Added: 5 years ago
From: magicbird05
Views: 1,644,737
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (185)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • fireflame625 babies don't watch anything MORON!

  • 123456789101112

  • wow this show is for baibes lol

  • Ahh good times as a kid good good times

  • Was looking on youtube some time a go know and in the USA they have built a full size version of the Thomas in the TV series.

  • This bring backs so maaannnyy memories. :3

  • @emoperson667 the fact they have changed his name is an outrage!!!!

  • @TheJoelfletch It was for political correctness

  • why is the fat controller topemhat,and wheres ringo,is this the usa version?

  • WHAT DID THEY CALL THE FAT CONTROLLER?!

  • 1:04

    Toby disappears, but henrietta is still there

    what is up wit dat?

  • Thanks to you, I just got a rush of nostalgia and now I have to go digging through my basement for my old VHS tapes. Wish me luck!

  • MADE B4 MA B-DAY

  • I stumbled about this looking for videos of REAL trains, but I must give you congrats on making it four years and 1,000,000 views without a copyright notice. Impressive.

  • @gguru1 thanks im suprised too

  • @magicbird05 I'm trying to do the same, I've NEARLY got a million on mine.

  • ahh good old thomas i remember those days

  • wow 1 million views...thanks guys =D

  • @magicbird05 we sure do love thomas!

  • thumbs up for Richard Starkey aka Mr. Ringo Starr :)

  • 2:51 Oliver: Wow... fail.

  • 40 people missed the button. :P

  • good ol george carlin may he rest in peace

  • RINGO!

    hes the only reason Im lisining to this. Im 14, and Im watching this shit. lol.

  • @brecre i got you beat, im 19 lol. i miss watching these as a kid on my VHS

  • @brecre 14 and swearing? This is unacceptible!

  • @ApertureScienceLabs Oh my god! Get over it.

  • @brecre no! Never!

  • @brecre why in the world at any age would you call thomas sh!t?!

  • @saurfan Its a video about a talking train. Need I say more?

  • @brecre ive done my part ill let the huge amount of other fans handle you

  • Wow, this video is about to push a 1,000,000 views.

  • where's the big city anyway?

  • @LDtheBrachio london

  • @Smoofie92 okay thanks

  • Two things:

    1. When the narrator said Donald whistled hello and spoke to Thomas, Toby, and Percy, it was really Douglas.

    2. The only reason Thomas's brakes didn't work is because he was manufactured by Toyota™

  • Sir Toppem Hat?

    Fuck off, he will always be The Fat Controler

  • Not to most people who live in America.

  • i would like to meat oliver

  • memories, now i am a big railfan :) im 13 now,

  • ahh, the memories

  • wow I dont remember it being that short!

  • It's not fair. Why don't Oliver, Bill, Ben, Boco, Mavis, Donald, and Douglas get to go, too? They are Sir Topham Hatt's engines, too.

  • Because this is a heavily modified version of The Fat Controllers Engines from the RWS book Eight Famous Engines. Duck, Gordon, Henry, James, Thomas,Percy, Toby and Edward were the only Fat Controllers engines in that particular story and their work was done by engines from the other railway while they were away. The Engines in this have basically taken on the responsibilities of what the engines on the other railway did while Thomas and all were away.

  • The TV series could've done with models for engines on the other railway.

  • Cai loves James. Choo choo

  • Oh, I adore Carlin's narration! Ringo was great too. Baldwin never impressed me...

  • Why is this video about a childhood cartoon plagued with ramblings about which version is better? It's a child's television show if you dare slander any version of it because of your foolish national pride then you are a bigot. This show is to make children smile not to show differences in American/British accents. Please get over yourself and leave your patriotism at the door.

  • here here well said indeed

  • this is the american version cause americans cannot understand anyother accents other than american dumb asses

  • Screw you, we Americans are not as stupid as you steroetypically think, our railway terminology is just different, thats all.

  • It's live action animation. The trains are all electric model engines ;)

  • i remember this with Welsh accents?

  • Endless happy memories... i watched these until I was 11!

  • The Fat Controller!!!!

    This video is bullshit.

  • NO, you're bullshit for insulting us Americans like that. Our terminology is different, respect that or gtfo.

  • his name is Sir Topham Hatt

    The Fat Controller is like a nick name

    they went with Sir Topham Hatt in the US because Fat Controller is a little offensive.

    either way nither of them are wrong.

