@atheoch it's not the point, tobestill has a very lovely voice, and as a budding artist posting video, her guitar is fine. By the way, there are 3 rules in life, the first one is to be kind, the second one is to be kind and the third one is to be kind! Somebody smart said that.
I had never heard Dylan wrote this song. News to me. After all these years. Of course I'm just now learning the telling lyrics. Men can be so insensitive.
@Ed534 Immediately with the sexist anti men remarks.. Dylan is extremely sensitive and not sexist, based on the words of all the hundreds of his songs
listening again - surely I've been here before though I didn't find... I'd totally love to hear it how it sounds if you'd use the head register... have a good week tobee!! ;o)
She found it written on a napkin or scrap of paper when they were lovers..He didn't recall writing it or so it goes....What another great song.....by Bob
my very favorite song ...performed so gently by you...your voice and guitar...adds the sweet melody...that has me hitting 'replay'...again and again....
If it's of interest, the reason Dylan never recorded this himself is because he knew the melody was extremely similar to "It's All Over Now Baby Blue." If it were his voice singing this, that fact would've immediately been obvious, and critics might've accused him of repeating himself.
@000Yerch000 As far as I can remember from the Road-Movie "Don´t Look Back" Bob wrote this song but gave it to Joan because he mightn´d had a use for it. So you can say the rights of this song are by Joan though the credits say Written by Bob Dylan.
Very, very nice. Your guitar playing reminds me a little of Paul Simon, but your voice is uniquely you, which is a good thing. Any more information to offer on your profile, so we can know a little more about the artist who is known simply tobestill? All the best. - Mark
Thank you very much for your comment. I don't really like to expose myself, I mean apart from the singing, on the Internet, so I won't disclose more than what I have already written on the description area of my channel; maybe I'll do it when I get a little more confident about what I do, or when I have written my own songs....but I can always answer to personal messages though. Thanks again for your support, best wishes!
haha! yes, it's not meant to be serious, but that's the word she actually ironically uses :) she said that, at the time, he wrote so many songs he didn't even remember them and so she would pick or "steal" some of them without him noticing :)
Merci beaucoup pour ce commentaire! Ma guitare est une Takamine, j'aimerais bien tester une Martin un jour...
Vous avez l'ouïe fine: au début je faisais une seule prise mais ça ne rendait rien au niveau du son (décalage entre celui de la guitare et celui de la voix) donc maintenant j'en fais deux. Ca me permet aussi de faire moins d'erreurs à la guitare, vu que je suis encore débutante ^^
Ce qui prouve la qualité des guitares Takamine...
Tester une Martin n'est pas le plus difficile. Et puis si vous vous mettez à chanter dans le magasin, le vendeur va vous sortir le grand jeu.. Martin ne fait plus payer ses guitares à Joan Baez depuis plus de 40 ans, c'est même l'inverse.
une de mes chansons préférées chantées par Joanie et je dois dire que ton interprétation est excellente - cette chanson n'a pas l'air très facile à chanter . Ton jeu de guitare est vraiment bon aussi
Merci! oui le chant n'est pas facile sur celle-ci, entre les aigus et les "semi-parlés".... J'aurais dû la chanter une tonalité un peu plus basse, comme la version studio, mais bon, c'est toujours possible :) ! Le picking à la guitare est vraiment chouette, il faut que j'arrive à trouver un moyen de rendre le son de l'instrument plus net :)
Merci beaucoup pour ton commentaire! Oui je m'y suis mise toute seule il y a un an et deux mois maintenant très précisément ^^ ! Disons que c'est Joan qui m'a permis de passer à la vitesse supérieure...!!!
i guess it's why you never have 'left' me....and why i return....beautiful voice....beautiful 'you'....
ibtheonlymarktoo 1 month ago
Great cover, sounds just like a Joan Baez accoustic version. Good job
Phantom3907 1 month ago
Oh you're too kind! I've never thought it was that very good but then it is a difficult song to perform! Glad you liked it.
tobestill 1 month ago
good job!!
kanavulator 1 month ago
Thanks!
tobestill 1 month ago
@atheoch it's not the point, tobestill has a very lovely voice, and as a budding artist posting video, her guitar is fine. By the way, there are 3 rules in life, the first one is to be kind, the second one is to be kind and the third one is to be kind! Somebody smart said that.
fernwood01 7 months ago
Are you nuts? Joan stole this song? Then she stole all the songs he gave her to sing (hopefully because he was and is unable to sing).
