Scissor Sisters - Comfortably Numb

[Phedrus1975]

Sacrilege.

WTF were they thinking?

What's next, a synth-pop version of 'Brothers in Arms'? Electro-pop version of 'November Rain'? If I want to hear clown music, I'll visit a circus...

[BitaminaTek]

Why isn't this song on top of the search results when i am searching for "comfortably numb"? What the fuck is Pink Floyd? Are they a rival gay band? :-D

[ZwergbuntbarschLP]

@BitaminaTek I hope you are not serious.

[MrFeedback71]

Horrible. I hate when these pop groups try to remake a good song and completely change it to their own style. If they had left it close to the original with just a bit of their own flavor mixed in, maybe it wouldn't have completely sucked.

[po0pdawg]

@MrFeedback71 so basically copy the original song and then just change it a little? great advice.

[MrFeedback71]

@po0pdawg

I stand by what I said. A classic like this should not be turned into some pop BS. Leave it be or write something original. Not disco dog$hit like this.

[po0pdawg]

@MrFeedback71 Oh... I see. You'd prefer it as though it were like Billy Idol's cover of Mony Mony by Tommy James and The Shondells?

[MrFeedback71]

@po0pdawg

Could you throw out a more obscure example?. I don't even know Mony Mony by the Shondells so I couldn't possibly have an opinion on Billy Idol's version as compared to that.

[po0pdawg]

@MrFeedback71 Well I assumed since you knew so much about rock and covers that you would know one of the most popular covers of all time.

[MrFeedback71]

@po0pdawg

I think you just want to argue. I never said anything about my knowledge. I simply stated an opinion. But if you really do want to know, yes, I am a musician and I did play in a rock/metal band for years. IMO, this type of cover sucks. And, IMO, this is the kind of thing that is wrong with the music industry today. I wish groups like this would just write their OWN crap for their OWN audience and quit ruining great songs by great bands by making lame, junk covers. Again, just my .02.

[po0pdawg]

@MrFeedback71 I see your point, sir, but let me tell you why thats bullshit. How many of the greatest bands of all time have made covers? Bands Such as Queen and Led Zeppelin.

[Donorix]

Ich kotz gleich!!!

zum Glück gibt es da noch die version von kirlian camera

[Krandorr]

I just threw up

[CoversUnited]

@Krandorr nub

[noniar45]

God

How can ruin such a good topic?

David guilmour is the best, this is an insult

[CoversUnited]

@noniar45 nub

[scissorever]

yeah some prrof are in Scissor Sisters first dvd and it is said in a interview with them....@GotTimeToooKill

[scissorever]

say say it poor david gilmour...but our David gilmour says in 2003 "the most Beautiful cover of our song!" and he wanted a Single disc of Scissor Sisters' cover!!! shut up YGibsonY!!!

[GotTimeToooKill]

@scissorever WTF when did he say this?!?! thats def a lie send me some proof

[serberious]

Maybe the thousands of people who turned up to hear them ?.

[MrMaxspd]

Ok.. seriously.. WTF??... is this for real?? ... is it a kids show?.. is it a 3rd world country band?.. are they high?... what could possibly make them think this is even remotely anything good?.. *Puke*

[rydothemaniac]

they should be done for murder they destroyed an amazing song

[CoolIizard]

@rydothemaniac I actually kinda like the lyrical dissonance. If you listen, it's that much more disturbing.

[occamshairbrush]

Babydaddy's guitar parts are so much better in the live versions.

[YGibsonY]

LOOSER, LOOSER, LOOSER, LOOSER

poor David Gilmour

This Band is one of the greatest "looser-bands" all over the world!

[yermanferreira]

QUE BUENO, LOS AMO!!!

[MadisonPatrello]

This Made Me Want to rip My Ears off

[scissorever]

bellissimo video!! un pò sfguocato ma va bene lo stesso ^_^ c'è pure il sito e il forum italiano uficiale su forumfree bye bye

[missanamatronic]

i tried really hard to come see this gig..but finally it didn't work =(

i left italy two days too early...

thanks for posting!!