Metallica vs Bullet for my valentine

[Megapie678]

You can't really compare the 2, their actually very different, even though bullet are HUGELY influenced Tallica

Metallica have written some amazing riffs

Bullet have their fair share

Hetfeilds voice us unique

Tucks is good, but he does scream a bit

Kirk is a god

Padge is good

Bullet are a lot more modern

Tallica are kinda stuck in the late 80's

( not that that's a bad thing :) )

[SupineCleic]

Bullete rules

[ankitkhadka758]

metallica rules for ever!!!

[matej70100]

BFMV

[Exxile4000]

both metallica and bullet for my valentine kick ass. Simple as that. BFMV is just a new generation of music and they love metallica themselves.

[JustImpaler]

Metallica definitely !!!!!!

[1994mickeyb]

I perfer BFMV cause they're more my style. Metallica is awesome but i never got into them big time. But Metallica is the better band.

[xmacobor]

metallica

[luc00leh]

Metallica is legends and my favurite gene in thrash, and Im this kind of metalhead who hate nu meta or any metalcore.

[MrMetalb0y]

well bfmv was inspired 2 metillica

[xtheryuzakix]

Bullet for my valentine are the Metallica of the future! :D

[HonkeyTheBear]

@xtheryuzakix No they're not. They're just another gay metalcore band that got lucky. They shouldn't even be compared to Metallica!

[ROONER48]

@HonkeyTheBear stupid gay band youre an idiot kiss my ass bullet for my valentine is more better in mexico we say tu you pendejo

[xtheryuzakix]

@HonkeyTheBear fuck off bitch, how can you call bullet gay metalcore band? O_O

and they choose to best british metalcore band in the world! so stfu!

[metallicadit]

@xtheryuzakix They are Welsh, not English, If they were English, I would hate them. SO much.

[falcopotter]

Metallica tiene una trayectoria de mas de 30 años y quieres compararlo con un grupo que no tiene ni la mitad de fans y ademas se hace grande a base de covers de metallica...

[xX0UndegrounD0Xx]

primero me gusto metallica luego conoci a BFMV los dos grandes, esto no me agrado, muchos dicen que metallica es mejor, tienen mucha experiencia y la forma de ejecutar instrumentos es extrema, de esa forma digo que gana metallica pero en si como bandas las dos son grandes, quisa no del mismo lv por la experiencia de metallica pero BFMV promete mucho yo les voy a las 2 arriba ambas bandas Metal Rules!

[xX0UndegrounD0Xx]

no me latio esa comparacion, por que metallica es metallica y va para 30 años desde su formacion, es una banda trascendental su trabajo es muy diferente a BFMV no maaa a mi me gustan mucho.... ahora bullet para mi es una banda que creo que es la estafeta sedida de metallica ellos son mas recientes aparentemente pero los considero la mejor banda que hay ahora, metallica fue de antes y sigue causando euforia ninguna es peor que la otra las dos bandas son las mejores no impporta de cual hablemos

[falcopotter]

Metallica tiene mucho mejores solos: Ride The Lightning The Four Horsemen Creeping Death Escape Metal Militia Disposable Heroes To Live Is To Die Enter Sandman Y si de covers hablamos pues ahí te van mas: Whiskey In The Jar Turn The Page Stone Cold Crazy Blitzkrieg Am I Evil? Last Caress y tengo mas que decir :D pero Metallica se grande con un solo cover :D así que METALLICA GANA :D

[falcopotter]

Metallica es muy bueno pero este grupo hace covers de Metallica asi que por eso gana Metallica :D

claro se que Metallica se hecho todo un disco de covers pero para ese entonces ya era muy, pero muy famosos.

Así que desde mi punto de vista Metallica gana

[IDwIMIxIHD]

METALLICA

[Akadiaan141]

Vocals:Mettalica

Guitarist:Bullet For My Valentine

Drums:Mettalica

Base:Bullet For My Valentine

Technique:Bullet For My Valentine

Age Of Skill:Bullet For My Valentine

BULLET FOR THE WIN!!!

[IdiotsRUsLtd]

@Akadiaan141 Um...fail.

Look at Bullets songs,all about the similar things, simple easy repetetive riffs and the same solo in every song.

