redacted: a man needs to be told

[Bflave420]

ITS FUCKING WAR. SHIT HAPPENS AND PEOPLE GO CRAZY. so all you peace loving pussies who dont know what your talking about shut the fuck up.

[youngie123]

its sad that the charlatans needs to be the soundtrack for a bunch of anti american internet warriors.

[connaught2008]

can u post the whole song pleasssssse

[spacest]

sorry, i don't have it anymore, but it's called "a man needs to be told" by the charlatans

[Lewphil]

Ha ha get away

[soon2befree]

hey foreskin 2007...im sorry you feel that way about soldiers. you cant judge the mass with what a small group of soldiers did or was it marines? who cares? they were sick for doing what they did.

[forestrain2007]

Mahmoudia is Iraqi version of My Lai. So this isn't the first.

American soldiers are a bunch of pigs who have no courage or honor. They rape and kill little kids. They are all high school drop outs and will do anything when given a gun. They are all mentally ill. They can't behave right.I guess it has to do with American society, which is all about sexy and rape. I mean what kind of sickos gang rape a 13 year old girl with 8 people and then kill her and her family? It's unimaginable.

[albatrossforlife]

You fucking loser.

[bensolloway]

I think your getting it all mixed up there.. what kind of people allow themselves to be brainwashed into thinking they receive all those good things when they die!!! Bunch of fucking idiots!

[iGotYourWife]

Fuck off USA saved the ass of the Europe during WW1 and WW2 ! each country makes mistakes so shut the fuck up ! One day you'll wake up with Al Qaeda bombings in your city , with muslim demonstrations in your streets and you'll pray your own god to stop this shit ! I live in France , 9.000.000 of muslims in my country are making our lives harder, destroying our culture and the same thing happens in the UK ! You're just living behind your computer but you don't know what the reality looks like !

[enneking10]

Mujahadeen=Baby killer

Al queda= filthy scumbag

USA=Victory!!!!

[insmode]

us = victory ?

like vietnam ? or ?

dont make me laugh..

US is just a balloon..

[enneking10]

You are a cowardly fool. A balloon? You and your country are a joke.

[KBirdmanK]

I just thought the movie kinda sucked lol. On a purely nonpolitical level

[stefantheman13]

Good movie i applaud Deplama for telling the truth about what can happend to people over there

[lukexavierderivan]

it is a fictitious story. . .based on factual stories. . .supporting fictitious, and factual perspectives on a fictitiously factual-seeming war. . .

[mopsius]

I have seen it. The film is a small masterpiece.

[mopsius]

There may have been others not now known, but my nominees for the three bravest Americans in Vietnam: Hugh Thompson, Jr., Glenn Andreotta, and Lawrence Colburn.

[enneking10]

Brian Depalma is an Al Queda whore!!!

[paipon14]

then youre bush whore!!

[enneking10]

No,

you are just a filthy muslim whore. Do not reply back. You must be French..what a joke.

[Motherfucker5000]

i got a question for brian depalma why doesent he make a movie shining the light on the Jihadists like them cutting off heads on the internet or bombing mothers and fathers in city markets oh thats right he doesent give a fuck he only cares about his anti america values

[parsecbwoi]

actually the movie does include a simulated beheading, you would have known this if you had actually seen the movie before judging it

[mopsius]

Watch a film before judging it? For shame! Medved obviously didn't, why should his camp followers.

When you are right and "God" is on your side, who needs an independent mind?

[frio109]

Brian Fucking Depalma is a lieing pig fucking bastard.

[parsecbwoi]

Medved thinks the film portrays the marine corps when in fact it is clearly about the U.S. Army

[frio109]

Yeah it show a Marine lose his head in a sick and twisted way. Fuck Brian Dog shit eating Communist Palma lies.

[amsterdam78]

during the Vietnam War, "we saw the images. We saw our casualties, we saw their casualties. That's what got us out into the streets, and that's what got us out of the war." At the end of Redacted, he shows a montage of victims of the Iraq War as well, although their faces have been digitally obscured, reportedly on orders from Cuban. Nevertheless, De Palma observed, the original photographs appear all over the Internet "and yet none of these images has ever gotten into the mainstream media.

