Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (408)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • لا إله إلا الله

  • Islam and christianity do not worship the same GOD. Islam believe in one God while Christians believe in Father, Son and Holy Spirit. John 3:16 is the only hope mankind has to be with GOD take it or leave. This is not about religion, its about salvation. We are all sinners, none of deserve to be with GOD no matter how much work we put into it. It is only by grace can we go to heaven.

  • I can answer that question about the sun being created after vegetation. GOD created light first. In Quantum mechanics light is what holds all atoms together that's why he made that first. John 9:5,8:12;Psalms 27:1 says that Jesus is light! Hebrews 12:29 says GOD is a consuming fire. Even more powerful than the sun, hence no sun was needed since GOD was there hallelujah!

  • @JenFever sounds like a monster...god consuming fire? is that true?

    u twad...Jesus is light..it means he gave all the followers an enlightment..read it and dechiper it carefuly

  • any person knows that cold water rises to the surface and hot water sinks. thats why you think the bath water is warm enough but when you get in, it is hot. the guy had nothing to back up his claims, 1st he gives an example of a friend and then he talks about his own experience with no evidence so if i said my friend told me she saw the ghost of jesus, would i believe her without any evidence to back up her claim

  • Is not a matter of opinion. Careful! with Religion, Science, or Politique. Do your search. The Bible is the Highest authority. Satan is ruling & misleading the earth 1John5:19; Revelation 12:9. 1John4:1 Don't trust all inspired word, test them to see whether they originate with God, false prophets have gone forth to the world.

    I found this helpful, verify for yourself(Ephesians5:10). Go to "Watchtower org" website click "Index" or "Search" your subject, if U click 'Contact Us' you'll get help.

  • the quran is the word of god

  • @ServantOfYeshua1

    Why do you need hoovind up there. Is william campbell not good enough. I think he is good enough. His facts are the well known facts about science in the bible that is used by the christian scholars. Keep in mind also that William campbell is also familiar with the islamic texts. So i think he does have more advantage compared to hoovind.

  • Blah blah blah.....he is soooo boring I'm really trying to follow him but I get lost while he is looking through the papers. Dr. Zakir Naik doesn't have to stop and look at anything and that's another miracle from God; preserving the truth and knowledge through elocuent people like Ahmed Deedat or Dr. Zakir Naik.

    Allahu Akbar!!!!!

  • @ServantOfYeshua1 Jesus prayed to God and said that God had sent him. So we Muslims do the same. Why pray to Jesus who can't even feed himself. God is the one that feeds us.

  • So everybody will have to go home and think about it themselves INDEED

  • You can't convince people with fairy tales, prove your logic with science. DR William has no scientific proof, I think this is a debate on scientific signs in those books. May Allah show him the right way. Allah o Akbar.

  • Islam  = Science

  • ISLAM = Sience

  • Why is camp bell talking about prophisies. it is in the light of science not predictions

  • Masallah this video sealed my faith in Islam rather than anyother debate, speech, kuthba, you name it. man science unlike anything else is hard facts and its either right or wrong unlike prophecies that can say this and that!

  • He said that rainbow is promise to not flooded the earth again , but didn't we witness that 2001 have a tsunami

  • All praises are due to allah who gave me the most precious of gifts al-islam.

  • just check the level of confidence that Dr William had in his 1st debate and in this one & as Dr Zakir said he just gave answers to 3 questions and just look at the example which he gave about his friend in Morocco(God knows whether he existed or not) .

    He should have given some reasonable answer,solid 1 AS IT WAS A VERY SERIOUS DEBATE....Dr Zakir gave clear & solid answers

  • In any case, Dr, Cambell resembles a professional call girl who just confessed to her husband on national television her secret profession. He was handed his own rear end, and got schooled so bad I doubt he will ever decide to debate Dr. Zakir Naik. I still believe Ahmad Deedat was our best debater to date, that man of God simply sent shivers thru the spine of a Christian before the debate even started.

  • I however, believe it isnt simply a matter of not comprehending, what plays a large part in the embarrassing tactics employed by the Christian is their inherent hatred for Islam, so they fill their websites, books, videos etc, with lies, concoctions, half truths, and disgusting insults.

  • @masterofyou888 thats what their bible teaches them. The type of hypocrites (these particular group of people not all) they are

  • I cannot believe I still see the verse of the Quran about the sun setting on murky water on every anti Islamic website after it has been explained to them in detail. That single verse embodies the Christians utter inability to comprehend when it comes to Islam and the Quran.

  • @masterofyou888 ooh no worries...the kuffar will do anything to put the light of Allah away... but they can never be...

  • @masterofyou888 You do not have to explain "in detail" something that is completely absurd:

    The sun does not move so it cannot set in a murky spring or anywhere else on Earth.

