@ptzzone15 i'm glad someone else understands! i don't get how a lot of these people think the white stripes version is better, they totally killed the song. i couldn't even listen to it for more then a minute, it made my ears bleed!
@abbamonstergrrrr i do apologize for the bleeding in your ears. But i personally like both versions, i prefer the original because i love Tegan and Sara. But i also like the White Stripes version and how they made it there own. So there is merit to both points of the argument.
@OnlyEmoRocks i mean i like the white stripes and i get they were trying to make this into their own version, but i guess i just love the tegan & sara version so much i just feel like the killed the song, i the only part of the white stripes version of the song i like is the instrumentals, when they add in the vocals it kind of killed it for me. although it gets better at the end, since i listened to the whole song finally haha
@ptzzone15 no i don't actually. i think all these people are taking shit personal as if the stripes were trying to insult tegan and sara. bullshit! cover songs are as old as time. just because these two chicks are so precious and cute.. doesn't mean jack white is some big bad man raping their song. i am not takin shit personal on here i never do.
@ptzzone15 good comeback. you should write for pitchfork about people who write decent songs but have no personality. gee i wonder who would that could be like.. ah... hmmm.
@angryguy306 um no. the only decent thing about this song is the instrumentals, and that's the only thing that may even compare or maybe even be slightly better than the original, but the vocals by the white stripes destroyed the song. the original is way better, the vocals are one-hundred times better than this version.
I feel like there is one chord that is supposed to be or at least sound minor but it isnt..and he is a little sharp when he sings "please"..but yah. i mean whatever. nbd
I love both versions but I feel like this one was missing something. I have no idea what, but it feels...empty, if that makes sense. I love what he does with the guitar though. Idk. It had amazing potential, but something was lost in it.
as much as i love the white stripes, tegan&sara does it way better. plus i'm kind of in love with tegan so that automatically makes me love them more. hah.
because they play the song in their own way? A bad cover is one that sounds exactly like the original, who wants to listen to the same damn thing from some other artist?
@aidanday Geez no need to get your panties up in a bunch. I just said I pefer the original.. I respect u like Jack White's better and you should respect that i like T &S better
@aidanday okay... you do realize that the biggest thing that makes music "emo" are the lyrics, right? And Jack White is singing the exact same song... So is he emo? Yeah, so just be more respectful of others opinions in the future, it might do you some good later on in life.
Regardless if you like this cover or not...just think of how awesome it must be for Tegan and Sara to have THE WHITE STRIPES cover one of your songs. Crazy.
It's not that I don't like this version. I do. I love the white stripes. But I really love Tegan and Sara and have a lot of loyalty and respect towards them. So I do love the TnS version better, by far. Plus, have you heard Sara Quin sing this song? It's fucking adorable!
So wait is this T and S covering the White Stripes or the other way around? I'm slightly confused by your comments...and this doesnt sound like T and S
Im sorry i dont listen to the white stripes much. Thanks for the insult tho. Why dont you continue your pathetic life of watching stupid youtube videos and jackin off. Seems to be all that you're good at.
@Paaltaaa Jack White is only about 1000 times more important to the music of the 2000s than T & S. Best guitarist of this generation. T & S are good and all, but they're LUCKY that Jack White honored them with this cover. A lot of you guys who think this sounds choppy aren't comfortable with the experimental timing he's doing. Must take a musician to appreciate it...
@Paaltaaa Yeah. Lesbo twins. Not creepy at all. Go listen to some child abuse music. OMG, did I just imply that twin lesbians might have suffered some kind of child abuse? OMG, I did! Crazy!
@aidanday OMG are you admitting you're stupid? Crazy! Cause you do know that there are many speculations as to why some people are gay and some are not. Not a single one is child trauma... So think before you say something stupid...
