Added: 2 years ago
From: highlore3
Views: 113,585
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (146)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i hate the voice acting...

  • Why does everyone sound constipated in this?

  • I thoroughly enjoyed this collection. I really hope they do more like it for other comics.

  • I really hate their vioces.. Just me.

  • My opinion on arguing 'bout which is better, motion comics or comic books.

    (On youtube) /watch?v=BNsrK6P9QvI

  • I'd love to try making a motion comic. This stuff looks pretty cool.

  • Liked watchmen bought d live action film ultimate cut own d comic n juz bought d action comic it was good but hated d way they used man voices on female character . Why the hell would dey do such a thing???

  • Why is everyone complaining that this is just for people who are to lazy to pick up the book? I read the graphic novel and THEN watched this, and personally, I prefer this. Not because I'm too lazy to read or anything, but this just totally brings the comic to life! The colors, the movements, the music, hell even the narrator's voice! It's all just mesmerizing to me! I think it's amazing and anyone who is a fan of Watchmen should really give it a try.

  • @jrad10x10 I'll take the graphic novel thanks, I tried this motion comic and just couldn't finish it because of the subpar narrator, plus them leaving out whole chunks of the graphic novel like 'A Man On Fifteen Dead Men's Chest' (which gives the whole back story of The 'Tales of The Black Freighter' comics) and 'Under The Hood'

    The motion comic just really came up short for me. I had read DC has made Watchmen available for downloading on an E-Book Reader ?!?

    That should be..... interesting.

  • graphic novels suck. motion comics are way better and easier to listen read as well.

  • @jeevanirajiv

    No way is this better than the graphic novel. Alan and Dave crammed in a lot of techniques that could only be done in a comic and would simply  never survive the translation to any other medium, which resulted in both the film and the motion comic being no where near as deep.

  • better than that crummy movie

  • This is for those sad people who are too lazy to read anymore. I mean, c'mon! Read the original for chrissake!

  • i love watchmen but this cartoon was very disappointing! crap even!

  • its not even the complete complete novel frame by frame as they say they cutter a few frames and dialogs form each chapter :(! but more complete than the movie... it works for lazy guys who dont want to read!

  • I don't why is everybody complaining about the Motion Comic. It was great, you're right about the females voices, but besides that, it was awesome! The music fits perfectly and the narrator did a great job for male characters. I totally loved the Chapter IV, the voice he gives to Dr. Manhattan was terrific!

  • LOL the voice acting for Rorschach is shit!

  • no matter what you do with it, how you remix it or move it, it is never gonna be better than the original comic book. Constant moving camera just makes it worse and voices in your head when you read it are so much better and quite more real than this clumzy voiceover... It is just another poor moneymaker from one licence of such a good novel.

  • Watchmen - The complete Motion Comic

    Featuring spoken dialog with acting as bad as in the original Deus Ex.

  • @spliter88 In the fresh?

  • For people who are too lazy to read. Dont pick this up if you havent read the comics first. When I read watchmen I was totally blown away. Theres just so much thats lost in a translation like this. Read watchmen then read it again to see all the things you missed the first time. Then go watch this. I hated the movie but most fans were split about it, so I wont say dont go see it. It had its moments but some of the music/casting choices were terrible and killed the overall mood of the story.

  • Motion Comic is amazing, dude, why are all you dissing it? He's a great narrator, too...frikkin watch it before you knock it, I hate people who assume.

  • Not bad but they needed more than one person doing the voices.

    I mean c'mon, even Mel Blanc needed help with the female voices.

  • Why not just make an animated TV-series instead? Duh?

  • is it unabridged?

  • this asshole sounds like hes just reading it. sounds a lot better with alan moore

  • the voice acting is kinda sucks...

  • laury jupiter voice sounds like shit!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • meh should of used actual actors

  • Should have used kitties!

  • If only they hired a woman for female voices, instead o use a man for both male and female. But this motion comic worth be watched.

  • Comment removed

  • @SupaFastVideos Yep.

  • The movie version of Rorschach was I think the definitive version of what his voice should be. But I guess this is ok.

    Motion comics remind me of old Marvel cartoons.

  • dont know why but when i first readed watchmen i imagined that the characters voices would sound like this, but all changed after watching the movie

  • Reading your comment as well as seeing this trailer suddenly made me realize that I like Rorschach's voice much better on this.

  • I wish his head was driven up his stomach in the movie.

  • This vid is awesome! Watchmen is brilliant!

  • If only they used different voices for the different characters.....if only..

