all people is not equal under the communism china,most of people is so poor,but major communist has so many privilege,car house food etc etc,,,,,,major communist in china just want to keep those privilege,so that why they killed historical amount of their citizen,its typical characteristic of communism,communist kill their against people without any permission necessary,china is perfectly lawless zone,chinese communist party killed historical amount of people for keep major communist`s privilege
dude 300-800 people were'nt killed it was like couple thousand that died but it was never officialy recorded of how many people died exactly. Also soldiers of an elite army of China of that time fiered upon other soldiers if they did'nt shoot at the people or students.
Welcome to all Chinese users who finally have the rightful opportunity to view this content. Well done to Google for finally giving two fingers to the corrupt Chinese regime. Hu Jintao and his communist colleagues should be tried fro Treason and then shot!
I was reading Forbidden City by William Bell, which was all about this Tian An Men Massacre in 1989. The deaths of thousands of Chinese people were decided by the Chinese government, and no one else is to blame; not the westerns, not the whole asian race, and etc.
They claim China kill it's own people, but they also did the same. Look at lady Diana.
They claim China is vanishing the Tibetian culture, but if you go to Tibet now, most people there are speaking in Tibetian language; But if you go to north america, CAN YOU FIND ANYBODY SPEAKS INDIAN LANGUAGE????
Democrazy and Communism are both killer ideology. In fact, human has no ideology at all. It's more about own benefit.
agree with Halim, westerns are the reason this happened, this is what happened when Westerns brainwashed stupido in Asians. All thanks to Mao Ze Dong. China is number 1 country in the world now. US is going down.
These western countries can do anything they want to,
- kill people,
- torture people (Guantanamao),
- fund any separatism, etc.
Actually their goal is not the freedom or human right, they just want the Asia nations to be separated and weak. This is called MODERN IMPERIALISM. Now they are aiming at China, because of the growth in China. In their calculation, China will soon take over them, so they will do ANYTHING they can, to stop it. And human right, freedom; are just one of the bullshits.
Democracy is not a dream, we can all live in a better world but, the people who think different have to fight, fight fight the oppressors, we have oppressors in Italy too, fight borthers of China, life is one.
Every man dies, not every man really lives (Breaveheart movie).
you r such idiot person. western just jealous about chinese economic grwoth. i am not chinese, but i do like china so much.i know that you western are just jelaous about china
you know, the tank man incident happened the day after. and It didn't last for an hour. He yelled at the tank for 5-10 minutes until some people came and dragged him away.
there is no neeed for you to be rude sir. U might want to enlighten me by using less offensive words, so that i can be able to understand what are you trying to say.
Hey BigBro1043, u are a fascist, a communist POS,your stupid comment its like saying a rape victim is to b blamed for the rape if she was wearing a skirt, because it might insite men to want to have sex with her. Moron.
the simple fact is- there is not perfect form of government... All flawed. Communism would seem ideal, except it's still ran by humans; flawed, selfish humans who manipulate power to their benefit... their will. I believe in the power of revolution... All powers should be held in their respected places, or completely discarded. Many times China's government has failed to do their purpose: Protect the people of China. But that's the same with many countries... Even the U.S.
to xboyonfirex,I don't recall the United States of america ever killing houndreds, perhaps thousands on the streets because they are protesting. when u went out and protested, how many times u saw ppl getting killed out on American streets,moron. If u believe in the power of revolution so much, why dont u take your pampered american ass to China and see what ur revolution its gonna bring on u ,brat. LIBERALISM IS A MENTAL DISORDER
As you know,the students were peaceful. but some western countries made use of the youth`s passion and the love for China. They want to break down the socialism and the communist of China.
Do you know the life of lower classes in China that time? What makes China become stronger ang stronger? Which leader want their people get suffering and sarrow? And do you know whom behind of these student? History`ll prove all the things. who are murderers
wow...wanna speak ur mind in china..lol..bad choice..in china ..i mean common..the police cud drag ur ass off at braod daylight n they wud be bno witnesese..haha..great china,great murderers
They are also young people like the students. They had gun, but no shoots. Why? If I was a solider there at that time, I would shoot any students who wanna to hurt me. Kill them all!
I'm chinese,my government has hiden this truth for decades,but they never prevailed because they can't absolutely forbit the people to get informations from the outside of our country.And no matter how they wanna justify for themselves,the massacre IS a crime.If they wanna suppress the protest,why do they have to kill those people?Why don't they use the water blast gun or the tear gas?They don't have those things?That's bullshit.every excuse is so PALLID in fromt of our queries.
