You can't really blame JDB for his musical mistakes. The band were still shaken by Richeys disappearance and trying to prove to their fanbase (the very few who were at this gig) and everyone else that they were still a unit, they were playing to Oasis fans who didn't really give two-shits about the Manics and would chant "Where the fuck is Richey?" and they were adapting to a new "mainstream" sound as opposed to their darker, previous album.
Will this song ever get boring? To all who are saying this is for an Oasis gig; you're wrong, it was the Hillsborough Justice gig in 97 where these, The Beautiful South, Lightning Seeds, Stereophonics, Dodgy, Space and Smaller performed...at the time of this gig; Oasis were doing promo work for Be Here Now.
@manutd798 What are you on about? The Manics love Liverpool, they even wrote a song attacking the South Yorkshire police for their role at Hillsborough.
The crowd really are'nt going for it are they? Wrong crowd for this type of music or at this time of day. JDB looks genuinely overawed. Must be hard to sell a song about the emptiness of consumer culture and modern living to a crowd expecting cigarettes and alcohol. Good try though.
i remember seeing this on tv, good performance! Ive always wanted to see footage of there first comeback gig - I think it may have been Sound City in Nottingham in 96/97
@telecaster228401 no mate they did their first gig as a 3 piece supporting The Stone Roses @ wembley in december 95 hey were great but nervous (understandable)
they'd have a job being there for wonderwall.... oasis didn't play the justice gig!!
the crowd was made of two thirds families who went because it was 'the right thing to do', and they rest were teenagers and 20-odd year olds who saw it for what it was - a day to get drunk and watch quite a few bands do some pretty good sets in all fairness.
throw in Frank Sidebottom as the mid-act entertainment, and you've got an amazing day - one i'll not forget in a hurry!!
This is a great performance if you ignore all the oasis groupies who are pathetic and could not spot a classic like this if it hit them in the face and dont get me wrong oasis have good tunes just the crowd isckealry here for wonderwall the absolute bunch of cunts
@nickftm ugh...that description gives me the willies. i wished you'd stopped at "oasis groupies." This song is still a religious experience after 20 yrs.
everyones commenting sayin the atmospheres not great well its a charity gig so the people dont got specifically to see the manic street preachers, they mightent even like then so what do you expect?? lol
You can't really blame JDB for his musical mistakes. The band were still shaken by Richeys disappearance and trying to prove to their fanbase (the very few who were at this gig) and everyone else that they were still a unit, they were playing to Oasis fans who didn't really give two-shits about the Manics and would chant "Where the fuck is Richey?" and they were adapting to a new "mainstream" sound as opposed to their darker, previous album.
iamjoshandyouaredaft 2 months ago
this is a very low energy performance compared to how james usually gives it up
fuckamericanidiot 4 months ago
Hahahaa, what's he singing at 2:03 - 2:11 ? Poor, James. He forgot his lines!
ReignBeauJo 8 months ago
Will this song ever get boring? To all who are saying this is for an Oasis gig; you're wrong, it was the Hillsborough Justice gig in 97 where these, The Beautiful South, Lightning Seeds, Stereophonics, Dodgy, Space and Smaller performed...at the time of this gig; Oasis were doing promo work for Be Here Now.
PhilSupernova88 8 months ago
i bet they just wanted to tell the the crowd to get fucked
manutd798 8 months ago
@manutd798 What are you on about? The Manics love Liverpool, they even wrote a song attacking the South Yorkshire police for their role at Hillsborough.
felix8989 7 months ago
The crowd really are'nt going for it are they? Wrong crowd for this type of music or at this time of day. JDB looks genuinely overawed. Must be hard to sell a song about the emptiness of consumer culture and modern living to a crowd expecting cigarettes and alcohol. Good try though.
caraticus12 10 months ago
@caraticus12 This was their first song for the gig, as for the crowd, have a look at their reaction to Australia, superb
Bordessa72 6 months ago
that main road?