    Besides, the sun is a million times bigger than any spring on Earth.

  • @BjornPalmen

    the dark water in the sun is mentioned from Dhul-Qarnayn's point of view verse 18.86,

    where in 18.90 its continued "Until, when he came to the rising of the sun, he found it rising on a people for whom We had not made against it any shield"

    again from POV, it doesnt mean the sun was literally climbing the faces of these people like a spider climbing a face. therefore 4 versus earlier it doesnt mean the sun literally went into dark water...but it means how he saw it.

  • @prototype00000 I said: The sun does not move so it cannot set in a murky spring or anywhere else on Earth.

    Besides, the sun is a million times bigger than any spring on Earth.

    So the story must be wrong.

    Now you say: "the dark water in the sun is mentioned from Dhul-Qarnayn's point of view."

    So this view makes the Sun one million times smaller? Not possible.

    The Sun does not set anywhere on the Earth because the Earth is orbiting the sun. The Sun is NOT moving, nor is it setting anywhere.

  • @prototype00000 You say:"Until, when he came to the rising of the sun, he found it rising on a people for whom We had not made against it any shield,"

    This passage is racist. And nobody can "come" to the rising of the sun, because the Earth is a rotating planet, the Sun rises anywhere. The story is completely impossible. The sun cannot set in a spring of muddy water, but it can look like it sets in the ocean, if you are very ignorant. Then again, the ocean is not muddy water.

  • @BjornPalmen

    definition of racism

    Racism is the belief that the genetic factors which constitute race are a primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race

    you said "This passage is racist"

    how is that racist? thats the most ridiculous thing ive ever heard.

  • One thing I have repeatedly noticed about non-Muslims and Christians in particular is that even after decades of scholarly work, they still manage to make such blatant baseless accusations a bout Islam. What a 12 year old child finds self explanatory, perplexes a Christian scholar of Islam. When it comes to the Holy Quran, suddenly a well educated scholar adopts the linguistic, grammatical, logical skills of a child.

  • @masterofyou888 well for them they can't figure out whether God is 1 in 3 or 3 in 1. Its a mystery, no wonder they can't understand Islam when they apply this confused mind to it.

  • @masterofyou888 You say: "...What a 12 year old child finds self explanatory ... "

    Yes you do reason like a 12 year old.

    Now please start reasoning like a grownup, ok?

  • the Quran is word of god

  • Yes geeflyboy - ure coming up with supposedly hundreds of errors - that are only errors if u interpret them in certain ways or have been translated incorrectly

    Dr Cambell found errors - he gave a talk on them - he never mentioned any of those that u mention so what makes u think that the anti-islam sites u found are more credible than dr cambell. I think Dr Naik has won as dr cambell is unable to respond to many errors mentioned whereas Naik has fairly rebutted everyone cambell mentioned

  • Lol, dude u need to give google a rest, and as i told you before, all ur doing is bashing Muslims over and over again, you still cannot give me ONE single mistake in ISLAM. What do Muslims have to do with it? No christian has ever followed christianity perfectly, nor any other religion. I love how u say we are like hitler because we hate jews, then u throw racist slander about Arabs. I am not Arab, most of Khilapha was not Arab, still one thing wrong with Islam please? I disnt ask about muslims.

  • @HezbAlih One single mistake is that the Earth is laid down as a carpet.

  • Read what I just said down there... BUSH. There WAS no Islamic court in Somalia during the Clinton years dumb-ass. The Islamic courts were established after 2001. In the 4 years since, Piracy was at its lowest point, the killing had stopped, the school systems were coming back, the government was getting ahold of itself. Seing this flureshing Islamic country coming to life after so many catastrophies conflicted with the Image of Islam Bushes media wanted to portray. So he got the warlords back

  • Into the country, payed them with AMERICAN tax money to have weapons, transported them all back into somalia, and the warlords, with Bushes help, startted the killing again, and now u have what somalia is. Its a very famous story, i dont know how you never heard of it. I guess u have no time for reality, anyways, thats fine, like i said, Bushes actions, or that of any christian for that matter, do not reflect on christianity. But just so u know why they hate you. its for killing their children.

  • care to give me one of those flaws and fulse claims? just one single contradiction in the Qur'an please?

  • Quran source is flawed, false, man made, plagiarized, full of scientific, historical errors and contradiction. That is the good part, it is full of hate, intolerance and call for Jihad, to "Fight until all religion is for Allah." (2.192, 8.39) Quran corrupted before Caliph Uthman =DUWOBBWtC8g Quran plagiarizes Thomas =KICeC9UUlRs The origins of the Koran and Islam =O5R_-0UO4fs Is the Quran the Word of Allah? =njXuoF8toUg The history of how Quran came to be =b1yxtag7v4s
  • Cut & Past the =ID into YouTube search for previous posts.

