I never understand when people prefer one key over another (except for reasons of fingering and coordination with other instruments or voice, or perhaps for those with perfect pitch). I think all tempered keys in the same mode sound the same. Of course, if a piece modulates from one key to another, the specific target key becomes very important. If different keys truly felt different, then wouldn't A=473 feel different, and maybe "better", than A=440? It's a reductio ad absurdum!
@AbsoluteZ3R0 Agreed! My favourite major key is D flat; to me it's just... lush, for want of a better word. It just has something that none of the other major keys have, and I think it's great for tranquil, pensive, sentimental pieces. As for minor keys, I like C# minor too. And I love the richness of C minor.
For me there's quite a big difference in sound between the flat keys and the sharp keys. Of course, that's until you get to the signatures with 6+ sharps/flats, and they start to blend.
Love this one, too. As per the Lady Gaga, let me know if you're interested in me scoring these and including them in some concerts that I'll be holding this year. Thanks!
This is so witty and clever! The descending chromatic lines on "loneliness"; the sudden flourish of 16ths on "give me a sign"; the recap in F Major suggesting a resolution of the opening D Minor "agitato"; the use of a duet texture to lament "my loneliness"... I especially love the sequential repetitions of "did it again", and the way the sequences completely alter the harmonies. Of course, the juxtaposition of texts about her own loneliness and reducing others' loneliness goes without saying!
(Taneyev's specialized field of study was counterpoint. He engrossed himself in the music of Johann Sebastian Bach, Giovanni Palestrina and Flemish masters such as Johannes Ockeghem, Josquin des Prez and Lassus. Eventually, he became one of the greatest of contrapuntalists)
you should try a fugue for an Iron Maiden song like hallowed be thy name, dance of death or no more lies.. the vocal lines are great! it would be interesting :P
@colourfulwithaU Dude, it's a reference to "This is Spinal Tap". Nigel said that line and proceeded to play a very sad composition of his: "Lick My Love Pump".
@colourfulwithaU I chose D minor for a matter of registers. If you notice the piece could hypothetically be performed by female choir, a couple of violins doubling the choir, and continuo section. Anyway: yes, I love D minor..
@artofcounterpoint D minor iz da BOMB, yo! It falls nicely under the hand on the keayboard, and for organ music it allows the full use of the lower register while still providing a leading tone (C-sharp minor works for that too, but really?). Hang on, tonus primus!
@estring123 Even minor keys can have major chords in them. Plus, because there are so many extra sharps and flats added, the key changes quite often. In fact, most of this piece is in major keys. The middle section (oops I did it again) is in C Major. The return of the opening, towards the end, is in F Major.
I'm gonna download the score now and give it a try. It's the perfect mix of classical music and modern music! I'm kinda looking for sth. like this a couple of weeks now :)
Awsome!!! for the people that doesnt understand Counterpoint or FUga now can more or less imagine whats that...or the way the people were thinking to write the music..awsome....is also very good fo people that study music ..make it easier :)
this is great! Is this also written for voice? 'Cause it would be a delightful Choral piece... wanna arrange this... can I?!!
Thanks!
octavine 1 day ago
do u use a program to write the notes down and play them? in that case, what program`?
Ludwigooo 2 days ago
Can i buy/download the sheets anywhere?
milfsound 4 days ago
Sublime dude
thedrumbum1990 1 week ago
mine is E flat major!
MeandmagiC 2 weeks ago
Brilliant
AbsoluteZ3R0 4 weeks ago
I never understand when people prefer one key over another (except for reasons of fingering and coordination with other instruments or voice, or perhaps for those with perfect pitch). I think all tempered keys in the same mode sound the same. Of course, if a piece modulates from one key to another, the specific target key becomes very important. If different keys truly felt different, then wouldn't A=473 feel different, and maybe "better", than A=440? It's a reductio ad absurdum!
david203 4 weeks ago 2
@david203 We're all different and therefore are more attuned to different things. Quod Erat Demonstratum.
fevimaster 4 weeks ago 5
@david203 If you have perfect pitch the keys all sound very different. My personal favorites are C# and F# minor
AbsoluteZ3R0 4 weeks ago
@AbsoluteZ3R0 Agreed! My favourite major key is D flat; to me it's just... lush, for want of a better word. It just has something that none of the other major keys have, and I think it's great for tranquil, pensive, sentimental pieces. As for minor keys, I like C# minor too. And I love the richness of C minor.