Look for the NINE COMMENTARIES or internet or see the video's on YouTube. Learn the truth about CCP communists. Millions Chinese left the CCP, it's falling apart and so it's regime. Look on NINE COMMENTARIES and spread this
As far as i know units of all the different (6) armies had to take part in the massacre to prevent that any of the generals criticises the events in later times.
And rumors say that several of the units involved were drugged to put their level of aggression up and their "own free will" down
American Government should be resposible for it. It was American behind that supplied the painting and organized students with an attempt to pull over the government like what Americans doing in other place in the world.
warmleo: That is weakest propaganda I ever read. All those Chinese citizens who challenged their own goverment were not manipulated by the U.S. Gave your fellow country men more credit they deserve.
Hahaha! You must be kidding?! I'm not a fan of the US but they have nothing to do with this massacre. OR maybe yes US and Europe opened those students about the despotic governement that rules China since Mao.
they should be glad, after all the massacre is the only reason the CCP still exists when other communist powers collapsed.
although the statement that there is still a great struggle for democracy in china is kinda wrong. with a booming economy and rising living standards, democracy isnt really on people's priority list nowadays
just want to point out that the students were not protesting for 'western democracy' but for a more democratic form of socialism. even this was too much for the government. china took a big step backwards that day...
Ooo those chinese, cant stay mad at those little guys.
beazwolle 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
all people is not equal under the communism china,most of people is so poor,but major communist has so many privilege,car house food etc etc,,,,,,major communist in china just want to keep those privilege,so that why they killed historical amount of their citizen,its typical characteristic of communism,communist kill their against people without any permission necessary,china is perfectly lawless zone,chinese communist party killed historical amount of people for keep major communist`s privilege
77777XYZ 7 months ago
Im chinese too and I just think this is most likely never going to happen agen
BombEatingPacMan 1 year ago
dude 300-800 people were'nt killed it was like couple thousand that died but it was never officialy recorded of how many people died exactly. Also soldiers of an elite army of China of that time fiered upon other soldiers if they did'nt shoot at the people or students.
hunter5559 1 year ago
hahahaha kill all those democratic pigs viva la communism
antiemoallience 1 year ago
music ruined it
myNAMEisUNAVALIABLE 1 year ago
Welcome to all Chinese users who finally have the rightful opportunity to view this content. Well done to Google for finally giving two fingers to the corrupt Chinese regime. Hu Jintao and his communist colleagues should be tried fro Treason and then shot!
timpat29 1 year ago 2
China firewalls these sites, so they won't be able to see it still
cmorera 1 year ago
@cmorera It's extremely easy to bypass China's "Great Firewall". Just use a proxy.
PwnforceFrank 1 year ago
Human Rights Now !
dglshenry4 1 year ago
I was reading Forbidden City by William Bell, which was all about this Tian An Men Massacre in 1989. The deaths of thousands of Chinese people were decided by the Chinese government, and no one else is to blame; not the westerns, not the whole asian race, and etc.
xoxxmusic 2 years ago
Chinese people kill themselves without mercy.
JustForMyMemory 2 years ago
American people kill Native American without mercy
j101311 1 year ago
@j101311 I'm not American.
What is right and what is wrong: Everyone knows it!
Don't blame American
JustForMyMemory 1 year ago
@JustForMyMemory
Where did you get the idea of "without mercy" part?
Do you even know what exactly happened?
Please tell me why you are so sure about this is a simple right and wrong question.
j101311 1 year ago
@j101311 please search more info on internet. i can't write much here.
You can read wiki page about that.
JustForMyMemory 1 year ago
@JustForMyMemory
What are these excuses?
I don't need you to tell me that.
I am asking you. Do you even know what exactly happened?
If Wiki is what you based your common on,you'd better find other sources.
If you don't know, don't act as you do.
j101311 1 year ago
An American people kill Native Americans without mercy
j101311 1 year ago
@j101311
¿A cual pais de America te refieres?
¿Which countries do you mean America?
TetsuoCtes 1 year ago
They claim China kill it's own people, but they also did the same. Look at lady Diana.
They claim China is vanishing the Tibetian culture, but if you go to Tibet now, most people there are speaking in Tibetian language; But if you go to north america, CAN YOU FIND ANYBODY SPEAKS INDIAN LANGUAGE????
