Roger Waters, David Gilmour, Nick Mason and The Bleeding Heart Band: Outside The Wall, Live O2 Arena

[darkside1995]

como se festejo ese abrazo, jeje, vamos todavia david , roger, nick, y tambien rick

[smedoiunarcis]

live long Pink Floyd!

[cuerpoeperra]

Davis always so quiet....God bless him

[wats8800]

I love when roger puts his arm around nick mason and starts swaying....thats great....I know rick wright is gone..but these three need to get back together man...

[wats8800]

awesome....best thing ever......

[Squeaky300]

And Rog still has those outrageously large biceps :)

[MUSKAO95]

ROGER...IS...GOD

[hzone2008]

Los Jefes de Jefes

[AK4TsEv3N]

My god what a precious moment! :D

[tonylion]

"And from us" Absolutely classy :)

[kmarshall08welding]

good to see those friendly hugs

[aafalk3]

Den beste musik ..love it.

[jorxe21]

nick mason, so pure...!!!

[zaccarroll72]

this is so cool!!!

[taylz94]

1: I almost cried with this... such a warming moment... THIS is what we should be looking up to...

2: Awesome music, awesome people, awesome concert

3: Someone else noticed the click at the end of the video, matching with the TV's used in The Wall?

[dsantanafarias]

David Gilmour at 4:27: "God damnit, I forgot the lyric!"

[dsantanafarias]

David Gilmour at 1:29 : "For Christ sakes, what's he doing?"

[manzadrogada]

i'm not going to lie, i almost cryed

[Melvin9201997]

its like when pink floyd split god split in two, now there are two pieces and there would be world peace if they both went back together

[gdkzen]

Wow. An awful lot of complete garbage going around about Pink Floyd. The war is over. Gilmour and Waters have sat down at the truce table. I'm just happy that Richard Wright lived to join with them and Nick one last time. David and Roger wasted 20 years on a nasty feud. What kind of loser wants to continue that crap, when they have been wise enough to end it?

[echoes983]

Cold, cold, cold David Gilmour.

[ratsalad420]

Brazil awaits you David !

[MongoTheLloyd]

@ratsalad420 Take him, please. Keep him too. Never send him back. Tell him to stop getting his lyrics written by the girl in his bed. They suck as bad as she does. We will replace him with a potted plant that will actually do something; create oxygen instead of merely sucking it up like Dave does.

[HuterDerSchwelle]

i feel so bad for roger. you can see in his eyes how sad he is for how it ended. i understand HE did it. but that doesnt mean you cant feel for him.

[97MrBlues]

@HuterDerSchwelle did what?

[memyselfandi337]

@HuterDerSchwelle if ya dont mind explaining, what exactly happend to the band why did they break up?

[eiffler714]

@memyselfandi337 Roger Waters took over Pink Floyd after "Animals". He badgered the other members into recording and performing "The Wall" which was HIS project and largely autobiographical. He fired both Richard Wright and Nick Mason during this time, realized he should just be a solo and quit the band after "The Final Cut". The other members, reunited under the name Pink Floyd, recorded and toured. Waters sued saying it couldn't be Floyd without him. Gilmour counter-sued and won.

[memyselfandi337]

@eiffler714 thank you, ive been curious about that

[TheMorges1]

@HuterDerSchwelle as the saying goes... you don't know what you got till its gone

[krishu1997]

What an amazing reunion!!! and can anyone tell me what guitar is that ?

[1987BigStu]

@krishu1997 The one that David is playing? That is a mandolin!

[sandwichdisease]

14 DISLIKES???????? What IN THE FUCK.

[anaelpocoyo]

melhor banda que já vi, musicalidade sem igual.

[wavid117]

1:14

Dave: "You have some bad B.O.

1:18

Roger: "If you turn the other way you might smell it less."

[MrFreedomGotAnAK]

Cannot watch this without a smile on my face

[CallSignRaven]

Wonderfull how just this simple happening can make a grown man shed a tear and smile at the same time!!!

Once a Floyd forever a Floyd!!

[MososarkusN]

So...since when has Roger been a trumpeter?

[yehohanan66]

Espero y esto represente una oportunidad más para mi y todos los que nos gusta Pink Floyd de tener al menos un tour más o un disco nuevo... no importa si sólo graban 5 canciones nuevas, compraría el album sin dudarlo.

[ckielthy]

I'm glad to see Roger & David have made a sort of peace after 20+ years.

We saw a reunion at it's best for Live8.

Any more would be sad. Let's let a couple of old farts make up & leave it at that.

