfficial Mika - Happy Ending

  • Seriously ? He has that desire of motivation to change, I think cheryl is one fucked up bitch. He's begging for a change, he DID change during those 3 years, he cleaned his image and his attitude, yet simon ( the dick whore that he usually is ) obviously says no, and the girl in the middle regrets her decision couple of seconds after she says no. Thats no professionalism judging, that's pure amateur and cold. You can't judge 1000 people with one person, each indvidual is special.

  • @TheNewStoryLine They did him a favour, if they put him through he had no chance of ever winning or even going to next round, it is a shame he put in so much effort but some things just aint meant to be. they were right to do it, otherwise they just give the guy false hope, maybe he can channel his energies into something more suitable, instead of returning each year hoping to improve somewhat.

  • @TheNewStoryLine The point is he dosen't have IT. Would going to bootcamp really have made him fulfilled ??? It's best that his X Factor journey ended the way it did...gracefully.

  • @TheNewStoryLine He only changed because he saw how grotesque he looked on tele back in 2005.

  • Comment removed

  • Poor lad, he is so nice but i guess Cherly does have a point!

  • @fireflylight1000 He can just hold a tune, that is all. No Star Quality.  No Charisma. No Vocal Artistry. Just a man trying to redeem himself from his infamous rant in 2005.

  • dumb bitch cheryl hasn't seen 1000's of shit, producers see all the hordes of people and separate the cattle. only problem was they sent him through again hoping for a similar reaction to his previous audition, but they got a changed man who worked hard for something he believed to be attainable once he got to the judges. shame they had to take that away from him, but thats show biz i guess.

  • However....she's got a good point. It'd be bad to say yes now, and then he gets sent home right after.

  • @mario54671 Yeah true, he came from the North-East afterall and would have to go to London for bootcamp. Sod that !!!

  • I feel really bad for him. Yeah the guy wasn't amazing...but he wasn't bad. I think they're looking for stage presence more...since Justin Bieber and Taylor Swift don't have amazing voices..they just seem to have stage presence and were marketed well. But it's kind of sad that they let through that spanish girl before when Sharon Osbourne was still on the show, and then this guy isn't let through.

  • He´s not bad at singing, If he wants to sing he should start up a band instead of going to a singing competition. I think his voice and his attitude is ok for a rock or a pop band but not for a pop star.

  • nicely said man

  • it wasnt bad at all

  • Simon is right, a very average voice, no range, depth, or artistry.

    He be better doing cabaret or musicals, he dosen't have the STAR QUALITY to be a popstar.

    Whatever vocal training he's had it certainly improved his voice but only slightly, it certainly sounds BRIGHTER than it did 3 years ago. But that is all.

    The performance itself was very dull, you can tell from it that he does not have STAR QUALITY or ever will.

  • at 4:48 cheryl does the sweetest face ever!!!!!!!!

  • I would of said yes, but Cheryl is a really good judge and she's so true.

    But he had worked for 3 years so I would of said yes but only out of the kindness not out of fairness.

    Poor guy felt really sorry for him when he said "Please.." so sad :(

    Cheryl, best judge♥

  • when the judges say yes or no, it sounds like a movie with the music and stuff..it's like the anthony guy proposed to cheryl and she doesnt wanna give him another chance cuz he like cheated or something..:P this is so irrelvant! sorry!!

  • I get where the judges are coming from, because his voice may be okay, but he obviously has a lot of trouble maintaining the tone and stuff like that... I feel sorry for him cuz he obviously made a lot of changes for the better, but Cheryl was right, there's no way he would've gotten past the 2nd round...

  • He really wasn't that bad. Especially for today's radio standards.

  • At least this time he took it like a men..well almost

  • i just don't understand why cheryl and simon said no. Anthony is a damn good singer and he deserved yes from them.

  • He worked so hard for 3 years...changed his "image and everything". his voice has improved like 5%, he lost 4 stone? pfff looks more like 1 stone max. And he shaved his head and bought a different t-shirt, right?. An average person could do all those things within a month ez-mode. And stop crying you twat, the good news is you're very mediocre, but not awful, and out of shere pity, next year they may let you through to the next round, where you undoubtedly will find your waterloo then.