What? Tegan and Sara are TWO girls.. just like the white stripes were TWO people (since when does the number of people in a band decide the quality of their recordings anyways).. and this is a cover. They did not make the song better, they interpreted it for themselves. And I don't like this version at all - it feels too choppy to me.
this is TERRIBLE. tegan & sara's version is so much better.
abbamonstergrrrr 7 months ago
@abbamonstergrrrr AGREED.
ptzzone15 7 months ago
@ptzzone15 i'm glad someone else understands! i don't get how a lot of these people think the white stripes version is better, they totally killed the song. i couldn't even listen to it for more then a minute, it made my ears bleed!
abbamonstergrrrr 7 months ago
@abbamonstergrrrr i do apologize for the bleeding in your ears. But i personally like both versions, i prefer the original because i love Tegan and Sara. But i also like the White Stripes version and how they made it there own. So there is merit to both points of the argument.
OnlyEmoRocks 7 months ago
@OnlyEmoRocks i mean i like the white stripes and i get they were trying to make this into their own version, but i guess i just love the tegan & sara version so much i just feel like the killed the song, i the only part of the white stripes version of the song i like is the instrumentals, when they add in the vocals it kind of killed it for me. although it gets better at the end, since i listened to the whole song finally haha
abbamonstergrrrr 7 months ago
@ptzzone15 its the same arrangement. get over yourself lesbian folk nazi
putdownan8dude 6 months ago
@putdownan8dude its an opinion dude. chill the fuck out. you take shit way too personally.
ptzzone15 6 months ago
@ptzzone15 no i don't actually. i think all these people are taking shit personal as if the stripes were trying to insult tegan and sara. bullshit! cover songs are as old as time. just because these two chicks are so precious and cute.. doesn't mean jack white is some big bad man raping their song. i am not takin shit personal on here i never do.
putdownan8dude 6 months ago
@putdownan8dude okay dude, whatever.
ptzzone15 6 months ago
Comment removed
putdownan8dude 6 months ago
@ptzzone15 good comeback. you should write for pitchfork about people who write decent songs but have no personality. gee i wonder who would that could be like.. ah... hmmm.
putdownan8dude 6 months ago
@abbamonstergrrrr AGREED.
ptzzone15 7 months ago
@abbamonstergrrrr Yeah.. no. This ten times better than the squeaky original version.
angryguy306 7 months ago
@angryguy306 um no. the only decent thing about this song is the instrumentals, and that's the only thing that may even compare or maybe even be slightly better than the original, but the vocals by the white stripes destroyed the song. the original is way better, the vocals are one-hundred times better than this version.
abbamonstergrrrr 7 months ago 2
@abbamonstergrrrr Yeah, uh huh, you just keep telling yourself that.
angryguy306 6 months ago
Absolutely TRASH
corndog12100 7 months ago 2
meh , mooooooooooooo
TheDandita 7 months ago
I feel like there is one chord that is supposed to be or at least sound minor but it isnt..and he is a little sharp when he sings "please"..but yah. i mean whatever. nbd
millerbeezie 8 months ago
The White Stripes along with this cover is SO much better than Tegan & Sara.. And I'm a lesbian, :p
DanaDelV 9 months ago
this blows
missbigmouth 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i sort of imagined that was megs hand on jacks arm and its kinda freaky
putdownan8dude 9 months ago
i can of imagine that's meg's hand on jack's arm and its freaking me out
putdownan8dude 9 months ago 13
@putdownan8dude Why? They're not actually siblings.
musclecars60 8 months ago
@musclecars60 Because it looks like she has a giant hairy man-hand.
suzywao 7 months ago 2
@putdownan8dude thats not her hand...its his hes crossing his arms!!!
persiancatlady2 6 months ago
@persiancatlady2 ha ha i know i just thought it was weird to think of it that way.
putdownan8dude 6 months ago
I cant see ANY big difference in versions
GuessWhoCame2U 10 months ago 3
no way!
jkonu2 10 months ago
I love both versions but I feel like this one was missing something. I have no idea what, but it feels...empty, if that makes sense. I love what he does with the guitar though. Idk. It had amazing potential, but something was lost in it.
sudachinohi 10 months ago
The White Stripes aren't emo, fags.
wyattE415 10 months ago
@wyattE415 , No...they're just fags.
this cover is complete shit.
pumkieem 8 months ago
i love tegan and sara and all
but its clear most of you have no idea who the white stripes
they are hella sick
TheElectricFirebolt 10 months ago 4
ummm no.
xobandanapanda 11 months ago
I think Tegan and Sara are better!