[thegoonch]

complete with faggoty indie music, fantastic job

[joserivera409]

If Mark Cuban had kids fighting in Iraq or Afghanistan he wouldn't make this movie.

If it's your kids, he doesn't give a shit.

[Doc418]

hey, the kids in Iraq actually committed this crime. Where is your outrage at that fact?

[frio109]

Only this movie is communist political bull shit lies by Brian Fucking Palma bastard.

[Madmoe77]

I served in the army D795th MP batallion and went to college-still don't support the war. When you kill someone you don't change minds. Know matter the intent. What the film depicts is ignorant actions of bad soldiers behaving unappropriately without a sign of human deceny. It happened. It was real. Can't take that back. Just like death.

[thehotshirtguy2008]

@Madmoe77 They're just hajis dude. They earned it.

[theseeman]

Reefer? Really?

I agree with you that there are bad men and even good men who want to kill us. But can you not see how expressing your opinion, one backed up by research, makes a person a bad man? And if De Palma isn't a bad man, but merely your country man, enjoying his rights by defending his country, in his own way, then why not treat him like a fellow American?

[junior8219]

I was a soldier and served over there 3 times, and i NEVER witnessed any atrocities committed by soldiers nor were our orders to murder innocent civilians. I will tell you what, why dont you guys go over there and have a sit down with the extremists and see if they care about your political affiliation

[Motherfucker5000]

hell yea brother Brian DePalma is Anti America I will Protest this Movie we should never give the benifit of the doubt to our military if Brian Depalma hates america he should go hide in a cave with BinLaden

[Casleigh3911]

Bring your fight to the top and to this war-mongering administration. The troops have nothing to do with it. 99.99% of them are following orserds corerectly and trying to stay alive. Leave them out of it. There are some bad apples and they deserve to be in jail where they are, but this fight needs to be brought to Bush's doorstep, not these poor kids who are duped into fighting this horrendous war.

[phuchton]

Very well said Casleigh, but I believe that this is what Depalma is trying to do. Imagine if our network news showed our brave troops coming home in coffins,imagine if they showed the innocent people that this war has affected, the death, the injuries, imagine if the true cost of war was shown to the American people, as it was in Vietnam, perhaps more people would be on Bush's doorstep, except our president summarily ignores anyone that doesn't agree with him...

[CINDYSHEEHANWASRIGHT]

Hows that WMD Search going cons? Rummy? Gonzo? hahahha

[Motherfucker5000]

IF Cindy sheehan is so right howcome she cant even buy a tombstone for her son who was killed in Iraq

[cornbiker]

because she is a worthless bag of shit, who wanted her 5 minutes of fame and did so by using her dead son.. She never really loved him.. And another thing Cindy... If there were not any WMD.. then so what.. but how about all the American hater that flocked to Iraq to kill innocent women, children and men.. all in the name of allah.. If we were not thinning them out over there, do you think they would come over here.. Oh wait.. they did come over here. and to Britain and other countries..

[freakyfatdog]

Iraq wasnt a hot bed for Al Qaeda cells. If you think Al Qaeda is going to send more than 1% of their support to Iraq to killed in some meat grinder you are a fool. They have cells all throughout the eastern world. They have African, Middleastern, east European and Asian cells. We are the idiots wasting all our money and manpower in one place. You think that's good?

[frio109]

Some was found in schools, parts were found in bunkers buried in the desert. There were 93 flights made by two modified transport planes while most of the rest was shipped by truck in long convoys to Syria.

[ericasboyholla]

"It saddens me that the stories of the good men and women are being overshadowed by the horrible acts of monsters. " i couldn't have said it better myself. fuck all cospiracy theory nut jobs. oh and hakeroo, fuck bush? why, do you have a good reason for that or are you just and ignorant liberal high schooler that didn't know what else to say so you just read the back of clever bumper stickers and let them make the decision for you.

[fekiramic]

I guess americans think a little slow ha?no wonder you think what cha doing is right.

