What happened was Already Gone was made before Halo, but Halo was made public before Already Gone. Kelly tried to stop Already Gone from being made public(out of respect for Ms. Knowles), but it was out of her hands.
i don't think Ryan Tedder did anything wrong on purpose. But who knows. I do know, as a songwriter, that people have their own styles... many of my songs sound similar. And If Kelly is that concerned about it, She should write her own songs. @jjjaaaccckkk I didn't know that about Beyonce having such a big hand in her songwriting. That's awesome.
I think Beyonce's Halo is great for what it is and Kelly's Already Gone is great for what it is. I don't think this version would sound louder that it sounds now when Beyonce performes it. The same if Beyonce performed Already Gone.
I wouldn't have picked the up the similarities between the songs... they have a totally different spin on them....they each do a wonderful job on their songs, and that is all that should matter :)
In actual fairness, these two songs are played at different tempos, its just that this guy made aligned the tempos and now it fits in well with the halo beat, but i'd like to see it the other way round
The real genius here of course is One Republic's Ryan Tedder. Gave up one song and earned twice the money as both were successful.
I don't think it's a big deal really, I mean these days it seems like every song that comes out is a remake/remix or copy of some variety. Plus Kelly Clarkson and Beyonce are known for being singers not song writers, they don't compose their own music so who gives a shit where the tune comes from, either way it won't be their creation.
@jjjaaaccckkk Kelly has co-written 30 of her recorded songs, including 98% of My December.
In fact she had full writing power with My December and went against Clive Davis' request to accept a handful of Kara DioGuardi songs that she had previously written for Lindsay Lohan (she turned down $5 million!!).
@FakeHipster yeah I know she co-writes lyrics, I was saying she doesn't compose the music. I also mentioned in one of my other comments that she co-writes and so deserves more credit than beyonce in this scenario. I respect the singers who write their own lyrics a lot.
@jjjaaaccckkk Just came across a comment you posted 8months ago.Beyonce is a song-writter. Billboard listed Knowles at no.17 on their list of the Top 20 Hot 100 Songwriters, for having co-written 8 singles that hit no.1 on the Billboard Hot 100.She was one of only 3 women on that list.
[HALO] was composed by Ryan Tedder, Evan Bogart, and KNOWLES within 3 hrs in Tedder's studio.
[Beyonce] is the 1st black woman and the 2nd woman ever to take home the ASCAP Pop Songwriter of the Year Award
To be honest there is a similar feel and production to the songs but niether of them sound similar to me at all. Alot of hype and controversy over nothing.
@musicguy713 Both songs are actually written by Ryan Tedder of One Republic. He's a producer in the industry and constantly writes for many artists. He also wrote Bleeding Love. So it's natural they sound similar. He used variations on a single theme.
@gariadara Yeah but the songs sound completely different the themes are opposite and the feel is a tad similar but still i have never thought they sound the same. But if they did it wouldntbe that big of a deal since ryan tedder wrote both ad produced them.
@musicguy713 they are different songs. The melodies are completely different indeed. But both songs use the exact same tempo, key, and phrasing. These are perhaps slightly more subtle but that depends on the listener, some people notice these "subtleties" than others. If you are highly sensitive to rhythm, for example, you'd pick up the identical beat right away. It's Ryan's M.O. In fact many of Tedder's songs have a driving beat motif: Apologize, Bleeding Love.
I can at least find humour in imagining Timbaland creating a Mini Me and out comes OneRepublic Guy to continue Timbaland's work when he dies, the work of doing the same minimal thing for every song.
Though I don't think he's got to the stage where he's shoehorning himself into every song + video (looking like a paedophile on drugs) to make it look like he's the one who did all of it.
'Apologize by Timbaland (oh and feat. OneRepublic)'?? What??
Read the article on wikipedia regarding the similarity between Kelly Clarkson's already gone and Beyonce's Halo. They also have Ryan Tedder's [the front man of one republic which helped wrote both songs for Kelly Clarkson and Beyonce] satement on this 'problem'
I think I remember beyonce getting mad about Kelly's song. Then they found out about the producer. didnt he get in trouble for it? I could have sworn i read about that.
this is so awesome! for real. and youre right from one producer came already gone and battle field, the other halo. but my own producer now. got a new llist.
it's totally off at some points which goes to show you it's not exactly the same but there are def similarities. Tedder is an ass but both ladies are very talented, love AG more though
Kelly clarkson worked with ryan tedder on this song, so did Beyonce on Halo so its acceptable that they sound similar. Clarkson was mad at first but Already Gone has outdone Halo so she's not so upset anymore :)
@hames100 actually, halo reached a far higher peak on most charts throughout the world compared to already gone. so sorry, halo outdid already gone easily.