Democrazy and Communism are both killer ideology. In fact, human has no ideology at all. It's more about own benefit.
halim181276 2 years ago
agree with Halim, westerns are the reason this happened, this is what happened when Westerns brainwashed stupido in Asians. All thanks to Mao Ze Dong. China is number 1 country in the world now. US is going down.
tanto88 2 years ago
These western countries can do anything they want to,
- kill people,
- torture people (Guantanamao),
- fund any separatism, etc.
Actually their goal is not the freedom or human right, they just want the Asia nations to be separated and weak. This is called MODERN IMPERIALISM. Now they are aiming at China, because of the growth in China. In their calculation, China will soon take over them, so they will do ANYTHING they can, to stop it. And human right, freedom; are just one of the bullshits.
halim181276 2 years ago
Last time when the British invaded China, they brought opium and gave it to Chinese people, caused many people died and a lost generation.
Last time when British first came to north america, they massacred the Indian and stole the land, which today become USA and Canada.
Last time USA attacked Iraq and killed many people, because of WMD, which until today never ever being found one.
Are these against human rights??? Where is the freedom of Chinese, Indian and Iraq??? WHERE????
halim181276 2 years ago
fuck communists, wipe out communists, the communists are the most rubbish on the earth.
davidleetube 2 years ago 2
indeed :)
CommunistSuperChina 2 years ago
Democracy is not a dream, we can all live in a better world but, the people who think different have to fight, fight fight the oppressors, we have oppressors in Italy too, fight borthers of China, life is one.
Every man dies, not every man really lives (Breaveheart movie).
Dippi17 2 years ago 2
you r such idiot person. western just jealous about chinese economic grwoth. i am not chinese, but i do like china so much.i know that you western are just jelaous about china
bataxsolo 2 years ago
you know, the tank man incident happened the day after. and It didn't last for an hour. He yelled at the tank for 5-10 minutes until some people came and dragged him away.
CandyYum96 2 years ago
And than killed him.
damasta940 2 years ago
Wow thats pretty crazy
I just finished reading the book... The Forbidden City
And now I have a bettwer understanding of it
ilyshannon17 3 years ago
i checked this out because iam reading the forbiddin city......one of the pics is off the cover of the book
anime666king 3 years ago
but i dont blame it on you, less educated people tend to behave this way. thanks for the attention anyway.
BigBro1043 3 years ago
and yes, I am a communist, at least in principle.
BigBro1043 3 years ago
there is no neeed for you to be rude sir. U might want to enlighten me by using less offensive words, so that i can be able to understand what are you trying to say.
BigBro1043 3 years ago
the goverment has already warned them, they asked for the trouble.
BigBro1043 3 years ago
Hey BigBro1043, u are a fascist, a communist POS,your stupid comment its like saying a rape victim is to b blamed for the rape if she was wearing a skirt, because it might insite men to want to have sex with her. Moron.
skld46 3 years ago 2
the simple fact is- there is not perfect form of government... All flawed. Communism would seem ideal, except it's still ran by humans; flawed, selfish humans who manipulate power to their benefit... their will. I believe in the power of revolution... All powers should be held in their respected places, or completely discarded. Many times China's government has failed to do their purpose: Protect the people of China. But that's the same with many countries... Even the U.S.
xboyonfirex 3 years ago
to xboyonfirex,I don't recall the United States of america ever killing houndreds, perhaps thousands on the streets because they are protesting. when u went out and protested, how many times u saw ppl getting killed out on American streets,moron. If u believe in the power of revolution so much, why dont u take your pampered american ass to China and see what ur revolution its gonna bring on u ,brat. LIBERALISM IS A MENTAL DISORDER
skld46 3 years ago
Four students gunned down by the US army at an Ohio University.
It's not hundreds, but China has about four times more the population of the US and has a much smaller geographical land mass.
damasta940 2 years ago
No China is bigger than the U.S. 1 Russia 2 Canada 3 China 4 U.S
AcidFreak96 2 years ago
democracy is the ultimate punishment for a dumbed down retarded society! remember that 51% rules the other 49% !!!
vote for torture anyone? it's supposed to keep the streets safe...
stonerj0e 3 years ago
true have u heard the saying democracy is like too wolves and a sheep deciding what to eat
Atomicnat666 3 years ago
Comment removed
samueltrevino 2 years ago
i ahte the capilatalist state of china it makes communismseem evil
Atomicnat666 3 years ago
because it is!!!
stonerj0e 3 years ago
and you like world poverty created by capiltalism
Atomicnat666 3 years ago
Communism, horrible.
Facist PLA.
Bad Rage against the machine music, ruined the video
cougarwolfhawk 3 years ago
i was still a kid in 1989. but i still remember this incident, even though i am not chinese.
mayyaz 3 years ago
I am a Chinese high school student.
