Added: 6 years ago
From: nivlak
Views: 395,893
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,964)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I've been watching this vid again and again sporadically over the years, I always come back to it and I always show it to people.

  • This is a very "tedious" video. =p

  • @edstone61n ???

    

  • It really says something that despite the film's shortness, it's able to carry enough emotion to give the impression of there being a really powerful story (particularly, in my opinion, one with some level of moral ambiguity in the characters) about these people that we are seeing a mere snapshot of.

  • Actually I am just a touch curious. Was the lightsaber color choice done on purpose, or selected for ascetics? red is almost always exclusively used by the Sith and Dark Jedi, where as purple was the color used by Jedi who had mastered Sith force powers and fighting techniques but managed to not fall to the dark side. That was why Sam Jackson's character was supposed to be so bad ass, and the best at lightsaber combat among the jedi.

    Makes this video a touch more epic, I think.

  • @TheResistancezero love is forbidden in the jedi order so only one other way to go for force sensitive people.....

  • Wow..can't believe that I am still watching this again after 6 years!! omg!! haha

  • @bloodykiller9898 Me too dude ^^

  • I think it'd have been cooler if his double blade came apart like Obi-Wan did to Maul in "Phantom" and not just pulled apart.

    I've had this video in my favorites for a few years, now, and frequently watch it. This is definitely one badass video.

  • @majorxtc Actually I like it like this.. every double blade made to be pulled apart gives a huge avantage in a fight

  • my favorite

    

  • Bad to the BONE!

  • You guys still have the best lightsaber duel anywhere on the net that I've seen. And apparently, everyone else agrees with me!

    First time I saw this, I cried a but at the end. A fallen general, unable to make it back to his family. Really causes some emotions to flare up. Good work. Hopefully, we'll be seeing more of you guys in the near future.

  • What lightsaber combat form do you think each fighter is closer to using

  • @mauricio231 red saber seems like a mix of form 2 and 4. purple... no idea

  • Wow! Really cool choreography!

  • I agree with others that this is the best saber duel on the 'net. Top notch, considering your resources. Hopefully we haven't seen the last of you guys.

  • this is still my favorite saber fight on youtube you guys are awesome.

  • A++++

    a light saber would not sick up in the ground like that. But it looks cool!!

  • Absolutely still the best fan made lightsaber dual. Watching these guys move versus other videos you can the fluidity and smoothness of the coreography. Other videos have soem decent duels, but the techniques are sloppy and slow, especially when compared with this one.

  • Comment removed

  • Despite the low quality.......I'm very impressive. I'm saying that as an individual in the film industry. The only thing I didn't, or more-so, thought could of been better was the voice-over for the narration. Didn't buy the emotion quite well. Excellent backdrop. The set-up with the MA style with the civil war letter(possibly the most famous war-time letter in existence) was very original and really set the mood and grabbed my attention. Certainly had an emotional stirring in me.

  • @JXZjeremy hilarious typo there.... "i'm very impressive"

  • @Lostprophetzzz Hmmm-no, I think he meant to say that...

  • Just awesome... after all this time, still THE BEST

  • It's crazy how some low budget fan made lightsaber duels are better than the multimillion dollar versions.

  • the best one EVER!

  • I must've seen thousands of lightsaber duals and this by far the best on youtube in my book... I hope someone is showing george lucas this because this is what a fight in the movie needs to look like.

  • this would be even more epic with a two steps from hell music piece ;o

  • so...fucking...epic!

  • I freakin love this video. It was so well done. So glad I found it again.

  • Amazing. You did a wonderful job with this short film here and should be very proud.

  • Very touching dramatic theme with the Civil War backdrop. Excellent lightsaber choreography - bravo! For real Force Healing click my channel.

  • You would think that after 6 years someone would make a half decent lightsaber fight that holds a candle to this.

  • Just rated number 2 lightsabre fight in scfi, in the Top 10 scifi list on blip tv...