[darlenmarlen]

"Hooah"("All-right!" in army lingo) for "Ferenheit-11","Jarhead",and "Redacted". You guys are the real patriots.ENOUGH WITH THE WAR PIGS.The first Americans came to this land to escape slavery from the English Feudists (Capitalist land-nation owners),and to have equal opportunity and to exercise their freedom of speech and belief.

[frio109]

You suck Brian Bastard Palma's asshole.

[Finenatty]

True ........wake the fuck up .....u r rold lies all the time and when the truth is told everyman goes through.... 1st denial

2nd anger opposition and 3rd accepted..........Time to wake up ....wake up....wake up...time for the revolution!!!

[bernalyckan]

AMI GO HOME

[Hakeroo]

fuck bush

[crabseabHaNdSoMe]

Fuck america fuck israel fuck siyonist köpekler Fuck america fuck israel fuck siyonist köpekler Fuck america fuck israel fuck siyonist köpekler Fuck america fuck israel fuck siyonist köpekler Fuck america fuck israel fuck siyonist köpekler Fuck america fuck israel fuck siyonist köpekler Fuck america fuck israel fuck siyonist köpekler

[dinnerat942]

Hey, really thoughtful post coming from a guy who thinks 9/11 was an inside job by jewish conspirators.

[frio109]

Fuck craBASTARDfuckingSEAlieingBITC­H

[RiverBirch1967]

It saddens me that the stories of the good men and women are being overshadowed by the horrible acts of monsters.

[insidebetween]

America is a democracy. YOU choose the government. The government represents YOUR will. When you think you fucked a foreign people over and won your war, everything's peachy creamy and Bush can land his aircraft with his eyes closed and you're proud of your president. When you DON'T win a war, it's the government's fault, 'we didn't want it' etc. PATHETIC! No HUMAN BEING would agree to serve in the United States armed forces at this point in time. Period.

[123456pau]

great!

[tom500k]

We Americans must see the horrific reality of our crimes in Iraq before we destroy ourselves along with the rest of the world.

If we have any humanity left, we must leave Iraq at once. Vote Sen. Gravel for Pres.

[starrynightz]

why doesn't DePalma make a film about the thousands of girls stoned in honor killings? Oh, liberals think that would be hateful...LOL

[Herseykardeslik]

you are exaggerating the reality. noone supports honor killing. however,this does not hide the reality what really happened. this guy did some couregous job to speak up about poor voiceless girls.

[caffeine1]

It's not America's job to protect women from honor killings, you moron. Where in the Constitution does it say that the USA must protect foreign citizens from anything? You think an American soldier's life is worth protecting non-citizens from their own culture?

Haven't you ever taken a civics class? You're so typical of a stupid inbred American you make me want to vomit.

[friendlier]

This video is just ... nothing.

[caffeine1]

Yeah. Really disappointing. It's not a teaser at all. It's just a couple of screen shots to music.  I've seen better home videos on youtube.

[SMOKINGfeet9]

Depalma is nothing more than a predator.

[mproductions12]

The fact that Brian De Palma wants to depict solely the evils of war and disregard what great good our troops are doing is deplorable and reprehensible. You Mr. Palma deserve nothing but the same our troops received after the Vietnam war you deserve nothing less you pig...

[CINDYSHEEHANWASRIGHT]

king kong you are right on man! The depth of their sickness to harm and kill is worse than the nazis!

[000oKINGoKONGo000]

The neo-fascist wannabe "neocons" posting sickness and hatred here with absolutely nothing to gain from these crimes (unless they work for Halliburton, BP, Goldman Sachs, etc.) know this is happening. They enjoy the suffering of others, solely for the sake of feeding their psychoses. Disgusting.

[PersianGuileAgain]

First militant: "Question: If 'we' are all Hizbullah, then why are not all of us crouched down here in earthen bunkers drinking warm water and eating stale pita pieces beside buckets of our own waste, waiting for the IDF to spread us like pistachio paste into their tank treads?"

Second militant:

First militant:

Second militant:

Second militant: "Uh, because Allah works in mysterious ways...?"

[000oKINGoKONGo000]

"A former U.S. Marine staff sergeant testified at a hearing Tuesday that his unit killed at least 30 unarmed civilians in Iraq during the war in 2003 and that Marines routinely shot and killed wounded Iraqis.