  • Using different actors would have put them in a position of comparisons being drawn between this and the movie actors. Plus, they didn't want to go the whole hog and release TWO fully-acted Watchmen movies... this really is just something extra (and a substantial extra, too) for fans of the comic.

  • the voice sounds like there just reading it of page

  • Yea.. Rorschach talks like a machine in this...

  • at least he's not talking like Christian Bale

  • He talks like a machine running out of oil in movies. I see no problem with this voice.

  • No one really cared. No one cared ..BUT ME.

    Seriously, I liked the movie's dialogues more..

    But I can't wait to watch this!

  • Rorschachs voice should be much more darker.

  • im sure this would be cool, but the voice acting needs to be a little better.

  • I love the voice acting... except the terrible female voices.

  • i don't like rorschach's voice in this. the voice in the movie was better

  • Movie was very good, but... Come on!!! Better than the graphic novel?!?! They are not even on the same planet, the GN is far more complex, deep, interesting, etc, etc, etc. Gn is way better.

  • Yes I feel the same....

  • @H3nrix hahaha (this is not a complain to you xD, but) how could the "movie" be better than the NOVEL when the movie was "based" on the novel and even so , the movie its kind of a summary not the complete idea and cutted all supportive characters... Novel= Awesome, movie= something you might want to watch before reading the novel to get a brief idea of what the novel is...

  • @H3nrix They're different media, follow different rules, it's not wise to make that kind of comparison, one should judge them sepparately. It;s a very common mistake, that we all seem to make now and then.

  • @Pablowanjedi It's the same story, so the comparison is valid if you are talking about that. As a media, you can still compare. Both of them are graphic, one static and the other with motion and sound (quite a clichéd soundtrack, unfortunately). It is different when you "translate" words to video, but that's not the case here. In any case, I'm not complaining visually. Very well done, here. But as a story, nowhere near the original. Your approach is biased and a bit naive, but thanks still.

  • @H3nrix I get what you say, after all it is your perception regarding the story and it is valid. I better go check the comic to know how good it really is storywise. Though I would still not make a direct comparison :)

  • i got mine for 10 dollars =)

  • I have the series. It's amazing, but it does give me a headache afterwards. (The moving pictures make me slightly dizzy).

  • man people should so have done this with evry marvel and dc comic cuse then it would as well be a whole lot more exiting to read

  • ok, someone tell me this:

    are the female voices being voiced by a guy?

  • The same dude does every voice but its still amazing nonetheless.

  • Yes.

    It sounds weird at first,

    But after a while, you get used to it.

  • Still sounds awkward.

  • Yes, Laurie feels more like a drag queen now.

  • Ruined it for me actually, I was getting really immersed in it, then Laurie talked and it was a male voice and I was totally torn out of it, I mean would it have been THAT difficult and costly to hire a female voice actress? If it hadn't been for that this would have been like an awesome, fully fledged Watchmen animation, and probably the best comic book cartoon ever.

  • Yeah, i thought that to at first,

    But i thnk it's supposed to be like YOUR narrarating it.But i still think that they should have used a womans vioce for Laurie.You get used to it though.

  • Yeah, I appreciate that, It's just, you shouldn't HAVE to get used to it, ya know?

  • But when I read it, Phyllis Diller did the voice for Silk Spectre.

  • can someone explain what a motion comic is

  • It is basically the graphic novel but in motion picture form. It is meant to be a page by page adaptation unlike the movie not to mention it has the art style. I still like the movie though.

  • okay thanks

  • It's like one of those recorded readings they do for books. The voices don't fit because it's one guy doing them all.

    As for rorschach's voice, before the movie trailer, I had never imagined him of having a batman-esque voice, I always imagined him with a light New York accent and maybe a bit of scruffiness to it.

  • No! They runied Rorschach's voice!

  • I know, the video actually seems really good but I can't stand it because Rorschach's voice sounds far too smooth. =/

  • i just bought this two days ago

  • man i just really wish that guy didnt do the female voices too.

  • 1:12 is awesome =] love the comic, might watch this

  • You should. It's sooooooo much better than the movie.

  • yeah...i just don't like Rorschach's voice too much =/ i liked it the way it was in the movie

  • now is dr manhattins cock going to be flying around like in the movie

  • the voices are gay

  • I don't like the fact the ladies parts are read by a bloke though, sounds a bit weird :-(

  • yeah I just watched the DVD, the bean 'juice line' is in there, every word seems to be included and every image

  • what, no "bean juice" line?

  • Terrible terrible voice overs

  • wait til you hear the man do laurie when she's kissing manhattan...ha ha ha awkward

  • Wow that is some brutal voice acting.

