This is far superior to meats singing,,, real origonal and more power to it,, infact all the sings on the bad for good album that was copied by meat are much better, pure raw and origonal
2. since he wrote it I think its his song not meat loaf's
3. its meat loaf
4. I don't think you can compare them since each were recorded in different decades and Bad for Good was more of a concept album so it was meant to be rough around the edges
@12bobpop What about Elton John and Bernie Taupin? And Paul McCartney and John Lennon? And Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel? And Tom Scholz and Brad Delp? And Mick Jones and Lou Gramm? And Niel Young and Crazy Horse... and Stills and Nash? And Townshend and Daltrey? And Rick Davies and Roger Hodginson? And Freddie Mercury and Brian May? And All the others?
Yea, one thing i'd like to correct in my opinion, hes the best rock song writer of the last century. I truely believe anyhow.
Ever since he went into audition for the part of Rabbit in More than you deserve, how he ultimately met Jim, was with this other guy who ran the New York Shakespeare festival and the rest was just as it went.
I have to say Marvin Aday (I think his surname is, correct me if I'm wrong please I dont mind we're all fans I think its fair to say), his daughters gorgous, Pearl
Wow - I'd only heard the Bat II version before, there's so much more energy in this one! :-)
ca1977a 1 week ago
This is far superior to meats singing,,, real origonal and more power to it,, infact all the sings on the bad for good album that was copied by meat are much better, pure raw and origonal
farmerdan1 1 year ago
idiot
alidonli 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
rubbish copying meatloafs song
TalkingLemons 2 years ago
1. its not a copy this is the original
2. since he wrote it I think its his song not meat loaf's
3. its meat loaf
4. I don't think you can compare them since each were recorded in different decades and Bad for Good was more of a concept album so it was meant to be rough around the edges
RockOn164 2 years ago
jim kicked meats ass on this song they
worked togehter for years and are still
the best song writers ever period
12bobpop 2 years ago
@12bobpop What about Elton John and Bernie Taupin? And Paul McCartney and John Lennon? And Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel? And Tom Scholz and Brad Delp? And Mick Jones and Lou Gramm? And Niel Young and Crazy Horse... and Stills and Nash? And Townshend and Daltrey? And Rick Davies and Roger Hodginson? And Freddie Mercury and Brian May? And All the others?
slotwinski1414 1 week ago
bud jim steinman wrote this. so i dont think its wrong for him to sing it.altho i do think meatloaf is a better singer. not a better song writer
scottjop656 2 years ago
@scottjop656 jim steinman is a much better singer than meatloaf.he's raw and that suits these type of songs.
justmee70 1 year ago
steinman wrone nearly all of meatloafs songs and most of bonnie tylers.
but i think meat sings much better but steinman is good
hatstalker 2 years ago
this is the opriginal
jhniscol 2 years ago
Pesonally I prefer the instrumental parts on this version of the ssong but meat loaf is a much better singer and Stineman knows that!!
pjsdoggy 2 years ago
Love that artwork!
MidnighWolf 2 years ago
Much better then Meatloafs version, much groooovier! I love this song!
slimkling 2 years ago
good writer okay singer but marvin is better than jim
hatstalker 2 years ago
Yea, one thing i'd like to correct in my opinion, hes the best rock song writer of the last century. I truely believe anyhow.
Ever since he went into audition for the part of Rabbit in More than you deserve, how he ultimately met Jim, was with this other guy who ran the New York Shakespeare festival and the rest was just as it went.
I have to say Marvin Aday (I think his surname is, correct me if I'm wrong please I dont mind we're all fans I think its fair to say), his daughters gorgous, Pearl
jsmith19810808 2 years ago
Aday is correct
hatstalker 2 years ago
I didn't know Jim Steinman did his own version of this song. To be honest, even though he wrote it I like Meat Loaf's version better.
jtm101583 2 years ago 8
ありがとう。
聴きたかった。
2tg1600 3 years ago
Doi tashi mashte
dawkinsfan41 2 years ago
Jim rules!!!
emperormegadeth84 3 years ago
Cant compare to Meat's
Tell ya the truth, the FIREs are very weak.
But thanks for sharing!
WarioLoaf 3 years ago
agreed but as far as song writing, jim may be the best ever, or at least top 5.
Crusader38 2 years ago 3
this is great!!!
milvagochimango7 3 years ago