1994maaike 11 months ago
How about both versions are totally rad!
ephemeral1989 11 months ago 2
ok glad this is cleared up. i thought that it was the other way around
XXsk8trgrlXX 11 months ago
Tegan and Sarah suck. the'r voices are annoying. The White Stripes made this song 10 x's better!
ashleighbebe 11 months ago
@ashleighbebe lol you like the white stripes? your a douchebag they fucking suck
DJSexLeopard 11 months ago
@DJSexLeopard yeah piece of fucking shit, how dare you like a band? cunthed
davidkolo 11 months ago
@DJSexLeopard wow that bitch is stupid.
gingerlovesyou11907 10 months ago
yeahh tegan and sara please! i dont like the white stripes cover of tegan and saras song! it kinda just hurts my ears!
TheSamisgreen 1 year ago
as much as i love the white stripes, tegan&sara does it way better. plus i'm kind of in love with tegan so that automatically makes me love them more. hah.
melodye07 1 year ago
I think its better than tegan and sara
AlphaJEAN95 1 year ago 4
Good until 1:55 .
symbiotwofive 1 year ago
This is pathetic... He's playing the wrong chords and everything... Horrible...
benconoramanda 1 year ago
@benconoramanda
because they play the song in their own way? A bad cover is one that sounds exactly like the original, who wants to listen to the same damn thing from some other artist?
Aum4Matt 1 year ago 2
@benconoramanda so what the song sounds way better!
ashleighbebe 11 months ago
Jesus, people. BOTH versions are great in their own respects. Calm down...jeesh
coitinsforyourocky 1 year ago 2
for me
this one´s better :3
Qulukraly 1 year ago 3
This kills tegan and sara
kaydenkasprick 1 year ago
Terrible cover. The original is miles better.
Enfolds 1 year ago
prefer jack's and meg's.
Derakonlolz 1 year ago
gah... this sucks compared to T&S
inaction5446 1 year ago
T and S version sounds silly compare to jacks voice. idk i'm use to his voice.
kennydiedhere 1 year ago
i have to say i prefer the Tegan and Sara version better. the vocals in this one sound funny.
jaymeluce 1 year ago
lets all calm the fuck down.... OMG!@%*!%#*&%
lordrunken 1 year ago
THIS SONG IS SO FUCKING AWESOME ;p I MASTERBAIT TO IT EVERY NIGHT ;p
ihatexxmakeupiscool 1 year ago
i dont like this cover at all
NessalovesParamore 1 year ago
@NessalovesParamore Because you have bullshit garbage taste only up to T&S. Go emo more. We don't want you here.
aidanday 1 year ago
@aidanday Geez no need to get your panties up in a bunch. I just said I pefer the original.. I respect u like Jack White's better and you should respect that i like T &S better
NessalovesParamore 1 year ago
@aidanday okay... you do realize that the biggest thing that makes music "emo" are the lyrics, right? And Jack White is singing the exact same song... So is he emo? Yeah, so just be more respectful of others opinions in the future, it might do you some good later on in life.
edierockz 1 year ago
i'm sorry but this cover sucks big time (for me). It sounds so... weird, not good, hurts my ears. Ooh no, not my thing
Carolientj1 1 year ago
thts rele random. why would they jus cover tegan and sara? hm. not as good. sadly:(
hulaxhoops 1 year ago
It's actually an okay cover i expected it to suck more ...
AcousticEvan 1 year ago
@sandrajh1 actually it's the other way around, this is T and S's original song, Jack just liked it a lot and decided to cover it
81215 1 year ago
the white stripes is the orginal song T and S cover it
sandrajh1 1 year ago
gross... this version sucks! i like tegan and sara's wayyy better!
BaSKetBalLer385 1 year ago
BEST SONG EVER!!!!!
spudow 1 year ago
ewww this hurtz my ears =(
NinjaGuitarKid 1 year ago
T egan and Saras version is wayyyyyyyy better
skullcandy481 1 year ago
Regardless if you like this cover or not...just think of how awesome it must be for Tegan and Sara to have THE WHITE STRIPES cover one of your songs. Crazy.
googlethatbadboy 1 year ago
It sounds a little too all over the place but it isn't bad. It is an interesting take on the original, but the original will always be better.