  • what's the name of the song at the end??

  • Well said Simon. He is a walking bag of mediocrity

  • His singing is all good, the image bollocks is bullshit though he still looks like a complete prat

  • @Ihatemyusernamemore His singing wasn't that good, very boring actually, no spark.

  • Fuckk cheryl & semon!! whats there to say YES??? damnn They destroyed his life!!!

  • cheryl is not a good judge at all... it would have been so easy to make this guy happy just giving him a yes for working hard for 3 years but she takes her job too serious...whatcha gonna do?!?! fuck this world!!!!

  • I thought he was really good...

  • Fair play to chez though for being honest and puttin him thru and not givin him false hope, when he probs wouldnt of got past boot camp! Her and Simon are theee best judges on there, so honest love um both!!!!!!!! <3

  • :( give him a chance :( please!

  • Cheryl

    is so dramatic.

    she has put people through before that weren't so good, but she said with training.. they could be better.

    This guys one of them.

    so has also put people through just because Simon would say yes, and she played devils advocate for a bit.

    give the man a chance . jeez.

  • @wwegurl101 wot do u mean give him a chance he had a chance right here and is deffinetly not good enough

  • @wwegurl101 He's voice is to fragile to be trained so hard in a few week.

    He will loose he's voice in one of the live shows and he alreaddy can't hit the high note's.

    That's a diffrence.

  • go back to sainsburys !

  • Damn i feel sorry for him! He's grown so much from the inside. How he took that 'no' from the her...Amazing. Really really impressed. Grown a lot from inside. +50 respect points=max lol.

  • This guy should have had a yes after 3 years of hard work!

  • He was alright at first (from what I saw) and now he's better. With the right music behind him it's perfect.

  • OMG... cheryl is so fucking gorgeous

  • I totally agree with Louis!!Cheryl must give him a chance...!!

    His voice it's good,but needs the right training....!!He tried so hard and with so much agony to persuade Cheryl...and she just ignored him!!

    and btw Cheryl's voice it's not better...than Athony's!!

  • @tsitsijoker I agree, if only he could have had a chance. I feel sorry for him, I really do.

  • hahahah when he took off the dress! hahahahah and come up with that t-Shirt

  • omgshhh lmao simons eyes when anthony walked in hahhahahahahahah louis face when he took his clothes off lmao

  • LMAO, the way Simon looks at the guy when he walks in. Like he's completely suprised to see him back.

  • He's not terrible, he actually has some really great moments in this song, but he is fairly average.

  • Cheryl didn't give him a chance because he doesn't looks as good as for example Joseph. A litle bit unfair...

  • Sorry about this, But is there a video of him in 2005?

    Thanks.

  • average voice indeed....so stubbern brat!

  • i agree with louis. I mean sure he would have been disappointed later...but for all that work he's done...he definitely deserved a little chance. Then he could have learned something and come back. They didn't even give him advice. He's not a terrible singer. He actually has a voice, he just sang a completely wrong song.

  • needs counselling sessions, not voice coaching

  • he isnt that bad just abit training

  • Well done Cheryl

  • Fail,that guy seriously fails. Hes ruined my day.

  • If he really has the X Factor, he will realize that one more year of training his ass off with a voice coach and getting all delusions out of his mind, working on his weak points, that he can come back and definitely make it through. THAT is what the X Factor is all about. The greatest men on earth were most often the biggest failures for a very long time.

  • cry fat boy cry!!! ya cant sing ya numpty!!

  • @dubmurphy LOL!

  • well i thought this would be kind of funny.... but its kinda sad so im outa here.

  • She did what was right. He wouldn't have made it. She made it hurt right there instead of later on.

  • he turned in to a ok guy into a skinhead nice voice tho

  • first he said he lost 3pounds then 4.5.... anyway he is a psycho! One of those who explode one day and kill 12 people in the supermarket.

  • He has to realise that there is more to life than the X factor.

