She was my favourite, and a fantastic singer in high, low, belting, and in acting/emotional expression. I was so sad that she was voted off. I would love to see her play Rose in a production of Gypsy! I would go to see that again and again! (At least Elicia was my second-favourite.)
same here her parents were my parents close friend....and she was voted off because she was a lil over weight cuz if she was skinny no girl could touch her!
donna is the best girl in this competition. the "janna" support is so annoying because hello people; voting for janna would be so typical! just because she has the haircut and looks a tiny bit like julie andrews doesnt mean she should win. shes talented but not like donna. donna will bring something new to the role, some youth (as janna looks just too old...and tall) as well as a new image.she can belt act and do soprano!!
Fact: the real maria Vontrapp was a full figure woman
No offence to anybody's opinions or her BUT I don't think Donna should be Maria. I mean, her voice is great, but her attitude isn't. It's like she doesn't care for anyone there but herself. I'm sorry, but I don't appreciate that. That's just what I think.
Yes Donna and Elicia are the best but I don't think it was very fare to give Donna such a great song to work with when a lot of the girls got horrible songs.
She's really good! Wonderful voice! Very talented. And just for the record, I think she's beautiful - I don't care what she weighs, and only a small minded fool would even bring that up, as it is absolutely irrelevant!
This is the first performance I've seen of her, but just from that last note- she would make a good Elphaba in wicked.
Asperger1993 6 months ago
shes so awesome :) a great person to work with :)
ATLmusicislove 1 year ago
holy crap donna can sing!!
Lahela12 2 years ago 2
how far did she come?
shes amazing
anyone else thinks she looks a bit like shoshana bean
Jamiekennywicked 3 years ago
She had a outstanding voice, but I agree with sorhythmic, her voice was too powerful, and her look isn't right for Maria.
chaoskade379 3 years ago
Elicia won.
vegi3tarian 3 years ago
She was my favourite, and a fantastic singer in high, low, belting, and in acting/emotional expression. I was so sad that she was voted off. I would love to see her play Rose in a production of Gypsy! I would go to see that again and again! (At least Elicia was my second-favourite.)
gogododonna 3 years ago 2
same here her parents were my parents close friend....and she was voted off because she was a lil over weight cuz if she was skinny no girl could touch her!
just2hot 3 years ago
donna is my ex boyfriends sister..i think she is amazing!!!! GO DONNA!!!!! ill keep voting cuz i think u are amazing!!!! GOOD LUCK!!!
brandie062778 3 years ago 2
I LOVE Marisa :) She's great AND very cute!
vegi3tarian 3 years ago
donna is the best girl in this competition. the "janna" support is so annoying because hello people; voting for janna would be so typical! just because she has the haircut and looks a tiny bit like julie andrews doesnt mean she should win. shes talented but not like donna. donna will bring something new to the role, some youth (as janna looks just too old...and tall) as well as a new image.she can belt act and do soprano!!
Fact: the real maria Vontrapp was a full figure woman
fact:
jacobmacinnis 3 years ago 7
OMFG THANK YOU ME AND MY DAD HAVE sAID THAT THE HOLE COMPITION!!!
just2hot 3 years ago
Just a reminder this is a casting process for a very specific role. Not the search for another pop star. The show is taking place down the road.
Donna is a remarkable singer but ultimately not right for the role. There's no foul in saying that.
This is just another reason why someone should be creating an Idol style vehicle for something other than children to compete in.
thefreepresstheband 3 years ago
No offence to anybody's opinions or her BUT I don't think Donna should be Maria. I mean, her voice is great, but her attitude isn't. It's like she doesn't care for anyone there but herself. I'm sorry, but I don't appreciate that. That's just what I think.
vegi3tarian 3 years ago
well she is in a fucking compition u asshole
just2hot 3 years ago
Beautiful
jaromir 3 years ago 6
Yes Donna and Elicia are the best but I don't think it was very fare to give Donna such a great song to work with when a lot of the girls got horrible songs.
ChristinaAguilera17 3 years ago 2
The 3 favourites for me - Donna, Elicia and Janna. Great performances all 3.
Will be good to see if Donna can do high-end and ballad/subtle, she can clearly do low-end belters.
Can someone please shoot the costumier?
Can John stop repeating everything 3 times as he kept doing in IDA, it's so irritating?
John - you're a prat, a prat, a prat.
ps. Can the presenter and judges get any more camp? The performers are practically tripping over the limp wrists.
Keep watching folks.
lukedean999 3 years ago
Donna reminds me a bit of Kate Smith.
Canadian99999 3 years ago
she really reminds me of Jodie from I'd do anything (the voice and personality and stuff) anyone agree?
xHatchx 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No affiance to her but
Shes Fat!
Rihannaiskool1 3 years ago
Ahem, Donna's my cousin...
So awesome when I heard she's on the show and suddenly she's one of the best singers on there i was like:
"Sweet!"
Andokool12 3 years ago
She's really good! Wonderful voice! Very talented. And just for the record, I think she's beautiful - I don't care what she weighs, and only a small minded fool would even bring that up, as it is absolutely irrelevant!
Canadian99999 3 years ago 2
i am sooo sorry about this comment.... I WAS HACKED!
i thinks shes good! its nice to no she ur cousin best of luc.
but i like Katie
Rihannaiskool1 3 years ago 2
I agree. The best 2.
MissiCharli 3 years ago