atheoch 7 months ago
tobestill, you almost had me fooled. It took me almost 15 seconds to realize you are not Joan. Nevertheless, it was an excellent cover.
fernwood01 8 months ago
Thank you very much!!
tobestill 8 months ago
@fernwood01 Honestly 15 sec was too much. You can't even compare guitar playing....
atheoch 7 months ago
Omg! Is this really you?! You sound exactly like her! Keep up the good work! :D
TheEpicMusicChannel 8 months ago
Thank you!! Yes that's me :) you're very kind!
tobestill 8 months ago
@tobestill I'm only saying the truth. There really no comprassion. Your voice is so flawless! I'd love to hear more of your covers!
TheEpicMusicChannel 8 months ago
Thanks so much. I have quite a few other songs on my channel, including real videos and I plan to upload more :) you can check them out!
tobestill 8 months ago
Dylan wrote this song for her to sing during one of the many times he squatted at her house.
2832633 10 months ago
Bravissima!
maximolb 10 months ago
tobestill, why no carreer, your amazing!!
pbesmer 10 months ago
Thank you, you're very kind! Maybe someday I can play live more but for now music is "just" a passion not a job :)
tobestill 10 months ago
this is really an amazing cover...both the guitar and singing are top notch. one of the best i've heard on youtube.
TubeUser718 11 months ago
Thank you very much, you're very kind. I'm glad you liked it!
tobestill 11 months ago
I had never heard Dylan wrote this song. News to me. After all these years. Of course I'm just now learning the telling lyrics. Men can be so insensitive.
Ed534 1 year ago
@Ed534 Immediately with the sexist anti men remarks.. Dylan is extremely sensitive and not sexist, based on the words of all the hundreds of his songs
pbesmer 10 months ago
THIS IS NOT JOAN BAEZ SINGING.........I HAVE HER CD OF THIS SONG AND THIS IS DEFINATELY NOT HER.
MrStarbucks10001 1 year ago
THIS IS NOT JOAN BAEZ SINGING.........I HAVE HER CD IF THIS SONG AND THIS IS DEFINATELY NOT HER.
MrStarbucks10001 1 year ago
this is the best ' singing / understanding ' of a bob ' song '
that i i will ever hear ! '
thank you ' you are a beautiful soul ! ' you play the guitar like an angel ! '
mark
markparrgardiner 1 year ago
I would love to hear you sing Girl Child Linda (Written by Donavan) covered by
J Baez MImi.&J Collins.I think you would do true justice to that song
God bless
topgate 1 year ago
I LOVE yer accent !
sublimeruca27 1 year ago
listening again - surely I've been here before though I didn't find... I'd totally love to hear it how it sounds if you'd use the head register... have a good week tobee!! ;o)
frozenwhitebear 1 year ago
Dude your version is better than Joan Baez's, its really beautiful (not that her's isnt), but its just awesome.
germansoccerfn 1 year ago
Wow thanks very much, I've never really liked my recording of this but glad YOU did!
tobestill 1 year ago
Oh yes, thanks for your cover and sharing with us.
napman99 1 year ago
Thank you very much for listening and commenting.
tobestill 1 year ago
She found it written on a napkin or scrap of paper when they were lovers..He didn't recall writing it or so it goes....What another great song.....by Bob
B4001950 1 year ago
Very well done... you have perfect voice.. this is one of the best cover I've heard ! Btw its difficult song! ... x x
terianka 1 year ago
my very favorite song ...performed so gently by you...your voice and guitar...adds the sweet melody...that has me hitting 'replay'...again and again....
ibtheonlymark 1 year ago
Thanks again for stopping by and leaving a comment. I'm touched you like listening to my songs. Take care
tobestill 1 year ago
Lovely
vintagezigg 2 years ago
I Love your version of this song its my favorite beside the one with Earl Skuggs, and Richard Watson. Very nice good job
blueridger28 2 years ago
loving that guitar in the background already!
you sound like a hybrid between Joan and Dylan. It's quite magnificent. :] very very nice cover.
Happy holidays.
annwnevelyn 2 years ago
If it's of interest, the reason Dylan never recorded this himself is because he knew the melody was extremely similar to "It's All Over Now Baby Blue." If it were his voice singing this, that fact would've immediately been obvious, and critics might've accused him of repeating himself.