Beyonce's Halo is a beautiful, beautiful, unique song that is unlike most songs on the radio at the moment. Kelly Clarkson's AG is saved by its deep, heartbreaking message but the backing track, unfortunately, is kind of forgettable. If it had as strong a beat as what's on Halo (yeah, it can be argued that it's just AG's beat juiced up) then it would be an even more powerful song. If Beyonce had the original AG beat, I doubt her song would have been as big.
I'll tell you what I'm looking for... an actual MashUp of both tracks... It HAS to be doable...
I've trawled the next and so many people have (badly) just put one vocal track over another backing track... or played both songs simultaneously..and called it a mashup.
Pleeeease tell me there's a way of doing a mashup? Especially of someone of your talent?? Even if it's a dance remix?
Kelly makes me tingle all over. And I love both songs!
well yer, the backing tracks are uber similar. I still think that the guy who made them....cant remember his name. stuffed up big time and should admit to it if he hasnt already
uhmmm actually noone copied who they both got thier song writen from the same songwriter/producer Ryan Tedder of One Republic whihc accidently sound alike so blame him
No one stole anything or copied anyone. "Already Gone" was already produced before "Halo". It's just that "Halo" got released a single before "Already Gone" did. Kelly tried to stop her record label from releasing it (out of respect to Knowles), but they ignored her and went ahead with it. Ryan Tedder used the same beat on both songs. It's his fault. Not either of the girls. Both songs are really good, though.
One song is so full of hope (Halo) and the other is so sad (Already gone)... what a contrast! It expresses different feelings altogether.
I dun care if the beat & notes sound similar. Comon so many songs in the world can be played with the G note. Isn't there an evolution of song on youtube that proofed that? So as long as it's a good song, (which these 2 are), that's good enough for me.
if he wanted he could of sang these songs himself and made them even better, (he actually did, search them) and got allllll the money, but no. he shared with others.
Okay, all you retards that think these two songs sound the same need to get your heads checked! Just because a song goes with the same beat of another song, doesn' t mean they are the same... This remix proves it! 90% of the song goes off key with the harmonies of the other!
Prove my point? Are you deaf? The point where Clarkson sings "I didn't want us to burn out. I didn't come here to hurt you now I can't stop" does not go with the melody of the part when Beyonce sings "It's like I've been awakened. Every rule I had you breakin. It's the risk that I'm takin'. I ain't never gonna shut you out" Notice how the background music sounds off key at this point? This is just one of many examples. Proof enough?
the stupid prducer is to blame! even though i like both songs, i hate the producers for doing that and making everyone that beyonce stole kelly's song or that kelly stole beyonce's song
U R WRONG!!!! IT WAS THE STUPIS PRODUCER WHO WANTED TO SELL HIS STUPID SONG AND TO DO SO HE SOLD IT TO THE 2 BEST SINGER AVER
BEYONCE AND KELLY SO KELLY HAD IT FIRST BUT THEN THE PRODUCER CAME TO BEYONCE AND SOLD IT TO HER BY THAT TIME KELLY HAD RELEASED HER ALBUM WITH HALO AND BEYONCE 2 SO ITS THE STUPID PRODUCER TO BLAMO NOT BEYONCE OR KELLY
its unfortunate that this Mr. Tedder guy sold the musical score to both Beyonce and Kelly without them knowing. Both are amazing songs but I cant listen to one without thinking of the other.
Although Halo was released first, Already Gone was recorded first. Halo was also first given to Leona Lewis as a single but didnt make the album and was later given to Beyonce. Kelly's record company made Already Gone a single and although she arugued against it, it was out of her hands. As a music industry major I know she wasnt lying when she said that bcuz they do that like seriously they do. But I love both versions and even did Beyonce's on my page here on Youtube.
Well. They sound alike but why do people need to make such a big deal about it? Both artists are great and did a really good job on these songs. Do you all honestly want to lose one of these songs? Don't you rather appreciate how good both sounds? Well I do.