[GuitarTosh007]

I truly cried! :)

[donstuie]

14 dislikes?

[monkeybear]

I honestly don't cry at all but this made me shed quite a few tears.

[demonheart06]

the best 8:58 minutes of my life!!!!! :)

[dari654]

To piękny widok,oni razem na jednej scenie,wiemy że to komercja,a jednak cieszy

[DanAndromedaMusic]

I consider myself extremely lucky to be one of the few who where there to see it. I'm not gonna lie I cried like a baby during this <3



[janeddyottem]

wow, its just amazing to see them together again, i wish they could make a last tour as PF. And big thx to Sir Bob Geldof that made them able to talk to eachother again.... i love Pink Floyd

[selktube]

Quanti anni sprecati a litigare...quanta musica meravigliosa avremmo potuto ascoltare!! PECCATO!!

[jackmorefx]

@selktube Davvero,quanti anni! Magari se le cose fossero andate diversamente e fossero rimasti sempre uniti Rick sarebbe ancora vivo,magari :)

[DanikaJadeee]

It was lovely to see the last members left of Pink Floyd together for probably one of , if not the last time.

[Sophie2oo8]

"you're great audience" 5:21 = saying this with Jimmy's voice south park ^.^

jk i love you Wizards ♥

[ThePigBlimp]

I promised myself, that I would not cry...gasp* inhale.



[yanis0061]

All stories deserve a happy ending... even as ones as complicated and grim as the wall

[MUSKAO95]

what i would give for Floyd to do this one more time infront of the world

[VivTheORage]

This moment should be mentioned in history books used at school.

[valdivia562]

@VivTheORage i would rather read about this in school than to read about a black guy being elected president and not doing anything for 4 years

[shikamaruxb3]

so, the question that won't be shut: Will Pink Floyd reunite again?

[Fons1958]

Why is ther so much hate under me

here...????

[LizardKing625]

I'm sure this has been said time and time again, but Outside The Wall would be such a satisfying song to die to. I may only think that though because I could not stop thinking of Rick and Syd through out the performance. Such a magical performance, all while being incredibly bittersweet. Long Live Pink Floyd.

[rockerbestial]

This is fantastic!!! I am so glad to see them on the same stage again. I hope that maybe, one day, they will write some new stuff toghether.

[TheAfs08]

is there any david gilmour concert in the future?

[skyroad3131]

I remember seeing Floyd back during the animals tour in 1977. You could tell back then Roger wasn't a happy camper during the proformance. It was a great show then, but I think as time has gone by and with the deaths of Richard and Syd he looks at his mates a with true affection today. Davis seemed geniunly pleased as did Nick. It is great that they have reconciled.

[ZetMedful]

Verlos juntos aqui es una gran idea nostalgica, incluso con syd,..that could be a....

[ZetMedful]

sailorpsycho.Gracias por la respuesta.Ellos,Waters y Gilmour vinieron a colombia por separado. Gilmour en el 86, en Cali(tenia yo 7 años yo no sabia nada de PF), y en 2007,Waters con el Dark side of the moon tour(bogota),el colorido haz de Luz saliendo directamente del prisma de cristal, pegaba sonoro en mis ojos mientras Roger tocaba y cantaba eclipse...onirico...

[TonyNewman]

Well it's good that Roger admits that he was hard on his bandmates during the Wall and the Final Cut (and indeed afterward). I'm glad he's no longer a grumpy person.

[marceloelperry]

sera un deja vu de lo que va a pasar en argentina????

[DaveGuilmour]

@marceloelperry Si vienen el gordo y Mason me agarra un derrame cerebral ahi mismo en la san martin alta

[IlliniJake]

one of the most stunning things I have ever seen. 

[ZetMedful]

Hello, please i d like thah someone make spanish traslation about speaking. its so amazing see them toghether

[sailorpsycho]

@ZetMedful roger hablaba de finalmente ese era el dia en el que el y gilmour podian compartir escenario en the Wall (haciendo alusion al fallido intento de reunion de 1990) y que; por una extrana coincidencia tambien se habia encontrado con otro miembro de floyd llamando a nick mason cuando terminan waters habla sobre que hace 30 años, mientras hacian la gira de The Wall el era una persona algo amargada y antipatica hacia el publico rocanrolero en general

[sailorpsycho]

@ZetMedful y que todo eso ha cambiado que el no podria estar mas feliz de estar ahi con ellos y con la gente ahi presente; comienza a presentar a cada uno de los presentes y dice alfinal cuando abraza a nick "Y de nosotros, gracias!"

