I'm not from Hong Kong but please do not lose this battle. If everything is direct-elected, everything will be controlled. You can see what's happening in China. Yes cities like Beijing and Shanghai is prosperous but you do not see what these 2 cities shadowed the hundreds region in China that is suffering because of the impotent communist government that cannot even manage their other region filled with bribes and power abuse crippled the development and lead to resident suffering.
There is no accountability for those picked by the central gov't.They only listened to the central gov't & don't care the wishes from the citizen of Hk.
There is no accountability for those picked by the central gov't.They only listened to the central gov't & don't care the wishes from the citizen of Hk.
They should create online polls that allow participants to record their opinions of this referendum. Participants should be allowed to change their survey answer whatever and whenever they like. 7/24 available secure computer in shopping malls suburbs transit stations libraries ... cellphone ... to show real time survey and index them close to second and let the world to learn from Hong Kong.
She is one of the councillor really working for the true benefits of HK citizen,unlike lot of other useless ones sitting there barking for their own interests
Congratulation Tanya. What you are doing isn't easy especially you were given a choice. Full support from HK public. Keep up the good work, and hope to see a positive outcome.
the civil party is going to lose many votes in the next election. Its supporters are not those who would go for extreme. Many of them are professionals themselves and would not support anyone who do things only with passion but do not think deeply enough.
Universal suffrage elections and Democracy will come to Hongkong and China eventually, hopefully it is sooner than later.
When it come, people will find that it is not the "Magic Pill" that people think it is. But it is fair to say that it is still the best system there is. The challenge is to tailor it to suit the Chinese culture and its people.
As for Beijing, on the issue of Hongkong's readiness for universal suffrage elections, there is nothing as 100% ready suffice to say that it is ready enough.
There is no better place in China to test universal suffrage elections than in Hongkong, there is much to learn from the process which also benefit China.
it's now probably a bit late for 2012, but it's still six years to 2016, Why can't 2016 be a possibility!?
More delays will only cause the Hongkong people to lose heart with China.
Article 23 in exchange for Universal suffrage elections in 2012 !? Anyone !?
Before you jump up and down, think hard about the conflicts/contradictions in the question, taken into account that Hongkong is not a sovereign country.
When these conflicts are resolved through compromises, Universal suffrage elections will come sooner than you think.
The problem is No fucken politicians in Hongkong have the political wisdom to do it.
That's what a political leader should do. They should provide a vision to all people. So if u look at what 民主黨is doing..... u will know they are shit!
憑高超演技,倘若在娛樂圈發展,陳淑莊早賺得盤滿缽滿.
為反極權專制,爭民主自由,陳淑莊犧牲自我,參與五區公投,
一句"點解唔得呀!"擲地有聲,大義凜然.
巾幗英雄之氣慨在市民中感心動耳,蕩氣迴腸.
yindugu 7 months ago
搞公投的無上裝最為突出 , 雞型雞相, 活現眼前
david4chan 7 months ago
omg i love her! The speech is quite touching at the end
kam0226 9 months ago
I'm not from Hong Kong but please do not lose this battle. If everything is direct-elected, everything will be controlled. You can see what's happening in China. Yes cities like Beijing and Shanghai is prosperous but you do not see what these 2 cities shadowed the hundreds region in China that is suffering because of the impotent communist government that cannot even manage their other region filled with bribes and power abuse crippled the development and lead to resident suffering.
kienez 1 year ago 2
唔好向惡勢力低頭~!!
appleip1171 1 year ago
Comment removed
thwongkevin 1 year ago
形容唐英年為“嬉皮笑臉”﹐真是入木三分!淑莊﹐妳真是我們值得尊敬和愛錫的民
主女兒。
Kewmate 1 year ago 2
所有心急如焚, 萬望香港不會淪陷給魔共的人都必需一讀; 特別今天(23.6.2010)在立會內準備通過改良方案的尊貴議員.
胡蝶 : 泛民分裂後果堪虞 (蘋果 23/6/2010)
laiandgan 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
要辭職, 又要搞禁多野. 禁即係唔想唔做喇. 跟本就係度乞飯食. 扮清高.
assuntac 1 year ago
好索wow
lok1007 1 year ago
邊有絕對民主咖?資本主義都唔無啦~~~
kimtaihei 1 year ago
投左票之後, 係唔係個社會會有魔法? 無人再窮,政府會有無限資源餵飽所有人?