IDLERACER 2 years ago
@IDLERACER lol like dylan would care what the critics thought; how can you be so stupid
moceanu 1 year ago
yeah.. good song, but it's not really a cover.. when as far as i know she was the only one who recorded it to an album
000Yerch000 2 years ago
As it is me singing here, it is at least a cover of Joan Baez if it's not a cover of Dylan :)
tobestill 2 years ago
@000Yerch000 As far as I can remember from the Road-Movie "Don´t Look Back" Bob wrote this song but gave it to Joan because he mightn´d had a use for it. So you can say the rights of this song are by Joan though the credits say Written by Bob Dylan.
ryanrocks84 1 year ago
Very, very nice. Your guitar playing reminds me a little of Paul Simon, but your voice is uniquely you, which is a good thing. Any more information to offer on your profile, so we can know a little more about the artist who is known simply tobestill? All the best. - Mark
manriq47 2 years ago
Thank you very much for your comment. I don't really like to expose myself, I mean apart from the singing, on the Internet, so I won't disclose more than what I have already written on the description area of my channel; maybe I'll do it when I get a little more confident about what I do, or when I have written my own songs....but I can always answer to personal messages though. Thanks again for your support, best wishes!
tobestill 2 years ago
simple beautiful
b00027628 2 years ago
lol, she didn't steal it from him...u should change that in the info window.
welldonefromhereon 2 years ago
haha! yes, it's not meant to be serious, but that's the word she actually ironically uses :) she said that, at the time, he wrote so many songs he didn't even remember them and so she would pick or "steal" some of them without him noticing :)
tobestill 2 years ago
cool :) ..thnx 4 clearing that up! :)
welldonefromhereon 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
great job! let me know what you think of my covers as well.
giants4635 2 years ago
C'est nickel, et ça fait plaisir que des jeunes de 20 ans continuent de faire vivre ces joyaux des années 60.
Je me demande juste si vous enregistrez en " one take " ou 1) guitare + 2) voix.
Il me semble reconnaître le son d'une Martin, une D35 ?
Bravo. les étoiles vont s'accumuler...
zardozfrance 2 years ago
Merci beaucoup pour ce commentaire! Ma guitare est une Takamine, j'aimerais bien tester une Martin un jour...
Vous avez l'ouïe fine: au début je faisais une seule prise mais ça ne rendait rien au niveau du son (décalage entre celui de la guitare et celui de la voix) donc maintenant j'en fais deux. Ca me permet aussi de faire moins d'erreurs à la guitare, vu que je suis encore débutante ^^
tobestill 2 years ago
Ce qui prouve la qualité des guitares Takamine...
Tester une Martin n'est pas le plus difficile. Et puis si vous vous mettez à chanter dans le magasin, le vendeur va vous sortir le grand jeu.. Martin ne fait plus payer ses guitares à Joan Baez depuis plus de 40 ans, c'est même l'inverse.
zardozfrance 2 years ago
une de mes chansons préférées chantées par Joanie et je dois dire que ton interprétation est excellente - cette chanson n'a pas l'air très facile à chanter . Ton jeu de guitare est vraiment bon aussi
christophe76382 2 years ago
Merci! oui le chant n'est pas facile sur celle-ci, entre les aigus et les "semi-parlés".... J'aurais dû la chanter une tonalité un peu plus basse, comme la version studio, mais bon, c'est toujours possible :) ! Le picking à la guitare est vraiment chouette, il faut que j'arrive à trouver un moyen de rendre le son de l'instrument plus net :)
tobestill 2 years ago
J'adore cette chanson et ma foi, je dois dire que ta reprise est vraiment chouette !!! Très jolie voix et jeu de cordes très sensible !
Attends, tu as appris à jouer de la guitare en 1 an comme ça ?
Je vais vite me cacher, là... Ouyouyou ! :)
nemito79 2 years ago
Merci beaucoup pour ton commentaire! Oui je m'y suis mise toute seule il y a un an et deux mois maintenant très précisément ^^ ! Disons que c'est Joan qui m'a permis de passer à la vitesse supérieure...!!!
tobestill 2 years ago
Très belle interprétation
fannydecouverte 2 years ago
Merci beaucoup Fanny!
tobestill 2 years ago
this is a powerful rendition! :)
frozenwhitebear 2 years ago
merci!
tobestill 2 years ago
You really don't need my help...! Brava! Ciao, Marco.
marcoacca 2 years ago
Thank you Marco... I feel a little guilty, I hope I didn't waste your time...I'm sorry!
tobestill 2 years ago