[dellyta]

kill 14 people

[Ashienoelle]

They're all such cute old men!! XD

[tcollins297]

It would suck if you had tickets for any other night of this run hahaha

[Gorrrillla5]

@tcollins297 lol i did :\ i got tickets for his final night in London while this here was his first. :O but anyway it was an incredible show.

[bratzo87]

ROGER!! WAIT TILL YOU COME TO SOUTH AMERICA!....HERE YOU'LL EXPERIENCE A REAL AUDIENCE!!!!!

[acarlbom]

@bratzo87 The kind that throws rocks at performers?

[musicofrustrado1]

tremendos, tremendos!!!



[351974gordon24]

I love how Roger is so much more genuine towards his brothers in Floyd than he used to be. Richard Wright is smiling down from heaven and proud of his mates. :-)

[MongoTheLloyd]

@351974gordon24 Roger was geniune back in to 70s and 80s. He didn't appreciate having to carry the other three, whist listening to their incessant whining that Roger's music wasn't the direction they wanted to go, as they shoved the cash into their pockets that was earned from the genius of Waters. I am sure that his anger was geniune. Waters has simply moved past the anger, rather than suffer it.

[Pexster]

@MongoTheLloyd CARRY David Gilmour??? You are one fucking stupid idiot!!! (I was there, from 1971.) Get some better drugs, dude!!!

[MongoTheLloyd]

@Pexster Yes. Carry Gilmour. You CAN read! I am amazed, Butthead. Usually, from folks who do "dude" coversations... one cannot expect literacy. You were where? Up Dave's ass? Son, I have been to every Floyd tour from DSOTM until the band ceased to exist, when Roger left. Furthermore, I don't do drugs. I don't need them to function, or to color music to make it sound better. Listening to Gilmour, I can see why you need to. Dave is a rat bastard, who only made it because of Waters' genius

[tjrrockandrollmaster]

@MongoTheLloyd You are Brad Cole the troll who trolled Pink Floyd forums. Roger got boring and bland as he got older in addition to greedy, crazy, egomaniacal. I can also say that Neil Peart (pronounced PEER-t with long E) wrote more meaningful lyrics since 1980 than Roger. Amused to Death and Radio KAOS (all crap in my view) pales compared to "Red Sector A", "Manhattan Project", "The Pass", "Ghost Rider" among other great tracks.

[MongoTheLloyd]

@tjrrockandrollmaster No. I am not. But, I won't bother trying to convince an idiot of reality. That would be a waste of my precious time. Yeah? neil Queert, huh? With a long E, you say? Man, you need help. Seriously. Move out of mommy's basement. Sel; your X-box. Use the proceeds to buy a used life off ebay. You might find a deal!

[tjrrockandrollmaster]

@MongoTheLloyd My mother DIED you heartless jerk and I take care of my father you obnoxious punk. You are Brad King that troll who spammed Pink Floyd forums with your "man-love" for Roger Waters and hatred for other bands. You trolled the Floyd videos with your useless rhetoric. In my humble opinion, I think Neil Peart became a better lyricist than Roger with age. Roger has been fixated with same old I hate war, my father died and so forth since The Final Cut.

[shikamaruxb3]

@MongoTheLloyd Roger Waters is a genius indeed, but David Gilmour too. If you were a fan from Pink Floyd, you would know that many of the great songs of the great albuns of Pink Floyd like The Dark Side of the Moon and Wish You Were Here were composed by him.

[MongoTheLloyd]

@shikamaruxb3 Waters IS a genius. Gilmour is not. I am a Waters fan... since he wrote the VAST MAJORITY of Pink Floyd's material in the last 5 albums. Hard to call myself a PF fan, when the other 3 didn't contribute much, as they readily admit in the "Which One's Pink" documentary. I know which songs Dave CONTRIBUTED to, since he only wrote 3 songs himself. Waters = 37 solo credits and 21 co-credits. Dave = 3 solo credits, 24 co-credits. Dave's only genius was NOT WORKING MUCH.

[shikamaruxb3]

@MongoTheLloyd I can't deny that Waters wrote almost the entire albuns of Wish You Were Here, Animals, The Wall and The Final Cut. But Dark Side of the Moon, Obscured by Clouds, Meddle and Atom Heart Mother were wrote by them all. Besides, David wrote a Momentary Lapse of Reason and The Division Bell by himself pratically. And one of the most aprecciated songs of Pink Floyd, Echoes, was writen by him.

[Smodog124]

@shikamaruxb3 i thought nick mason wrote echoes?