    Watch videos first. DO NOT write me unless you can answer all the ERROR'S and CONTRADICTIONS and PLAGIARISMS in the QURAN (with out changing subject or blaming Jews). Quran was written by Arab men with the help of Gabriel (satan transforms himself into an angel of light, 2 Cor 11:14). In 20 yrs mohammad never talked to God?

    NO EXCUSES, WHY IS THE QURAN SUCH A MESS? IS ALLAH STUPID? (allah = 1 of 360 pagan arab idols, the moon god)

  • Scientific Errors in the Quran =pz2AfvD4INA Quran Science - Scientific errors in =wYwvLNTA1no Quran The Biggest Blunder In History =FtcDsXC8g2Q Contradictions in the Quran - Koran errors =Yq-gzYZ6PG8 51 errors in the "perfect" Koran =kuvB-UDMJ38 Proof that the Koran of today is different from the original (END OF ISLAM!) =z8RJaJbKog4
  • Islam is the only "religion" (cult) in the WORLD based on lying & attacking other peoples faith, religions, cultures and nations. ISLAM = false & flawed, hell bent on WORLD DOMINATION any way possible, including kill/murder/death. See the lies. Dr. Zakir Naik (clown), Google:

    answering-islam org/Responses/Naik/index

    Ahmed Deedat (DEAD) threatened w/ deportation from Australia, God struck him down!

    answering-islam org/rebuttals/deedat

    answering-islam org/Responses/Deedat/downfall

  • Quran Contradictions, Google:

    answering-islam org/Quran/Contra/

    Islam can't stand. It destroys it self. We see the culture & societies islam breeds: poor, unsuccessful, repressive, ignorant, worse places on Earth, massive human rights abuse (especially Women & Children), violent history and centers of TERRORISM, ALL MUSLIM! It's IRRELEVANT if it's only 10%.

    Christians, Jews, Hindu, Buddhist are NOT flying planes into builds, suicide bombing buses, trains, mosques, embassies, MUSLIMS ARE.

  • Islam cant stand, yet you have not given me one contradiction, just googled shit off the internet. I still await for you to tell me one contradiction please. Secondly, you claim that muslim countries are poor and uneducated, and a lot more slander. To that I say, WHAT MUSLIM COUNTRIES?

    If you look at the only true Muslim nation, the Kaliph, you find flourishing culture education science madecine, and progress for all humanity. Then it was destroyed by the colonials and u have what u see today

  • Muslim Caliphate? Ha ha oh yes the TRUE MUSLIM NATION. It's always some one else fault and if sucks it's not I"true slam"? Sure.

    Islams CLAIM to fame in Science and Education and Medicine is WAY OVER BLOWN. Yes some people that Muslims invaded did make small contributions. HOWEVER many claims of Muslim discoveries (not ISLAM) where predated by others. Also the real progress was made after with true useful technology. Persians and Greeks where WAY MORE advanced over the barbaric Bedouin Arabs.

  • @HezbAlih you said: "I still await for you to tell me one contradiction please. "

    If the Sun allegedly setting in muddy waters is not enough for you NOTHING will be enough,

    Why is it so wrong:

    1, The sun can not be seen setting like an airplane landing in a spring, because in reality it is the Earth that is moving, not the Sun.

    2. The Sun is millions of times bigger than the Earth so there is not room for it to set in any water.

    3. The muddy water would instantly turn into steam!

  • @BjornPalmen

    So are you saying this verse (which you stupidly claimed racist for some reason) is in the literal sense? Are you saying the qurna teches the sun was LIERALLY rising on the faces of these people? like an insect rising on your face? "18.90 its continued "Until, when he came to the rising of the sun, he found it rising on a people for whom We had not made against it any shield"

    if u are then i cant help you. its a childish thing to say. learn what a sunrise/sunset is in english

  • @prototype00000 Without a shield people turn black. This idea is racist.

    Sunrise/sunset is in EVERY LANGUAGE the result of the Earth rotating in 24 h.

    Nothing climbs up people's faces, they are just turning with the Earth so the Sun can shine on them.

    Btw you changed "rising on a people" into "rising on the faces of these people".

    A child can see that you changed it! You changed sun shining in space into insects on your face.

    If you continue changing the sentences no discussion is possible.

  • @BjornPalmen

    i CANT BELIEVE YOU SAID THIS "Without a shield people turn black. This idea is racist"

    this is now the most ridiculous thing ive ever heard lol. Are you shielded in summer?

    "Btw you changed "rising on a people" into "rising on the faces of these people".