TokyoPikachu 1 year ago
Fuck you all idiots,wtf they killed the music? its so good this cover,so much more better then the original!
SignUpsucker 1 year ago
I'm so loving this cover.. :3
Jazzandaliens 1 year ago
Personally, I hate this version. I think it kills the Tegan and Sara version. Ugh. ew.
I respect those who like it though.
Sieieb 1 year ago
he looks like ville valo O o
KingPinKiller666 1 year ago
Very Good cover!
bobtheking72 1 year ago
Yeah Jack is Much better sininging his songs, Little ghost is a much better white stripes song.
InvisibleChicken999 1 year ago
The autotune makes them sound like they are choking to death underwater.
mateotheflip 1 year ago
The autotune hurts my ears, original kills this song, I feel like puking.
mateotheflip 1 year ago
good cover...i am rather biest towards the girls.but like this is quite good
just proves how cool tegan and sara are that the white stipse cover them
insertBoringName 1 year ago
This is the more rocky version so it's good. The original is good to those who like the more...softer sound
Paranomasia12 1 year ago
stupid...stupid
killed it
theirishmusician 1 year ago
i don't like this... the vocals are annoying
junkee4 1 year ago
its ok i like t ans s better
kmd317 1 year ago
the white strips covered tegan and sara
maplehugs
music12348 1 year ago
I love The White Stripes!!!! In my opinion Jack White can do no wrong!!! I love this cover!!!1
JoeyRamone129 1 year ago
Had so much potential, but there are a few things that I can't get past in this cover. Sounded like it was going to be good in the beginning...
DurrennV2 1 year ago
no...
xFCUKurLyFEx 1 year ago
um i heard this version first..i wish i hadnt..
dallascwbysluver07 1 year ago
haha
RaquelTheGreat1 1 year ago
It's not that I don't like this version. I do. I love the white stripes. But I really love Tegan and Sara and have a lot of loyalty and respect towards them. So I do love the TnS version better, by far. Plus, have you heard Sara Quin sing this song? It's fucking adorable!
gliteranddisaster 1 year ago
i heard this first, but i deffinitly like them both equally.
themerseybeats 1 year ago
Definately prefer this version over the other. I do agree though, it has a bit to do with which you are more familiar with.
taryndactylable 1 year ago 2
wow.
i like tegan & sara's version SO much better...this sounds so off haha
but probably it would be the other way around if I heard this first..
teamjonaslovexo 1 year ago 11
sounds like a joke.
aliceinwonderlandx 1 year ago
People who are used to the Tegan and Sara original likes that better. But I heard this first, and I like it a lot
Jigsaw2533 1 year ago
People are hating on this song because Jack chose to sing it differently. :P
Anyway, I really like the double sound and the bass in this version. More than that, they're really similar.
fabbelabben 1 year ago 2
Sarah is the only person who should sing this i think.
DeliciousXCupcakes 1 year ago 3
Sara. But I agree.
OnaSundayMorning 1 year ago
no offense she cant sing...tegan and sara is WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY better!!!by like FARR!!!!
soraXduck23 1 year ago 2
@soraXduck23 lol, she?
bakaneko1337 1 year ago
THIS IS DEFINITELY SO MUCH BETTER
RAWRkt0729 1 year ago
I think this is so much better than Tegan & Sara's, quite glad to be in the minority as well.
tyren14 1 year ago
I love The White Stripes but for this song, Tegan and Sara ftw!
cupcaakes 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Wait a minute...White Stripes covering T&S? It's supposed to be the other way around :P
MrMeter 2 years ago
i like this one better. haha :D
koigecko 2 years ago 2
sounds like fuckin balls
mAxImUs2233 2 years ago 5
prefer tegan&sara
chika007 2 years ago 29
I love The White Stripes, since their from Detroit.....But this is a terrible cover! Tegan and Sara's version is definately better.