It's not their faults the same guy wrote both songs and used the same back beat and Kelly apoligized and didn't even want to put this on her soundtrack cuz its similar so it's not Kelly's fault
me gustan las 2 rolas originales, i no mpiezen qon q una le copioa a la otra xq nada q ver, el compositor d las rolas dijo q abia echio las 2 al mismo stilo y q sta la d kelly fue grabada primero pero fue lanzada primero halo de beyonce,,,las 2 soen moei bnaz
funny how kelly continues on being accused of ripping off the song when beyonce has not said a word about anything. Beyonce song was written and recorded after kellys. why doesnt she explain herself?
no offence but i think u used halo's beat and put kelly's singing into this remix to make it seem liek itz her fault. but her song beat sounds different
the producer admitted to giving them the same beat correct me if im wrong, but i think kelly clarkson song came out about a year earlier than beyonce's halo.
Yah. It's not her fault that her song sounds the same. But can't blame her song writer either...he did come up with A nice melody. Anyway this isn't the first of many songs that sound alike..nice mash up.
sounds like Kanye should run up to Kelly while she is talking and intterupt her and start to talk about this. "Sorry, Kelly, your good and all, but....HALO IS THE BEST SONG EVER!! EVER! Just saying."
it's the same music with different words...and the two version it's so great...the beyonce's version is important in a moment of my life...but i like the voice of kelly......
Technically...Beyonce and Kelly Clarkson had the same writer...Kelly didn't "steal" Beyonce's song Halo, matter of fact, the guy who wrote it fucked up really bad and made two songs that sounded almost the same...
What happened was Already Gone was made before Halo, but Halo was made public before Already Gone. Kelly tried to stop Already Gone from being made public(out of respect for Ms. Knowles), but it was out of her hands.
expressyourself2222 3 weeks ago
Stop Poliiiiice!!...THIEF...THIEF
slimms013 3 weeks ago
i don't think Ryan Tedder did anything wrong on purpose. But who knows. I do know, as a songwriter, that people have their own styles... many of my songs sound similar. And If Kelly is that concerned about it, She should write her own songs. @jjjaaaccckkk I didn't know that about Beyonce having such a big hand in her songwriting. That's awesome.
EmelyneMusic 3 months ago
I think Beyonce's Halo is great for what it is and Kelly's Already Gone is great for what it is. I don't think this version would sound louder that it sounds now when Beyonce performes it. The same if Beyonce performed Already Gone.
islambek88 8 months ago
I wouldn't have picked the up the similarities between the songs... they have a totally different spin on them....they each do a wonderful job on their songs, and that is all that should matter :)
lisaralph0505 10 months ago
its the first time that i think it sounds like the same. kellys is better :D
4lovekelly 10 months ago
this version is awesome
Aaron0141 11 months ago 3
i like this version
Aaron0141 11 months ago 2
In actual fairness, these two songs are played at different tempos, its just that this guy made aligned the tempos and now it fits in well with the halo beat, but i'd like to see it the other way round
dvdshaya 1 year ago 2
"I love her eyes" LMfaoo <3
tellittomonday 1 year ago
The real genius here of course is One Republic's Ryan Tedder. Gave up one song and earned twice the money as both were successful.
I don't think it's a big deal really, I mean these days it seems like every song that comes out is a remake/remix or copy of some variety. Plus Kelly Clarkson and Beyonce are known for being singers not song writers, they don't compose their own music so who gives a shit where the tune comes from, either way it won't be their creation.
jjjaaaccckkk 1 year ago
@jjjaaaccckkk Kelly has co-written 30 of her recorded songs, including 98% of My December.
In fact she had full writing power with My December and went against Clive Davis' request to accept a handful of Kara DioGuardi songs that she had previously written for Lindsay Lohan (she turned down $5 million!!).
FakeHipster 1 year ago
@FakeHipster yeah I know she co-writes lyrics, I was saying she doesn't compose the music. I also mentioned in one of my other comments that she co-writes and so deserves more credit than beyonce in this scenario. I respect the singers who write their own lyrics a lot.
jjjaaaccckkk 1 year ago
@jjjaaaccckkk Just came across a comment you posted 8months ago.Beyonce is a song-writter. Billboard listed Knowles at no.17 on their list of the Top 20 Hot 100 Songwriters, for having co-written 8 singles that hit no.1 on the Billboard Hot 100.She was one of only 3 women on that list.
[HALO] was composed by Ryan Tedder, Evan Bogart, and KNOWLES within 3 hrs in Tedder's studio.