另外....第一, 民主假設個個人民都係高等智慧, 識得投票. 第二, 民主係需要全民投入. 對於第一點, 我諗大家有眼觀察. 第二點, 我估, 歷史上的確出現過真正的民主, 就係文化大革命的時候, 全民投入, 反階級, 反權力, 全民鍊乜鍊乜.
newson23003 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
雞莊食屎屙飯
job1186 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我都係香港人民bor ~ 但係真係唔想有咩野公投bor. 其實歷史上有冇出見過完全的民主, 民主一定好咩? 有邊個見過真正的民主?
民主係唔係人民話曬事? 如果一個話叫天落雨, 一個叫天唔落雨, 咁個天落雨定唔落雨好?
newson23003 1 year ago
1. hk冇公投的 無端佢地點講 呢個都唔會係一個真正o既公投
2. 民主唔係話大家可以話灑事 重要o既一點係當一個領導或者一d議員 交唔到貨或同民意背道而馳個陣 民意可以用佢地o既選票表達佢地對呢d人o既不滿 甚至更換佢
shitmanmk 1 year ago 2
@newson23003
There is no accountability for those picked by the central gov't.They only listened to the central gov't & don't care the wishes from the citizen of Hk.
This is why we want 公投. Understand ???
miespma 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@newson23003
There is no accountability for those picked by the central gov't.They only listened to the central gov't & don't care the wishes from the citizen of Hk.
This is why we want 公投. Understand ???
miespma 1 year ago
They should create online polls that allow participants to record their opinions of this referendum. Participants should be allowed to change their survey answer whatever and whenever they like. 7/24 available secure computer in shopping malls suburbs transit stations libraries ... cellphone ... to show real time survey and index them close to second and let the world to learn from Hong Kong.
beancube2010 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
民主"呢個詞很是廣義,也可以很狹隘 ?不同人有不同去解釋,有幾多人能真正了解"民主"呢個詞語 ?打著"民主"口號?做出反"民主"的事,
無其不用"民主"倆字,順應者就係"民主"?不順者就係"保皇黨 ","建制派"?睇美國打著:民主"人權"口號,到處橫行.
今日香港'社民連"那班日日大叫"民主"到底他們是否真的為,香 港市民着想嗎?還是搞亂香港?
johnshiu63 2 years ago
陳淑莊 Good job well done.
PKHKSAR 2 years ago
She is one of the councillor really working for the true benefits of HK citizen,unlike lot of other useless ones sitting there barking for their own interests
miespma 2 years ago
Congratulation Tanya. What you are doing isn't easy especially you were given a choice. Full support from HK public. Keep up the good work, and hope to see a positive outcome.
alphaatube 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
收啦,戲子莊,讀多2年藝員訓練班先
JackRay97 2 years ago
@JackRay97 關藝員訓練班乜事呢?
你認爲以行動來表示,議員份工都辭埋係做戲?有必要嗎?又唔見其它人辭?
你個人都幾攪笑架喎,用下個腦先講野啦!
alphaatube 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
港人思想比較單純,所以有咁多祈福黨搵食
JackRay97 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
耗費社會的精力,浪費(納稅人的金錢).死淫亂(狗屎幫)黃膠民的(變相公投) ,硬要說是給市民來個(變相公投),聽來真動聽,恍怫置其於道德高地.無非是打劫其他[犯人派]的票源,因為打劫建制派的票是比命中六合彩更難.
say4man7lin9947 2 years ago
Good JOB WELL DONE
miespma 2 years ago
i urge all the people to stand up & support your sincere dedicated fearless effort
miespma 2 years ago
She will be the star of HK Councillors
miespma 2 years ago
請加入facebook群組
"!我 相 信 可 以 召 集 100,000 個 厭 惡 民 建 聯 的 人!"
albinomons 2 years ago 5
做得好!!
Support!!
kelvinaaa 2 years ago 2
佢諗左呢段野幾耐呢?
由心的發出
sonicxking 2 years ago
第一次聽佢講野.. 好有power.. 有質素o既發言!
kin880806 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
戲子莊去做雞
JackRay97 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
surprise a lawyer reads the draft, not presenting from her own words. I am questioning her speech and presentation skills.
jimfee42 2 years ago
我諗我有少少鍾意左佢, 點解唔得呀!
myeaffair 2 years ago 9
而陳淑莊小姐也不要妄自菲薄,妳本身依然是年輕人來。亦十分欣賞陳小姐為五區總辭,全民公決,以至新民主運動,所提出的一句﹕點解唔得呀!單是這一句,妳已經夠格成為未來香港的新希望!
