oh the jealousy of the talentless people who have nothing better to do than spend their lives on youtube, critisising other people to make themselves feel better about their own lack of talent.
this girl is amazing at singing, i know this is opinion, but if you disagree then do us all a favour and leave the girl alone.
Do you see her arguing with you or defending herself, no because she doesnt care. So before you write your next oh so witty reply and waste more time, try doing something more worthwhile with your life maybe then you wont be so bitter about people who have genuine talent.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I think she kicks Elkie's voice to the curb!!! I'm a pro vocalist- I have been On -Broadway and was a winner on Star Search...Elkie in my opinion is a one trick husky voiced pony...this young girl can sing rings around Elkie...who cares if Elkie is famous?! Everybody that beacame famous at one point wsn't (lol)! :D
I think what you are forgetting is that this is a 15 year old singing a song she loves and that your arrogant comments however intelligent you think they are, dont mean anything to her.
the fact is that she has a wicked voice. Do you see her arguing with you or defending herself, no because she doesnt care. So before you write your next oh so witty reply and waste more time, try doing something more worthwhile with your life maybe then you wont be so bitter about people who have genuine talent.
I know I wrote I wouldn't reply again, but this deserves some kind of reply..lol
I am American, however, I did pay attention in English and Grammar class. I am older than you, older enough to laugh at what you call "the English language". I am a nerd, but a nerd with a girlfriend, my own car, a job, a college degree, and etc..
You called this version "OK" earlier, now you call it horrible, because of what? My rebuffing of your statements. Please, go get a life.
Some people cannot accept comment's if they do not agree with theirs. This is an O.K. version. Should not be compared with the version by Elkie Brooks. This song was given to Elkie by the legendary team , Lieber & Stoller(check them out on Wikipedia)they also produced it. THEY seen Brook's vocal talent.Enough said.
Might I suggest more grammar and composition classes for you, because your comments borderline on impossible to read. Hundreds of songwriters and producers created/create songs for Britteny Spears, and Spears is a largely untalented person. Whom something is made for doesn't matter, only who does it better matters. You think Elkie does better, I think she doesn't. That simple, you won't change my mind, I won't change your mind.
Interesting. I stated my opinion as my own, but was replied to in a manner that implied there was something wrong with me for not liking EB's version. This is absurd..IMO of course.
I actually am a musician. (now you say, but your not famous to me) and I say (I know a lot of non-famous good talent) then you say (only the best make money) and I say to each their own. Seriously. I was paying Georgia Oldman a compliment. Just because I do no particularly care for your precious little Elkie's over-raspy melancholy voice doesn't mean I have bad taste, it means I just cannot stand her voice. Georgia's voice to me is superior, but like I said, to each their own. Lay off folks.
As a musician I find this version at best to be O.K. Why people like her take on songs that are bigger the the can cope with is beyond. Cannot compare to the original by Elkie Brooks. Only friends of this singer would disagree.
Nope, not a friend or even an acquaintance of this woman.
Maybe you need to troll somewhere else. Honestly. You're only 17yo, so you need time before your ears are fully developed enough to judge the nuances of voices. IF that isn't the case, then I maintain; to each their own. Funny thing is, I am a Diana Krall fan; similar voice to Elkie's, but there is just something about Elkie's that doesn't sound good to me.
I won't reply again about this, as it is a royal-waste-o-time in my mind.
Georgia Oldman , you have a really really sweet voice and you have given a stunning performance. Looking at your performance there is no doubt that you are fantastic and will definitely win any competion.MAy God bless you and give you lots of success in the near future.
OMG that was .. BRILLIANT i have never heard any one sing like that! Mum told me i should watch it and finally i got the time and im glad i did. xxx HOPE TO SEE U IN AUSSIE SOME TIME TO !!
OMG that was .. BRILLIANT i have never heard any one sing like that! Mum told me i should watch it and finally i got the time and im glad i did. xxx HOPE TO SEE U IN AUSSIE SOME TIME TO !!
oh the jealousy of the talentless people who have nothing better to do than spend their lives on youtube, critisising other people to make themselves feel better about their own lack of talent.
this girl is amazing at singing, i know this is opinion, but if you disagree then do us all a favour and leave the girl alone.
xRaaarx 2 years ago
Do you see her arguing with you or defending herself, no because she doesnt care. So before you write your next oh so witty reply and waste more time, try doing something more worthwhile with your life maybe then you wont be so bitter about people who have genuine talent.
You Have Obviously Never Met This Girl in Person.
Bluetit you could be my soul mate :P
awsomeperson124 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think she kicks Elkie's voice to the curb!!! I'm a pro vocalist- I have been On -Broadway and was a winner on Star Search...Elkie in my opinion is a one trick husky voiced pony...this young girl can sing rings around Elkie...who cares if Elkie is famous?! Everybody that beacame famous at one point wsn't (lol)! :D
michelletuthill 2 years ago
I think what you are forgetting is that this is a 15 year old singing a song she loves and that your arrogant comments however intelligent you think they are, dont mean anything to her.
the fact is that she has a wicked voice. Do you see her arguing with you or defending herself, no because she doesnt care. So before you write your next oh so witty reply and waste more time, try doing something more worthwhile with your life maybe then you wont be so bitter about people who have genuine talent.
alycyarose 2 years ago
I know I wrote I wouldn't reply again, but this deserves some kind of reply..lol
I am American, however, I did pay attention in English and Grammar class. I am older than you, older enough to laugh at what you call "the English language". I am a nerd, but a nerd with a girlfriend, my own car, a job, a college degree, and etc..