[Beyonce] is the 1st black woman and the 2nd woman ever to take home the ASCAP Pop Songwriter of the Year Award
fckingkim 4 months ago
Hey! My a cappella group does a mash-up of this too! We're called Acappellics Anonymous-Check us out!
youtube.com/user/ACappellicsAnonymous
AmandaSpinella 1 year ago
To be honest there is a similar feel and production to the songs but niether of them sound similar to me at all. Alot of hype and controversy over nothing.
musicguy713 1 year ago
@musicguy713 Both songs are actually written by Ryan Tedder of One Republic. He's a producer in the industry and constantly writes for many artists. He also wrote Bleeding Love. So it's natural they sound similar. He used variations on a single theme.
gariadara 1 year ago
@gariadara Yeah but the songs sound completely different the themes are opposite and the feel is a tad similar but still i have never thought they sound the same. But if they did it wouldntbe that big of a deal since ryan tedder wrote both ad produced them.
musicguy713 1 year ago
@musicguy713 they are different songs. The melodies are completely different indeed. But both songs use the exact same tempo, key, and phrasing. These are perhaps slightly more subtle but that depends on the listener, some people notice these "subtleties" than others. If you are highly sensitive to rhythm, for example, you'd pick up the identical beat right away. It's Ryan's M.O. In fact many of Tedder's songs have a driving beat motif: Apologize, Bleeding Love.
gariadara 1 year ago
@gariadara Thas what i was gettig at its the beat and rhythm that sound similar but like you said its more of a ryan tedder style song.
musicguy713 1 year ago
already gone was written before halo. but halo came out before already gone. so it looks like kelly copied beyonce...noo
they are written by the same person
jonazbros 1 year ago
Haha Kelly slays Beyonce anyday. No competition at all. Kelly is an artist, Beyonce is Copycat
ViolaXZ 1 year ago 3
The Sad and Hope mixed together and equal to the Sad but still Had Hope
strangerdune 1 year ago
A BATTLEFIELD, A BATTLEFIELD, A BATTLEFIELD
I can at least find humour in imagining Timbaland creating a Mini Me and out comes OneRepublic Guy to continue Timbaland's work when he dies, the work of doing the same minimal thing for every song.
Though I don't think he's got to the stage where he's shoehorning himself into every song + video (looking like a paedophile on drugs) to make it look like he's the one who did all of it.
'Apologize by Timbaland (oh and feat. OneRepublic)'?? What??
Oscy 1 year ago
Read the article on wikipedia regarding the similarity between Kelly Clarkson's already gone and Beyonce's Halo. They also have Ryan Tedder's [the front man of one republic which helped wrote both songs for Kelly Clarkson and Beyonce] satement on this 'problem'
AaRoNdEAnGelo 1 year ago
i love her eyes too :D
AaRoNdEAnGelo 1 year ago
DOWNLOAD LINK PLZ?
JESUS LOVES YOU †♥
tenrairibon 1 year ago
Kellys SO MUCH BETTER
MrCircusBoyy 1 year ago 4
i think it's obvious...
viaiphone 1 year ago
i like already gone better, only becuz i'm a die-hard kelly fan, but beyonce's good too.
1200randomgirl 1 year ago 5
LOL, this is given..it's the same song :)))
swatwhatbutgawd 1 year ago
Both songs are great, but it's messed up how that producer gave them the same beat.
Halo - over 2million copies sold & peaked at #5
Already Gone - over 1million copies sold & peaked at #13
So they both did well.
10deandre10 1 year ago
I think I remember beyonce getting mad about Kelly's song. Then they found out about the producer. didnt he get in trouble for it? I could have sworn i read about that.
CommandoMomo 1 year ago
Okay Kelly Clarkson came out with the song first!!!!
mialyssalol 1 year ago
Is it awful that I don't think they sound similar?
brittnypeachpie 1 year ago
this is so awesome! for real. and youre right from one producer came already gone and battle field, the other halo. but my own producer now. got a new llist.
misticalchick23 1 year ago
I heard that Halo, Already Gone and Battlefield sound similar because the same dude helped write them at around the same time
Sal17M 1 year ago
hey! download link please!? haha! :))
sadone29 1 year ago
Kelly clarkson is tons better than beyowolf.
EvFan1985 1 year ago
it's totally off at some points which goes to show you it's not exactly the same but there are def similarities. Tedder is an ass but both ladies are very talented, love AG more though
Lostie424 1 year ago
wow ;] love this!
loveistrueandcool 1 year ago
@MysteriousNight: can i ask for your Kelly clarkson acapella?the already gone Acapella..