[MongoTheLloyd]

@Smodog124 All four received credit for writing it. But, the idea came from Syd. The Gilmour-is-God crowd learned from their master, to take credit where credit is not due. Like father, like idiot bastard children.

[MongoTheLloyd]

@shikamaruxb3 Waters wrote most of DSOTM too. OBC, ASHM were complete tripe. Meddle, yes, some of the 3 boat anchors deserve a little credit for it. The post-Waters albums were not PFloyd. They were Pink Fraud. A mockery of the group itself, and its remaining audience. No, Gilmour had help... his GIRLFRIEND who wrote many of the lyrics. No... Echoes was Syd's idea; it isn't one of the most appreciated songs, being largely forgotten except by die-hard Gilmour penis worshippers.

[shikamaruxb3]

@MongoTheLloyd "Die-hard Gilmour penis worshippers"... That's what i get for trying to dialogue with a fat lifeless coward.

[MongoTheLloyd]

@shikamaruxb3 I don't believe I implied that you specifically worshipped his penis. But, since you mention it... guilty conscience?

[MongoTheLloyd]

@Pexster Uh... and Butthead... since you do seem to need so much correction... it would be "one stupid fucking idiot", not "one fucking stupid idiot". Ah... but you can't expect that Gilmour fans would be good with the English language. Even Dave had to have his girlfriend write the Pink Fraud lyrics after the talent left the band. Words hardly matter when there is that one "Comfortably Numb" solo you can play over and over, ad nauseum.

Moron.

[tjrrockandrollmaster]

@MongoTheLloyd Brad Cole, the best years of Pink Floyd was when Roger's ego was in check by David Gilmour and Rick Wright. Roger became a greedy, crazy, egomanical prick starting with Animals (which Roger rejected anything Rick wrote). David's girlfriend/wife was proofreader on The Division Bell lyrics. He gave her a credit as it said Lyrics : Gilmour/Samson (which means Gilmour AND Samson). Because someone wrote something, there's more to it than that.

[MongoTheLloyd]

@tjrrockandrollmaster Brad Cole? Who is brad Cole? Look son, MANY folks share my opinion that Gilmour and the other two boat anchors did little. In fact, Gilmour, Wright and Mason all admit as much on "Which One's Pink". So, they agree with me that they did little; the actual ALBUM CREDITS buttress my argument; Waters agreed that he pretty much did most of the work. Why can't YOU just accept fact, son... instead of farting out "You are Brad Cole" false accusations?

[tjrrockandrollmaster]

@MongoTheLloyd Mongo you are Brad King. I'm not stupid so don't lie about it. You hate Phil Collins, you hate Neil Peart. Animals was the start of the "Roger Waters Power Trip" where he reduced David Gilmour and Rick Wright's contributions and they went and did solo albums. The only reason why The Wall turned out the way it did was because Gilmour and Bob Ezrin kept Roger's megalomania in check which it then spun out of control with The Final Cut. By the way it's David NOT Dave you sick ogre.

[Pacheik]

if I had been there would have cried like no tomorrow

[tatometal]

PINK FLOYD  FOREVER

[khyron62]

So much awesomeness together.....man....

[kofreone]

Pink Floyd...ever ever ever Pink Floyd....

[citr1992]

@jjairojj

roger has learned from the past the hard way, and has shown that

but david has actually become really egotistical and refuses to work with roger, although i do see that they're polar opposites on the stage, and they've both said that

nick mason is awesome, and one of the best drummers ever, and kept to himself

R.I.P. wright and barrett

i'm so stoked to see roger at the memorial coliseum in L.A. next year woooooo!

[bratzo87]

@citr1992 come on.... thats over....a band has a moment...what you must remember is what they produced! not if they will play together like if it was the 1st year of Pink Floyd.....

[jjairojj]

Roger is a riffraff, tried to destroy pink floyd, treated David, Nick and Rick like nothing,and now treat them like friends?what does he want to show?repant?he is a cool guy?no way,we can see clearly in david and Mason faces that they r not happy,but they r making a great effort being there,Roger is a fucking stupid,and that ``THE NICE GUY SHOW``was shameful, thats all.sorry my bad english

[notnowjon]

@jjairojj Vero, nelle loro facce non c'è allegria, è come se pensassero "cosa avremmo potuto fare se fossimo rimasti UNITI..." Respect!

[jorgealbertobaron]

EMOCIONANTE REENCUENTRO DESPUES DE CUMPLIR MÁS DE 60 AÑOS CADA UNO

[guinness75]

You ever watch these videos and feel like you missed out on seeing one of the greatest bands ever live? Such an experience for those who see the three of them now, but still... to have seen them back in the day...