    BOLD FACED LIE! I NEVER AND ITS IN THE QURAN SO READ IT YOURSELF. SURAH KAHF CHAPTER 18 VERSE 90

    "Until, when he came to the rising of the sun, he found it rising on a people for whom We had not made against it any shield"

  • @prototype00000 You added "faces" and you added "insects" so you should win the argument - but those words do not exist in 18:90. Who are you to rewrite the Surah Kahf 18:90 ?.

  • @BjornPalmen

    faces and insects are in MY question, they were NOT added in the quotation of the quran. i am asking you a simple question, you claim this verse

    ""Until, when he came to the rising of the sun, he found it rising on a people for whom We had not made against it any shield"

    means the sun was literraly climbing these peoples faces. you have to as you claim the prior verse means the sun was literally going into the water. you find things very difficult to understand child

  • Secondly, you say first that ISLAM cant stand, then, insted of giving me ONE valid backup to this, you start talking about whats wrong with MUSLIMS. Muslims answer for Muslims, my friend, and Islam answers for Islam. If we use ur method, Hitler, who was the worlds most famous catholic, is responsible for currupting Christianity? No, because his actions do not reflect on the religion, nor do bad Muslims reflect on Islam, they reflect on their own actions as well as their culture. not religion. :)

  • Muslim Caliphate? TRUE MUSLIM NATION? LOL!

    Muslims claims of Science, Education and Medicine is WAY OVER BLOWN. Yes some Muslims made small contributions. HOWEVER many of these so called discovered were predated, BEFORE ISLAM. The real progress was made after by others with true useful discoveries. The Persians and Greeks where WAY advanced over barbaric Bedouin Arabs.

    Muslims BRAG how Islam is MORE THAN RELIGION, it's a total way of life (CULTure). You can't have it both ways.

  • No HITLER was not Catholic. His family was Catholic and he rejected it, and said JESUS COULD NOT BE GOD BECAUSE HE WAS A JEW. Not a Christian.

    In fact MUSLIMS have MUCH IN COMMON WITH HITLER. You both hate Jews (because they are God's people). Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Haj Amin al-Husseini, organized the WWII Handzar Division of the Nazi's Waffen SS for HItler, which killed 80% of the Jews in Bosnia. STOP LYING. Hitler & Muslims & Satan are all on the same team.

    =EAxrg7nMcs4

    =HfLvP2jTVq8

  • Thirdly, you state that Christians and hindus are not flaying planed into buildings, bombing people, causing terrorism. To that i ask you, if it is not terrorism, what do u call the Hindu's mass rape and live burning of 500 muslim women and girls? what do you call Israeli and modern crusaders terrorising of Palestine? what do u call the bullshit war for "WMDs: that are, apparently, invissible. What do you call genocide in Bosnis and Kosovo, what do you call genocide in chechnya of wom and child?

  • References references reference please? I recall muslims are killing the Hindu, but link the report. I suspect it was retaliation and doubt your 500 number. (Everthing else you said is wrong.) I KNOW MUSLIMS ARE KILLING HINDU AND BUDDHIST AND CHRISTIANS AND JEWS EVERY DAY. Google:

    islam-watch org

    Thereligionofpeace com

    answering-islam org

    muslimhope com

    investigateislam com

    gotquestions org/Muslim-questions

    apostatesofislam com/index

    faithfreedom org/testimonials

  • geeflyboy UR STILL A BOY DR WILLIAM LOST HANDS DOWN,HIS AN MD AND MY MANS GOT A PHD,COULDNT EVEN SCRATCH ISLAM,,AND THEN THERES U,UR GOOGLEING ALL THE ANTI ISLAMIC SITES,BY THE WAY THESE ARE,,YOU DONT U USE UR BRAIN AND THINK IF CAMPBELL CUDNT DO A GOOD JOB WHAT MAKES U THINK U CAN,,,ANYWAY LIKE IT SAYS UR JUST 1 OF THE DUMB DEAF AND BLIND..

  • Remember the Black hawk down incident where samali terrorists were dragging the bodies of innocent young americans through the streets with pickup trucks? After the establishment of the Islamic courts those warlords were exiled, and the country began to have order. Bush couldnt let this growing Islamic government be as a modle for the world, so he got the warlords back form ecile, gave them $30,000 us TAXMONEY and put them back in somalia. To kill and murder, and maybe drag more dead americans.

  • Why are you changing the subject Muslim? I gave you some examples (100's) of Quran errors. I hear nothing from you? Silence is golden. You admit the Quran is flawed and false than. Thank you!

  • @HezbAlih you asked for "just one single contradiction in the Qur'an please?"