2035105 1 year ago
i hate it so much, don't you know that messed up already gone? it's the best song ever.
adorableLAUTNER 1 year ago
Kelly clarkson worked with ryan tedder on this song, so did Beyonce on Halo so its acceptable that they sound similar. Clarkson was mad at first but Already Gone has outdone Halo so she's not so upset anymore :)
hames100 1 year ago 2
@hames100 actually, halo reached a far higher peak on most charts throughout the world compared to already gone. so sorry, halo outdid already gone easily.
burbscinates 1 year ago
Beyonce's Halo is a beautiful, beautiful, unique song that is unlike most songs on the radio at the moment. Kelly Clarkson's AG is saved by its deep, heartbreaking message but the backing track, unfortunately, is kind of forgettable. If it had as strong a beat as what's on Halo (yeah, it can be argued that it's just AG's beat juiced up) then it would be an even more powerful song. If Beyonce had the original AG beat, I doubt her song would have been as big.
floriszaire145 1 year ago
I like this remix a lot because the instrumental of "halo" for me is a way better and the voice of kelly clarkson is so beautiful.
And sincerelly I love the both songs too.
kirellabcn 1 year ago
Easily Kelly Clarkson. Anyone with common sense would pick Kelly.
AnimeStargrl15 1 year ago
I love this video! It is sooo cool. The original isn't that good though.
Lira24689 1 year ago
i love what they did this is tight. but beyonce still has the better song
TheWalkeraaron 1 year ago
i like kellys song a lot better than beyonce anyway. halo is very annoying in my opinion. most of beyonce's songs are way to repetetive for my taste.
missmermaid4 1 year ago
I'll tell you what I'm looking for... an actual MashUp of both tracks... It HAS to be doable...
I've trawled the next and so many people have (badly) just put one vocal track over another backing track... or played both songs simultaneously..and called it a mashup.
Pleeeease tell me there's a way of doing a mashup? Especially of someone of your talent?? Even if it's a dance remix?
Kelly makes me tingle all over. And I love both songs!
girlinemptyroom 1 year ago
@magicpen just rip off from you tube the song in mp3.if you wanna know how to do that,google is your best friend
saimir77 1 year ago
@saimir77 That's what I do :P But I use Any Video Converter. It's my best friend lol
Kelitude 1 year ago
You have to remember that these are pretty standard chord progressions. It's not ripping something off; it's simple musical theory.
doisch912 1 year ago
both songs are good.
gonzrule 1 year ago
this is the best remix ever i luv it......its a good combination of both songs
insanitypink2 1 year ago
well yer, the backing tracks are uber similar. I still think that the guy who made them....cant remember his name. stuffed up big time and should admit to it if he hasnt already
aditboy 1 year ago
Ryan Tedder :]
and he hasn't, he said it was Beyoncé herself who changed the beat/melody...
kcloverkc 1 year ago
this is beautiful!
xXCLUB30Xx 1 year ago
uhmmm actually noone copied who they both got thier song writen from the same songwriter/producer Ryan Tedder of One Republic whihc accidently sound alike so blame him
PiinkDiino 2 years ago 30
And the background drum beat is the same as in Apologize by One Republic....which was made by Timbaland...so I guess Timbaland teached Ryan that!!
adriana20222 2 years ago
@adriana20222 It was just produced by Timbaland. It was still written by Ryan Tedder
mramywinehouse 1 year ago
@PiinkDiino Damn you Ryan Tedder!
rezellehime 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No one stole anything or copied anyone. "Already Gone" was already produced before "Halo". It's just that "Halo" got released a single before "Already Gone" did. Kelly tried to stop her record label from releasing it (out of respect to Knowles), but they ignored her and went ahead with it. Ryan Tedder used the same beat on both songs. It's his fault. Not either of the girls. Both songs are really good, though.
soundslikeblue 2 years ago 2
One song is so full of hope (Halo) and the other is so sad (Already gone)... what a contrast! It expresses different feelings altogether.
I dun care if the beat & notes sound similar. Comon so many songs in the world can be played with the G note. Isn't there an evolution of song on youtube that proofed that? So as long as it's a good song, (which these 2 are), that's good enough for me.
lekristajojo 2 years ago 53
@lekristajojo and @mzholleewood i agree with you guys completely. you took the words right out of my mouth.
salasjz 1 year ago
maybe beyonce didn't copy kelly maybe her producers/songwriters did...?
but artists do it all the time.
no biggie.
:)
sweetig217 2 years ago
Kelly didn't copy Beyonce... :)
Already Gone was written in 2007.
Halo was written in 2008.
Kelly had been planning for All I Ever Wanted for a looooooong time!
