This song is my life! My ex and I were engaged but with our jobs we hardly saw each other. It was like living with a stranger after a point. We broke off our engagement the day before Christmas Eve. Last week I went to a bar with my bff to have some fun. I saw him with his new girlfriend. I left the bar and got into my car and was heading home when the CD I had in was on shuffle and this song came on. I had to pull over and cry. I'm happy for him, I can’t hold onto the past for forever...
I started listening to this band when I was thirteen or fourteen and I loved them ever since.. I am sixteen years old and still their lyrics get to me.. Josh Ramsay is one of my biggest Inspirations and he has saved me LITTERALLY with his music and voice. ;3 I drink coke zero and listen to their music and SING MY HEART OUT , keep it up!
@SiNg4LiFeX It's amazing and they are all very talented.. all four. Yes I have a majour obsession with Josh but Ian, Matt and Mike get CREDIT because without them there would be NO MARIANAS TRENCH !
@cheemokinz06 The physical copy of the album is not out yet in the US. I heard its gonna come out in 2012 but Im not sure :/ but you can buy the digital on Itunes :D
@xxXemokittycatsXxx i want him to be happy i just wish i was the one that made him happy. When i was falling in love with him he was falling in love with her..... this song is exactly how i feel...
@xxXemokittycatsXxx That's true to an extent, he's not saying he wants her to be miserable, he just wants to be the only one to make happy, so to that he says why can't you just be lonely?
Alright, So I was talking to my ex, telling I still had a huge amount of feeling's and all the time I was talking to her, I was listening to this song. I do admit it brought tears. Just because I miss her so much, she is the best thing for me. Have you ever had that one person that made you feel so good and then just out of nowhere something fuck's up and their gone? ....Don't care it you read it or not. Had to tell someone.
i love this song, but i don't understand it. its like, he's singing about how he wants her to be lonely and all 2 himself, but then hes saying its just 'so soon'.
@bluemuffinsentertain Here's the way I see it: They broke up. She went and found someone new. He knows she needs someone to be with, and they both agreed that they shouldn't go back together, but he doesn't want to see her happier with other guy because that hurts.
This is a song about selfishness. Thus "Why can't you just be lonely?".
The "So soon" line means they haven't broke up for that much time for him to get over it.
@matheuslynar your wrong its the fact shes filling the void she feels with someone else they both still care and love each other shes to proud or to afraid to say she wants him i have been there and that's what causes someone to hurt so many people before they feel like they have even moved on that person pretends but in the end they are in just as much pain as there other love is litterally a one time thing don't waste it feel it and use it to feel every minute of life its the only way
@matheuslynar him and Porcelain broke up in Fallout, he misses her. They get back together in No Place Like Home, then "Happily, Ever After we lived the end"
i wanted to b a singer though i new i wud b terrible so i got into acting i love it its just singing will always b in my heart i always wanted to write songs and sing them like theres no tomm but i rly had no idea how marianas trech rly inspired me to let my feelings out on a peice of paper nd ill instintly feel better i wanna live my dream and ian,mike,matt, and josh i believe r rly my true inspiration i say this abut alot of ppl but i think this one i actually mean and i kinda feel it to
It is way too soon for you to be moving on from "the love of your life, your true love, ypur soulmate" wish you wouldve meant what you said and stuck to it, cause i DID mean what i said. And i have always fucking loved you
@bluemuffinsentertain oh ur not the only one. I told my parents i wanna b a singer ad they started laughing...... THANKS FOR SUPPORTING GUISE!!! singing and acting is kinda my passion (gotta admit im embarresed to say that) i always say to myself, ill show u what ill become
i like how the changed it up on this one. like in all the other albums the slow songs always pick up at, like alibis and lover dearest, but this one stays soft. i like them both, and i like the change.
@MTrenchLoverr You are a fucking retard. Listen to the lyrics, then come back and comment something positive. This is me and my ex-girlfriends song. So dont talk trash.
