i think you're good and you've managed to get the tone correctly from the original soundtrack. But the tempo is a bit inconsistent,it goes on a slow and steady pace, and suddenly it becomes fast, as though fast forwarded or skipped on a few notes.
Yes you are right. I listened to the original recording again and really played some keys different. This hapepens to me when I play piece for a longer time just with "music memory" without looking at the sheets...
The part at 4:10 could have slowed down a bit...that's right...
i think you had errors from 1:08 to 1:20, just the timing, it kind of slowed down...and the note on 1:15 i think is incorrect? but overall, well done.. still the best piano piece for me so far.. =)
Yes, I always slow down at this part because in my opinion it sounds more lovely...but that's subjective...
And yes, the note on 1:15 is wrong. It should be an F but I played an Eb. I don't know why but I always play an Eb in this part. Somehow it sounds interesting in my eyes but you are right that an F would be more harmonic...
There were some parts that sounded different 'cause they weren't played with the right notes (I'm learning this myself, I know), but what was cool was that it fit anyway. You played it really nice. Just try not to rush it, and contrast your dynamics a bit more. Great performance!!
Thanks, but can you tell which parts I play with the wrong notes? I just can remember that I made a mistake in the end of the main theme...but I think everything else was played like the Piano Collection(I think so)...
They are just randomly placed, I can't really go back and find them all, but if you listen to the professional recording of Eternity, and then listen to your performance, you can hear it. Its really just wrong notes from the sheets, but it fits into the song.
I really can't say how long it took me to learn this piece because I practice very unconstantly...
I just can say that I needed a long time to play this piece the way you can see it in the video because it is very long and there are some difficut and frustrating parts in it...
wooooow...beautiful...thanks for playing! >.<
PeanutTheInga 1 year ago
Cool
tchingtchangtchong 2 years ago
Comment removed
aqwarian 2 years ago
try to keep the tempo more consistent.
i'm playing this same exact song too and i know it's a bit difficult to keep it steady during the 16th notes part
17kitai 2 years ago
i think you're good and you've managed to get the tone correctly from the original soundtrack. But the tempo is a bit inconsistent,it goes on a slow and steady pace, and suddenly it becomes fast, as though fast forwarded or skipped on a few notes.
airisu 2 years ago
Could you record this and upload it as an mp3? It's so beautifully done.
groobert6456 2 years ago
damn...this was the best version i heard no matter what ANYONE SAYS :) you ROCK!!
mya619 2 years ago
Who cares if timing and some notes were off? Great Job!!
chaosfromthedeep 2 years ago
this is such a difficult song... some of your timing was off.. and a few off notes, but it all still sounded good lol... well played =]
chanemell 2 years ago
PRO LOL
whattheasiann 2 years ago
i love this song i wanna play it on the piano too . But first i need to know just HOW to play the piano. Pretty song ^^
animepeach112 2 years ago
Love it!! I wanna be able to learn this sort of thing. Thing is I need a keyboard
TheBalambGarden 2 years ago
i'm learning to play this WITH sheet music. and it will go up on youtube. :}
Monatee 2 years ago
no sheet music!! impressive
Calmonay 2 years ago
this and the piano version of 1000 no Kotoba.. (1000 Words i think) gets me everytime.
syxx7wun 2 years ago
so amazing
i could only play half of it only
the other half my hands sure stuck half way how long did it took you to mastered this song?
Careen95 2 years ago
i prefer the version on the game.
mangacrazy07 2 years ago
so much emotion
NyappySBY 3 years ago
really touching. grats
DeeaZanz 3 years ago
:'(
EmeraldKouga 3 years ago
sigh that was so pretty! great job!
xOJinJu 3 years ago
omg wow this is amazing, i can only play half of it =(. this was played beautifully.
xArktronix 3 years ago
how old are u
mknela 3 years ago
20 ...
tybaltmercutio 3 years ago
simply beautiful
NeuCraft 3 years ago
Beautiful. Absolutly amazing.
Sometimes it was slightly too fast
but I understand 'cause it's not the worlds
easiest song to play :)
Keep up the good work!