SpearsProductions 2 years ago 8
@SpearsProductions yu tell em ! LMFAOO.
cutiibabii83 2 years ago
@miaka697
hahaha ryan tedder, no talent??
are you serious? do you really know who he is?!
if he wanted he could of sang these songs himself and made them even better, (he actually did, search them) and got allllll the money, but no. he shared with others.
thats talent.
DEATHDEALER224 2 years ago 4
I love onerepublic! He wrote good songs.
zonebran117 2 years ago 5
I like already gone better than Halo
Nurizzuddin 2 years ago 6
uhhh maybe its because both songs "already gone" and "halo" were written by RYAN TEDDER!
DEATHDEALER224 2 years ago 7
@DEATHDEALER224 which makes Ryan Tedder have no talent. If he couldn't come from the same sound.
miaka697 2 years ago 2
Okay, all you retards that think these two songs sound the same need to get your heads checked! Just because a song goes with the same beat of another song, doesn' t mean they are the same... This remix proves it! 90% of the song goes off key with the harmonies of the other!
ArgoX2007 2 years ago
prove your point, bro! I don't what u r talking about.
btcool2008 2 years ago
Prove my point? Are you deaf? The point where Clarkson sings "I didn't want us to burn out. I didn't come here to hurt you now I can't stop" does not go with the melody of the part when Beyonce sings "It's like I've been awakened. Every rule I had you breakin. It's the risk that I'm takin'. I ain't never gonna shut you out" Notice how the background music sounds off key at this point? This is just one of many examples. Proof enough?
ArgoX2007 2 years ago
LOL. That's enough! I didn't really pay that full attention to the lyric, but since you stated it like a pro, I take it as a precise critique. LOL
btcool2008 2 years ago
both songs are played on the same chords, i tested on the piano if u only mastered one of it its easy to master the other one both songs are nice
jahurz93 2 years ago
the second chord is diffrent.
OriginalsketchPiano 2 years ago 2
Thank you for knowing what you're talking about. I'm glad someone can tell.
drkmgkrlr303 2 years ago
yea its on the E not B sorry for ma bad
jahurz93 2 years ago
its all good:)
OriginalsketchPiano 2 years ago 2
its cuz the same person wrote both the songs.ha
1129brittany 2 years ago 4
Blame the "ARTIST" who should write their own music!!!!
sandwichsally 2 years ago 5
the stupid prducer is to blame! even though i like both songs, i hate the producers for doing that and making everyone that beyonce stole kelly's song or that kelly stole beyonce's song
MizMazikuni 2 years ago 2
of course she didn't steal it
imthetube44 2 years ago 2
Its sounds the same becuz the guy from one republic wrote both Songs and the producer u a similar concept in the beats
DreamTeamGeneral 2 years ago
it sounds the same like HALO but halo has clapping
karmagurl11 2 years ago
yea i thought the same thing. i was like why does this song sound like halo? haha its has the same song structure
drumgirl187 2 years ago 4
yup yup it was Ryan Tedder that made this mess =/
PinkPearlz33 2 years ago
good (:
juliajasdi 2 years ago
your absolutly right about that stupid producer... and BTW; kelly had that song first.
she had it on her album aand beyonce liked it.
that's the way it went
ashleydebest 2 years ago
@ashleydebest
U R WRONG!!!! IT WAS THE STUPIS PRODUCER WHO WANTED TO SELL HIS STUPID SONG AND TO DO SO HE SOLD IT TO THE 2 BEST SINGER AVER
BEYONCE AND KELLY SO KELLY HAD IT FIRST BUT THEN THE PRODUCER CAME TO BEYONCE AND SOLD IT TO HER BY THAT TIME KELLY HAD RELEASED HER ALBUM WITH HALO AND BEYONCE 2 SO ITS THE STUPID PRODUCER TO BLAMO NOT BEYONCE OR KELLY
aerie5497 2 years ago
i blame nobody BUT the Stupid proucer read my message (carefully) again
DutchGirlAshley 2 years ago
I did the same thing. I started singing remember those walls i builtt... and it was another song! ahaha...but I love bothh!!!!!!1
jessicaescudero19 2 years ago
Wow this is great! nice work. When I clicked on it I didn't think it would be this smooth. Amazing job!
GrahamLif3 2 years ago
the very very very first time I heard the original "Already Gone" (not this version)
i started singing "remember those walls I build.." then i was like WTF? but after i heard this song a few times, i love it better then Halo.
yes, both originals sound almost exact.