@MTrenchLoverr you're not a real fan then because a true marianas trench lover would love there song no matter what i think you just a fan girl. Get a life
@iloveyou1rst LOL the fuck...Me get a life? Ha. Actually think the majority of their new songs are a tiny bits of shit compared to theirold stuff. And just because you like a band doesnt mean you have to like all of their songs. Soo, how about you get a life and not comment on my shit. XoXo, Fan Girl <3
I was so happy to hear josh and Amanda broke up, not because of stupid fangirl jealously, but because when I first saw her picture she just didn't fit Josh at all, idk he just needs a girl that fits his personality and style.. xD so I wasn't surprised when they broke up. But he makes better music sad so it's good. And yes I have met Josh. ;)
i think the person who disliked just had a finger twitch and missed the like button. Cuz theyd be crazy to actually like this. I've never cried because of a song, but i was pretty frikken close here...
So, I've listened to this song like 100 times and it's my second favorite song by Marianas Trench. The first will always be the acoustic version of Cross My Heart. I love Josh's voice!
This song reminds me of a guy I'm crazy about. We talk on the phone for hours about life, death, music, and so many other things. He's so special to me:-)
alright to put things straight. josh and amanda are in love with each other, they did not break up. Proof: get the Ever After CD, read the thanks at the end...an entire paragraph is designated for Amanda
@bpboop personally, i disagree. i think that line holds more of a mean like so - They broke up, he wasn't over her, and she's already moved on. That doesn't 'generally' mean cheating. and truthfully, we'll never know exactly what the songs about unless josh ramsay tells us himself. so. :/
to me, most of the lines stand for a break up. not cheating. there isn't any resentment, or anger which would normally come with cheating.
Good God. THIS is wondertastic. The piano and strings are spectacular. The lyrics are so vulnerable and its pulled together like a professional heart.
@xoxjesstownxox I thought that too as well, but most of the songs on the CD sound like they broke up.. Like she cheated on him maybe? And Maybe they broke up and he still loves her but doesnt wanna be with her (cause she cheated) and he wants her to know he will always love her? I dunno... its just my opinion. I think they did, but no one really knows for sure!
i'm not the one for sappy love songs but... damn
OneMillionRadishes 1 day ago
me and my girlfriend broke up yesterday and she has this song as her signature. now i feel like a jerk
TheKommykiller 3 days ago
i miss you
hiimbilleh 3 days ago
lol...how do you not understand what this song is about...its pretty straight forward...
ShietEverywhere 4 days ago
...............................................
ryab8787 5 days ago
This song is my life! My ex and I were engaged but with our jobs we hardly saw each other. It was like living with a stranger after a point. We broke off our engagement the day before Christmas Eve. Last week I went to a bar with my bff to have some fun. I saw him with his new girlfriend. I left the bar and got into my car and was heading home when the CD I had in was on shuffle and this song came on. I had to pull over and cry. I'm happy for him, I can’t hold onto the past for forever...
silvereyes181 6 days ago
Thanks for spending valentines with me... along with a jillion other girl at rexal X)
blondeandbluetiful 1 week ago 2
Canadian Pride <3 Happy Valentines Day
Ruletheworld3 1 week ago 5
happy valentine's day...
TheKalaChu 1 week ago
ya that is what i thought what it means
mattymatt1231 2 weeks ago
I was born to be a canadian i drink like a canadian and i party like a canadian...
1sing2sing3 2 weeks ago
give me the stupid top comment already!!!!
Devosimms 3 weeks ago in playlist good songz
lovelovelovelove♥
SiNg4LiFeX 3 weeks ago in playlist More videos from mtrenchislove
i want to download it so bad... but i can't stand crying to this song
OneMillionRadishes 3 weeks ago 5
How does this video only have 92,000 views?!? I mean, I swear I've listened to it more times than that :P
AwksNinja1 3 weeks ago
i swear I have been all the views to this song <3
GlamorousFabulous228 3 weeks ago
I started listening to this band when I was thirteen or fourteen and I loved them ever since.. I am sixteen years old and still their lyrics get to me.. Josh Ramsay is one of my biggest Inspirations and he has saved me LITTERALLY with his music and voice. ;3 I drink coke zero and listen to their music and SING MY HEART OUT , keep it up!