  • fairly good voice. but he was straining at some points. i think he was a bit too nervous

  • Which song is that at the end?

  • @valerio2006 the song name is Happy ending

  • My Step Brother! He Tryed So Hard, i really think cheryl could of given him that chance, he wud of tryed better than some of the others! Yea maybe he would of got kicked out of boot camp but at least he would of got threw one stage! He really had changed, Lovee you anth bruv! xxx

  • I remember this. In the same series they had that stupid Shirley who had a crush on Louis and all but Simon said yes to her. Anthony wasn't that bad. He spent 3 years trying to perfect his voice yet Shirley probably only spent 3 seconds perfecting her voice. It's cruel, wrong and unfair to do that to people.

    Cheryl is a bitch in this and must have pigshit for brains.

  • Not an exceptional voice, but he definitely has a better look and attitude than 3 yrs. ago. He'd be good in theatrical musicals, not necessarily as a pop star.

  • i thought he's actually a pretty good singer, nothing special, but good enough to get to boot camp

  • Cheryl is a really good judge

  • cheryl is a bitch

  • @cmpunky I agree 100%.

  • @cmpunky agree totally

  • @cmpunky wats the song at the end dude

  • @09liban not sure mate, sorry

  • @cmpunky its ok

  • @09liban mika i think.... happy ending.. check that one

  • is this real ? or are they all great actors ?

  • its real man

  • dayum, all that drama

  • She said "i have to be true ta me self" lmao,

  • Urmmm...

    Its Audition not Adution.

  • @BigJ378

    Spell check mothafucka.

  • Thanks for that?

    Its like in a few years time lifes gna be so slangy that x factor is gna be 'adtnng'

  • "I lost 4 stones"..what is that in kilos?

  • 25 kilos

  • Drama queen

  • it's not the end of your life

  • @blackwarb

    No but 2012 is.

  • lol doubt that:)

  • He is such an inspiration to so many people, bt it would have been unfair 2 put him through to the nxt round and let him think that he could go even further wen he cudnt xo

  • 2:24 LOL.... so he shaves his head, & wears a chain... he looks like a YMCA reject

  • 1:41 LOL

  • No, Anthony! Those three years weren't for nothing... so you didn't get through on "X Factor". Pfft. You've still come so far and you've earned SO much respect. Your spirit, your motivation, the incredible progress you've made. It's really inspiring. You've got such strength. Most people don't even have it in them to make progess like that. I really, really admire you and I hope one day I'll be able to reach the level of self-improvement you have achieved. Never stop!

  • Im a big fan

  • dont give up! Im a big fan!

  • I'm Sorry I go wright in Portuguese, Foi a primeira vez que vi alguem injustamente excluido. A ti Anthony se algum dia conseguires ler isto, Felicito-te pela tua preserverança e digo-te além de teres uma boa voz, poderias ter também tido a oportunidade. Por vezes as pessoas tem o poder na mão e julgam poder fazer o que querem dos outros.

    Lamento mas quem saiu a perder não fos-te tu, foi quem não conseguiu ter a coragem de te dizer sim.

    Obrigado

  • OOOOMG!! How could she say NO to that face!! u_u

  • kldasjkas'dkl;askl;dklasd asd asd asd asd

  • He is right, with the right training he could do it

  • bullshit Cheryl !!! you people make me ill whats wrong with giving some one at least 1 chance...good onya Louie !!! least someone has a heart !!

  • Bullshit what Simon said. "At the end of the day it comes down the voice" That's so hypocritical of him to say that. He puts tons and tons of average people through mainly girls who he thinks are attractive but can hardly sing. This guy deserved a chance for coming back and improving on everything. Bullshite

  • simon knows that the guy have a good voice but he wants to show him that I RULE ..

    and cheryl is BITCH

  • WTF? the guy voice is very nice but softly.

    they past many idiot voices and this guy no? Cherry would say yes yesterday she told me that. x) Stpuid

  • cum on cheryl u let shit ppl through cos they r nice hes gud and u say no

  • cheryl is the worst donno y they got her.