MermaidPaige 2 years ago 4
I want you to know, you couldn't of loved me better. But I want you to move on, so I'm already gone.
best line EVER in a love song.
MermaidPaige 2 years ago 2
It's not "of." It's " 've." Learn to spell.
Katyjen 2 years ago 4
what r u talking about????
MermaidPaige 2 years ago
When you said "couldn't of"
Katyjen 2 years ago 3
I spelt it correctly, look at my comment again
MermaidPaige 2 years ago
Yeah, it's supposed to be "have" or " 've."
Katyjen 2 years ago
Omg, I forgot you were my English teacher!
MermaidPaige 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
MermaidPaige 2 years ago
Comment removed
MermaidPaige 2 years ago
i like kelly's better. she is so talented... i have seen her in concert and she just blows you away with her voice!
JONASBROTHERLOVER711 2 years ago 3
NOT KELLY's FAULT! If you want someone to blame, blame that asshole Ryan Tedder!
OneAndOnlyGazzy 2 years ago 2
its unfortunate that this Mr. Tedder guy sold the musical score to both Beyonce and Kelly without them knowing. Both are amazing songs but I cant listen to one without thinking of the other.
Dusty2K6 2 years ago
i have the same eye color as her! behind these hazel eyes lol
Demi12345Lovato 2 years ago
Although Halo was released first, Already Gone was recorded first. Halo was also first given to Leona Lewis as a single but didnt make the album and was later given to Beyonce. Kelly's record company made Already Gone a single and although she arugued against it, it was out of her hands. As a music industry major I know she wasnt lying when she said that bcuz they do that like seriously they do. But I love both versions and even did Beyonce's on my page here on Youtube.
wooyea08 2 years ago 4
wow it blends great!
pitbulalshkirafan1 2 years ago
Well. They sound alike but why do people need to make such a big deal about it? Both artists are great and did a really good job on these songs. Do you all honestly want to lose one of these songs? Don't you rather appreciate how good both sounds? Well I do.
mzholleewood 2 years ago 45
@mzholleewood I know right!!! like this world is so full of corrupted mean stupid ppls always judging!! GOSH
paLeevang 1 year ago
@mzholleewood i agree
rickyluna55 1 year ago
both are good songs
WesDavisJr 2 years ago 5
Well. Kelly made it great with that song, that's all it matters. I prefer Kelly's version =D
Ngelcanfly 2 years ago 3
It's not their faults the same guy wrote both songs and used the same back beat and Kelly apoligized and didn't even want to put this on her soundtrack cuz its similar so it's not Kelly's fault
Boprey148 2 years ago 6
They sound alike but are very different in their own unique way!!!!! Those comment about copying each other. Just stop!!!! :'[
BellaCullen2123 2 years ago 7
Woahhh`
JENNIFERYANGG 2 years ago
me gustan las 2 rolas originales, i no mpiezen qon q una le copioa a la otra xq nada q ver, el compositor d las rolas dijo q abia echio las 2 al mismo stilo y q sta la d kelly fue grabada primero pero fue lanzada primero halo de beyonce,,,las 2 soen moei bnaz
1pako5 2 years ago
The piano in this is beautiful. I know that it is from Beyonce's song but it works out so well. They should get together and redo the song.
0n3lyf3 2 years ago 3
omg this happened with pixie lott and amy whinehouse. kelly clarkson & beyonce's backtracks for these songs are the same. duh!
scoobii124 2 years ago
funny how kelly continues on being accused of ripping off the song when beyonce has not said a word about anything. Beyonce song was written and recorded after kellys. why doesnt she explain herself?
zalvi22 2 years ago 3
LoL! Don't explain yourself til his/her slow ass.
ELiR0TFL 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
so bascially yur trying to make this seem like kelly copied off of beyonce
obsesstvbfan 2 years ago
what the fuck can't you understand?!!
LOOOK AT THE DAMN INFO BESIDES THE VIDEO!
DONT dare to debate this again unless you are sure of your knowledge!
MysteriousNight 2 years ago 8
It's funny how people do not understand what you're trying to say.
By the way I'm loving this!
Allaboutmucis 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
no offence but i think u used halo's beat and put kelly's singing into this remix to make it seem liek itz her fault. but her song beat sounds different
obsesstvbfan 2 years ago
I'm sorry, but I am offended
It said HALO REMIX,not THE ORIGINAL SONG!
:P
MysteriousNight 2 years ago
@MysteriousNight Don't be offended MysteriousNight. First ask yourself "What would Sir Mix-alot do?"
