Added: 5 years ago
From: rickgiron
Views: 107,687
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (579)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She's pretty good xD Why's everyone she sucked lol

  • ..Regina George is that you?!

  • u seam like a stuck up rich kid not to sound mean it just comes across that way

  • she does look like the mean girl at school

  • hey i wore a dress like that!! in hairspray...

  • haters gonna hate, don't let them put you down :)

  • Hi, i'm a singer and it wasn't terrible for a solo at 13. But, i do agree slightly with some of the comments, more relaxed would help to create a better scene. And it may of helped just to have ur Elphie friend stand there watching as if your actually talking to her in the scene because the audience never reacted and if u search this on here you will see all the Glindas have the audience totally peeing themselves so work on your vocal strength and performance, but final note, you were great!

  • sucked... notice how the audience is silent...

  • @baybeeboo2919 i agree big time

  • too choreographed...needs a bit of work, feel more natural when you act; just relax and let it flow...but on a pluss note you did a fab job :)

  • And the last note sounded off. Sorry im not trying to be mean, im just very critical. Dont worry im that way to myself too when i sing. Especially when im practicing this song lol

  • You went a little flat in some parts...am i the only one who noticed?

  • wow........ u kinda look older than 13.... u are awesome singer!!! Did u get like private singing lessons strait from Megan Hilty !?!?!?!?

  • u may be a singer. ur not an actress.

  • I think this is great for your age :-)

    xx

  • You did a good job, but u should have done the last part in ur head voice :) constructive criticism i did this song 4 a performance 2 check mine out if u want

  • You did a good job, but u should have done the last part in ur head voice :) constructive criticism

  • Good sining but the acting maybe it's the problem, but she's good! :D I don't think that  just a soprano can sing this but she need more high tones for this song.

  • my friend performed this at the talent show....last yr it was so amazing....but whitney should try singing something else though

  • @WickedTheatreFreak She may not be an alto...i have a deeper voice and im soprano...she may be able to be an alto AND a soprano

  • ur supposed to be a soprano for this song. TERRIBLE STAGE PRESENCE

  • great voice, HORRIBLE stage presence

  • she's amazing!

  • Good voice but dramatic much!

  • I'm nearly 16 and i think i lok younger than her O.O are you sure she's 13?

  • She might have a good voice but her staging and acting are horrible

  • Ummmm shes 13??? Shes looks like shes like 20!!!

  • she looks like rachel mcadams :)

  • @ebzrules00 I know right? That's what I was thinking!

  • ok this is creepy im 13 and i have to sing this song for my exams (but im probs nt as gd as her) xx

  • That was a good performance. You can kinda tell she was becoming exhausted towards the end. The last note seemed a little off to me. An amazing performance nonetheless.

  • She's not Kristen Chenoweth, thats for sure :P

  • holy crap she's 13???? way more developed than me!

  • um shes not as good as some other ive seen but o well shes pretty good, but i agree with irinarox's coment

  • hot as a mofo, awesome voice and knows how to move on the stage, no doubt why she won.

  • love her dress!

  • Not bad...but the "la las" were a little shaky. The spinning was a little wierd.... and when she spun, you couldn't hear her when she faced the back. But good job, and good luck in the future!

  • Not really good! :( I've seen better. She isn't made for Broadway! NOT AT ALL! FIRST place! YEAH RIGHT!!!!!

  • Great performance! :) (and cute dress.)

  • not bad but i could do alot better!!!!!

  • u were dancing :) not bad.. but u werent very good at acting. like i sed, u were dancing but not really acting it :/ the dance moves didnt seem to fit the lyrics..

  • good singing but her facial expressions need to be bigger for stage, she'd be great on screen but everything needs to be bigger than this for stage! keep working hard!

  • Considering her age, that's quite impressive. It's a tough song, and she manages to inject just enough personality into it to make it cute. Lovely.

  • shes good, but she would have better dance moves if she didnt wear high heels but even so luv this song :) and nice performance

  • Comment removed

  • this is good and all but she's singing, acting and dressing way too old for 13. Really, i think somebody needs to remind her thats she's a thirteen year old girl not a 30 year old broadway star as of yet.

  • amazing..

  • she is really good but she looks like bulimic... cuz she looks way to skinny for her height i guess like her legs and stuff make her look sick i guess

  • i love her dress

  • flat lar lars

  • flat lar lar

  • Dumb

  • she is 13 she looks 20

  • Well, i thought she was brilliant.

  • u look like the mean girl at school!!!