  • idiot idiot idiot!!! LET THE GUY THRU U FREAKS.

  • lol yeah cheryl is right...he actually wants to win..so it would have been hard for him if he got booted out in the next round..unlike other ppl she put through like that old guy...its cos he was old and loveable and probably arnt that serious about winning the competition.

  • still even so thats no excise Naruto...old and lovable dont cut it...

  • how is she, she is right it would have been harder for him in the next round and they say no ! she was right to say no

  • yh but he worked for 3 years in 2005 no cuzz of his attitude but he has improves the voice i think.

  • cheryl said yes to some people just coz they're sweet, they're nice but at least he has decend voice here and she turned him down and said no. hmmm.. btw, what's the song at the end?

  • omg fucking cherryl BITCH FUCK U !

  • She wanted him and he turned her down the bitch...She never forgave him. Dam it! Whaaaaaaaaaaa Whaaaaaaaaaaa

  • she is a bitch ;)

  • Iam so sorry for this guy poor man

  • if he were handsome the bitch would have said yes.

  • POOR MAN

  • How was she been a bitch :s, she was been true to herself and she was right, if she did put him through to the next stage it would be harder coz he would of probs got sent home so that would of been harder then just gettin a no in the audition, she wasnt been a bitch at all xo

  • Bitch!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • cheryl is sucha bitch here. she said yes to shirley (the old lady who had a crush on louis) n here she says no.

  • because they don't see all the acts.

  • that was awfull to watch.. poor guy..

  • how does simon remember these people??? out of so many contestants

  • because the producers inform the judges of each contestant. obviously, simon was informed of anthony and reminded that he had seen him before.

  • lol yeah i swear they dont actually remember these ppl, its the producers who tell them oh this person came on before and when they come on, ohhh yes i remember you lmao...i think its put on

  • Comment removed

  • lllllooooooooooooooooooooossss­eeeeeeerrrrrrrr jajajajajajajajajajajajajajaja­jajajajajajajajajajajajajajajA­jajajajajajajajAJAJAJAJAJAJAJA­JJAJAJAJAJA...je

  • Well, it's neither Simon's nor Cheryl's fault that he couldn't get through, as she said it wouldn't be right towards him either..

  • I think his voice is OK, though I do think that he picked the wrong song. I don't know what he might sound good at, but I'm sure a carefully selected song that exhibits his strengths would have probably got him through this round.

  • Antony spent to much time on his image then on making his voice better

  • cant get enough of luis walshs face at 5:56 dno why so sad :(

  • ooh...That's harsh.

  • I really don't get why people are getting angry at Cheryl. This guy used three years improving himself just so he could make Simon proud. He thanked Simon and said that he was right about him, and then Simon is all cold and crushes his dream for lifetime

  • lui feels for him!

  • I feel so sorry for this guy. He deserved a chance

  • i liked cheryl alot b4 i saw this, not anymore lol shes hot but not nice :(

  • What???

    She's being nice, she would be giving him false hope if she said yes, He would have gotten further in the competition with alot more hope and confidence, but then when compared to an amazing singer he'd suck.

  • as luis said to simon he could been giving hope, now three years wasted, atleast if he got further he wouldn´t lost the 3 years... poor guy, i mean its nothing for simon but if he is so cold cheryl could give him a chance, i mean comon

  • Simon isn't cold. He acts that way because he gets paid to be like that, it's good for the publicity. He was a bad singer and shouldn't have gotten through. He didn't.

  • I think he was good. who cares if he did not make it today. if he really wants this that bad, he would achieve the dream one way or another. X-factor is not the only way. he shouldn't let the judges put him down. dreams come true if you work hard .. just don't give up .

  • This guy sings good, in our country he would have won for sure, we aint got huge talents here and he is good

  • what's the name of the song that plays at 6:01???

  • There IS more to life than X Factor! The way people get on is as if it's the end of the world ALTHOUGH I didn't think he had a bad voice - just lacked power, but with training it could become more powerful!

  • Poor guy. This is his dream