Added: 5 years ago
From: anthonygiannotti
Views: 93,856
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,644)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • shes just nervous. my god-- give her a break. you try get up their and sing!

  • But she does seem very nervous. I feel bad for her,, I like the recordedversion of this song. And she isnt a mistake full stop. She is a canny nice person actually. One bad performance doenst meen anything. Bless. Your not a dickhead! But... You really shouldnt publicly embarras he rover UT. Thats really sad,, and just plain nasty. I have opinions of certain celebs but i wouldnt post this. And i would NOT create a hate club! Calm down a bit!!
  • Haha, seriously. Why dont you get a life mate?

    You really started a hate club of her? Are really so pathetic and sad with your own life that you have to put your hate to someone else.

    Lol I would like to see you get up there and sing in front of thousands, then we will judge you and say we hate you if you get anything wrong, how does that sound?

    Dickhead...

  • We all sound crap when we're terrifide.

    Christ.

    You get up there and fucking sing.

    It's hard.

    And at least she sings live unlike -cough-britneyspears-cough- , certain people.

  • this performance may not be as good as others, but at least it proves she sings live, unlike other artists who dont.

    if you dont like her, why did you post this and why do you listen to her music??

  • Ok, so she is a bit bad in this video, but if you think shes so bad then why do you listen to her music anyway? If I thought someone was bad I wouldnt listen to their music, not enough to make videos about them. Give her a break, its not so easy to sing in front of so many people and you could tell she was nervous in this video. I doubt you would do very well in the same situation. Im not trying to be a bitch, I just like her songs.

  • I kind of feel bad for her. She obviously seemed nervous and went flat quite a few times but it's not the disaster I was expecting. If that was how she performed all the time I wouldn't expect a record company to encourage her to sing live at big events.

  • its not that good no offence but i love her songs!!

  • little trick, when ever there is a lot of people there, you always stare straight into the light and try not to look at the audience, that way the only thing you see is the staging ( coz it is equally brightened) and the other ppl on stage, this helps to forget the people

  • she looks scared to sing her nerves are definetly effecting her in this but its not horrible

  • Shes terrified... you can hear the nerves in her voice thats why shes singing so bad. Ive herd her live before and shes pretty amazing!

  • Im not a fan of steph but hey at least she is actually singing! Alot of people get stage fright. Have you seen how many people there are there???

  • Her singing isn't that bad but think this all artists sing worse when they are singing live

  • Most of them do, but you should listen to Adam Pascal live and recorded-MUCH better live. It's weird.

  • Aww who givs a bulls crap about how bad her singing is i been her fan ever since she had her first song out if u think somethings wrong with her voice, i think u hav something wrong with ur ears..

    she's a great singer and SHE IS NOT TERRIBLE and we r defending her because we frigin care....

    TOO BAD if ur ears fall off GLUE THEM BAK ON!!!!!!!!!!!

  • What makes me laugh is the fact you have the time to make a video like this!

    Why not concentrate on doing something worthwhile, rather than taking the piss out of those out there trying to make something of themselves!? Youth think its easy selling your soul to record companies?!

    Not that im saying she should have a recording deal, but if you havent noticed, the music industry is a complete sham run by suits who are only interested in making money, nothig to do with 'music',u cant blame Steph!

  • they said her eye piece came out

  • her voice is far from great, but it's not bad... not even for a neighbours girl!

  • so what if she sings bad attest shes better then you i bet u cant sing good.If u think ur better then her why not put a video of u singing ...oh and not lip singing got it good : p

  • aww I think she's good!

    And why make a hate group I think that's awful! =[[

    she's only making a living and that's what everybody has to do, so leave her alone!

  • ur right!

    cmmon people hav a heart!

  • i think my ears fell off

    this is terrible

    why are people defending her?

    stick to acting love

  • She isn't all that bad, i agree with the dancing but her singing is not that bad, better then me!!

  • this guy is totally right!!!!!!!!

