Genesis - 21 - Throwing It All Away (Katowice, Poland 1998)

[browner2252]

no good. Phil is better. Sorry ray

[jillianah888]

Fantastic concert!! Ray Wilson is just an amazing, great man, so male, so passionate, so emotional and tender as well. I fell in love in Ray after this concert and I think it is much better show than with Collins.

[greatpcfan]

@jillianah888 are you nuts?you call this lad better than collins?

[splicer45]

Oh god! : (

[tiedupsmurf]

omg another bad version of a good song

STOP IT PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESERRRRRR

[66hourenergy]

I for one, really enjoy this version, especially with the dropped key. It seems much more passionate this way, particularly the opening guitar riffs..

[analogueaddict]

btw, if you don't like lower/different keys you won't like '07 reunion?!? Phil sang almost all the songs in a dropped key.

[66hourenergy]

Very true, and the songs sounded just as good, except for No Son of Mine. (It's my favorite song, so I tend to be a little overcritical of hit, but it was just lacking last time)

[analogueaddict]

Very good version, less poppy, more soulful.

[Squonk337]

zzzzzzzzzz. Ray doesn't sing this song with the emotion Phil does and the lowered key, as Tornado said, doesn't help matters. I think they only reason they performed these songs is because they are ones enjoyed by Mike & Tony. They weren't big hits in Europe. Even the audience don't seem that enthusiastic about them.

[TornadoOf07]

This version lacks fire. The lowered key kills the atmosphere and Ray's vocals don't fit it. This is definitely a PC song vocally speaking.

[GenesisPL]

Nareszcie jakaś pożądna wersja audio :) byłem na tym koncercie, chodź niektórzy mówią że to był kiepski koncert ja zawsze wspominam go bardzo ciepło. Jak dla mnie był to lepszy koncert od tego Chorzowskiego z Collinsem!

[Savanoja]

Marzyłam o tym koncercie, a gdy przyjechali ja oglądałam go z kanapy ze łzami w oczach bo byłam w zaawansowanej ciąży i pojechać nie mogłam. A koncert był super!!!

[EricGodClapton]

this is awesome

[jeromefreymond]

"Didadeo!, didadeo!", which was a trademark for Phil Collins is clearly missin' here. I'm sure Ray could have done this...

[dchasse12]

I didn't like that part so much. It's an emotional song about breakup and loss. I don't think that kind of call and response wasn't right for this song.

[jeromefreymond]

Well, Collins was a showman and Ray is not, So the emotions of the song can be brought to the audiance how they have to. But you are right. A sad song should not be interluded with a sing-a-long part.

[jaydeewayne]

I Think,Its good for Ray and the team..The Soul of Rock Harmony can you see it/feel it in this song.

[SirFunkward]

Great Version