For me there's quite a big difference in sound between the flat keys and the sharp keys. Of course, that's until you get to the signatures with 6+ sharps/flats, and they start to blend.
alexface211 2 weeks ago
E minor is the most funereal.
lennietristanojazz 1 month ago
B minor makes me want to dagger myself even having taken two Zolofts.
lexicalpianist 1 month ago
This is great! This makes her songs sound soo much better. ;-)
LaGazzaLadra1 1 month ago
Nice... Britney goes barroque!
borux 1 month ago
Love this one, too. As per the Lady Gaga, let me know if you're interested in me scoring these and including them in some concerts that I'll be holding this year. Thanks!
adrianhead72 1 month ago
Outstading!!
yunick07 1 month ago
You are my hero! Thank you for this. I love your work.
jdmazzify 1 month ago
wow making MUSIC out of crap. Amazing work!
shaivista 1 month ago
Just wonderful. The difference between music and music.
MATTiASNiLSSONcom 1 month ago
Please transcribe for sax quartet.
stldmb56 2 months ago
Excellent! This is a way I can finally listen to Britney Spears without wanting slit my wrists.
choirsteve 2 months ago 4
Molto bravo!!!
Flyalp 2 months ago
I think it would be fun to make it with vocal ensemble..The notes gets separate?
thorbjornsjogren 2 months ago
Geniale.
franzleone 2 months ago
Really nice. Would like to play it at concert, can we ?
viennachan1 2 months ago
@viennachan1 as far as I'm concerned... it would be great!
artofcounterpoint 2 months ago
Sin duda, todo es susceptible de ser mejorado....Bravo!
ilargiarensoinua 2 months ago
Brilliant!!
nuke97 2 months ago
You just made my day :) Thank you so much for sharing this and conceiving it too.
SingandSignSL 2 months ago
This is actually very nice.
Alexjr1543 2 months ago
Ingeniously composition and with much humor.
MartinRaetzJr 2 months ago
This is so witty and clever! The descending chromatic lines on "loneliness"; the sudden flourish of 16ths on "give me a sign"; the recap in F Major suggesting a resolution of the opening D Minor "agitato"; the use of a duet texture to lament "my loneliness"... I especially love the sequential repetitions of "did it again", and the way the sequences completely alter the harmonies. Of course, the juxtaposition of texts about her own loneliness and reducing others' loneliness goes without saying!
pianojerome 2 months ago
this is amazing! hahaha its so epic
RollerCoasterManiac 3 months ago
@guitarslim56 IMO the saddest is B minor. Just listen to any of Shostakovich's works in that key :)
LordN3mrod 3 months ago
@LordN3mrod
In fact, "pop corn" is in B minor, too :D
revilo111 3 months ago
100th Like. :-)
iOnlySignIn 3 months ago
And who says pop music can't be interesting...
keetner 3 months ago
lol
newFranzFerencLiszt 5 months ago
watch?v=mXIltZCAaxE
(Taneyev's specialized field of study was counterpoint. He engrossed himself in the music of Johann Sebastian Bach, Giovanni Palestrina and Flemish masters such as Johannes Ockeghem, Josquin des Prez and Lassus. Eventually, he became one of the greatest of contrapuntalists)
TheForestHedgehog 5 months ago
@TheForestHedgehog opinions vary, and the jury is still out on that one.
MuseDuCafe 4 months ago
you should try a fugue for an Iron Maiden song like hallowed be thy name, dance of death or no more lies.. the vocal lines are great! it would be interesting :P
dwayne515 5 months ago
Comment removed
dwayne515 5 months ago
D minor is the saddest of all keys.
guitarslim56 6 months ago 57
Comment removed
colourfulwithaU 6 months ago
@colourfulwithaU Dude, it's a reference to "This is Spinal Tap". Nigel said that line and proceeded to play a very sad composition of his: "Lick My Love Pump".