Futureispresent 3 years ago
wow u can really play the piano i can play it too but not as good as u can
Joeysgaurdianwolf2 3 years ago 2
Wow, thats pretty cool! Great job! =P
tomboyishbandit 3 years ago
Beautiful song, and the person here played it very nicely, but I like the original score alot better, even though its a bit simpler.
jesusfish305 3 years ago
So pretty! <33 But I got a different music sheet. Whenever I get one, the piano versions I listen to are different. -.-"
cut3lilasian 3 years ago 2
nicely done. memorized too :)
a few note changes here and there. but it happens to me too.
sounds BEAUTIFUL!
serika139 3 years ago
ah, beautiful perfection.
tranzzultimaga 3 years ago
not gonna lie, this song is pretty damn hard. it could take a while to perfect it. keep trying though
desgtoy 3 years ago
Look at my video response to this video...I've made a better recording...
tybaltmercutio 3 years ago
the gliss at the end was PERFECT
musicninja2 3 years ago 2
this is amazing, where did u find the sheets for this?
Kagome002 3 years ago
wow u are really really good u got all the notes rite awesome!!!!
GreenCupcakeX 3 years ago
very good mate :P
tidetidus 4 years ago
hmm i'm learning this piece myself, i'm almost done with it (i'm up to the 4 minute mark)
i thought the 1:08 - 1:20 u shouldn't have slowed down and the part at 4:10 was way too fast - also some keys are different but it still sounds ok
besides that i think u did great, i learn through memory too, don't need the sheets XD
wazzupyozz 4 years ago
Yes you are right. I listened to the original recording again and really played some keys different. This hapepens to me when I play piece for a longer time just with "music memory" without looking at the sheets...
The part at 4:10 could have slowed down a bit...that's right...
But thanks for your advice:)
tybaltmercutio 4 years ago
I find this insane. How can somebody remember all that and not read of a sheet? I wish I could play an instrument.
redcloud02 4 years ago 5
It comes with much much time, practice and patiences Lol
jetsqurriel 4 years ago 2
i think you had errors from 1:08 to 1:20, just the timing, it kind of slowed down...and the note on 1:15 i think is incorrect? but overall, well done.. still the best piano piece for me so far.. =)
carloenix 4 years ago
Yes, I always slow down at this part because in my opinion it sounds more lovely...but that's subjective...
And yes, the note on 1:15 is wrong. It should be an F but I played an Eb. I don't know why but I always play an Eb in this part. Somehow it sounds interesting in my eyes but you are right that an F would be more harmonic...
Thanks a lot for the comment...:)
tybaltmercutio 4 years ago
There were some parts that sounded different 'cause they weren't played with the right notes (I'm learning this myself, I know), but what was cool was that it fit anyway. You played it really nice. Just try not to rush it, and contrast your dynamics a bit more. Great performance!!
punkchick449 4 years ago
Thanks, but can you tell which parts I play with the wrong notes? I just can remember that I made a mistake in the end of the main theme...but I think everything else was played like the Piano Collection(I think so)...
Would be nice if you coult tell me...:)
tybaltmercutio 4 years ago
They are just randomly placed, I can't really go back and find them all, but if you listen to the professional recording of Eternity, and then listen to your performance, you can hear it. Its really just wrong notes from the sheets, but it fits into the song.
punkchick449 4 years ago
Wow! very very nice indeed! xD
How long did it take you to learn this? O.O
MDJianoran 4 years ago
I really can't say how long it took me to learn this piece because I practice very unconstantly...
I just can say that I needed a long time to play this piece the way you can see it in the video because it is very long and there are some difficut and frustrating parts in it...
tybaltmercutio 4 years ago
when you try , you succeed ;) and you sir! have done just that ;)
I envy how you can play zanarkand, wind crest and eternity xD
MDJianoran 4 years ago
ohhhh....wie schön! marius ich liebe dich! :D
philippkroll 4 years ago
danke süßer...:)
tybaltmercutio 4 years ago