  • omg your so mean shes probaly just nervous or something leave her alone. is that all you do in your life just put people down and make mean videos about the serously.....

  • shes ok....maybe shes nervous?

  • um.. all singers sound bad on stage, except for Avril Lavigne.

  • Avril is an amazing singer

  • I saw no problem with how she performed.

    So, I think that the fucking wog that made this video is retarded.

    Just like the rest of the fucking wogs in Australia. We'd better better off here without all you fucking wogs. Go back home.

  • ok, so maybe she isnt the best singer around.. but seriously , saying SHE is a mistake is wayyyy too harsh. and calling her names too. there is no need to be so harsh about her generally. - besudes not many artists can sing great live... like stacey 'fergie' ferguson from black eyed peas, she wasnt a great live singer.. until she had more lessons.

  • she can sing.....

    people always sound better than the live version.... there are no electrical devices added with the voice....i think she is reli talented....

  • She sounded fine :)

  • This was a pretty bad performance, admittedly, but where is *your* record deal?

  • leave her alone lol shes not that awful

  • I don't think she's bad. Is she that famous to have haters? God! Haters are everywhere!

  • 1. not that bad

    2.EVERYONE sounds bad live...oh wait...EVERYONE but lipsync-ers

  • it wasn't thát bad. jeez.

  • why is it whenever she went high.. she pointed up.. okaaay.. *coughpsychofreakcough*

  • OMG!!!! my dog could sing better! ...wait...did i just call stephanie a dog :S but yeah she cant even sing!!!!

  • :O

    W.O.W.

  • I used to love Steph, but re-watching this just makes me feel like an idiot for ever defending her.

  • yeah its true, most artists do sound really horrible live.... give her a break your faggot.

  • his faggot what? if you're going to insult someone, learn the language that you're insulting them in.

  • every singer sounds bad live i mean come on give her a break loser

  • lol every singer does not sound bad live... just the ones who can't sing.

  • omg my ears.

  • DON'T BE A BITCH AND BE NICE TO HER!!!!

  • gosh, leave her alone.

    it was one of her FIRST ever performances LIVE!

  • she made loads of 'MISTAKES' loool

    wooow thankgod for the back up singers ...although it sounded bad but at least better...

  • she came to Northampton uni and everyone booed her cos she was awful then she ran off crying - she was only on stage for 30 seconds and didnt come back haha

  • wow she sucks live hahahaha

  • Its not that bad. Its fine. Gosh.

  • Wow, I feel sorry for her but it really isn't a very good peformance.

  • bless i feel really sorry for her :(

  • You evidently have a big problem with Steph. To the extent where you look like a gay strop. If you don't like her, then keep it to yourself. I didn't find her that off key. There are tons worse.

  • uh oh =/

  • Wow! This is really out of tune. I'd like to think it was just nerves, but it probably wasn't.

  • i dont think that she suck .. is not a brilliant singer, but my ears arent bleeding neither ..

  • hahaha omg its not like she can be good at everything acting and singing no ones perfect lay off steph dude shes kool as and one of my best friends and omfg ur like totally annoying stephs rocks at acting u all no it so lay off

  • wow, whoever made this video is annoying :|

  • Chicken dance! Funky chicken!

  • Yeah it's shit, but I've heard plenty worse than this; that Taylor Swift lass sounds fucking awful live.

    This girl shouldn't have a record contract though - do we really need more generic pop-rock shite?

  • I remember watching this with my family, and we were all just cringing, the entire time.

    She started off bad, but i think she just lost confidence at she went along and bacame even worse.

    Wouldnt they have realised how crap she was in rehearsal?

  • haahaahahhahahaaha

    sounds like a group of girls having a party playing singstar or seomthing its badddd!

    my dog sounds better than herr

  • Anthony you poor little fag - posting shit videos like this on you tube after editing them with the Mac your Mum bought you. Poor little cunt you are - get a life.