Babiiqirrl 3 weeks ago
I'm.In.Love.With.This.Song.♥
SiNg4LiFeX 3 weeks ago
@SiNg4LiFeX It's amazing and they are all very talented.. all four. Yes I have a majour obsession with Josh but Ian, Matt and Mike get CREDIT because without them there would be NO MARIANAS TRENCH !
Babiiqirrl 3 weeks ago
why cant you just be lonely
Devosimms 3 weeks ago in playlist good songz
omg this song made me cry<3
MegaSookie123 3 weeks ago
dear youtube
there is a dislike buton and 5 people have acsadentaly click it plesse fix this
thebulieyvictum123 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
took this song and i played and it sounded good
Devosimms 1 month ago in playlist good songz
Comment removed
JackyxPenguin 1 month ago in playlist Music
Hedley stop coming in my suggestions! I like you guys but I like Mtrench better
93webkinz 1 month ago in playlist Marianas Trench
When I first heard Marianas Trench, I thought wow just another emo type band.
The second time I heard Marianas Trench I thought wow there beautiful lyrics.
The thrid time I heard Marianas Trench I thought to myself " Why couldnt I see this the first time I heard them"?
AustriaSkater88 1 month ago 7
I have been listening to this song for about an hour now... And it's not getting boring one bit <3
smalltowngirl771 1 month ago 5
Comment removed
JackyxPenguin 1 month ago in playlist Music
this song, like the others, amazing. i cry at almost all their songs, they are so relatable.
QueenOfTheFagg0ts 1 month ago
Life is not complete without listening to Marianas Trench atleast once a day :)
smileydannie93 1 month ago 7
The dislike bar is like a ninja.. u cant see it.. but u kno its there! (:
BroOkLynNCOaDyFaLCOn 1 month ago 2
@BroOkLynNCOaDyFaLCOn I don't think the dislike bar deserves the awesome ninja skill xD
kawaiikawaii1234 1 month ago in playlist Marianas Trench
@kawaiikawaii1234
lol xD True.
UnknownAwesomePerson 1 month ago
this album needs to come out in the US...like now, thanks! :)
scampster401 1 month ago
so hauntingly beautiful... he makes me fall in love again and again.
vesperoflove 1 month ago in playlist More videos from mtrenchislove 2
Bought the album:)
Jean3boi777 1 month ago
how the fuck can you dislike this if you dislike this you dont know poetry you need to die
IhatEmyyusername 1 month ago 5
I think the repeat button hates me
don't care
love THIS <333
HannahNoel105 1 month ago 5
I really really love this band .. this song is amazing
cjyp1991 1 month ago
This album is perfection :'3
GottaloveNicole 1 month ago
I listened to every singel Marianas Trench song and all off them are the best song EVER!!!!!
1joshramsayfan 1 month ago
@cheemokinz06 The physical copy of the album is not out yet in the US. I heard its gonna come out in 2012 but Im not sure :/ but you can buy the digital on Itunes :D
Unknown7251 1 month ago
Comment removed
Unknown7251 1 month ago
i love this song. i love this song. dear god, how i love this song.
forgive me for spamming, but i want people's opinions on whether i did this song justice. check out my cover? (:
singer2477 1 month ago
thumbs up if this song made u wanna hug Josh! ;-;
crazedjessicamoore2 1 month ago 12
I cant keep u for myself but i cant c u happy with sone1 else...Why can't u just be lonely?
sniff* crys* so sad..Thumbs up if u agree!
JackyxPenguin 1 month ago in playlist Music
VANCOUVER SPIRIT
Headshotking23 1 month ago 5
Comment removed
JackyxPenguin 2 months ago in playlist Music
Derp
zxcvbnmrach 2 months ago
@zxcvbnmrach Ok, I don't think he's a derp, but when I read your comment I burst out laughing! lol! XD
MissNeonChick 1 month ago
singing acoustic version to my ex...yep
singingshorty7 2 months ago
his voice is better than sex .
beccaluvstu 2 months ago 8
@beccaluvstu ya it is ;)
singingshorty7 2 months ago
@beccaluvstu so thats why my girlfriend says to play marianas trench when were doin it. =/
apossumhodown 1 month ago
Ilove this sonng ; <3 soo much.
jones3021 2 months ago
ummmm josh im lonely can you come cuddle with me because afterall you are my A-Team <3
SonjaRamsay 2 months ago 7
The chorus of this song annoys me but the rest of it is beyond amazing <3
WeBeliebs 2 months ago
geez this song = story of my life
369vicki 2 months ago 2
this is so beautiful, <3
thekeishalexander 2 months ago 4
i DONT KNOW U.....so sad..sniff..