  • Carlin narrarated my childhood

  • SIR TOP AND HAT

    WTF!?

    fat controller FTW!

  • Its sir Topham Hat

  • also hes called the Fat Controller not Sir top and hat

  • Erm sorry but ringo starr is from liverpool not the us And yes Ringo Starr and Micheal Angellis are irreplaceable Thomas narrators also how could they get rid of the old theme tune!!!!

  • Didn't you make a video response to one of my videos with this in 2006?

  • what no ringo star, ahh well PEACE AND LOVE LOL

  • this was the 100th episode of thomas the tank engine

  • WTF American Narrarator? This is shit as. The origional is way better

  • wat?

    george carlin did great!

  • @SodorProductions I'm not British. It's the original, or it's nothing! Like it or leave it! You don't see us renaming Barney, so don't you rename the Fat Controller - Hero of Sodor!

  • Excuse me but im british and that was out of order to say we are full of ourselves. I have nothing against te american versions of TTTE but both english ad american narrtors sound boring. And don't deny it. The only decent onesare Ringo Starr and George Carlin. The new one for amrica and Michel Angellis aswell as peirce brosnanmake it sound as if it was rwritten for OA's!!!!!?????!!!!!!! This controvasy ends now OK? Or i'll report all who made rude remarks to youtube. Understood?

  • Whoa there, I' saying there are fans out there who ARE so full of themselves that they have to dis the american dub, I wasn't saying all British fans are full of themselves! Sheesh people!

  • Ok then thats settled.

  • Well said. I agree completely

  • Not wanting to sound full of myself, but when the rights to a British series is sold to the US, this usually results in the content being watered down, the humour being watered down and in many cases, the content copied like for like.

    This isn't so bad, but what annoys me and many other people is when a series is then sold on to other countries by the US, it is marketed as a US show. The Office, Pop (American) Idol and the Sketch Show are classic examples.

  • I don't think you sound full of yourself, I can understand that

  • no offense dude but there are American Fans that are full of themselves too.

  • I know it's not right to hate on another country's version but on both sides you'll find U.K people that are full of themselves and American's that are full of themselves.

  • @SodorProductions so your sick of me?

  • No man, just random people who trash the US dubs,

  • @SodorProductions oh them yea i dont mind US dubs unless its baldwin

  • George Carlin is dead you jerk

  • try being nice- it might change your out look on others headbanger

  • 2.48 funniest thing i have ever seen in my life

  • this was also found on shing time station

  • This sounds so wierd. Im used to Ringo Starre narrating.

  • Comment removed

  • there's a total of four narrators that Narrated Thomas.

    1. Ringo Starr

    2. George Carlin

    3. Alec Baldwin

    4. Micheal Brandon

  • how can you forget the best one, Michael Angellis!?!

  • ... I don't remember him...

  • think he was only talking about the US ones and Ringo was the first US one

  • great episode.

  • When Douglas rushes through the station, why does George say "Donald"?

  • George Carlin freakin rules.

  • this is first time i heard george catlin narrate and i got to say he was a great story teller lol

  • Percy is so cute!

  • I hate these redo assholes!

  • does anybody know what happened to donald and douglas the twin engines? i dont see them on the show anymore

  • donald and oduglas along with oliver and duck there back on the show now

  • tlga

  • : )

  • at 0:18 you can here a door close

  • George Carlin reeli did justice to narrating Thomas and the other engines...way better than than Alec Baldwin or the other guy who does it now!

  • better than the new CGI ones...

  • What do you mean?

  • they destroyed the format. thier fdaces move!!!! :-(

  • NOOOOO.

  • That Scottish voice is so funny!

    Did The Fat Controller (a.k.a. Toppom Hat) say 'State City'?

    Did Thomas say 'Thank glad I'm a splendid engine'?

  • Guys quit argueing, who cares whose versions are better? To me, I like them both. I grew up with George Carlin though. Besides theres nothing wrong with it, STH and TFC are one in the same. He's called STH because when Britt was bringing the series to the us, the name TFC was kinddah offensive to some.

  • you wanker

  • yes, I am certain that the entire reason for us being called british is exactly what you have described. If you said it, then, well.. It just must be.

    Let's get out the History books hmm?