Jimmy J. Massey, a 12-year veteran, said he left Iraq in May 2003 after a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress."

[000oKINGoKONGo000]

"He said he and his men shot and killed four Iraqis staging a demonstration and a man with his hands up trying to surrender, as well as women and children at roadblocks. Massey said he had complained to his superiors about the "killing of innocent civilians," but that nothing was done."

[PersianGuileAgain]

First militant: "Remind me again how dressing as women makes us brave, Sulaymaan?"

Second militant: "Because, my brother, dressing as women is but a means to an end. Surrounded by the Great Satan's heavily armed paper tigers, the cagey Islamic warrior improvises to make his escape.

[Motherfucker5000]

Really who was that Jessie Macbeth?

[000oKINGoKONGo000]

"Dela Cruz gave similar testimony during a hearing for another Haditha defendant, Capt. Randy Stone, saying then that he had urinated on one of the dead Iraqis because he was upset over the death of Terrazas."

[000oKINGoKONGo000]

As if this is the only occasion that something like this has happened.

"The U.S. Marine sergeant accused of leading a 2005 massacre of Iraqi civilians in Haditha gunned down five unarmed men who were standing next to a car after a roadside bombing, a Marine from his squad told a military court on Friday." Today is that Friday.

[PersianGuileAgain]

First militant: "In the unlikely event I am killed by the toothless paper tigers of the American military juggernaut, Hassan, do you suppose Allah will allow me trade my 72 virgins for, say, a Playstation 2 with 'Grand Theft Auto'...?"

Second militant:

First militant: "...Because honestly, the last virgin I bedded just sorta lay there like a wet palm frond. Whimpering from time to time. And bleeding quite a bit from her --"

[supergenius18]

lol hhahaha so wrong

[000oKINGoKONGo000]

"Abeer Qasim Hamza al-Janabi was gang raped, killed and burnt by American soldiers in Mahmudiya, south of Baghdad, in March 2006. Her parents and younger daughter were also killed.

Five soldiers have since been charged with the attack. Four of them have been given sentences of between 5 and 110 years."

[PersianGuileAgain]

Overheard inside a Fallujah bunker, Wednesday, November 10

First militant: "You know, for paper tigers, these American infidels sure did pack enough ordnance, wouldn't you say, Farouk?"

Second militant: "I cannot feel my legs."*

[CINDYSHEEHANWASRIGHT]

GIANT smash hit at the film festival! Liar cons can choke on this one as hard as they have choked on the cocks of loose change and all the others! Way to go!!

[gussiefinknottle]

i'm with monocrater.  Isolated images of horrible events used to smear the entire effort. The removal of Saddam Hussein was the right thing to do, fact. Years from now all these leftist idiots will be embarassed they ever opened their mouths.

[TheDecidicator]

I thought Bush said when he was running for President the first tme that he was not a "Nation Builder". Guess what? He's right. He's not a city builder either! Nor a bridge builder.

[monocrater]

pure leftist anti-american propaganda. sure, the isolated and tragic events depicted happened, but this is like the KKK making a docu showing real black thugs raping and shooting innocents to justify going back to jim crow law. pure propaganda that will be loved by the sorry & deeply misguided leftists.

[ved76]

You don't even need no propaganda...when a 14 yo girl gets raped, beaten up and burnt alongside her family it's speaks for itself...THEHIP2007, how's your gas tank, allright? Moron...

[HelplessMammal]

This film is not lefty propoganda, it is real. Its sad Bush supporters do not know the difference.

[loadeddiaper]

WAR IS BAD....kumbiaya. Liberal-Progressive, Socialist always say war is bad when the US is involved. However not word when France was in commiting atrocities in Algeria or Russia in Afganistan. Only when the US is involved is war bad. Sorry Lefty, I don't buy your propaganda or your agenda.

[OneAngryDemocrat]

Most of President Bush's supporters would follow the man into Hell, itself.

And they unquestionably will.

[Juniorgman88]

you're right we will

[thehip2007]

another lefty propoganda film by a suicidal liberal....