AZUREAZURE007 2 years ago 24
淑莊,賢淑、端莊。兩者均能夠在陳淑莊小姐的身上、話中,找得到。
更難能可貴者,是其巾幗不讓鬚眉的氣魄,甚至說是氣度也不為過。其中指責唐英年、梁瑞麟等人的不知所謂,亦是沒有懼色,真的不可不謂之難能可貴!
AZUREAZURE007 2 years ago 27
陳淑莊!我真心鐘意你夠新 ! 加油呀!!
hatarakihiroko 2 years ago 5
努力!!!!支持支持!!!!!努力!!!!支持支持!!!!!
fortress2422 2 years ago 7
Comment removed
leehontak 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
陳淑莊收皮啦,學人選香港小姐,照下鏡先啦。
nalachou1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Chan Suk Chong bull shitting, R.I.P. !!!
kw97278641 2 years ago
努力!!!!支持支持!!!!!
ahlokwong 2 years ago 2
陳淑莊,香港未來超級領袖典範,香港民主未來希望靠晒佢啦,公民黨真係直得支持,香港普選有望啦,陳淑莊努力加油啊,所有有良知同有民主寄望市民,永遠會支持您架!
hongkongtko 2 years ago 6
陳淑莊 加油呀 !!
catinsogo 2 years ago 8
心有同感的一席話:
當我好似你們年青人的年紀時,我以為今天會有普選,可惜今天仍沒有,希望年青人唔好放過這機會,對自己、上一代、下一代也有個交代。
RestartGo 2 years ago 10
支持五區總辭. 全民公決
大家到時同家人朋友一起出來支持!
禁重要既民主運動係人都應該支持!
今次你唔支持,可能要等下一世!
167PC 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
167PC 2 years ago
the civil party is going to lose many votes in the next election. Its supporters are not those who would go for extreme. Many of them are professionals themselves and would not support anyone who do things only with passion but do not think deeply enough.
They are fighting a losing battle...
sonofanfield 2 years ago
點解唔得呀!點解唔得呀!點解唔得呀!
不單青年人為自己的未來要參予、要爭取。
青年人的父母、家長,為了你的下一代,更要支持、參予——〝五區公投〞!
ivorychau 2 years ago 5
公民黨真係直得支持
作為香港人應該主動, 而唔係由一個唔係我地選出黎嘅政府去領導我地
jackyyip2002 2 years ago 9
好.說得好.支持妳陳議員
NoteBook827 2 years ago 8
Universal suffrage elections and Democracy will come to Hongkong and China eventually, hopefully it is sooner than later.
When it come, people will find that it is not the "Magic Pill" that people think it is. But it is fair to say that it is still the best system there is. The challenge is to tailor it to suit the Chinese culture and its people.
I am cautiously optimistic !!
lostpebble 2 years ago
What about the Government official of HongKong !? You might ask ...
I am speechless !!!
lostpebble 2 years ago
As for Beijing, on the issue of Hongkong's readiness for universal suffrage elections, there is nothing as 100% ready suffice to say that it is ready enough.
There is no better place in China to test universal suffrage elections than in Hongkong, there is much to learn from the process which also benefit China.
it's now probably a bit late for 2012, but it's still six years to 2016, Why can't 2016 be a possibility!?
More delays will only cause the Hongkong people to lose heart with China.
lostpebble 2 years ago
Article 23 in exchange for Universal suffrage elections in 2012 !? Anyone !?
Before you jump up and down, think hard about the conflicts/contradictions in the question, taken into account that Hongkong is not a sovereign country.
When these conflicts are resolved through compromises, Universal suffrage elections will come sooner than you think.
The problem is No fucken politicians in Hongkong have the political wisdom to do it.
lostpebble 2 years ago
she is good!
jimli2000 2 years ago
busty....
Bossiiiii 2 years ago
good in bed indeed...
Bossiiiii 2 years ago
陳淑莊講得好
我支持五區總辭
一定會投泛民
cwcfrancis 2 years ago 2
支持五區總辭, 全民公決!
為民主,要爭朝夕!
rockytam0421 2 years ago 6
Well Speech.! You did a very good job.
Wai200808 2 years ago 2
陳淑莊在家豪會客室上講,
佢當上一年立會議員,
最主要成果只係去當義工教人講英文.
陳律師....妳今次既發言...先至係一個議員既貢獻....