Mrgalacticone 1 year ago
the producer admitted to giving them the same beat correct me if im wrong, but i think kelly clarkson song came out about a year earlier than beyonce's halo.
MartinG210 2 years ago
lol
mileyloverfan554882 2 years ago
Can you put on a link or something please ITS REALLY GOOD
maniissuite99 2 years ago
did u notice both songs start with the word "remember"
ECHfan8 2 years ago 4
this is beautiful, the harmony is insane!!
i like it better than the original
caaiimmyy1331 2 years ago
they do sound the same so no duh this would fit
USGamerGuy 2 years ago
I love this remix it was my 31 year old dads funeral song:(
ChamberCullen93 2 years ago 9
@ChamberCullen93 Im sorry. :(
adamstartsfires 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
such bullshit, if so you really must have hated your dad
kimangh 2 years ago
you fucking asshole they didnt hate their dad it just hits their heart and makes them remember how great they were, you heartless fuck.
Raven1015 2 years ago
nice! haha
101conspiracy101 2 years ago
LOL THAT'SS GOOD!
smone09 2 years ago
I thought that too, the first time I heard it.
But they're to different singers, both of them good.
I don't know who's my favourite but both songs are great :)
SofiaListing 2 years ago 2
nice remix better than alot of em
rockingothchik 2 years ago
Yah. It's not her fault that her song sounds the same. But can't blame her song writer either...he did come up with A nice melody. Anyway this isn't the first of many songs that sound alike..nice mash up.
lkraie 2 years ago
Kelly looks REALLY pretty in the picture. (: Her eyes are amazing. A nice shade of copper-y hazel.
<3 xoxo.
IzzyL123 2 years ago
so nice remix
bestpalsess 2 years ago 4
so nice remix
bestpalsess 2 years ago
have da same counts n besides that's the same producer who worked with beyonce
brookaida 2 years ago
sounds like Kanye should run up to Kelly while she is talking and intterupt her and start to talk about this. "Sorry, Kelly, your good and all, but....HALO IS THE BEST SONG EVER!! EVER! Just saying."
dg6ty 2 years ago 2
LOL
sarifynna 2 years ago
LMFAO...that's a good one.
miaka697 2 years ago
it's the same music with different words...and the two version it's so great...the beyonce's version is important in a moment of my life...but i like the voice of kelly......
joschoon 2 years ago
y a and this isnt the first one this was done months before this dude tried
Eapapaoo69 2 years ago
Technically...Beyonce and Kelly Clarkson had the same writer...Kelly didn't "steal" Beyonce's song Halo, matter of fact, the guy who wrote it fucked up really bad and made two songs that sounded almost the same...
xxvampirexfreakxx 2 years ago 3
so they have the same beat? so that makes it the same song?
tashmdizzle 2 years ago
wow this sounds so much better but with Ft. Brian on another vid, then it would be perfect!
toontownrox50 2 years ago
kelly clarksons song beyonce stole it!
xxpurplepotpiexx 2 years ago
i like halo a LOT more..
beyonce <3
dorabool 2 years ago
If the same person wrote both songs, how would it be stealing? Just a thought.
roCKtheARTs93 2 years ago 3
Written for different labels. It's been done before (being sued for your own music I mean)
Howitzer89 2 years ago
i love them both kelly and beyonce !
IZAZY57 2 years ago
This actually way better with halo's music!
MsTomatoJuice 2 years ago
The songwriter, Ryan Tedder, wrote both of these songs. thats why they sound the same and or similar.
MarkMusical 2 years ago 3
hey this sounds really cool. u should provide a download link.
plus a lot of songs sound the same. why do people pick on these two?
BrickByBoringBrick7 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuck beyonce!!! kelly is waaaaaaaaaaaaay better!!!<333
shyghost48 2 years ago
lol get outta here
flame6753 2 years ago
lmao, there's so many annoying Beyonce fans; its hilarious. XD
shyghost48 2 years ago 2
i like it cool
fredrules321 2 years ago
<3 it!
123iluvusomuch 2 years ago
What has Glee done to us that we're all mash-up obsessed lately? I like this though
RikkuChambers 2 years ago
i love the two songs but there better when the two songs are together its great and kelly didnt steal it
MegaRochie 2 years ago
wtf except they're in different keys
rexcherry33 2 years ago
thats only cuz they have changed it in thsi remix, the real versions keys are pretty much the exact same.
xONekoBoyOx 2 years ago
LOL sounds just like the original
that's a good pic of her
OKzs 2 years ago