    This is a pretty obvious contradiction:

    The Sun is observed setting in a spring of muddy water and stays there during the night,

    The Sun can not stay in the night because the light from the Sun would make the night turn into day.

    And the Sun is a million times bigger than any spring or ocean,

  • @BjornPalmen

    I think you know its not in the literal sense. to have a problem with it you would have to have a problem with the saying in your own culture of "sunsets" and "sunrise".

    from wiki

    Sunrise is the instant at which the upper edge of the Sun appears above the horizon in the east

    Notice the word APPEARS. Therefore you are arguing with the entire world on this.

  • @prototype00000 I am not arguing, I am just pointing out mistakes with the idea of a sunset in "muddy water".

    It was a good idea of yours to look it up in wikipedia:

    Earth's rotation period relative to the Sun is its true solar day. The true solar day tends to be longer near perihelion when the Sun moves along the ecliptic through a greater angle than usual, taking about 10 seconds longer to do so.

    Sunset has NOTHING to do with murky water, it does not even APPEAR to set in murky water,

  • @BjornPalmen

    So answer me was the verse 18.90 speaking literally? Are you claiming the quran claims the sun was literally climbing the faces of these men like an insect climbs a face?

    YES OR NO!!!

  • I love how the Muslims cheer because Dr. William Campbell said @5:20 he does not have a good answer. That's a fair responce.

    Howevery MUSLIMs have answers for everything, excusses, grand unsupported claims, lies, denials and play all kinds of games. That's why Islam is false. When challenged with WHY does the Quran say something wrong, hateful, intolerant or calls to kill non muslims (when it is clear), Muslims lie.

    Christians are honest. We don't lie like muslims. Islam is about Taqiyya.

  • @gmcjetpilot "Muslims cheer because Dr. William Campbell said @5:20 he does not have a good answer."

    The difficulty is entirely with islam, because there is no good explanation of the alleged "barrier" between river water (fresh water) and sea water (salt water). Then Dr. Campbell very graciously gives an exemple of the appearance of a "barrier" when he goes swimming in very cold water at the surface and warm water deeper down. The warm salt water sinks to the bottom. Eventually they mix.

  • @BjornPalmen

    Not only is just science messed up in the bible, you believe in some 3 god trinity which is a creed invented by the romans, more specifically a pagan called constantine. jesus never says he is god & to worship him in the bible. over 80 gospels were hidden & are TO THIS DAY in vatican..i wonder why? they invented christmas for u to coincide with a pagan holiday as nobody knows jesus's real birthday, on 25th dec which was rising of the SUN! jesus was made a SUNgod u worship on SUNday

  • @BjornPalmen

    christians have no knowledge of jesus anyway. jesus says he is not of equal power to god and god ALONE is good in matthew 10-17-18 (eliminating any equal trinity) but you claim hes son (sun) of god. he had a beard & his mother a headscarf like muslims today. pork is forbidden in bible but its muslims who dont eat it today.

    instead you "celebrate" his birthday which is not his birthday but SUNGOD horus on 25th dec as the pagans invented it. no wonder your so interested in the sun

  • * * * * * * COMMENTS ARE UNFAIRLY BLOCKED SO IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO REPLY * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

    MuslimByChoice is also censor by choice.

    @gmcjetpilot MuslimByChoice is blocking these comments so gmcjetpilot cannot answer,

    This is the final proof that MuslimByChoice HAS TO SILENCE REPLYS BECAUSE OTHERWISE HE WILL LOSE THE ARGUMENT. I say he has already lost with this desperate and unfair action.

  • @BjornPalmen

    is that why gmcjetpilot is sending me pms with silly unatuentic information? dont worry he wont win any argument anyway

  • @prototype00000 You say:"he wont win any argument anyway"

    gmcjetpilot has already won. The person that cheats by blocking his opponent ALWAYS LOSES.

    Another loser that thinks he has to block all answers is willywill1984. Shame on him.

  • his first answer is soooooo dumb. he tells a STORY...wtf..

  • @Jok3rDicE Actually he tells how he himself by swimming verified that fresh water and salt water do not mix, as the warmer salt water sinks to the bottom. There is no barrier because they wilkl mix far out to sea.

    There is no reason to call him sooooooooo dumb because YOU did not understand the point.

  • To NewUC: Shut up...

  • I've read william cambells book, and he devilishly quotes verses out of context, uses wrong translations and puts his own words in quran, to attempt to maline Islam. The reason he mostly attacked the quran at the start, because for eight years no-one replied to him, and he was one hundred per cent sure no-one would be able to. That's why he hardly spoke about the bible, in his hour talk.