以前果d算喇....以後...請多發聲!!
yoyosuperfan 2 years ago 2
民主黨繼續慢慢搞講座,搞遊行啦。
pomiuwong 2 years ago 2
第一次聴晒公民黨人講嘢。
komiya1 2 years ago 2
民主黨, 食蕉吧.................
galaxyswm 2 years ago 5
支持 !
hongkognpeople 2 years ago 3
陳議員講得好!!! 支持公民黨參加五區總辭, 全民公決!!!
holyjenni 2 years ago 3
以前都幾唔buy佢, 可能因為佢太後生, 演技有點浮誇, 而家就覺得Tanya好有heart, 真係青出於藍, 雖然佢証明咗我錯, but我錯得好開心, Tanya加油~~!!!!
8thpenguin 2 years ago
陳淑莊是一個有個性、有立場的年青議員,再者她很有星味,我想只要他能一路走下去, 將會是一個有好有建樹的從政人員
yeung666 2 years ago 6
好有heart!!咁至係!!!!!!!!
kinkingoalgoal 2 years ago
陳淑莊加油, good speech
lhol8888 2 years ago 3
靚女都企出黎支持啵 係人都知中國 香港 澳門都係中共控制架啦 單一個五區公投其實幫助不大 當然總比好過做漢奸果班乜都唔做只係用口講20年民主好 暴政才出暴民 良政才有良民 唔知現在香港良民多還是暴民多
him226 2 years ago
陳淑莊你有血有肉又有涙,我被你感動!
好,果然係一個香港人...........正
raynewone 2 years ago 3
support Tanya Chan
happyj122 2 years ago
Good speech, I really hope that you and your party will follow up and follow through to make it happen.
alanip 2 years ago
共產黨食屎
cowb222 2 years ago
陳淑莊 ok wor, i like her, haha
kkbush 2 years ago 3
影片上載兩天, hit rate 3,500, Tanya 妳要build up 定一個fan club 啦, 恭喜, 多謝, 努力.
vincidolphin 2 years ago
陳淑莊加油 !!
catinsogo 2 years ago 4
陳淑莊講得好有膽色,支持五區總辭,加油呀?
gary457228 2 years ago 4
bravo
paulnok 2 years ago 2
Good speech, deserve some encouragement ......
"Now it's time to make a stand !!"
"From little things big things grow."
"To show how power and privilege, could not defeat the people !!"
"If you fall, others are rising !!"
Quotes from the song "From little things big things grow" by Kev Carmody and Paul Kelly, You can see it in my Chanel.
lostpebble 2 years ago 2
要文有公民黨
要武有社民連
luvkarl 2 years ago 19
民主黨兩面不是人, 等收檔. ^^"
vincidolphin 2 years ago 2
A very good looking and passionate tenderfoot.
MegaChiuchiu 2 years ago 6
請盡量望主席,不要只望稿
sytong69 2 years ago 2
人人都說在爭取民主?越想越扯火!
肥仔明騙了我和家人十多年選票!
臨門一腳原來是個民主做假貨@#$!%
bbqwong123 2 years ago 5
佢咁樣幾靚
questerl 2 years ago 8
陳淑莊做得好,為新民主力量努力,Fully support
kewell168 2 years ago 8
That's the way a prudent politician should have.She passes the minimum criteria of a conscious elected Representative.
fgah 2 years ago
That's what a political leader should do. They should provide a vision to all people. So if u look at what 民主黨is doing..... u will know they are shit!
edwardau2046 2 years ago 4
ithats why we need young people to enter legco
there is much more passion
i didnt really know her before
but her speech is very impressive indeed
gd job!
newkidcc 2 years ago 3
Well done Miss Chan.......
kwong88 2 years ago 4
good speech!!!
ss611 2 years ago 5
good script
thechinaboy 2 years ago 3
靚靚女神^^
honghey 2 years ago 4
well written speech! a rising star!
writingcode 2 years ago 3
支持全民公決,一切權力歸於人民!
hkg214 2 years ago 5
言詞堅定,立論清式
chan69121 2 years ago 3
支持民主的陳小姐越看越靚,五區總辭、全民公决。可以令人青春常駐的
gowent903 2 years ago 7
好!要為陳議員鼓掌。
支持公投 人人有責。
TheSillyOldBugger 2 years ago 10
陳小姐加油!我一定支持妳!
kellymak9 2 years ago 8
港姐加油!
lamourdeDieu 2 years ago 6
支持五區總辭. 全民公決!!!
tongkk 2 years ago 7
Great Speak
支持五區總辭. 全民公決!!!
dragonstone1988 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
dragonstone1988 2 years ago
So sorry misleading you before, she is 陳淑莊 actually.
vincidolphin 2 years ago