  • @dancergirl3ful I think that's the role she was supposed to be playing.....

    lol

  • @dancergirl3ful why do you think she's singing "Popular"

  • I think that she's a good singer, I just wished she wasn't trying to sing it like Kristin Chenowith, one of the first rules of the stage: Create you own performance and don't try to copy the style from someone else. The choereograhphy is also very cute but it's to noticeable that it's choreography. She needs to not only sing and dance, she needs to emulate Glinda's character.

  • @mitsuchan325

    she wasnt trying to sing like Kristin, thts how Glindas character is. She was acting like Kristin she was acting like the character, which is wat she supposed to do :)

  • how could she win first place? i like the girls who danced to loathing!

  • wayWAYYYYY to coreographed

  • @bilykopeki123 AMEN!

  • Ok, first of all, I THOUGHT SHE WAS GOOD! And shes probably better then half the people who said she was bad! I completely agree with randomchic74!

  • sorry, but I think she tried way too hard. tone down the dancing a little and maybe the acting. She's into it, but maybe a little too into it. Trust me! I sang this same song for broadway night at my school!!

  • ok well maybe the performance she shouldve had somebody up there and change them and stuff

  • she looks older than 13 there

  • she is not 13, more like 18.

  • i like the dres........

  • Thumbs down me all you want for this but I tink she was trying waaaaay too hard, she was too quiet, and the hand movements were terribe.

    Half the time she looked like she was doing "Thriller">

    The other half she was off tune.

    I also think she was faking the voice shaking thing in one spot.

    I could probably do better and I'm 12.

  • FYI, It's not a liturgical dance. Hahhaa.

  • @PepperAnnBootsey she only 13....... how would you have felt if someone watched this video of YOU singing at 13 years old to this song and started dissing you then saying no offence. huh? well guess what? SHE IS PROB OFFENDED!! she was really good!

  • shes not always on tune because she 13! but you didnt a very good job hunny!! keep singing girlie!

  • okay seriously you guys shes 13! i dont think shes worring about if shes intune or if it sounds like a perfect broadway voice and she didnt stay in one place the whole time she moved around a lot at least she had the guts to go up and sing!

  • your okkk???

  • Move around a little, lady! You're a good singer but...get off the stage, you belong somewhere else. You're good but not the right voice for the song...but u got all the notes which isn't easy in this song.

  • Good Job Just not a voice for Broadway soz.but great job

  • she off tone.

  • laaas out of tune !!

  • By all means, you shouldn't just stand in one spot for the whole performance, but her excessive dancing caused her voice to distort occasionally. Other than that, she's a great singer, very pretty for 13, too!

  • really nice performance I think =) cute!

  • A bit scrachty, and alright like she can sing but not low or high just normal and she is DEFO NOT 13

  • uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuhhhhhhhhhh shes alright

  • She's cute =)

  • she's very good. although she moves a lot.

  • um...she's OK.

  • is she primarily a dancer because she just doesnt stand still! sometimes less is more in musical theatre

  • Great performance. I am 12 do you think this is a good song for musical theatre competiton or can you suggest something else.

  • it all really depends on ur voice range r u an alto? surprano? base?

  • She sang - loathing too, with somebody. Im looking for it but can't find it. Do you know what it's called?

  • its called What is this feeling

  • @BabyxBellax3

    It is called What Is This Feeling?

    Your welcome. LOFCforevaxoxo

  • Atleast the dress is cute

  • i think she's great for being 13. and i love her dress too. this girl is going places :)

  • its a cute dress.

  • annoying...

  • she is really good for 13. just needs to go other places on the stage

  • amazing for 13

  • i agree

  • she dances werid~~~

  • are u kidding me her dress is so long but it would of been better if it was pink cuz its like that.

  • @Faraday713 it's not short...she just has long legs :D

  • I agree with the broadway thing, she has a poppy voice, but she still sounded pretty awesome. How many 13 year olds do you know who'll get up in front of a bunch of people and do a performance like that? Not many, and the choreography was pretty good for a 13 year old. Awesome job!

  • ... ur not SUPPOSED to stand in the same position the whole time.

  • @IrinaRox She definitely didnt stay in the same spot she did a lot of the same things but she surely didnt stand in the same spot lol it actually annoyed me at how much she moved but I love her voice but yea it isnt for broadway

  • @IrinaRox good point :) i had 2 do this song , i didn;t stand still in a position :) have a look if u want ... its on utube

  • Come on people, honestly, would you rather have someone just standing there on stage in the same place the whole time or someone who keeps your attention but at least working to add something extra?

    She did pretty well for 13. *thumbs up*

  • Stop saying she moves alot shes singing and dancing god! shes really god who ever says mean things are just jelouas!!! but your really good i loved it :)

  • she moved around way too much, if she wants the audience to focus on her voice, then do less hand movements and running around the stage. unless she wants the audience focusing on her dancing.

  • really good!