TrevRockOne 5 months ago in playlist More videos from artofcounterpoint
Comment removed
colourfulwithaU 5 months ago
@guitarslim56 i feel D minor powerful, the saddest is F# minor I think, it is so lonely.
MegaUpstairs 5 months ago
@guitarslim56 i feel D minor powerful, the saddest is F# minor I think, it is so lonely.
MegaUpstairs 5 months ago
@MegaUpstairs poor guy, watch spinal tap and delete your messages :D
snufkin789 3 months ago
@guitarslim56 ur mom is the saddest of all keys
estring123 2 months ago
Comment removed
Floete22 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@guitarslim56
im56
right, but there's also g minor - this key can be very sad, to
Floete22 2 months ago
@guitarslim56 All minor keys are "sad". If you transpose this to C minor it would still sound sad
Fassislau 1 month ago
@guitarslim56 I respectfully disagree... C# minor makes me need a Zoloft.
CliffMusicSF 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
And then, of course, a C at the beginning of the next bar!
seandingley 6 months ago
Absolutely love this!
Not sure I'm convinced by the repeated E in the bass at 23 though... I'm leaning towards a D at that point!
seandingley 6 months ago
Comment removed
seandingley 6 months ago
This is absolutely wonderful! I hope I'll be able to write something at least vaguely similar to this someday.
Lei, signore, è un genio. Devo dire che sono veramente stupito. Davvero brillante!
Jacobiel 6 months ago
Man, you do great things. Especially with little material to work with. Keep them coming! Thanks
promotionmusic1 6 months ago
grande!
marcostrada5 6 months ago
Oops i farted again... oh wait... xD
Kayokak 6 months ago
D minor? Again? Is that your favourite key?
colourfulwithaU 6 months ago 7
@colourfulwithaU I chose D minor for a matter of registers. If you notice the piece could hypothetically be performed by female choir, a couple of violins doubling the choir, and continuo section. Anyway: yes, I love D minor..
artofcounterpoint 6 months ago 31
@artofcounterpoint D minor iz da BOMB, yo! It falls nicely under the hand on the keayboard, and for organ music it allows the full use of the lower register while still providing a leading tone (C-sharp minor works for that too, but really?). Hang on, tonus primus!
virginiaorganbuilder 5 months ago
@artofcounterpoint Please record it that way! :)
SecondAgeOfReason 4 months ago
@artofcounterpoint why does it sound happy if its in a minor key?
estring123 2 months ago
@estring123 Even minor keys can have major chords in them. Plus, because there are so many extra sharps and flats added, the key changes quite often. In fact, most of this piece is in major keys. The middle section (oops I did it again) is in C Major. The return of the opening, towards the end, is in F Major.
pianojerome 2 months ago
@artofcounterpoint To quote the great Spinal Tap - D Minor is the saddest of all keys.
ComradeCanadia 1 month ago
I must confess...I didn't believe you could produce something so awesome! Proved me wrong :)
Flanneryschickens 6 months ago
My most sincere applause.
hasumedic 6 months ago
That is just brilliant!
nothing more to say, sorry ;)
I'm gonna download the score now and give it a try. It's the perfect mix of classical music and modern music! I'm kinda looking for sth. like this a couple of weeks now :)
OrganPianoMusic 6 months ago
wow, thats talent :D counterpoint is so intricate and complex, wish i could master it haha xx
FuchsiaFloral 6 months ago
Awsome!!! for the people that doesnt understand Counterpoint or FUga now can more or less imagine whats that...or the way the people were thinking to write the music..awsome....is also very good fo people that study music ..make it easier :)
normatosca 6 months ago
wonderful its amazing how moving and dramatic it is.
WeeGrahamsaccount 6 months ago
This is amazing... I usually dislike all kinds of Pop music, but this arrangement is amazing! :D Wonderful!
BoyBlueberry 6 months ago