JackyxPenguin 2 months ago in playlist Music
i feel sad after hearing after hearing this..sniff but the i cheer up after thinking taht M Trench is Candian n so i Hedley
JackyxPenguin 2 months ago in playlist Music
i miss her so much.
hiimbilleh 2 months ago
Me and my recent bf broke up because he has always had stonger feelings for another girl...
i love him and would do anything for him..
they are going to start dating in less than a month.... idk what im going to do...
I want to be the person that makes him happy not her....
finallyMaddie1 2 months ago
@finallyMaddie1 my personal opinion is if you love someone you want them to be happy no matter what
xxXemokittycatsXxx 2 months ago
@xxXemokittycatsXxx i want him to be happy i just wish i was the one that made him happy. When i was falling in love with him he was falling in love with her..... this song is exactly how i feel...
finallyMaddie1 2 months ago
@finallyMaddie1 I totally agree with you
Masamarie14 2 months ago
@xxXemokittycatsXxx that doesnt mean that what makes them happiest isnt the hardest thing to stand back and let happen
ocean96701 2 months ago
@xxXemokittycatsXxx That's true to an extent, he's not saying he wants her to be miserable, he just wants to be the only one to make happy, so to that he says why can't you just be lonely?
JBKTV 2 months ago
ooooooommmmmmmmmmggggggggggg i fucking love this song, i listen to it every single day. i love you guys!!!!
FastballBabe97 2 months ago
@darkemorainbow I read your comment. That sucks :
Usedandunloved 2 months ago
Alright, So I was talking to my ex, telling I still had a huge amount of feeling's and all the time I was talking to her, I was listening to this song. I do admit it brought tears. Just because I miss her so much, she is the best thing for me. Have you ever had that one person that made you feel so good and then just out of nowhere something fuck's up and their gone? ....Don't care it you read it or not. Had to tell someone.
darkemorainbow 2 months ago 7
it's like he reads and sings your diary :P :o
11dayandnight 2 months ago 145
@bluemuffinentertain I think it means that he wants her but he isn't ready for her and he doesn't want her to be with someone else
Usedandunloved 2 months ago
i love this song, but i don't understand it. its like, he's singing about how he wants her to be lonely and all 2 himself, but then hes saying its just 'so soon'.
great song and all, but... WHAT THE HELL?
bluemuffinsentertain 2 months ago
@bluemuffinsentertain Here's the way I see it: They broke up. She went and found someone new. He knows she needs someone to be with, and they both agreed that they shouldn't go back together, but he doesn't want to see her happier with other guy because that hurts.
This is a song about selfishness. Thus "Why can't you just be lonely?".
The "So soon" line means they haven't broke up for that much time for him to get over it.
Anyone else agrees?
matheuslynar 2 months ago 53
@matheuslynar wow. ur great at explaining things.
bluemuffinsentertain 2 months ago 2
@bluemuffinsentertain Thank you. (:
matheuslynar 2 months ago
@matheuslynar
Actually, there's a whole fairy tale story written by Josh. The songs are about the story. The songs make more sence when you know the story.
LambertFan27 2 weeks ago
@matheuslynar your wrong its the fact shes filling the void she feels with someone else they both still care and love each other shes to proud or to afraid to say she wants him i have been there and that's what causes someone to hurt so many people before they feel like they have even moved on that person pretends but in the end they are in just as much pain as there other love is litterally a one time thing don't waste it feel it and use it to feel every minute of life its the only way
youngone190 2 weeks ago
@matheuslynar him and Porcelain broke up in Fallout, he misses her. They get back together in No Place Like Home, then "Happily, Ever After we lived the end"
krazypenish 5 days ago
@matheuslynar also, it "SEEMS so soon". Yes, he's being selfish. I approve. Trench on Twitter? follow @adamrwa, I'll follow back
krazypenish 5 days ago
@cheemokinz06 try HMV
bluemuffinsentertain 2 months ago
Comment removed
littlejj228 2 months ago
2 ppl can go to hell without Mtrench 4 all i care go 2 hell. The sin? Not knowing what good quality music is when it rapes thems in the butthole.....