  • i like her songs.

    but she didn't do too good & the awards but i think that was just nerves.

    supposedly she cried backstage..

    poor thing, she definetly has talent.

  • Lol, well of course she sounds crap live without all the editing.. she's a pop singer.

    None of them can actually sing.

  • i still think she's good.

  • You just won yourself a subscriber. Hahah classic commentary

  • She still sounds amazing!!! she's great!

  • she's good. the recording is good. live versions always suck. like taylor swift, she isn't good on live versions but i still love her.. so yep.

  • hahhah funny commentry :P

  • shes good

  • All artists sound better on the studio versions because its recorded multiple times to perfect it. But I think she sounded alright.

  • not all...real singers sound better live!

  • maybe it aint tht gd but stil good

  • I used to work at global tv where she used to work on neighbours. She was a stuck up mole.

  • Comment removed

  • Where's she from? I don't really know who she is???

  • Australia, She was a main character in a tv series called Neighbours

  • wasnt her name sky..or something near that? S: i used to watch neighbours.

  • Yeah Sky

  • Ohhhh :(((  Well it wasn't the best performance :S but maybe she was just having an off day :S it's still a great song though and she is an awesome actress! :)

  • i agree. Especcially with awsome actress hehe

  • her voice aint that good. flat notes everywhere

  • Why you hatin so much?! you jelous that she has a career? .. u need to get out more.

  • She starts bad but gets better, i agree on the dancin tho!

  • she sounds nervouss which is probably making her voice badd

  • u probly sound wrost then her

    am i crazy i like it :)

  • Blimey she sucks live, but then again so does other people. was this her first live performance? cos if it was she was probibly nervous and not useto being live.

  • hmmm...im...speechless

  • fail

    fucking epic fail

    and now she's finally disappeared

  • in her defence... at least it proves she doesn't lip-sync =/

  • I just watched your whole video through and it's a disgrace. Okay shes not the best singer but that doesn't make her a mistake. If you don't like her don't listen to her, simple as. A lot of people do like her and your comments on the video are extremely unfair.

  • i thiknk she was goood a little pitcy in some areas but ita hard song to sing but she did a good job

  • Oh right, to set you guys out right.

    1. Is you've ever actually sung live, like i have, you would know it can be very difficult to do!

    2. she is not that bad, as the song she is singing is actually a very hard one to sing

    3. half of you are probably jealous because she actually has the chance to perform in plces and you dont

    4. AT LEAST SHES NOT LIP SYNCING!

    so stop bragging about her? she tries, i'd love to see you lot chucked in that position and try and sing!

  • I don't really care whether she lip syncs or not because I like the song but I think your comment is silly - she put herself in that position therefore, she obviously felt she was good enough. She wasn't thrown in the situation she wanted to do it. If you can't sing, don't try and be an artist!

  • Its not THAT bad gosh!

  • -___- wow.

  • gollly molly - she's crap

  • man, she sucks, no wonder she has no more songs out

  • ouch

  • your being a lil harsh

    not every singer sings brill live do they

    and besides it is her 1st singing career

    xx

  • she is bad but i think thats probs nerves...

    i commend her for singing live with a voice that bad... you don't see Britney singing live! its all lip synched...

    good attempt steph!

  • Why did you put so much effort into this?

    And why are you obsessed enough to make this video about her?

  • Anthony you are a top man!!

  • Oh gosh... No offence, but I'm better than that... But I dont blame her, I'd be nervous in front of all those people... But this doesn't mean that her recorded music sucks lol

  • oh god this is so funny

  • so this is int her best performance everyone has worst day including Celebes's so bk of i like to see anyone else do what she does to a live audience and it really doesn't matter what we think the only think that matters is what Stephanie thinks

  • All singers sound crap live.

  • i don't think she sounds horrible. I mean this isn't her best. but the chorus sounded good.

