Mariah Carey, Celine Dion and Jessica Simpson - Oh, Holy Night

[pinko7589]

Mariah is way better than the others.

[mvpgary]

Should this really be a question? Of course its Mariah!!! And I do like Jessica but seriously....

[MUMU111088]

1st jessica 2nd celine 3rd maria

[keptdude]

I PREFER CELINE'S VERSION BY FAR...SHE HAS SUCH AN ANGELIC VOICE AND CHRISTMAS REMINDS ME OF ANGELS...

[EnzoLopez1962]

Celine Dion.

[Patsforlife1]

LOLZ! Jessica... really??? Mariah, on her worst day, sounds better than you do on your best.

[MusicLuver093]

MARIAH DUHHHH

[edantolin1]

beautiful song and good voice of mariah carey only. joaquin/marvin antolin

[nwt1234]

ok im not gonna hate on celine (i really hate her but anyway) judging this fareley i think she's got a good belting voice but i really really don't like her tone at all, it makes me flinch when i hear it. and jessica simpson has got a good voice but i can't compare her to mariah carey seriously. well mariah's version is just vocal perfection and just has so much control over her voice in this song.

[wittywooba]

i like mariah carey in this song:)

[chae101]

Celine Dion for sure! I love Mariah Carey but, I jst don't like the way she did this song! She changed it up a little too much for me (but i still love her) and i just don't really like Jessica Simpson at all...

[muscle25ftl]

I actually think Jessica has the best voice color.

[muscle25ftl]

You didn't include Jessica's big hit note at the end of the song.

[crazy2hazy]

Jessica has a decent voice, but she uses it all wrong. She has no idea how to sing so she settles on either breathing a song or blowing out her throat and calls it belting.

Celine has a very good voice, i'd even call it perfect, and her version is very good in my opinion.

But Mariah is truly a musical genius. I think her version displays the best vocal coloring, she goes into so many different registers, sustains crazy notes, and her phrasing is fantastic.

[bennyleipold]

hahah, when jessica came up, i just had to laugh..

[muechacha]

Theres no comparison Mariah and Celine r the best but it depends if like a more modern sound (Mariah) or a more I guess u could say 80's way of singing (celine)

[PrincessGabriela1987]

Why people always argue over such a silly things?!

[Tampabruh]

Mariah is the best to me, she doesnt hold back when she sings this song.

Celine word be number two, because she sing it the most uses the most classical method/ tone of voice.

Please dont hate me for saying this but Jessica sounds like a desperate Marolyn Monroe when she sings. Not cute at all.

[PsuedoSenator]

Celine's is the most powerful and emotionally inspiring. Mariah's is good too just too over the top and ostentatious towards the end..sometimes less is more. THING IS you didn't even include the final portions of Celine's or Jessica's versions.

[Devotedlamb19]

Mariah destroys both Celine and Jessica.

[MrxCasz]

I think Jessica is best... =)

But for some reason the creator of this video didn't show ONE part of the song where you can her how good jess' voice is... =\

[jerjuant]

i bet you put jessica in here just to be funny???

[hiloc19]

Mariah the best?...you people must have had your ear drums shattered when she hit her dog calling voice pitch!...Celine sang it the way it was meant to be sung...traditional,not r&b moaning!

[elie280838]

Mariahs version is the best ever!!!!

the vocals that mariah added to the song are on a much higher level than Celine can ever dream of.

i would love to hear Celine doing that " dog calling" ur talking about.

no one can compare to Carey's vocals. that means no one.

[hiloc19]

dog calling,glass breaking,or nails on a chalkboard...thats how Mariah sounds!High pitched ,ear bleeding noise!...very annoying!

[elie280838]

hahahaha.... thats kinda funny. the way u think. ( no offence)

[ramonsuave]

you would think Celine would be able to do whistle register i mean she is singing through her nose everything else. Mariahs version sleighs her version! its way better but to Celine's credit she does have the best classical version i guess.

[Tampabruh]

Lol dont be jealous.

[Tampabruh]

Dude or whoever you dont insult r&b like that. Just because Mariah sings with a little more effort than most singers doesnt means she's moaning. It means sings exhibiting talent! Something you obviously know little to nothing about!

[hiloc19]

Sounds more like she's exhibiting pain.If moaning and ear drum piercing noises are what you enjoy,i can't stop you!To each his own ...

[JeWiiSmilyface1]

Mariah and Celine are the best but if I must choose I choose Mariah. Her voice is hard to compete with.

[elie280838]

MaRiaH definetly. Mariha and celine are great.

[jigglegirl60]

mariah's and celine's version of oh holy night was the best. jessica's version was not that great sorry. that is my opinion.

[sweetyamyyy]

Celine Dion & Mariah Carey, sorry jessica

[suicas]

jessica simpson i love you but JS loses to both divas in terms of vocal strength, technique, range......

[riggs0403]

mariah carey all the way!!!!celine's version is very boring....i can't feel jessica in here..i'm sorry...

[angelvoice1993]

1#mariah carey

2# celine dion

.

.

.

999,999,999,9999,9999,9999, jessica simpson

hahahahahaha very lol

[singingdancing91]

mariah all the way

[blackforest]

celine dion was the most soothing.. mariah carey version was refreshing and of course her voice was really attrative.. JS loses to both divas in terms of vocal strength, technique, range......

[CFNumeroUno]

NOW, but her range was wider than Celine's when she first came out. That's a fact.

[Lexie5563]

no need 2 ask, every1 knows mariah would wins. she is totally best!!

[iotekhaneokwire]

Mariah's is the best version ever.

[mandomariah]

#1 MARIAH CAREY

#2

#3 CELINE DION

#4

.

.

.

#9,999,999 jessica simpson

[tangthebang]

Jessica Simpson's name should never be in the same sentence with Celine or Mariah. Whitney,Celine and Mariah are the top three according to most people(American Idol judges).

[mandomariah]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH LOL SO TRUE

[darkdolores]

Mariah Carey - best by miles of these three.

[lizitapril]

they all sucks

[Reynan12345]

MARIAH BEST RENDITION!

[hghtrn]

Mariah's the best! ♥♥♥♥♥...

[celinerocksxx]

celine x

[talentedchicka1]

jessica all that way!

[liketnlikis]

Mariah Killed it man i love her