JackyxPenguin 2 months ago 2
Sounds surta like bleeding at the beginning
Youw0tgetit 2 months ago
@Youw0tgetit does it?
bluemuffinsentertain 2 months ago
everything i've ever wanted to say to him.
hairsprayfanatic101 2 months ago
i love this song so much <3 it reminds me of that speacial guy! :/
missswagboss 2 months ago
i wanted to b a singer though i new i wud b terrible so i got into acting i love it its just singing will always b in my heart i always wanted to write songs and sing them like theres no tomm but i rly had no idea how marianas trech rly inspired me to let my feelings out on a peice of paper nd ill instintly feel better i wanna live my dream and ian,mike,matt, and josh i believe r rly my true inspiration i say this abut alot of ppl but i think this one i actually mean and i kinda feel it to
mrvicki321 2 months ago
It is way too soon for you to be moving on from "the love of your life, your true love, ypur soulmate" wish you wouldve meant what you said and stuck to it, cause i DID mean what i said. And i have always fucking loved you
ptwDestiny 2 months ago
im blasting the whole ever after cd....my neighbours better like Marianas Trench
mrvicki321 2 months ago 101
@mrvicki321 its my parents that i worry about!! >_<
bluemuffinsentertain 2 months ago
@bluemuffinsentertain oh ur not the only one. I told my parents i wanna b a singer ad they started laughing...... THANKS FOR SUPPORTING GUISE!!! singing and acting is kinda my passion (gotta admit im embarresed to say that) i always say to myself, ill show u what ill become
mrvicki321 2 months ago 4
@mrvicki321 word, me too !
BiGkIsS42 1 month ago
I'll shake his hand and smile and say I understand while I do. That don't mean I don't think about you. </3
JokerandtheThief7 2 months ago 7
i like how the changed it up on this one. like in all the other albums the slow songs always pick up at, like alibis and lover dearest, but this one stays soft. i like them both, and i like the change.
NeverLookBackDrummer 2 months ago
* ill shake her hand, and smile and say i understand* </3
GlamorousFabulous228 2 months ago
Fuck.. I thought I was getting over it... Guess this kinda showed me I'm not even close..
JBKTV 2 months ago 6
why can't you just be lonely...
idontcare0953 2 months ago
i cry every time i hear this... i love you <3
squidney71 2 months ago
@MTrenchLoverr I think its too funny how people.make a big deal out of things..lol
jackie45602 2 months ago
@jackie45602 LOL me too! Just wanted to see how many people would vote my comment down, didn't realize it would start shit with strangers.
MTrenchLoverr 2 months ago
veryy good song! <3
ThatGuitarChick01 2 months ago
Ohh my god ! Your voice make me fall in love ! Beautiful song <3 My favorite
jaanet93 2 months ago
This song gave me chiils, so beautiful <3 :')
GrrLauwa 2 months ago
LOOOL obviously i didnt mean it. thought someone would comment and tell me shit. .haha fuck off or untwist your panties.
MTrenchLoverr 2 months ago
@MTrenchLoverr hate to break it to you honey, but you're not funny in the slightest.
nerdymusicfreak101 2 months ago
@nerdymusicfreak101 guess it's a good thing i wasn't trying to be funny. Thanks for telling me though. <3
MTrenchLoverr 2 months ago
I think i might know how he feels qq
Jad3Kiwi 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song is horrible.