  • at the end of the day people she tried her hardest atleast she didnt mime

  • It's besides the point if her ear piece fell out; do you not think that she would be able to her herself singing because of the amps located all around the arena?

    It's no surprise that she failed as a singer, because, to put it simply, she can't sing. Through the magic of computers you could insert the sound of a screeching cat and it would turn out like the CD version. And I'm willing to bet that about 95% of the population can sing better than her; ie. anyone who's not tone deaf.

  • little bit too harsh, but your right. think about it,many singers suck at live, they still get paid. luv the song though

  • i like her studio music hahah lucky i dont have to see her live init

  • who cares?

    Britney has made a career out of not being able to sing, she just has more money to cover up her shitty voice in the studio.

  • do you notice at the chorus at the hard notes she sings very quietly and then the back up vocals take place if you listen closely you can hear her real voice and she really goes bad

    notice that the crowd isn't cheering or dancing

  • absolute shit even though on cd she sounds awsome i hate to say it but the only reason they made her a popstar was err tv there i said it thats the reason why she is shit but i love her someone had to say it also i could sing better than her any day sorry to say it i dont have fancy equiptment or a bloody earpiece hehehe

  • alright everyone, i know sstephanie mcintosh were family friends! and i asked her why did u sing like that and she said her ear piece fell out and she couldnt hear her self singing. so give her a break i bet u couldnt sing as gud as her!! she is a really nice person! and trust me ur pretty gay if u dont have anything better to do then make fun of celebritys. soo stop making out like shes the worst singing in the world she is really gud! GIANNOTII WTF IS THAT IT SOUNDS LIKE A PASTA BRAND BAHHAHAH

  • This video is pointless, you are just jealous of Stephanie. Stephanie was NERVOUS! She is a young adult performing in front of thousands of people, give her a break. Steph is a better singer than you ever will be. So shut up. 1*

  • I don't see noting wrong with this

    live video of stephanie mcintosh

    so she is not crapp to me. long is

    the pre recorded one is good you

    people should not be compainling!!!!

  • i dont think she would make it in idol these days !! lol =)

  • LOL!

  • ...wow. her voice is really tragic, but i like the pre recorded ones. lol. I like the lyrics. maybe someone should like... redo her songs... maybe someone who can actually sing?

  • omg she hits the really high ones but shes awful on the easy ones lol how sad i used to like her haha

  • I'm not saying that this is flawless, but you're being a little over critical. I've seen live performances that have been a thousand times worse by artists way more popular than her.

    If you get the time, look up Panic At the Disco performing "Nine in the Afternoon" on the 2007 MTV VMAs. That's crap.

  • in a way i feel bad for the steph because she's been told she's good and then she hears the pre-recorded one and thinks she's good lol i dunno if that made sceance but yer

    i've herd her do better but she's not the best lol

    :D

  • Sceance? i think your looking for sense, but maybe im just making no sceance at all...

  • oh yer oops should of proof read before commenting, me and my sucky spelling lol

  • maybe she was just having a bad day cuz iv'e seen her do better... on different songs by the way maemoe9977 that was funny and true

  • that was crap this was the first time ive seen her sing live gosh it sounded good on summer heights high

  • 'giving her a record contract was a mistake'

    LOL

  • Oh my. 3:25

  • i think she's good, its not that easy singing in front of people like that, her voice is unigue.... u think u could do better??? i'd like to see u try

  • ugh she made a mistake by becoming a singer!

  • why are you putting her down??

    YOU SHOULD SEE MILEY CYRUS!1 uughh!!!!

    shes actually good

  • I agree about Miley Cyrus lol - she's so bad.

  • Good grief, you're right...SHE'S TERRIBLE!!! Her voice shaking and flat on so many notes...*shudders* thanks for saving me my money! Her voice is painful to hear.

  • shes not bad. everyone sounds worse live. and if we like her recorded voice better even if its not her real, we dont give a care, its enjoyable to listen to!