  • @Spinobreaker what was #1?

  • @Astrolia1 - #2 look for spinobreaker on blip tv, i havn't aired the sabers episode yet

  • without any back story you guys assume a lot. Id like to hear their explanation for the color choices and reasons for the fight. for all we know he could have caught the other with his woman. LOL.:P

  • My favorite Star Wars FanFilm

  • This is a work of art. Destroy the Star Wars universe they will. Perfect choice of music. I think Darth Maul just took a shit in his pants.

  • Manys years on its still coooooooool!!!!!!!

  • I actually joined the sith 4 three reasons, 1-O.J.Simpson is on the dark side 2-they have cookies 3-Better health benifits

  • Great music from black hawk down, great last speech from the civil war, great martial arts like bruce lee, and lite sabers, WHAT MORE CAN I ASK 4

  • This is definitely the number one Jedi fight on YouTube, but one question...Why does the Jedi have a Red lightsaber while the Sith has a double bladed Purple? Dude, everyone knows only Samuel L. Jackson can handle a purple blade. lol, Awesome video though

  • Comment removed

  • @AGooeyCookie Sith have only used the red lightsaber so he is a Sith.

  • @AGooeyCookie

    the color of the lightsaber has nothing to do with the side you choose to be on. The color is a preference choice just like picking out a color for your sports car.

  • @hijinxDD Not true, the Red Crystals, used in building Sith Lightsabers only respond to hatred and evil, along with other traits of the sith. The jedi would never use these crystals when making their lightsabers. I do realize now however, the person with the red saber is a sith, this is just an alternative video where it is showing that Sith are people with lives and families too. However in most cases that isnt true.

  • @AGooeyCookie

    Jedi Adi Gallia wielded a red colored lightsaber

  • Comment removed

  • @hijinxDD Not in the Movies or Comics, so...what? her lightsaber was Blue. "While the Jedi used natural crystals, the Sith often used red-hued synthetic crystals." This is why the Sith have red lightsabers, the Jedi must meditate on their crystals for days or weeks at a time before they are able to be put into a lightsaber, The sith however create their crystals and they have a red hue.

  • Comment removed

  • @hijinxDD Also I would like to say one more thing to prove you wrong lol. The four main colors had purpose in the Jedi order. Blue was that of a Jedi Gaurdian: Someone who uses their physical powers with the force and lightsaber like Obi-Wan Kenobi or Anakin Skywalker. Green is that of a Jedi Consular: Someone who uses the mind powers and control with the force to destroy the sith with Wisdom like Qui-gon Jinn or Master Yoda. Yellow is that of a Jedi Sentinel: Someone who was balanced in...

  • @AGooeyCookie And what about Mace Windu's purple lightsaber? What type of Jedi does that make Mace in terms of Jedi status?

  • @Davis385 Mace Windu, Being the Master of the Jedi Council until after the Battle of Geonosis, after which he gave control to Master Yoda, Did no have a "rank" in the council. He was not a sentinel, guardian, or consular. Therefore, like most Jedi Not on the council. He found his own crystals, Violet obviously, and Meditated using the force on them for days. He is the most powerful Jedi with a lightsaber, being only bested in a sparring match by Yoda and Dooku, A jedi at the time...

  • @Davis385 ...those "rankings" I gave were for the Jedi that train in the Temple, such as, the Younglings, Padawans, Apprentices, and Jedi Knights. Jedi Masters/Master Jedi, whichever you prefer, have the choice to build there own lightsaber. However, Red is not a color chosen by Jedi as it must be meditated on using thoughts of Anger, Hatred, and Evil. Traits not commonly felt by Jedi.

  • @AGooeyCookie Thanks. That explains a lot. 