MTrenchLoverr 2 months ago
@MTrenchLoverr You are a fucking retard. Listen to the lyrics, then come back and comment something positive. This is me and my ex-girlfriends song. So dont talk trash.
darkemorainbow 2 months ago
@MTrenchLoverr and your username is mtrenchloverr? well that makes perfect sense. -_-
absofsteel691 2 months ago
@MTrenchLoverr you're not a real fan then because a true marianas trench lover would love there song no matter what i think you just a fan girl. Get a life
iloveyou1rst 2 months ago
@iloveyou1rst LOL the fuck...Me get a life? Ha. Actually think the majority of their new songs are a tiny bits of shit compared to theirold stuff. And just because you like a band doesnt mean you have to like all of their songs. Soo, how about you get a life and not comment on my shit. XoXo, Fan Girl <3
MTrenchLoverr 2 months ago
HOLY CRAP THEY BROKE UP?WHAT DID THAT RETARD DO TO HIM?!?!?!WHO IN THE WORLD COULD HURT JOSH SO BAD?
JUICE0BOX0 2 months ago
just broke up wit my girlfriend last night... :(
ManMusic2212 2 months ago 2
oh god... i accidently clicked the dislike button. NOT WHAT I WANTED. THIS IS AMAAAAAAZZZZZIIIINNNNGGGGGGG.
emyk2013 2 months ago
i loveee this song
laurproductions 2 months ago
@Ramsayfan101 Actually? Who the hell would cheat on him? He's fricken beautiful.
Bananner94 2 months ago 2
The Masterpiece album and Ever After album both follow a concept, like a story. Search it up buddies! .
cyrus364 2 months ago
I was so happy to hear josh and Amanda broke up, not because of stupid fangirl jealously, but because when I first saw her picture she just didn't fit Josh at all, idk he just needs a girl that fits his personality and style.. xD so I wasn't surprised when they broke up. But he makes better music sad so it's good. And yes I have met Josh. ;)
TheSierrarox 3 months ago
@TheSierrarox Even if they don't seem right for each other, you shouldnt be happy that their going through a break-up.
xMTrenchAngelx 2 months ago in playlist Marianas Trench
@GleekyGAGA1 yeah but is it worth it when Josh has to pay the price?...... No what screw that he'll get over it! But we need amazing music! xD
TheSierrarox 3 months ago
Him and Amanda broke up, but why is there a super sweet thank you in the thank you section!?
meghan486 3 months ago
@meghan486 i guess its just his final thanks and goodbyes for her. maybe closure?
SkitttlezzHaterrr 2 months ago
@meghan486 Or it could be an epiphany. Like thank you for making me realize there is someone else out there for me. I'm not sure. Just a guess.
nicholeodian17 2 months ago
this song is amazing!
imJZTme4EVAbitch 3 months ago
He's like taylor swift, when his heart's broken he's a much better person. Keep getting dumped and writing amazing music! <3
GleekyGAGA1 3 months ago 3
@GleekyGAGA1 lmao :)
imJZTme4EVAbitch 3 months ago
I don't wanna see you happier with somebody else, </3
KarateGal978 3 months ago 114
Breakups hurt </3
applescandance1442 3 months ago 3
I spent like 3 hours listening to this song. Over and over again, and each time I feel all the pain. Well done boys its irresitable.
JemmaLautner361 3 months ago 4
there's a problem.. I don't like this song..
I absolutely LOVE it, it's just soooo amazing, I think anyone can relate to this <3
ilu4life902 3 months ago
i think the person who disliked just had a finger twitch and missed the like button. Cuz theyd be crazy to actually like this. I've never cried because of a song, but i was pretty frikken close here...
hockeychicksaywhat 3 months ago 3
@hockeychicksaywhat "Cuz theyd be crazy to actually like this." Ermm.. You mean they'd be crazy to actually DISLIKE this? o-o
ZzzSpeicalzzZ 3 months ago
@ZzzSpeicalzzZ ooope....yep well thats embarassing.... ahahah yes that is what i meant...... aaawkward...;p.
hockeychicksaywhat 3 months ago
1 dislike!? ryl do u need ur ears checked!? this song and band is freaking amazing! MT forever <3
popstar111213 3 months ago 2
So, I've listened to this song like 100 times and it's my second favorite song by Marianas Trench. The first will always be the acoustic version of Cross My Heart. I love Josh's voice!