Staff777 1 year ago
@Staff777 it's Anfield - this was the Hillsbrough Justice Concert from 1996
donners1982 1 year ago
A GREAT TUNE END OFF IF YOU DO NOT AGREE YOUR A CXXT NO NEED FOR SWEARING PEACE TO ALL MANKIND
masherdan 1 year ago
imagine playing for a crowd that huge! blimey...
daziel6 1 year ago
@daziel6
Woodstock?
acdcrockon1000 10 months ago
Thanks a million for posting this. I've been searching for years for it. Such a great gig.
witchpiss 1 year ago
wonderful world of -- what?
greendaycranberryfan 1 year ago
@greendaycranberryfan purchase power
Ellenberg88 1 year ago
i remember seeing this on tv, good performance! Ive always wanted to see footage of there first comeback gig - I think it may have been Sound City in Nottingham in 96/97
telecaster228401 1 year ago
@telecaster228401 no mate they did their first gig as a 3 piece supporting The Stone Roses @ wembley in december 95 hey were great but nervous (understandable)
goonchistaw 1 year ago
i love every single of ur song ..
Astrieeee 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It's hard to put into words just how sad/shit this is. It would be better expressed just by taking a really big crap on the floor.
ryko26 1 year ago
Does anyone know where you can get a hold of this concert please :) ?
ItsTheJade 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love this song, tried it on piano if anyone has time maybe check it out. Not the best version but had a go,cheers
ryanonpiano 1 year ago
Comment removed
hendo70 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Who is Stadium?
albertinoaquilani 2 years ago
Who is Stadium?
albertinoaquilani 2 years ago
Anfield
glentoranfan247 2 years ago
Amazing song, I tried this on Piano if anyone has time to check it out. Thanks.
ryanonpiano 2 years ago
they'd have a job being there for wonderwall.... oasis didn't play the justice gig!!
the crowd was made of two thirds families who went because it was 'the right thing to do', and they rest were teenagers and 20-odd year olds who saw it for what it was - a day to get drunk and watch quite a few bands do some pretty good sets in all fairness.
throw in Frank Sidebottom as the mid-act entertainment, and you've got an amazing day - one i'll not forget in a hurry!!
donners1982 2 years ago
This is a great performance if you ignore all the oasis groupies who are pathetic and could not spot a classic like this if it hit them in the face and dont get me wrong oasis have good tunes just the crowd isckealry here for wonderwall the absolute bunch of cunts
nickftm 2 years ago 9
@nickftm ugh...that description gives me the willies. i wished you'd stopped at "oasis groupies." This song is still a religious experience after 20 yrs.
ahagestedt 1 year ago
the reason the crowd are bollocks is because they're complicit in this motorcycle emptiness...they are the main culprits fuck sake?
MichaelFrances 2 years ago
LOL James totally forgot the lyrics at 1:56 he covered it well though
thepanwithin 2 years ago 2
ive noticed he does that often, he makes shit up too, but hes a legend and it shows he knows how to improvise which any good musician should do :P
Biker16Madd 2 years ago
i think its a good version, awesome, bradders looks real young
Biker16Madd 2 years ago
i sort of meant all together, but i get wat ur sayin, btw- GT was only JDB musically. Seans drums were edited in, not actually recorded.
boeingbloke777 2 years ago
everyones commenting sayin the atmospheres not great well its a charity gig so the people dont got specifically to see the manic street preachers, they mightent even like then so what do you expect?? lol
rharris2727 3 years ago
even if they dont like the manics, they have to admire the great vocal and musical ability of all involved in the manics!
boeingbloke777 2 years ago 6
anyone got this in good qaulity
allenpapi 3 years ago
They are so totally bored!
cabbaman98 3 years ago
i think they look sad it just makes me sad watching it :(..
heyaevery1x 3 years ago
UHHH James plays a solo at the end
Aboycalledgill 3 years ago
Atmosphere looks a bit flat, still a great song though.
Manics1989 3 years ago
wasn't it the hillsborough benefit gig?
didz83 3 years ago
Yep, thats right. :)
whispersandechoes 3 years ago
no solo crap
Dext37Fielding 3 years ago