Look at the difference of Metallicas songs, from Unforgiven to Master of Puppets. For whom the bell tolls to The day that never comes.

100 million albums sold.

Metallica are THE best band ever.

By the way i still love Bullet and i'm going to see them live this Sunday :-)

[jonazz48]

@Akadiaan141 Bass Bullet for my Valentine? Cliff Burton IS BEAST, ROBERT TRUJILLO IS TOO, Jason.. well he's good but amazing at back vocals..

[nextheisman11]

no question metallicas better, but only cuz theyve been around for so long. if bullet was around at the same time it wuld definetly be bullet!

[harryknucles]

if it wasnt for metallica there would be no BFMV bc bullet was inspired by them so metallica wins

[NSRExTYLERx]

Bullet For My Valentine is my favorite band up to date. Metallica is Second or third.

[hhssoundguy]

There is no Metallica VS BFMV...they are both Hardass bands with two different sounds. They really need to tour together it would be INSANE!!!!

[NSRExTYLERx]

anybody who hates either one of these bands is shamed upon by god!

[StallionTTT]

Littlebruners a faggot how the fuck would bfmv win this your fuckin stupid

[NSRExTYLERx]

@StallionTTT quit talkin bout' yourself like that

[skullcrusha50]

wow who would even make this video lol wow

[MrMegadeth12345]

METALLICA! \m/

[Metaltik666]

METALLICA !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[NSRExTYLERx]

@Metaltik666 BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE !

[NSRExTYLERx]

@Metaltik666 BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE !!!!!!!!!!!



[Stephen5125]

you cant really compare the two because Metallica is like one of their idols basically , BFMV started off by covering their songs.

[bfmv6664vr]

too bad you made the video in 2009 because the intro of Alone (bfmv) is awesome =D

[ItIsmell69]

No doubt those two band are fucking awsome, Metallica is an 30 year old band and they made history since black album ! Bullet for my valentine arent that old but they also made a part of history, James and Matt both have fucking epic voice, Kirk and Padge are both awsome guitarist, Lars and Moose are epic at drum and Cliff, Jason (metallica) Robert and Jason (bullet) are best basist ever !

Soo actualy i can't decide which band il pick cuz they are both fucking awsome band of all the fuckn time

[TheKevFella]

@ItIsmell69 WOW you no fucking nothing about metallica!!!!! They're not famous for the black album thats such a noob thing to say. They're FAMOUS FOR CREATING THRASH METAL ALONG WITH THE OTHER 3 FROM THE BIG 4 AND I BET YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW WHO THEY ARE.

[sweetchildomine14]

@Honkey3rdMD how did bullet sell out? the new album is fucking kick ass

[Eric2364]

idk bout u guys but i think that bfmv is better. metallica is awesome but they kinda got to old 4 me

[TheKevFella]

@Eric2364 Queer

[Shadowpredator1394]

@HarrisWuzHere firsy of all just hear hammet and hear Paget hammet sucks dude

but come on the songs that he put from BFMV are the worst

[TheKevFella]

@Shadowpredator1394 Padge does nothing but finger tab in most of his solos which is piss easy

[bml106]

An emo band that tries to play thrash. underground thrash is better than big 4 anyway.

[kungfudragon99]

@bml106 bfmv arent emo u fucking retard

[fasthunderful]

Bullet!!!!!! wins they are better

[18andLifeSR]

@fasthunderful I agree with you 100%

[JaMpNuMBerONE]

metallica is better until there load albums after that they suck

[OpenCasket6669]

metallica is better they where one of the first metal bands who started thrash metal and next time somebody compares metallica to another gay emo band use metallica's first album called kill'em all

[morkgork]

in my opinion bullet should get another vocalist other lyrics and another name

[BFMVpwnsBieber]

neither of them win because they're on the same level of epic win

[harryknucles]

anyone that says bfmv is better ur just retarded they are good but metallica is lengends bullet every song on every album is good bullets albums only have like 2 or 3 good ones on each

[fukvevo]

@harryknucles go fuk yourself theyre both badass end of story

[787sulav]

both post Justice METALLICA and bullet for my pussy SUCKs.... Cliff rules..