kissypherr 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 40
@kissypherr hell yea this is one of my new faves but my top is low and good to you
lilsnow92 2 months ago
This song reminds me of a guy I'm crazy about. We talk on the phone for hours about life, death, music, and so many other things. He's so special to me:-)
TheCannibalKate 3 months ago
I heard they broke but I'm not sure but the cd sounds like she broke up with him for another guy.
joshramsayscat1228 3 months ago
@XxXxXjacqueline HE HAS A GIRLFRIEND??????????? lol
shortsweetheart08 3 months ago in playlist Marianas Trench - Ever After
alright to put things straight. josh and amanda are in love with each other, they did not break up. Proof: get the Ever After CD, read the thanks at the end...an entire paragraph is designated for Amanda
XxXxXjacqueline 3 months ago 3
the funny thing about the whole "cheating" thing, this song doesn't even portray cheating. like seriously. xD
ITSKAIRIBITCH 3 months ago
@ITSKAIRIBITCH actually it kinda does. It could be about just a breakup but theres some parts that do like
"I dont want to see you happier with somebody else" -Could mean that she broke up with him for the other guy, and generally that means cheating..
bpboop 2 months ago
@bpboop personally, i disagree. i think that line holds more of a mean like so - They broke up, he wasn't over her, and she's already moved on. That doesn't 'generally' mean cheating. and truthfully, we'll never know exactly what the songs about unless josh ramsay tells us himself. so. :/
to me, most of the lines stand for a break up. not cheating. there isn't any resentment, or anger which would normally come with cheating.
ITSKAIRIBITCH 2 months ago
Love it
neeneray 3 months ago
guys she totally made an assumption bc of this song. :P
XxXxXjacqueline 3 months ago
the way he says ooohhh before the chorus... <3
cookableang 3 months ago 4
Man does this song ever hit home. It's beautiful though.
DDM765 3 months ago
ohhh josh... we are so much better then that cheating bastard...
dancergirl4570 3 months ago
this song makes me fucking cry <3
eeemmiilly 3 months ago 2
@mXtrenchXfan Ikr isn't it awesome :)
Heey123ish 3 months ago
Actullay .. If you read the story for ever after .. it's about the Stuttering Wise Man giving up his heart to save everyone else's :3
mXtrenchXfan 3 months ago
I love this, listened to it 7 and a half hours straight! -3
Heey123ish 3 months ago
oh man. It does sound like it's saying balogne..
LausIgnem 3 months ago
Good God. THIS is wondertastic. The piano and strings are spectacular. The lyrics are so vulnerable and its pulled together like a professional heart.
God. Amazing <3
iamlivingbubbly 3 months ago 3
Okay, so I'm not the only one who thinks Josh and Amanda broke up..
Kalibrooks27 3 months ago 19
@Kalibrooks27 no they're still together in the Ever After "thank you's" he mentions amanda lol so they didnt break up unless they're now best friends
xoxjesstownxox 2 months ago
@xoxjesstownxox I thought that too as well, but most of the songs on the CD sound like they broke up.. Like she cheated on him maybe? And Maybe they broke up and he still loves her but doesnt wanna be with her (cause she cheated) and he wants her to know he will always love her? I dunno... its just my opinion. I think they did, but no one really knows for sure!
Kalibrooks27 2 months ago
@Kalibrooks27 didnt even know he had a gf ):
Jad3Kiwi 2 months ago
@Jad3Kiwi Yup. Amanda.
Kalibrooks27 2 months ago
this son exsplains how i feel about josh.. :/
popester279 3 months ago 4
this is how i feel all the time lately...
ClaiklynLeah 3 months ago 4
Eh
BrandonsThaughts 3 months ago
Darn...I can't figure out which song is the best one...one is better than the other:)
speo24 3 months ago
@speo24 honey dont compare. like them all for them.
TheeCocooChanell1 3 months ago
:'( <3
Sacredstar23 3 months ago
So Josh Ramsay's Girlfriend cheated on him and now they're not together. I'm sorry Josh Ramsay. :'(
Ramsayfan101 3 months ago 76
@Ramsayfan101 How'ed you know that?
MTrenchGurl 3 months ago
@MTrenchGurl I was asking. But The songs do sound like it.
Ramsayfan101 3 months ago