As you know,the students were peaceful. but some western countries made use of the youth`s passion and the love for China. They want to break down the socialism and the communist of China.
Do you know the life of lower classes in China that time? What makes China become stronger ang stronger? Which leader want their people get suffering and sarrow? And do you know whom behind of these student? History`ll prove all the things. who are murderers
ai3abby 3 years ago 7
I thought vietnam has given the usa a lesson, now they aree getting on china's nerves. stop or you'll regret it.
061616161 3 years ago
tibet is chinese willy nilly, even Mr Bush can't say no... china has nuclear weapons that can reach washington. So better shut the hell up
061616161 3 years ago
great american anti communist propaganda in 2 min
trueservantx 4 years ago
Yes, I like it too. Great clip indeed.
wheelfly 4 years ago
way to trivialize a travesty with your music choice...
it becomes a video game
karinasquared 4 years ago
wow...wanna speak ur mind in china..lol..bad choice..in china ..i mean common..the police cud drag ur ass off at braod daylight n they wud be bno witnesese..haha..great china,great murderers
tse011 4 years ago
good video nice editing and background...history lesson in 2min 32seconds. cheers
barryh20 4 years ago
Things are not what they look like...
xnimous 4 years ago
Some soliders were burned alive. Why no pics?
They are also young people like the students. They had gun, but no shoots. Why? If I was a solider there at that time, I would shoot any students who wanna to hurt me. Kill them all!
ygao41 4 years ago
The students were peaceful, the soldiers started the violence.
kikyo4815 4 years ago
It doesn't matter who started the violence first. You have a gun with real bullets. That's enough.
kayuraaa 4 years ago
you idiot, you are just another chinese living in canada and talking split tongue-talk.
sidbarreth 4 years ago
I'm chinese,my government has hiden this truth for decades,but they never prevailed because they can't absolutely forbit the people to get informations from the outside of our country.And no matter how they wanna justify for themselves,the massacre IS a crime.If they wanna suppress the protest,why do they have to kill those people?Why don't they use the water blast gun or the tear gas?They don't have those things?That's bullshit.every excuse is so PALLID in fromt of our queries.
ethusiasm 4 years ago 7
I agree with you !
shizhinan007 4 years ago 2
Look for the NINE COMMENTARIES or internet or see the video's on YouTube. Learn the truth about CCP communists. Millions Chinese left the CCP, it's falling apart and so it's regime. Look on NINE COMMENTARIES and spread this
arafel1964 4 years ago
you don't know this at all
holdingsky 4 years ago
As far as i know units of all the different (6) armies had to take part in the massacre to prevent that any of the generals criticises the events in later times.
And rumors say that several of the units involved were drugged to put their level of aggression up and their "own free will" down
bolungdo 4 years ago
American Government should be resposible for it. It was American behind that supplied the painting and organized students with an attempt to pull over the government like what Americans doing in other place in the world.
warmleo 4 years ago
Really? Any evidence?
lzy7071 4 years ago 6
warmleo: That is weakest propaganda I ever read. All those Chinese citizens who challenged their own goverment were not manipulated by the U.S. Gave your fellow country men more credit they deserve.
myASIMO 4 years ago
Hahaha! You must be kidding?! I'm not a fan of the US but they have nothing to do with this massacre. OR maybe yes US and Europe opened those students about the despotic governement that rules China since Mao.
chongtak 4 years ago 2
This would be a laughable suggestion if it wasn't so serious. You can't seriously believe this warmleo?
ajh24 4 years ago
Americans seem to be more upset with our TIAN AN MEN square victims than Iraqi war victims, huh?
22omg22 4 years ago
Right,guy~!
shizhinan007 4 years ago
Europe is uptset about chinese government crimes as well.
chongtak 4 years ago
Ever since the PRC was founded, it's always the evil side of the Party that prevailed.
xuke3cn 4 years ago
What do the comunists say about this?
Calnevor 4 years ago
they should be glad, after all the massacre is the only reason the CCP still exists when other communist powers collapsed.
although the statement that there is still a great struggle for democracy in china is kinda wrong. with a booming economy and rising living standards, democracy isnt really on people's priority list nowadays
fludblud 4 years ago
Excellent point of view fludblud. I agree with you.
Calnevor 4 years ago
just want to point out that the students were not protesting for 'western democracy' but for a more democratic form of socialism. even this was too much for the government. china took a big step backwards that day...
garythegit 4 years ago