  • her voice isn't for broadway. i mean, yeah she's a good singer. but she's not meant for broadway. good performance though (:

  • @jelikuhh i disagree. with some training she could be broadway-bound. i think she has potential. and to be on broadway you don't have to have any specific sounding voice....it depends on the character you play. :)

  • @jelikuhh I agree I have a friend just like that

  • @jelikuhh shes 13 give her a fucking break

  • if you so purfect why don't you git a life bich

  • little sharp and too many hand actions.. sorry but its true... and stop moving

  • realy great!

  • Theres something off about it. Shes doing the actions and singing well. But theres no connection between the too, it seems quite fake and put on instead of truly acted. I dislike it. She has a nice voice though.

  • Ahh....Soooo many things I want to say...but I won't for her sanity.

  • the last note was SHARP! very good for 13 tho!

  • good singer but she comes across as someone who doesn't care and always thinks about herself

  • great movements... i do think to improve though u might want to add a little more emotion and stuff to your voice. over all great performance though!

  • the last note was too sharp

  • agreed

  • tooooo choreographed. i agree.

  • Your reeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaallllllllllll­lllllyyyyyyyyy GOOD

  • great your really good!

  • she looks totally like rachel mcadams

  • too choreographed

  • it looks a bit choreographed and the thing that makes it funny in the show is that its so random and looks like she's making it up on the spot but u have a nice voice

    x

  • amazing! nice singing! thumbs up!

  • Gee, she's full of potential! Keep goin' Whitney!

  • I think she is really amazing!!

  • I think she's really good, but she ran out of breath quickly...

  • she needs to work on her singing more. she has potential, but she isnt putting as much emotion in it as she can and should be. she also cracked a bit. but good for a 13 year old!

  • i completely agree!!!!!!!1 x

  • The movements are SUPPOSED to be over the top. it's how the character is. I think that this girl did perfect. there's nothing wrong in the slightest way.

  • shes only 13????!!!!!! reele good!!!! xxx

  • Its pretty good but at 1:08 she looks like she's doing that teapot dance.. and maybe less moving about , it makes me feel seasick. Aside from that she's good for a 13 year old.

  • pmsl

  • too much movement to me, and the voice is kinda deep for the song

  • i have tht same exact drees 4 my old bratz doll!

  • not bad but ur voice is 2 deep 4 that song

  • just a bit dramatic.. haha...

    but good

  • if u stop with all of that movement :L

    and the dramatic skills then wud be mint :P x

    but good voice

  • i agree 100%

    she goin over the top with movement and acting (or what she thinks actiing is :L)

    but she is aa good singer.

  • LUVIN IT! well done! <3

  • Nice, but the last note wasnt good! Sounded weird to me! But doing this when being 13 is very brave!^^

  • Dramatic, a bit.

    But i liked it.

    :)

    Work on the right notes, you sang wrong notes on some words.

  • i sing this for all my auditions

    she dropped alot of notes

    and cracked

    but she did alright :)

  • OMG you did an amazing job! you have inspired me 2 do this next year for my 8th grade talent show! But i dont think im as popular as you, lol!

  • thht waz good did ur school do tht for a play?

  • not bad:)

  • that's really good!!

  • Fantastic!!!! Beautiful voice and great performance!

  • hey great job but cut back on some of the moves a bit over done but otherwise awesome job keep it up

  • obviously people dont realize this song is from a Broadway Musical.

    I love how she included so basic choreography and how she emphasized the right words with her movements.

    Great performance.

  • This is so good!

    The la la las were a little dramatic though.

    Overall, it was really truly amazing!

    I would vote for you, I think.

    ~Kate

    P.S. It is 2009 now so is Whitney 16 now?

  • great, great, GREAT!

  • that was really good, but ya the lala's were a little over done, but Amazing job!!

  • Very very very good. I lovee it she wasnt 13 come on and if she was she's gorguess i mean like seriously you go girl

  • I agree, she's doing really well for a kid whose barely a teen. :D

  • pretty good, but i feel like shes just trying too hard

  • shes good but likle nt really glinda x

  • So great i sure cant get up on stage and do that she must have practice alot!!! =D

  • ...i don't like it

  • she sings really good but its just not the musical version

  • ur pretty but u really cant act.

  • well dun!!! xx

  • 3:15 and on, i thought she was going to blow me away, a little louder, and longer, but it was good :)

  • ur thirteen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • That is awsome! Exept, you don't look in Pink. Not to be Glinda!

  • Thats very very good! A little less twirling tho! But exellent!

  • Good!

  • definitely amazing for a 13 year old!

  • OMG we have the same name as me!!!

    and the same age and an amazing singer i sing but not half as good as you!!!!

  • That's very good. You'll be amazing when you grow up :-)