[fukvevo]

@787sulav ur so damn gay dude just go suk a dick

[GNRslash28]

Metallica is my favorite band of all time and BFMV is my least favorite band of all time.

[fukvevo]

@GNRslash28 go to hell u fuking dike bastard

[GNRslash28]

@fukvevo Ya, and this is coming from a BFMV fan that goes around youtube leaving comments like this to real metalheads. Have you ever heard of a thing called opinion you narrow-minded asshole?

[fukvevo]

@GNRslash28 ya and i also listen to metallica u dumb shit since i wuz like 2 i still remember master of puppets the first i heard it so ya ur gay

[GNRslash28]

@fukvevo Ok let's see what your comment contains:

-words you purposely spelled incorrectly

-you calling me a homosexual even though I'm hetero

- you remember Master of Puppets, wow, I don't think many people know of that song.

I was just simply stating that I like Metallica & dislike BFMV, why are you being such a douche?

[johnpoop123456789]

great stuff

[Shadowpredator1394]

BFMV

metallica is good but you put their best songs why didnt you doit with bullet formy valentine??

[HarrisWuzHere]

@Shadowpredator1394 best songs????? i didnt see orion, the thing that should not be, escape, trapped under ice, mama said, carpe diem baby, seek and destroy, whiplash i could go on.....all this guy picked are songs that a emo/fuck face would know the ones that make them say they love metallica but they only know those songs

[xxxbullet88xxx]

THEY COULD OF PICK BETTER SONGS TO PLAY FOR METALLICA LIKE

SANITARUIM

FADE TO BLACK

THE UNFORGIVEN

WHERE EVER I MAY ROAM

THE CALL OF KTULU...but still pretty good

[assain246]

@xxxbullet88xxx excuse me sir, i am not a plural

[xxxbullet88xxx]

@assain246 it dont matter to me what you are!

[ludacrisjr7]

@xxxbullet88xxx i think sanitarium would be a good song to do a comparrison on seeing how bolth bands do that song i think they are bolth great

[macc99809]

Metallica are better, after all they are the ones who influenced bullet

[shadowraidon]

BFMV man Metallica may be more famous btu BFMV has overall better music...guitar... and vocals btu i do like Metallica

[macc99809]

@shadowraidon BFMV have no way got better vocals than metallica, most of the time its just screaming. No shit i like BFMV but metallica are way better, they are alot more talented. Listen to master of puppets, then you will know they are superior at guitar, or if you already have then i don't know how you think they are alot more talented at guitar

[slashman08]

dude bullet os my fav band i play all thier shit with my band but also metallica has always been a big part of my music to but bullet wins hands down best band of all time

[TheBlackheart117]

come on man .. really ?

Metallica .. by far.

[Deathbladezero]

Let's note that Solo's aren't great if they have fast fingering with no rythym or distinct relation to the song.

[blackmustang728]

stop comparin a legendary band to a band that looks up to them

[The5fdpfan1]

It kind of seems like you WANTED BFMV to win. That's ok I kinda did too. Love BFMV, but Metallica is my all time favorite. I think you could've picked different Metallica songs to give them a fighting chance because BFMV definitely won I think. But kickass video man, I can tell you worked hard on it.

[multipleoranges]

BFMV all the way

[knightMetal22]

people design that is the best bandapero metallica the best band is iron maiden

"BFMV is better than metallica for me

[Gambit7Beyond]

i love both bands, but there no doubt that metallica is better

[LittleBruner]

@Gambit7Beyond I love both bands to but, since BFMV are younger and less EXP, Bullet has my vote, because metallica are legends but BULLET has got them beat , The guitar from Bullet could melt some ones face.

I Love Mettalica and always will But I say this battle goes to BULLET they diserve it.

[001DRose]

bullet cant and will not ever even come close to being as good as metallica. i like bulet dont get me wrong but i dont think bullet will ever sell over 15 million copies of one album like metallica has

[nosibok]

esto esta mui loko me gusto mucho este mix

[3acdc3mtlca]

who the fuck is bullet for my valentine

[dmc1234master]

wow the gernre are so fing different

[SHess10n]

Metalica is a classic metal band but BFMV is way better.

[RebellicA1]

like both these, but metallica will always be my favourite! but its hard to compare two so different bands. :)

[destructionman1]

Both are totally badass!!