You called this version "OK" earlier, now you call it horrible, because of what? My rebuffing of your statements. Please, go get a life.
alexkerhead 3 years ago
Who is("this is"...wtf?)? Me? I never would consider myself insipid, but I would consider myself opinionated.
In my opinion, a user with the name "farttart" has no taste to start with. So, I won't even bother rebuffing your opinions.
alexkerhead 3 years ago
ROFLMFAO!
alexkerhead 3 years ago
Some people cannot accept comment's if they do not agree with theirs. This is an O.K. version. Should not be compared with the version by Elkie Brooks. This song was given to Elkie by the legendary team , Lieber & Stoller(check them out on Wikipedia)they also produced it. THEY seen Brook's vocal talent.Enough said.
bluetit1991 3 years ago
Might I suggest more grammar and composition classes for you, because your comments borderline on impossible to read. Hundreds of songwriters and producers created/create songs for Britteny Spears, and Spears is a largely untalented person. Whom something is made for doesn't matter, only who does it better matters. You think Elkie does better, I think she doesn't. That simple, you won't change my mind, I won't change your mind.
Bye Bye
--Keep up the good work oldmanfamily!
alexkerhead 3 years ago
Comment removed
bluetit1991 3 years ago
Thankyou so much for all your amazing comments :)
oldmanfamily 3 years ago 3
Sorry for the arguing brought on by my comment. I still maintain your version is better!
alexkerhead 3 years ago
This is phenomenal! I never liked Elkie's version(or Elkie's singing for that matter). When I hear this version, I really like that song now.
alexkerhead 3 years ago
Elkie's version IS fantastic , a powerful voice.For that matter you a lacking in taste.
dizzi0000 3 years ago
Interesting. I stated my opinion as my own, but was replied to in a manner that implied there was something wrong with me for not liking EB's version. This is absurd..IMO of course.
alexkerhead 3 years ago
Elkie's version was and IS the only version.
farttart00000 3 years ago 2
Elkie's singing is very much admired by other singers, which I am guessing you are not.Elkie has to be the best female singer to come from the U.K.
bluetit1991 3 years ago 2
I actually am a musician. (now you say, but your not famous to me) and I say (I know a lot of non-famous good talent) then you say (only the best make money) and I say to each their own. Seriously. I was paying Georgia Oldman a compliment. Just because I do no particularly care for your precious little Elkie's over-raspy melancholy voice doesn't mean I have bad taste, it means I just cannot stand her voice. Georgia's voice to me is superior, but like I said, to each their own. Lay off folks.
alexkerhead 3 years ago
As a musician I find this version at best to be O.K. Why people like her take on songs that are bigger the the can cope with is beyond. Cannot compare to the original by Elkie Brooks. Only friends of this singer would disagree.
bluetit1991 3 years ago 2
Nope, not a friend or even an acquaintance of this woman.
Maybe you need to troll somewhere else. Honestly. You're only 17yo, so you need time before your ears are fully developed enough to judge the nuances of voices. IF that isn't the case, then I maintain; to each their own. Funny thing is, I am a Diana Krall fan; similar voice to Elkie's, but there is just something about Elkie's that doesn't sound good to me.
I won't reply again about this, as it is a royal-waste-o-time in my mind.
alexkerhead 3 years ago
shes my mums cousin
littlebro9 3 years ago
Georgia Oldman , you have a really really sweet voice and you have given a stunning performance. Looking at your performance there is no doubt that you are fantastic and will definitely win any competion.MAy God bless you and give you lots of success in the near future.
Sohail Rafiq (from Reading)
sohail815 3 years ago
OOOPS I SENT IT TWICE HEHE
MrToobMan 3 years ago
Hey its Genevieve (Michelles Daughter)
OMG that was .. BRILLIANT i have never heard any one sing like that! Mum told me i should watch it and finally i got the time and im glad i did. xxx HOPE TO SEE U IN AUSSIE SOME TIME TO !!
MrToobMan 3 years ago
Hey its Genevieve (Michelles Daughter)
OMG that was .. BRILLIANT i have never heard any one sing like that! Mum told me i should watch it and finally i got the time and im glad i did. xxx HOPE TO SEE U IN AUSSIE SOME TIME TO !!
MrToobMan 3 years ago
Hey Georgia, Michelle and Sam from Australia here =). That was awesome! You look and sound great. Good luck in the future!
MrToobMan 3 years ago
absolutly brilliant! amazing singing... More please!
Pretty7Princess 3 years ago
very nice....i love singing this song
livehighjive 4 years ago
Love it! Captured the " Elkie" sound, more please!!
rmberry2 4 years ago
Thankyou so much for all your lovely comments :D xx
oldmanfamily 4 years ago
Go Georgia!
We love you, such a lovely girl and very talented too.
sunnymason8 4 years ago
I agree =]
04gribblej 4 years ago
good, I love this song
gmason68 4 years ago
Love it!
She is too good.
xxxx
RosieYeaahhh 4 years ago
brill!! xxx
alycyarose 4 years ago
amazing and she looks stunning x x
mattneave1 4 years ago
A truly amazing performance, she has a wonderful voice.
coates1103 4 years ago
amazing.
PROUD. x
xRaaarx 4 years ago
Fantastic Performance - What a voice! Does Elkie Brooks and Peggy Lee credit?
PebblesBertie 4 years ago