  • Comment removed

  • fuck you

  • i know.

    the british cast only had 1 - 12

    now there's like a milloin new engines

    ps i prefer ringo starr's narration.

    he has that cool acsent

  • Comment removed

  • Man...These were the best. It's SO sad they don't use the extensive vocabulary & railroad terms in the new ones...I learned half the words I know from this show...now all kids know how to say is "Confusion" and "Delay".

  • this is how i learned english when i was a kid lol

  • 02:49 - Love the face! :D So cute.

  • thomias

  • i miss these kinds of stories, not the new crap ones

  • agreed

  • there in the national rail museum in york!

  • its awesome¬!!!11!!elventyseven!!1­1!!one!

  • OMG is this the american version

  • its awful!

    he NO ringo star!

  • George Carlin was a WAY better narrator than Ringo. Such a variety of voices, a soothing, kind demeanor. All-Round really well. RIP George.

  • we never got George Carlin in the UK

  • We got Ringo for the 1st 2 seasons Then Britt Alcroft decided to choose an American narrator for those in the U.S. At that time, Michael Angelis (sp?) took over for Ringo in the UK and Australia/New Zealand.

  • Ringo and Michael Angelis sound alike!!

  • i've noticed something: Duck and Toby have never interacted in a story together. why is that?

  • probably because they both have separate branch lines on different parts of the island

  • well they did kind of interact in Donald's Duck..... but just a couple lines.... and they were on the same side of the island pulling cars.... i just wish they could have a story revolving around just them two, besides Toby Had A Little Lamb lol

  • George Carlin!!!!!!!!!!!

  • yea!!!!!!

  • well i guess oliver does make a good imatation for jinty since in the railway series jinty nad pug only helped out.

  • where toby says how can something be up when its down. its out of time. Tobys eyes go up for up and then they go down 1 or 2 seconds after he says down.

  • Duncan

  • this is george carlin narrating rite?

  • I guess Ducks Boiler is squared shaped so the Fat Controller could sit on.

  • LOL!

  • Pannier Tanks; More than the usual train purposes.

  • Wouldn't it be hot up there?

    (Obviously not after hours of not having the fire going I mean)

  • taken from Shining Time Station

  • Thomas & Oliver!!! are they friends?

  • yes.

  • This is my theory about BoCo's absence.

    When the episodes with Daisy came up, they morphed BoCo into Daisy. Daisy's faces are pretty much just BoCo's faces with makeup. So BoCo disapeared because he turned into Daisy. When Mavis and BoCo go by, they try to hide BoCo's face. I think I saw some blush on his cheeks, but Im not sure. But how BoCo's body managed to return to its original form pretty much shatters my theory...

  • Does his Body look Like Daisy's to you?!

  • they probably rebuilt it.

  • + Look at other vids of this and you'll see they have no blush

  • But Daisy showed up after Boco dissapeared, so thats just one of the changes they made after Boco's absence.

  • ye your right there is some pink make up/blush and he has long girl eyelashes

  • Daisy has Boco's face. They used makeup for Daisy. Boco has nothing.

  • Boco still appeared after Daisy Showed up

  • hes right. he really is. there is blush on boco. seriously. zoom in. with the scroll clicker and ctrl and pause it. there is orangy pink stuff on his cheeks

  • i guess thats also why they did buffer up with bill and ben and donald and oliver. but they stuffed that to. who wouldnt notice that donald was called douglas and vice versa. but douglas and oliver are tight thats why it was a mistake. they said oliver and douglas for a reason. but mixed up the models.

  • daisy and boco share faces

  • why did goerge Carlin call them trucks in this episode?

  • they never said Cars or trucks! tell me where you here them?

  • Toby and percy were each on a truck

  • Well,they were on trucks.

  • i like the accent that this guy does for donald and douglas! lol!

  • wait a sec!

    arent Donald & Douglas the fat controller's engines?

  • Mavis is with Boco, Bill and Ben at the station. After Boco left, Mavis replaced them and in this episode we see them coupled together. Was something going on between Boco and Mavis in the past few seasons? ;)

  • Did you notice that George Carlin said that Donald said Sorry we can't stop, and It was acctully Douglas?

  • i like the english vershon

  • HEY!Did I say you can post fun facts???J/k,lol.I didn't know that.

  • Another Fun Fact: This was made on Thomas' 50th Birthday

  • Another Fun Fact:Some of the Season 5 music is heard before the ariel shot of the engines.

  • Fun Fact:This is the 100th episodes in the series,so they made it special like this.