  • Quran 61:9

  • I am a catholic but i thought the q'uran's view on science was more convincing than christian bible, The catholic bible on science i will have to read

  • brother without any doubt you

    (21ADUB87) are the small fraction of honest christian! don't hear others sarcasm & condemnation on Islam & Holy Quran, search the light of truth yourself, read and analyze with open heart the bible & Quran, i will pray 4 u. Im myself was unbeliever b4, but thank God I had found the Truth in Islam =)

  • Salaam bro thanks for your kind words

  • it's really good to find an open minded brother and pured hearted that uses his logic and mind :D

    thanks for ur sensier message.

    i wish for u guidence n peace

  • good and keep trying for the truth...

    is any douts i will do my best for u

  • To 21ADUB87: May Allah guide you towards the truth. I respect that you are honest and use logic. Bless you.

  • @21ADUB87 so what do you think about the Qur'an's position regarding science

  • koran-science . com

  • there must be much better christian scholars then cambell in christian community

  • i agree

  • i want to cry, by the beauty of this!

  • Dr. Campbell pretty much gave up when he said, "There are these problems that he said and I don't deny them or have good answers for them." lmao hahaha, you just forfeited the debate with that statement alone!!!

  • This is so heart warming! I am so proud to be a muslim

  • The quran says that the bible is the word of god. But Jews and other disbelieving men have changed the content of it. How could it be cald the word of God after that. There is a reason why Mohammed(PBUH)told muslims to memorize the Quran and guard it. So no damn jews would destroy a beautiful religion. as they did with another potencialy beautiful religion,Christianity. Today christians is ruled by zionist wich tries to use them against muslims.Jews try to egnite a huge conflict.

  • Lamps8er is real smart. He sees the whole picture properly. Mashallah!!

  • hehe, thanks brother ;)

  • that's right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • ma sha allah,, dr zakhir naik is a great scholar.

  • kevluigi anyone who knows 40 Hadiths(to their nearest effect) by heart will be raised with the Scholars on the Day of Judgement!! Inshallah Dr Naik is a Scholar

  • campbel out of topic .

  • I never said you said the Coran wasn t the truth. What I said is there is absolutely nothing wrong in exposing faults. When someone is in error you have to show them the right path. Imagine Allah the Lord and Creator of the Heavens and Earth making scientific faults. He expose the faults not to make them feel bad but to see the truth. I hope this is clear for you brother.

    Salam

  • Brother the Coran is the truth. And if you re a believer you should be proud of him and not see it as a problem. What good is it to know the truth and not bring it to light? What good is it to see errors (faults) and not expose it? That is the true essence of a believer. Just ponder on it. Assalamoualeikoum.

  • Masha allah this is a very good talk and also may allah guide Dr. cAMPBELL THE THE true path.

  • Dr.Naik smashed Dr.Campbell into pieces!!

    You can't help but feel sorry for the old fool but the truth is that Allah is the Lord of the Worlds and the Quran is the true revelation of God.

  • Indeed.

  • Dude you shouldnt call him foolish. Just ask ask yourself if you are. Besides he knows the truth. He however will continue to believe in the word of the bible. Besides the bible is rhe message of islam in a corrupted form. And dont fight about religion. Islam is a peaceful religion anyway.

  • i'd like more info bout Campbell,just how venerated was he by the christians,an wots he doing now,cant find anything on net. thanks

  • Look how happy Dr. Naik is compared to William. Islam brings happiness because it's the truth... Williams face tells us what his Bible has brought him :)

  • true

  • The science of the Quran is more accurate than of the Bible. However the Bible is much older so they didn't have a chance to rip off more modern discoveries. However there are things in the Quran that seem to explain recent scientific discoveries. I can't explain that.

  • Then, when it was time for William to give a rebuttal, all he could say was he disagreed with Dr. Zaik, and that he saw big problems within the Quran. What??? That's not a rebuttal. This was even more pathetic than his presentation. I really wish the moderators could have chosen someone who could articulate the Christian position, argue with passioned logical arguments, and expose the fallacies of Dr Zaik's arguments.

  • Oh my, I am a Christian, and I was absolutely appalled by Williams weak and pathetic presentation in which he obviously forgot that the topic was on both the Quran and the Bible in the light of science, and focused almost his entire talk on embryology in the Quran. Out of all the fields of science thats all he could come up with. His talk was passionless, and missed half the topic. He was so outclassed by the muslim it was almost embarrasing to watch. Get off the stage William.