  • @AGooeyCookie actually the colour of the blade is dependant on the colour of the primary focusing crystal and nothing at all to do with the meditation process. the coour of the crystal is chosen and doesnt change throughout the meditation any colour can be meditated upon using any emotional traits whatsoever and these emotions enhance the crystals and the blades properties. the colour in itself is symbolic only and for practical use irrelevant.

  • @brojajacra Lol, I remember having that argument a few years ago.

  • @brojajacra lol,, no offense man but you know waay to much about light sabers bro. lol

  • @c4nucksens8tion Lol none taken but I have been a SW fan for 34 years and I probably know way too much about most things Star Wars LOL

  • @hijinxDD ...both Wisdom and skill with a lightsaber like Jedi Master Plo Koon on the Council. and Red of the Sith Lord: Someone who is versed in the Dark Side of the force and uses fear, anger, and hatred to power themselves and to rid the world of the weak Jedi order like Darth Maul, Darth Vader, and Darth Sidious. Dont argue Star Wars with me.

  • @AGooeyCookie

    Ok I concede defeat. Just always thought the color the wielder chose was a preference. Also, don't get cocky by saying shit like "don't argue star wars with me," sure you may know more than I do but if it is about other things I will own your ass.

  • @hijinxDD I didnt mean to sound cocky haha, I just love Star Wars :P My favorite movies and im not even close to a nerd haha. Its kind of my hidden passion lol

  • @AGooeyCookie According to the The Old Republic from George Lucsa's point of view and Bioware. No. Viridian and Odagon crystal were usually mined on Dantooine the head quarters of the Jedi. According to what I heard they were also mined on planet Korriban during the Jedi civil war which was waged 5,000 years before Luke Skywalker's birth.

  • Poor Sarah

  • @tkotomy Yeah her Sith boyfriend is dead, blame the Jedi for that.

  • I first saw this years ago, and remember being in tears, like right now. I still love it, and it is still the best lightsaber fight on YouTube. The music choices are perfect, and the monologue does a lot to enhance the emotion of the film. First rate all the way.

  • man you guys out do hollywood.

    hands down the best saber fight i've seen

  • @haddukken Clearly you havent seen the fight between Obi-Wan and Anakin in The Revenge of the Sith. That is the best lightsaber fight ever. Id say this is the best fan made fight, but the fights in the movies definitly top this haha. Im just joking around though, this is a really good video.

  • how hard would it be not to corpse this....

  • Amazing coreography. Up top!

  • I like how the Jedi was hunting down the Sith, yet the storyline made it feel as if it was still a loss like in the movies.

  • @MRspamalot1 Makes you wonder who the real bad guys are doesn't it? BTW Sith always use RED light sabers, I bet he rebelled against the BS "celebracy" rule for all Jedis, hence the revolution. The sith fought well but not good enough, still best saber duel on youtube!!

  • best duel ever. even better than in the movies

  • @joeshow97 Damn right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • The best of the best. Great story line, great action. Love the music too.

  • a pity its only 240p

  • @musicman53100 its been 6 years almost

  • Depending on how you feel, you can almost feel sorry for the Sith. Though watching him fight you see a greater aggression in his style when compared with the Jedi.

  • @darkyoda What are you talking about lol

  • Comment removed

  • A year & 1/2 later and it's still the greatest Lightsaber Duel on the net ever!

  • Stunning work, very evocative and engaging!

  • Great video! Good mix of fencing and martial arts. Great work.

  • This deserves a digital remastering ;)

  • After 5+ years, STILL the best dramatic lightsaber duel on youtube

  • @SavageInsight anytime i think of lightsabers, next to star wars, i think of this video. such an amazing story, choreographing, and cgi

  • @SavageInsight and i still remember the first time i saw it in 05... i defficated myself.

  • @SavageInsight heck id say even in the starwars trilogy, but that would be going pretty far ya know? but heck its right up there, there was so much heart and back story in this short video with some of the best music to go with it

  • @SavageInsight way better than anything thats ever come out of lucasarts.......

  • These guys vs Ryan,Brandon, and Dorkman!