[21bfmv]

This is a pretty gay question, no shit Metallica is better there a fuckin badass band that made history, but Bullet For My Valentine is fuckin awesome two, i say both bands are fuckin badass no matter what!!!

[sweetchildomine14]

@21bfmv well if you think about it there would be no bullet if metallica wasnt here cuz thats how they started out.by doing metallica covers

[TheLawliet08]

@21bfmv BMFV isn't badass. In fact metalcore in general isn't badass.

[juanvencl94]

@TheLawliet08 bfmv is not only metalcore but thrash and hm

[jasje225]

@undergirl0714 no i was quite vague about itxD

[goodsanta01]

hey everyone that are being dick why dont you not pay something out that you dont like and just let them do there thing i like both bands alot atm i cant say whose better but all these dickheads saying shit like ahh bullet are anoying blah blah blah its there problem not yours so shut ur face and mind your own buisness

[MetalAndFuckingPunk]

bfmv!!!

[jasje225]

@undergirl0714 i wastn talking about your reaction. the personal thing was, which band is better. i dont want to have any trouble ok? i actually said that you are right. I just like bfmv better, but i understand it if you like Metallica better (old school). im sorry if i wasnt clear about this.

[jasje225]

@undergirl0714 indeed, but I like Bullet For My Valentine better. I guess you like Metallica, otherwise you wouldn't give a reaction like that (not that it is a bad reaction or something(:), but its all so freaking personallyxD

[metalhead898]

uh these guys are diffrent genres. bullet is like metalcore and metallica is old school metal. so u cant really compare nu metal to old metal. and metallica influenced these guys. i love metallica fave band of all time.

[jasje225]

bfmv is a whole lot harder to play on your little guitar my friends...xd

[dikkenerd100]

Bullet is emometal

[kennyquick3]

@dikkenerd100 how? 

[dikkenerd100]

@kennyquick3 They look like emos, there main fanbase is emo ( facts )

Now what is just an opinion, his voice sounds like a cat crying, very annoying ( especially on tears dont fall, hearts burst into fire and another song i forgot )

And the lyrics from Tears don't fall is soo bad, it's a shame

[sulfuras24]

I'd love to see some MEtallica covering some BFMV. just to see what it sounds like....lol that'll never happen but still it's be pretty cool

[MegaMave]

@sulfuras24 That will never happen, you're right. BFMV sucks dick and Metallica is very aware of that fact as well.

[sulfuras24]

@MegaMave It's not that BFMV sucks, they are a great band, their covers of like Sanitarium are good, it's just i don't think Metallica would take the time to cover one of BFMV's songs

[mybulletfan100]

bullet learns from metallica both are great =).

[Xsm11]

BFMV!

[gh31217]

es bueno el grupo de bullet

....pero le falta mucho para que sea como metallica

[nosmailliwekaj]

metallica wins but only cause they are legends. in modern day rock its avenged sevenfold and bfmv all the way

[horeheh]

those metallica songs sucked.

[MrMinxy13]

metallica definetly the only bfmv songs i like is scream aim fire and waking the demon

[cod93618]

dude everyone knows metallicas beter obviously theyve ben around longer and invented the thrash

[p00417]

Metalica is a shit load older then Bullet. But Bullet has better guitarist and know a better singer because Matt got better, compare his old performnces to the Bamboozle in New Jersy. To me I hate Metalica, I love Bullet<3

[metalhead9167]

this is hard because if it werent for metallica bfmv wouldnt be a band.because matt tuck(the lead singer/guitar)got into metal when he herd enter sandman(metallica song)on mtv so he may had never ben a musicain and that would have sucked.metallica is asome for makeing BFMV and bfmv is asome for music they are my fav band

[climbingbananatrees]

BFMV!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!

[TUGAmetallica000]

I love metallica and respect bullet. but even bullet for my valentine members now that metallica are better than them. bfmv started with metallica covers and I agree with oOAddY365Oo you hadnt put a solo of metallica. and is the obligation, for the guy who makes the vid of a battle of someone against maetallica, putting the "one" solo. and wheres master of puppets? wheres all nightmare long? seek and destroy? st.anger? the best musics you've missed onle enter sandman and one that u have there

[skaterdouche4]

@Tomseboll bfmv sucks ass classic heavy metal >>>>>>>>>>>>> metalcore ( which isnt metal btw even if it has metal in it)

[heavymetaldabomb]

metallica= gods. 

