Added: 5 years ago
From: cc011477
Views: 98,212
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (72)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 每個人對誰唱誰的歌的感覺本來就不同~

    但我比較喜歡Jolin唱這首,鼻音很好聽

    Elva我覺得唱的很活潑~

  • 愛的豬大哥??

  • 這首歌變得很可怕...

  • 不如蕭亞軒那麼有味道。

    現在的蔡依林唱可能又不同了

  • Elva is good at this song

    JOlin makes it not bad :x

    Lovw both of them :x

  • key不适合啦~Jolinの声音适合唱高keyの~如果调高k­ey来唱会比较好咯~

  • another pretty face, no talent asian singer. elva whoops her ass at this.

  • @raigami I think you are even more talentless. Congrats for digging up an old video to criticise a singer.

  • @o2kaya1: thanks, right back atcha. yea, i cant sing for shit, but at least i can tell who can and who cant sing.

  • ELVA唱得比較有力!POWERFUL!

    可是JOLIN聲音不適合這首歌-.-

  • jolin以前的歌声不太适合,现在她的歌声比较女人味,如果现­在唱应该会不一样吧...

  • ELVA聲音比較有後勁

    JOLIN聲音比較柔和

  • Jolin better !

  • jolin 的聲音不適合這類.

    畢竟這首歌也是為elva而定的

    elva比較好也是正常啊:)

  • 依林的歌声比较甜蜜,不太适合这种歌罢了。两个都有自己的特色吧­。

  • 對啊 歌路不同 難怪她們都能各有自己的特色生存在演藝圈

  • elva唱的比較好聽;D

    支持elva

  • 虽然不难听,但是声音听起来就没什么力气,觉得累累的,和萧亚轩­十分不同。可能蔡依林比较适合唱其他型的歌。

    应该说,一首歌还是原唱最能唱出那首歌想表达的感情、感觉

  • both elva n jolin my fav singers

  • 你在搞什麼

  • PUI. lose to elva la

  • her dancing is cool but i reserve comment for her voice...

  • lose to elva

  • 不好聽餒......=  =

  • i agree with you

  • Spare her...she's singing other people's song so give her some credit for trying. Elva will sound weird singing her song too, right?

  • 會的多過你

  • this also need to learn...you said she just know that then what did you know??

  • house舞曲被她唱成抒情歌了。。。

  • Anybody know the name of the song that's played? What album was this song released on?

  • Comment removed

  • elva siu- 愛的主打歌

  • elva的KEY比較低..

    這個音域對jolin來說不太能表現力道

    如果把KEY調高一點就能更完美了~

    他們2個都很棒

    但elva如果唱jolin的歌到了副歌可能會有點吃力不然就要­換假音

    每個人擅長的部份不同而已

  • 同意你說的~

    jolin同elva都好棒~

  • i agree with u too ^^

    this song just isn't in the right key for her, her voice is higher pitched than elva's

    certainly they both sing well

  • 唱歌的力道不夠

    我比較喜歡elva

  • so cute

  • ELVE 就是POWERRRRRRR

  • I love Jolin but this song Elva is better!!

  • I think elva was better.

    Whys Jolin singing anyways?

    Elva has a deep and rich voice thats better for this song :/

  • 唱什麼...還是elva強

  • lyk duhhhh...

    she is jolin nt elva, but she dun suck, jus dat elva is better...

  • Jolin唱什么Elva的歌啊。。。我比较喜欢Elva...­

  • 她在跳什麼耶...=.=''

  • 唱的沒瞎米味道!!

    舞也跳的很.......

  • cardio machine

  • heh...Jolin is better at singing her own songs, Elva is the best at this song, no doubt.

  • 唱得沒什味道....... 還是elva唱功比較強..

  • jolin so great~

  • Elva is much better!!!

  • although i luv jolin, but she ruins this song, i have to admit

  • jolin is a greate singer,

    but her voice doesn't fit with this kind of music. i think elva's version is better.

  • wow, large colourful floral prints. whenever was that in fashion? not in the past decade that i can remember. yeah she 72 变 auntie.

  • both singing and dancing are awkward

  • her voice are not suitable for tis kind of song.

    too girlish, tis song muz hav lots of power which she din deliver and not so high pitch.not comparing her wif elva. but tt juz wat i tink.

    and why jolin sing her song ?

  • jolin voice is more gentle... elva voice is more powerful...

  • her voice doesn't blend well with this song...

  • elva can dance better n sing better

  • how come everyone's like comparing elva to jolin? xD i know this is elva's song but on other videos they were like comparing elva and jolin. they both have different styles of singing and it's good in their own ways i don't really think there's anything to compare about them...

  • Elva is Dancing Queen!

    And Elva's voice is powerful than Jolin's.Jolin is kind of to mouth of the song

  • Are you sure? I feel that Elva can dance better and sing better than Jolin. Jolin's dance a bit weird!!!

  • jolin have her own way of singing.. jolin can dance better than elva..

  • I like hers better than Elva's, much more like a dance song. Elva can't dance.

  • No offense, but this version really gives me goosebumps. Her enunciation isn't as clear as Elva's...

  • i like the other version better

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more