  • 3:59 coolest move of the whole fight

  • The best saber battle, hands down, in anything ever. These guys would have kicked Luke and Vader's ass in saber combat..

  • Ah, this is such a beautiful piece.

    Kick-ass fighting!

    A beautiful setup with the opening monologue...

    And the way it ended.

    Just beautiful!

  • Thumbs up if you have watched this many times!!

  • I have indeed watched this Star Wars fan film many times. This is a true example of talent and skill. Hopefully the Ho brothers make something else. Hollywood needs to pay attention. George Lucas take some notes. Music compliments the fighting very much. Excellent choice.

  • Woah! THe best saber battles ever. Starwars should have had these two help with the fights

  • just the best fan movie ever period

  • I actually like the music here. Conveys a lot of emotion. Epic battle music was cool in the phantom menace, but I think it actually got "done to death" by the prequels (and other movies of the last ten years). My favorite lightsaber duel ever is the one in empire strikes back, which is done with almost ZERO music.

    This video is by far my favorite fan-made lightsaber/star wars movie.

  • Absolutely wonderful.. The Ho Brothers deserve all kind of praises!! Everything in this movie is right: from the song selection to the skill of both actors.. Just beautiful from start to finish.

  • pure talent and flavor without all the fancy special effects and editing, beautiful...

  • cooooooooooooool.........

  • would have been #1 with Epiic battle music

  • please buy an hd camera your film deserves it.

  • Tears And more tears

    

  • How has this not reached 1 million views yet!? its 2011 FFS!!!

  • this has got to be the first star wars vid i've seen where the antagonist wins

  • this brought tears to my eyes, so much emotion even though they are straight faced the whole time

  • truly art

  • An epic duel and a wonderful video, well done !

  • holy crap had this big realization i thought that you never see a good guy with a red lightsaber other than in this video. then it hit me what if the guy writing the letter is the bad guy like hes a SITH!! think about it the sith have passion and love but commonly misplace it (not this guy i guess) and the jedi are often emotionaly removed like they could show the video from a different point of veiw with the other guy as the good guy

  • He'll never return to Sarah :(

  • Speaking of! Why were there no Asians in Star Wars?? See how kick ass it would have been if there were? Great vid guys! :D

  • @MDJianoran there were a handfull of asian jedi. some of them were shown repetedly through episodes 1,2, and 3 but nobody there bothered to give them names. and in the comics madame wu was supposed to be asian but instead they cast the lady who played aunt may from spiderman

  • @iamproffitt i dont think that was her i see the resemblence but its not her

  • @Darthsantana eh. well they look alike

  • @MDJianoran as the video cleary shows, if there were asian jedi, they would pwn too hard for hollywood

  • Bultar Swan was...Asian...esque.

    There is no Asia in SW, but it's what you're looking for heheh.

  • I wish that the Brothers Ho would released a high def version

  • @Keihryon The brothers Ho should just make an entire movie!

  • the great music and artistiful moves make me wanna cry

  • if you listen close you can hear the laser doors opening and closing as well

  • YES THE AUDIO IS WORKING 

  • This is fucking incredible.

  • never has having an epileptic fit been so fun!

  • star wars version of the matrix!

  • Did you use Lsmaker this?

  • now see, these are the type of people that should be doing the jedi fight sceans. real righting, les computer action

  • you didnt really kill him right

  • Are those uillean pipes in the music?

  • asians can fight beter than others races and worck cpus beter dam and its suposta b lucky to b white?

    also dranage pipes beat toy

  • asians can fight beter than others races and worck cpus beter dam and its suposta b lucky to b white?

  • that's what light saber fightin' is about..the one with the dual saber looked serious.like someone took his lunch money and is out for revenge.

  • 3:52 purple windmill of death.

  • George Lucas please take notes. If they made lets say an old republic trilogy then they need to hire people like this.