  • actually, I felt that Jackie Earle Haley/Rorschach

    stole the movie by a mile

  • as much as i like the motion comic and the actual comic... and as much as the movie could've been better... look at Alan Moore reading an excerpt from Rorschach's journal. Pretty darn close to the movie's rorschach.

  • I was thinking of getting this, but the voices suck.

  • did they put the black freighter in the dvd too?

    sorry for the comment below

  • did the black freighter in the dvd too?

  • Holy crap, the scene from the book where Rorschach lights the cop on fire would look awesome in this!

    I don't like his voice actor though...

  • Yeah, why didn't they ask the guys from the movie to voice the motion comic?

  • right! people are fucking stupid.

  • the black freighter is the story overall of rorschachs soul.....peep it,a man who goes on a voyage with honorable motives(becoming a super heroe) and in the mix of his noble crusade to protect the innocent he loses his purity and descends into madness and by the end of the story he becomes as violent and heartless as those he fights against.plus eating a rawshark (rorschach) brilliant!

  • wow... thx...

    I understand Roscharch emotion only from chapter VI. I didn't know the pirates has any relation with Roscharch.

  • I think it's more about ozymandis. Driven by good motives (avoiding nuclear war) he deems neccessary to act evil and sacrifice people, so at the end he's a heartless and a mad person. Of course as everything in watchmen this too, is slighly more complicated. But hey, that's what makes the comic so damn good :)

  • johnpersons

  • I saw this on PPV, it's pretty well done.

  • Hmmm, good idea gone bad in my opinion. Read the book, its SO much more rewarding. And the movie, well that was different.

  • Why would they go through all the effort of animating the comic, but not hire FEMALES to read the female parts?

    Producer FAIL.

  • Is it just me or does Rorschach sound retarded?

  • He does. They got one person do voice act the entire cast. HUGE mistake. You're better off purchasing the graphic novel. It's cheaper and it's much more rewarding.

  • Yeah. I'm reading it now. I just don't like the Pirate comic that keeps on popping up. And do you have to read the excerpts and writing pieces between each chapter?

  • Yeah I do not understand the pirate part even after finishing the book, if someone will clear this up for me and this guy that would be sweet

  • I didn't read the excerpts and writings between the chapters, and I understood the entire book. Only read them if you're interested in some backstory of the characters.

  • You don't know how much you're missing, BillDing42. And nice name, btw.

  • on here yes, but in the movie he sounded awesome

  • Listen to almost any audio book and it will have one person for both male and female. Its just weird because you actually see her character with the voice.

  • uhmm.. in the Harry Potter novels is only one person for the whole novel. Jim Dale in the US and Stephen Fry in the UK. I listened to the motion comic and I give it 5/5

  • The only thing I didn't like about it was that they didn't hire an actress to do the voice work for the female characters. When Stechschulte does the female parts it just takes me right out of the comic. Lame.

  • It sounds like an old radio drama skit.

  • Is it just me or does Rorschach sound retarded?

  • Is it just me or does Rorschach sound like Ranier Wolfcastle?

    All the whores and politicians will look up and shout, "save us!" and I will look down and whisper...

    THE GOGGLES, THEY DO NOZINK!

  • lol when I heard Rorschach voice I nearly doubled over with laughter!

  • oh god the voices are fucking terrible. rorschach's voice is way too bland and it all just sounds so cheesy.

  • i hate the women voices!! lol so gross

  • I want to pwn this.

  • i just got this on dvd and it's really good! i'm not fond of the female voices but everything else is fine =) plus $7.50 off a watchmen ticket! that's a good deal!

  • should have let me do rorschach's voice, i might even voice over this myself...

  • Why did everyone thumbs-down this? He is.

  • yeah. he even has a moment there with nite owl at Arqui. wich made owl get quite embarassed.

  • the voices suck...but im definitely getting this on blu-ray

  • i really like it! i dont care if its one guy narrorating it, as long as the story is there

  • looks dope. I will be spending my hard earned dollars on this.

  • It would look better as an actual cartoon. Cool concept, though.

  • Sorry I meant to say March 6

  • o rly?

  • yeah, really. is there a problem?

  • actually the ending of the new movie will be different from this animated version and the novel

    plus some scenes were cut from the new film, but they'll be released in a director's cut film screening and dvd

  • This should look stunning in HD. If you already have the graphic novel, then there really is no point in purchasing this. Better to wait and see the movie instead.

  • the actors suck.

  • all of the voices in the motion comic are by one person. he even does the female character voices! lol

  • i'll buy it but those voice over actors were just baaaad choices. yuck

  • looks awesome!!!

  • nice one

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more