[MacePimpOutWindu]

Metallica = pioneers of thrash alongside Anthrax, Slayer and Megadeth. Bullet = metalcore, similar to a LOT of other bands.

Bullet is melodic, whilst Metallica is riff and speed based. A lot of Bullets songs have harmonised leads and melodies, pop-like choruses and screaming/clean vocals. Pre-90's Metallica has almost no leads that play over the verse riffs, and most if not all of the vocals are harsh and gritty. Damage Inc. is a perfect example. Also, this vid picked shite songs for Metallica.

[Epikarlos]

BFMV All the way.. Metalica sucks.. that my opinion.

Metalica's songs are just long and boring.. and boring..and long.

[PlayMetallica15]

@Epikarlos ..damn dude you must really be deaf?..how can you say metallica sucks and is boring, they influenced BFMV...even tho BFMV is my fave. band metallica is so much better..do you even play guitar?...u need help bro.

[MilosSub]

Omg....how can you compare the consequence to the roots?Bullet For My Valentine, as they have told,bands like Metallica (and mostly Metallica), have inspired them a lot!!!IThat's insane...Both bands are Awesome by the way...

[nosmailliwekaj]

both the best bands in the world?!?

[NickIz2Pro]

I think both bands are amazing and im a big time fan of bullet for my valentine, but obviously Metallica doesn't scream, of course they have good riffs and awesome solos, but BFMF also has good solos and crazy riffs and good course, bullet for my valentine does alot of break downs (leading up to the bridge)>>>>(part before the solo) well BFMV FTW!!!!! =]

[jeanaru12]

bfmv rules metallica the best

[RidleysChild]

you picked the best music to battle with =' ) love it so much.

[assain246]

@RidleysChild thanks mate

[kennyquick3]

@assain246 okay, this is for you. you basically set up bullet to win, you used all of their best songs, but not all of metallica's, i like bullet too, but this vid lacked Intros 1. Master of Puppets 2. Enter Sandman 3. the FULL One intro, with the solos. (even though you left out half of Tears Don't Fall as well) Chorus' 1. Master of Puppets 2. Enter Sandman 3. For Whom The Bell Tolls Solos 1. Master of Puppets (one of their best songs, completely excluded from the video) 2. One

[kennyquick3]

@assain246 okay, this is for you. you basically set up bullet to win, you used all of their best songs, but not all of metallica's, i like bullet too, but this vid lacked Intros 1. Master of Puppets 2. Enter Sandman 3. the FULL One intro, with the solos. (even though you left out half of Tears Don't Fall as well) Chorus' 1. Master of Puppets 2. Enter Sandman 3. For Whom The Bell Tolls Solos 1. Master of Puppets (one of their best songs, completely excluded from the video) 2. One

[kennyquick3]

@assain246 and yes i know that One is in this video, but you put in the harmonic interlude for the solo, the solo is where the fast tapping begins, which is also the best part. 

[1nespower]

i personally like both bands...but Metallica is better

[madaboutbacon]

I love both of them I think metallica are more heavy altho I love BFMV AND METALLICA AS MUCH AS EACH OTHER plus they have both done amzing songs

[93mcewen]

metallica is the best

[coolduderonit]

@93mcewen : which song is tht from 1:20???

YES !!!!...METALLICA IS THE BEST !!!

[TheMarkyy]

@coolduderonit suicide & redemption

[TheAlguien]

I would have chosen different songs for each category....Metallica wins though

[digitalph33rfan9]

Metallica destroys BFMV No contest. Why would you even make that comparison? They don't even fall under the same category

[PossessedDonutz]

@NinjaNaughtz Yes they are. They sing about such retarded things like really? "Hearts burst into fire" "Tears dont fall" it's so fucking emo.