    

  • Simply outstanding. The music selections added depth, the locale added grandeur, and the choreography was incredible. The camera angles were brilliant as well. This video really enables the suspension of disbelief, which is a major accomplishment when dealing with a sci-fi storyline.  I just wish the prequels had as much heart poured into them as this video obviously did.

  • 3:26 John Woo would've been Proud!! simply incredible...

  • @byte19 AM AGREED

  • @byte19

    F*** John Woo, Corey Yeun would have been proud!

  • @phuturephunk01 ooh... in that case... F*** Corey Yuen, YUEN WO PING would be proud!!!!

  • This never gets old.......

    

  • how does this only ONLY have 370k views....this is the best one out of them ALL

  • @TorqMeSilly About  200 of these views are from me.

  • hot damn, that was fast. my eyes couldnt keep up with them.

  • What's the name of the music at the ending credits?

  • @TheScumper it is on the gladiator sound track

  • It would be interesting to see a lightsaber duel or batle done in the style of Japanese samurai movies. Samurai fights are often quicker (and in some cases more realistic) than Chinese-style wu shu fight scenes. The original Star Wars lightsaber battles were more like samurai fights than wu shu fights.

  • This is the greatest fan lightsaber video that I had ever seen. Magnificent. I just wished that the force user who wielded a red lightsaber won the battle.

  • the best thing about this video is how uncomplicated, but perfectly executed it is. it was well-practiced but still fluid; the love letter COULD have been hammy, but you totally avoided that; and then the sound/visual effects, setting, and camera angles were all perfect.

    to summarize:

    bra-vo, ho bros.

  • 122 people must be blind...

    Or they don't like a good story. This video is excellent.

  • @ShadowkillerWM everyone has a right to their own opinion if they don't like this it's their loss. Don't fret over it.

  • very nice ha that fight scene was very entertaining and full of skill.....if you have time check out my movie....search "my latest and greatest jdm story"

  • i would just like to say that i love this thing you guys put together

    i watched this video with 25 people and not one said a bad thing about it well done

    my friends i still watch it to this day it is that best thing i have seen since the STAR WARS films and i tip my glass to you all at HO brothers it is truly a master piece

  • ..........deep bro......real deep.......

  • what language is the song in ?

    does anyone know ?

  • @Addinkuu breton

  • wow very nice

  • 122 people have no taste

  • nice job on the vid...if you get some time check some of my stuff out =] special effects and tuts

  • Very cool i made one too for all star wars fans it is in my profile and i posted to the response videos too :D

  • starwas eloaded and neo always wins

  • neo vs othe chinese dude matresxx starwas combo

  • at 2:08 you can hear the laser wall sounds from Phantom Menace in the background :D

  • One of the best pieces of starwars fan art / movies I've ever seen. Would have loved to seen this re-produced with modern high def cameras.

  • im rootin 4 the guy wit the sunglasses

  • Great Great fight... opening seqeunce a bit long though and most audiences get bored... a 6 min video requires 6 min of footage =D GREAT COREOGRAPHY!

  • @SethMilner A bit long? It's perfect as is. If an audience member gets bored, then let them go to their low-quality films.

  • the purple lightsaber guy looks like an asian matrix agent..... FROM OUTER SPACE

  • You guys should be costume. this is pretty good.

  • The opening music is beautiful 

  • Uhhh at 3:54 im pretty sure the dude with the purple saber's hits the other guy....or well it looks like he just stopped swinging at that moment...still really freakin awesome though!

  • Dude pulled a Voldo from Soul Calibur to finish him off.

  • where's the HD version? I swear there's a better version of this that I've seen. 240p doesn't do it justice.

  • Waitwait waaaitt..Their surname is "Ho" ?!

  • Who would dislike this?!

  • Wow, you guys actually look like you're trying to kill each other. Better than the more well known RvD and Concrete Hustle vids. The HK cinema flavour works really well, too. Bravo.