  • ok, yeah, its not the best. but unless you can do better, leave the girl alone.

  • Dude!

    Your the one who's a crap!

    She sound fine and not that bad.

  • Mate, She is good compared to "Metro Station" live.

    And "Short Stack"

    Their singing is fucking horrible..

    Check them out then you will know what im talking about.

  • Bad...Bad...Bad..FULL STOP.

  • ok that is bad but still on the scale -- WORST LIVE SONGS EVER... I kissed a girl katy perry live is also shit.. try it out

  • YES SHE IS

    Neighbours is a breeding ground for shit singers

  • i dont think shes that bad if u want bad have a look at katy perry shes sounds drunk on every single performance1!!

  • these days record company don't publish songs and artist becuase they can sing, but becuase they will drive in the cash! Im serious, I've tried getting published before and they ddin't care how good i was; if i dont have the fame, i dont have the deal. It's as simple as that.

  • This is what you spend your time doing. Not everyone sounds wonderful live. Shocking I know. So I guess if she is a bad singer like you say then your pathetic and have no life for pointing this out. Get A Job or better yet and hobby that doesn't make you look like a gianormous tool!~!

  • agreed!

  • did you ever think thay she may of have a really really bad cold

  • I wonder who were the "stunt hips?"

  • OMG! Cuz it's in the TV guide, nooooo! Whatever shall I do? I have no choice but to believe it, cuz it's not like I have a mind of my own! D:

    Idiotic. Live performances don't always sound the same as the album. Sooo sorry that NOBODY. IS. PERFECT.

  • I have followed young Steph for ages, I loved 'mistake' and didn't know any better (that she was a dying cat when singing) till I saw her live at the AVMA's doing "So Do I Say Sorry First" - my partner and I came home that night and youtubed her and saw that she has ALWAYS been as bad as she is, it's bizaare, I've never known a terrible singger to keep trying to sing live so much !!

  • She is the worst singer in the world. She deserves to be locked up in jail with that effort. It is evident she is so bad because she was quite famous before that, and now she hasnt produced any more songs. Burn Stephanie!

  • omg u r so mean! she is a great singer and maybe she was having a bad time! geez and she is not that bad u r just backing on her because she sings good and u cant god get a life and not hers!

  • I feel sorry for the crowd, they should demand a refund after being subjected to Stephanie's singing...urgh, GO AWAY! You're a mistake Stepahnie!

  • It was definately a "Stupid mistake" even letting Stephanie perform for the grand final show, this is painful...what a talentless waste of space and her dance moves are pathetic

  • anthony u r retarded shes not bad except for a few places id like 2 see u sing that! god does it matter? if u dnt like her dont go to her concert steph u rock

  • omg;

    people.

    ALL singers dont sound like the recordings on live performances. le duh xD

  • Haley Williams of Paramore is the real deal, voice and all, so that's not always true. She's better live! Check out her videos for her vioce school...

  • its pretty mean what u said about her, she was just nevous... but i do agree that she should get a few dancing lessons

  • It Wasnt That Bad!

  • so what? did u c how many ppl were there? i'd b pretty nervous if i woz her. plus that woz her 1st shot at singing so give her a break!!! i luved it! ;)

  • she not that bad when singing the chorus she just cant sing low

  • The last bit nearly made me cry, it was so funny.

  • I think....She was nervous...bahaha

    Funny comments though.

  • She's not that bad. At least she wasn't lip-syncing. She was actually singing live. She was probably very nervous and it was one of her first live performances. I'm not really a fan but she's not horrible

  • I think you got a point and it could be a scandle but liking to sing as well I think she is most likely justs sick not fake.

  • OMG LOL thats like a million testi pops and shes a girl haha

  • Hahaha... aaaahh, tragic! I *must* be bored. Damn I liked her on Neighbours. I just found out she only got the job cos her mum is a top exec at Ten. I guess it went to her head.

  • ye and her step bro is an ex neighbours guy jason donavon