[minervalion72]

@guinness75 I know exactly what you mean. It pains me that I was born in 1990. An older friend of mine always talks about seeing them at the World Series of Rock in 1977. I have a bootleg, but to have been there would have been unbelievable.

[MrMaximililano]

5:26 Nick is like "sure, leave me out, I was in Pink Floyd too, you know!."

[manzadrogada]

did any of you guys, had the luck of going to that show?

[wt8012]

@manzadrogada I did. I was there that very night when David and Nick appeared on the 12th of May! It was out of this world!!!

[sasoulas]

Why do they look so distant between them?

[dwarfitup]

Shame Richard Wright and Sid are DEAD Shane on you Crazy Diamond

[FOTOCHOCK]

roger crecio de manera espiritual mucho mas que sus compañeros de pink floyd

[Adennos]

2:14 I can see Richard Wright between David and Roger and Syd's face in the background. =''')

[PCEntertainment2]

Is this a DVD for sale?

[sheam907]

Historic. Their music will live on forever.

[scottruplin]

It's rather like a divorced couple getting over it!

[w26240]

I admit, there was a tear in my eye.

[MidnitePoison]

Syd and Richard were smiling while you played together...

[vladdytrout]

Fantastic.

[alezanin1]

PLEASE!!!all of us!!! STOP at 7:56 and listed this frame....it's the history of the past the present and the future of world music!! Simply EPIC!!

Pink FLoyd rules!! 

[MrNjaala]

@alezanin1 I agree, simply epic.

[hoopteechooptee]

The Wall, spectacular!

[PLASTICBRAINWAR]

PLEASE MAKE NEW PINK FLOYD ALBUM

[juzjuzek]

@PLASTICBRAINWAR No. Just don't. Maybe if Richard Wright was still alive...

[slat4090]

REFORM???? PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!

[Mastermind81179]

increible ojala haga lo mismo en chile

[musicjohng]

is that G.E. Smith wow!



[TheeBuschHeavy]

so glad Waters called himself out for being a douche.. good shit, emotional

[motk90]

i hate everyone who was there

[tommyrock69]

And Nick gets a tambourine.

[TubaDudeNick]

@tommyrock69 lmao

[BobMillahhh]

pause the video at 5:59... Roger Waters looks hilariously psychotic.

[caioxx2011]

Os três não existem,são de outras GALÀXIAS.

[nignonignonigno]

wonderful

[annaiscoollike]

They look a little bit uncomfortable at first! bit they're still awesome, best band in the world!

[Linosaaa]

Poxa, podia vir essa galera pros shows aqui no Brasil...

[antropoloco]

Rick and Syd is on the stage too... no doubt of that !

[lisandro1234]

comeback!

[MixedBag27]

I was 18 at this show (my little sister 15) and we never thought we'd ever see Pink Floyd...but that all changed when Nick walked on stage.

This was one of (if not THE) best night of my life.

[wt8012]

I was at this concert. What a show! And what a memory...

[holywoodj]

"As young David will attest". Haha.

[TranceOo]

i couldn't control myself from smiling all the time during this video . Wish i was there

[ganfmof]

how do i get on to the live radio show please?

[tigerek12]

Rick! How I wish You were here!

[guitarguy951]

i'm on the brink of tears as i see them all on one stage without rick...R.I.P. you will always be the greatest pianists in rock n roll. to you i wave my lighter, and raise my glass to. wish you were here.

[henrytdsimmons]

Shivers down the spine...

[gilbtx]

Wow!!! 

[fanatiquillo]

que emocion ver todos estos genios juntos de nuevo aunque sea por un rato aguante pink floyd !!!! una banda legendaria

[crizzy71]

Gives a nice sense of closure to all the Floyd drama. Well done, gentlemen.

[69treta]

My God, Roger, please bring David to Brazil too!

[toborthegreat]

Hey does anyone know if the guitar player next to David Gilmour is GE Smith? He used to be on SNL and was the guitarist for Hall & Oates. Thanks, Vic

[austin27332]

@toborthegreat it is GE Smith

[thomasin1000]

los amoooooooooooo!



[escaton74]

Rogers speech at the end was kinda heartwarming !

[CanTrk]

Wish Floyd would come to Moncton and play the hill!

[lynom1]

Sublime encore.

[MrBOB2292]

9 ppl are retarded and dont know about music

[instanceTu]

isnt thise were we came in?

[BobMillahhh]

I want this on DVD so fucking bad.