  • the black cumin cures everything but death..AID's causes DEATH! You cant live with AIDS you can live with seizures you CAN die but u can live. Aid's is out of the question of living. And im sure as it took time to discover new cures for various diseases they will find new cures for leporcy within time. Still the Qur'an and Sahih Hadiths stand strong! Have an open mind and look for the truth in the Qur'an i gurante you will find it before it's 2 late. inshAllah

  • i am 100 percent sure willim cried when he went home after that kind of a defeat ....open ur eyes chricstens ...how long can you go ignoring the truth .....allha u akbar ..mashallah

  • WHAT DOES THIS HAVE TO DO WITH SCIENCE??? lol hahaha campbell is lame, he cant defend he's own book, nor destroy our undestroyable book! PEace

  • Lets see.Your christian man in this debate sucked and kept stuttering and couldnt prove anything.While the Muslim speaker was speaking about everythng and knew everything he was talking about and proved everything he was talking about and even had proof by refering to verses in the Quran and bible.whats your proof.you have none.you are just ignorant.

  • He used scientific facts that were just recently discovered to back what the Quran has had in it for nearly 1450 years ago.If western science is so good why are they now committing fraud by throwing global warming in our face and saying it is real.when the only reason it is being pushed on us is so the elitists can fraudelently charge us a carbon tax.dont u understand.

  • LOL what are you talking about, your science was in the holy quran 1400 years ago, how can it be "WESTERN" science?

  • As there is nothing scientific to be found in the Quran that can't be found in earler and greater treatises on the subjects, I have to continue to defer to Western science.

  • Oh really? Was the concept of the big bang as a FACT present in science before the Qur'an? Was the physical appaearance of the stages of embryological development of a foetus present in science before the Qur'an? Was the idea that mountains were geologically stabilising the earth present in science before the Qur'an? These are just three examples.

  • Big bang? How about 'in the beginning...' The stages on embryonic development that the quran discusses are in the works of Galen and others. And, mountians do NOT stabilise the earth.

  • Galen made observations on the female reproductive organs but not on a foetus or the reproductive process involving the fertilsiation of the foetus. In his treatise "On Seed" he viewed the ovaries as analgous to the male testes. He however also made the mistaken assumption that females produced seed after observing a fluid in the horns of the uterus (before the fallopian tubes). Men produce seed(sperm), women produce the egg(ovum). Galen never described the stages of appearance of the foetus.

  • The stages of the fetus were described long before Galen. Aristotle observed them in many types of mammals.

  • @rencrow There is nothing about the big ban or atomic particles. Galen described embryos 1000 years earlier. Mountains are NOT geologically stabilising the earth, on the contrary! Mountains rise as continental plates collide, they are the sign of the most imaginable instability there is, continents diving under each other.

  • this guy is the biggest fraud and the biggest liar.

  • the guy under me clearly didnt do research the black seed aka the black cumin is used in EVERYTHIN MEDICAL MEDECINE AND CURES DONT BELIEVE ME GO UNDER GOOGLE AN TYPE BLACK CUMIN AN READ IT 4 UR SELF SALAMZ

  • Volume 7, Book 71, Number 592:Narrated Abu Huraira: I heard Allah's Apostle saying, "There is healing in black cumin for all diseases except death."

    Please provide the scientific evidence that black cumin will heal A.I.D.S or Leprocy.

  • well.there r many scientific facts which have been discovered only RECENTLY.and if u wud have asked me abt those particular verses 50 years b4 than i wasnt able to answer them.

    secondly the advancement in modern science hasnt been stopped .and probably people havnt researched on this one.

    and by the AIDS means death.(except for the initial stages).so if somebody has aids than he must understand that his time is near.read the hadith once more.Black cumin can heal everthing except DEATH.

  • Except death. When someone has AIDS they are NOT dead. So, black cumin should be able to cure AIDS. How about Polio. Can black cumin cure Polio. How about Measeals or Mumps?

    By the way. Every modern scientific advance has been in the West. Why don't go do some science instead of just talking about it.

  • well as ive already sai..probably people havnt searched for it...people hant tried to use it as a medicine ...

    secondly suppose we change the histroy and if these researches wud have been conducted in islamic countiries than u people wud have said that msulims have somewhere changed the QURAN and have made it compatible to science..

    so things become more authentic when yr opponent is saying something which matches yr statement

  • But, if its a scientific fact that black cumin can cure every disease except death, then why haven't Muslims made headlines with mirculous cures using it?

  • well u r rtaling abt a hadeeeth...i dont know of which level...if its from sahih bukhari than it is 100% right....if its not from sahih bukhari than there can b some doubt in it...Quran is the most supirior scripture in islam and than come hadeeth and Hadeeth from Sahih bukhari has almost the highest level

  • u r talking abt something which probably hasnt been researched so far

    now u can for yr sake..in order to satisfy yrself..u can take this one hadeeth and think..ok i dont accept islam.although u can look for many examples where the things have been prooved centuries later.on the other hand there r many approved miracles...which when u read in quran..than u get stunned how cud Mohammad SAW know them...but u wont think i know

  • You're refering to a statement from the Hadith, which are a collection of the traditions and sayings of the Prophet(pbuh). Unlike the Qur'an which is a holy scripture, the Hadith are subject to mistakes. Some traditions are authentic and some arent.