[izzystradlingnr10]

i like both but the best is bfmv

[DeadxHorizon]

bfmv is my favourite band forever but metallica is legendary

im sick of you calling bfmv is a gay emo or whatever they are the best new age rock metal whatever band.

we will see how far will they come in 20 years and then we will compare metallica here and bullet then

[granpez111]

bullet for my valentine wins

[xXdemoncityXx]

i like both but metallica comes hard with the solos i guess metallica

[zelda2594]

I love both but

Metallica of course

No Doubt

[PossessedDonutz]

Metallica is the clear cut winner. BFMV sucks balls. BFMV rips riffs from thrash bands like Slayer and Metallica and puts gay emo lyrics in there with annoying whiney voices. Don't even start, BFMV cryers. There is no talent involved. They aren't even close to thrash. They aren't close to anything decent. PLUS, BFMV is a core band. Core is not metal. so BFMV fails.

[tarawneh93]

metallica of course <<

[condemon01]

were is the master of puppets solo?

[dikkenerd100]

Bullet is just some other Mainstream band, why don;t compare them with bands like a7x or slipknot instead of 80s bands

[TheAirforce9]

Cliff Burton OR Jason Newsted vs Jay James?

[thenia95]

You can't compare Metallica with BFMV.... Metallica are legents... Bullet are awesome.... cold be legents in 10 or 15 years...... but now you can't compare them....

It's just my opinion.......

[mick23586]

Metallica -> Real metal

BFMV -> Fuckin fake poser metal

Hence MEtallicA>>>>>>>>>>>>>bfmv

[metalheadsway95]

look guys i love bullet and i love metallica too !!!! but metallica is metallica and is a legendary band !!!! metallica exist since 1981 and bfmv since 1998 !!!! they are awesome bands both of them !!!!! but metallica are still the greatest !!!!!

[KurtisxLogan]

With all that said..I'm so sick of these dumb motherfuckers who call BFMV gay when they're the closest thing to Metallica or any old metal band with unrealistically good solo's in ever song. All these little faggots today call BFMV and All That Remains emo and forget that they have way more talent than stupid ass mainstream bands like Disturbed.

[KurtisxLogan]

I know you guys are probably like wtf but, I'd take BFMV. First of all Kirk Hamment imo is the best guitarist of all time. James Hetfield is a great vocalist/rythym guitarist and Lars Ulrich is a great drummer. BFMV has covered 2 Metallica songs and made them sound far better than the originals. Matt Tuck's vocals have a lot more range and variety than Hetfields low growling voice. BFMV has better song/lyrical content than Metallica.

[Blackened1994]

Metallica wins by far and u guys shud no that Metallica influenced Bullet anyways BFMV is awesome too

[lokoporsche14]

is hard compare a trash metal band and a melodic metalcore band, but these 2 are very good bands in his genre....

(sorry my english)

[retardZX]

bullet top metallica no doubt about that but you got know that metallica infuelinced bullet

[MetalWillem1]

Why you don't use other songs.

As you have a solo of One. You don't need to put the intro of One in your video.

One has a great solo. But not a great intro.

Master of Puppets has both great.

[stro66]

bullet for my valentine is a great band but the voice is fucking terrible!!!bfmv are metallica with the voice of fucking shit of tokyo hotel!!!(sorry for my english)

[KrAzYDiAz970]

metallica all the way

[MasterOfPuppets762]

Metallica no doubt in my mind.

[Hardybigfan]

MetallicA wins by far but BFMV is a good band also

[pkerplayer87]

i take bfmv

[holym4m4]

RUNESCAPE SUCKS!

[HotFanNaruto]

BFMV had Metallica influence

but i like the both :D

[oOAddY365Oo]

ok guys .First:Metallica invented the thrash ,BFMV started to use thrash metal riffs and started by coverin' song from metallica(Metallica had great influence on BFmV).

Second:in this video the "assain246" put the best songs from bullet for my vallentine,but not the best of metllica

Third:I haven't heard the "one"solo.

BFMV Can't win even thought I'm a big fan

sorry for my bad english

[ThaNickstaftw]

Metallica is my favourite band but Venom was the first thrash metal band.

Welcome to hell came out in 81 and kill em all came out in 83

[oOAddY365Oo]

Metallica was the founder of thrash metallor one of them anyways.VEnom influenced the thrash but wasn't a founder

[MrBattery54]

@oOAddY365Oo No Venom invented thrah metal