  • 4r me. islam is a win win chose.

    why. becuse if all this is ture. then my prays well come in hand. . and ill get a place in heaven. . true. .

    o.k. now lets just say it was not true.

    (i dont believe it} but lets just say ya . . what im asking is what do yu think is gona happen. . . (with respect} my bodyz gona rotwayz in the grave. and so is my brain. . . so do you think im gona remmber anything on earth anywayz. ammm no. . so for me. islam is the only chose

  • I guarantee All christinas that sat through the entire debate had countless sleep less nights for days or even weks.

  • Did you see Sam Shamoun, he left the stage in the last mints ... I wonder why ?

  • was Sam shamoun there?? lol

    I saw hsi debate with Nadir!! it was great!

    Have you seen it yet??

  • Wow i guess Dr William Campbell, along with his anti-islamic followers hearts must have been shattered.

    this video makes me very happy! :)

    Dr Naik is a living legend!

  • Why dont you think that i am a Muslim?

    A

  • i admire dr. naik very much,,may god bless him and give him a very long life.

    more and more people are embracing islam every day.

    dont waste your time arguing with the ignorant, they only repeat what they hear. tell them read the quran.

  • ajel06 carm down. .

    truth well allways stand out from error.

  • help your self you old white hillbilly

    Accept Allah before its too late....you 90 something year old fuck

    LA ILAHA ILA ALLAH!!

    There is no God but Allah!!..the mercyful

  • Yeah What and you think you will be allowed to enter the Paradise of Allah with a filthy, dirty mouth like that... Where did the respect and hospitality go of the Muslims nowadays...

    A

    p.s. Does it not say in the Qur'an in Sueatul Hujuraat 49:11.... Please Check it up to benefit you my friend.. Peace

  • aww...that shaking christian....poor whitey..accept Allah!...he is great!...he awaits you!

    its good to see that he admit he's wrong.

    and that story about his friend being poisoned

    just wtf!

  • Lying Muslim. I speak Arabic. "Nur" does not mean reflected or borrowed light. Typical Lying Muslim

  • Fuck you , read the old literatures you will find its meaning to be the reflected light.

  • I thought Muslims are not allowed to use FOUL LANGUAGE...

  • The meaning of Nur Origin: Arabic

    Meaning: reflected Light.

  • Ha ha he why did you not right your message in arabic then or at least in a transcrition rather than argueing about the translation... Can you really speak arabic?

    A

  • Zakir Naik's argument about 'Noor' is a real joke. If Allah is a halogen lamp, then his light isn't his own light. Incandescent lamps glow due to electricity. Hence Allah is secondary in nature and the real source of his light lies somewhere else. Other arguments are also pseudo reasoning.

  • Actully u r the real joke!loool.

  • I found Dr zakirs answer better than dr cambell .his accent wasnt clear as i dont speak english well but man dr cambell lost me, he was so confusing!

    Anyways may god guide us to the right ways :)

    oh yeah also the bible and the christians are have the same god so lets just be very nice to them! as they shall do in return!

    so children lets respect each other!

    Peace yall!!

  • grow up ppl !!!

    the debate was very nice and each sholar respected the other, why dont u ppl do the same!!

    ideed a strong view from Dr zaik made me look deeper in my faith but we should look and see for ourselves for whats true...

    god bless both men, they helped me so much as i was very confused!!

    Peace yall

  • i am a MUSLIM too, n i totally agree that Dr. Zaik overcame Dr. Cambell in the debate, as undoubtedly, the Holy Quran is free from errors. HOWEVER PLEASE DO NOT SAY THAT BIBLE IS DEFEATED. Because the Bible is also the book of Allah S.W.A.T. The problem is that ppl have changed the the Bible, it has been tampered with. So plz do not degrade the Injeel.

  • you are wright my freind.

  • poor Dr Campbell. his face reveals how much he is embarrassed and cornered. next time he will thousand times before he attacks the glorious Quran. Christians were impatiently waiting for him to refute what Dr. Zakir had said, but they were really disappointed when he said that he had no answers.

    They deserve that. hahahahahahahha

  • You mean to say that ingorant people like you who are blindhearted are yet unable to see the truth. If Zakir's arguments are week, then what would you say about the arguments of Campbell. Are they strong? hahahhhahahahahahh

    It is a scandle that the bible and the christions will never forget.

    If Dr Campbell is unable to refute week arguments then he is a donkey.

    WHy do not you show up and debate in stead sinc`e you are so knowledgable?