Green87TNT 2 years ago 5
I prefer Tegan and Sara's
Electrophonique 2 years ago 37
So wait is this T and S covering the White Stripes or the other way around? I'm slightly confused by your comments...and this doesnt sound like T and S
MapleHugs 2 years ago
this is the white stripes covering Tand S
OnlyEmoRocks 2 years ago 14
U dumb as shit
seancon37 2 years ago
Im sorry i dont listen to the white stripes much. Thanks for the insult tho. Why dont you continue your pathetic life of watching stupid youtube videos and jackin off. Seems to be all that you're good at.
MapleHugs 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
@MapleHugs the white stripes is the original T and S covered it
sandrajh1 1 year ago
i love love looooove this cover
I'm speechless
I love them so much and then they covered one of my favorite songs!
thanks for upload this
<3
entchen6 2 years ago 5
your welcome =)
OnlyEmoRocks 2 years ago
this COVER really sux...
i prefer my beautiful twins T&S ♥
Paaltaaa 2 years ago 24
i prefer Tegan and Sara's original too, but all considering it isn't a bad cover. It's a bit choppy but it doesn't suck.
OnlyEmoRocks 2 years ago 5
@OnlyEmoRocks thats just their style. Both very different styles of the same fabulous song.
tapirsrcool 1 year ago
i T-O-T-A-L-L-Y agree !!
<3
Hloune 2 years ago
@Paaltaaa Hahahaha
molly1277 1 year ago
@Paaltaaa Jack White is only about 1000 times more important to the music of the 2000s than T & S. Best guitarist of this generation. T & S are good and all, but they're LUCKY that Jack White honored them with this cover. A lot of you guys who think this sounds choppy aren't comfortable with the experimental timing he's doing. Must take a musician to appreciate it...
aidanday 1 year ago
@aidanday Yes your right Jack is great but us as T and S fans all we're saying is that we prefertheir version
NessalovesParamore 1 year ago
@NessalovesParamore Then go listen to it. T&S are a footnote. Jack White is a chapter.
aidanday 1 year ago
@aidanday everyone have theyr opinion
, and sorry if u don't like mine, thats not my problem (:
Paaltaaa 1 year ago
@Paaltaaa agreeed
NessalovesParamore 1 year ago
@Paaltaaa Yeah. Lesbo twins. Not creepy at all. Go listen to some child abuse music. OMG, did I just imply that twin lesbians might have suffered some kind of child abuse? OMG, I did! Crazy!
aidanday 1 year ago
@aidanday OMG are you admitting you're stupid? Crazy! Cause you do know that there are many speculations as to why some people are gay and some are not. Not a single one is child trauma... So think before you say something stupid...
funkymonkey25852 1 year ago
@Paaltaaa
Go suck Jack White's cock.
mussman717word 1 year ago
@mussman717word hahahah sorry for you, I dont like cocks (:
Paaltaaa 1 year ago
@Paaltaaa
Do it anyway.
mussman717word 1 year ago
@Paaltaaa they're lesbians you know.
fwaa9 1 year ago
@fwaa9 yep I know, what with that ?
Paaltaaa 1 year ago
@Paaltaaa you're so wrong . the white stripes made this song sound 10x's better.
ashleighbebe 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Stupid! sara is one girl. these are the white stripes. they made the song better with lil efort
turtlewax3585 2 years ago
what i was saying was that this is a cover and not the original
OnlyEmoRocks 2 years ago
What? Tegan and Sara are TWO girls.. just like the white stripes were TWO people (since when does the number of people in a band decide the quality of their recordings anyways).. and this is a cover. They did not make the song better, they interpreted it for themselves. And I don't like this version at all - it feels too choppy to me.
Ejwoods08 2 years ago 3
awesome quality !!
sarkisyan17 2 years ago 2
There was one other video with this song, but the quality was AWFUL. Thank you OnlyEmoRocks :)
TheCongressman1 2 years ago
no problemo
OnlyEmoRocks 2 years ago
Uh..this isn't the sara and tegan cover?? This is the original?
KurdtKobain09 2 years ago
Tegan and Sara did the original so this is a cover of their song
OnlyEmoRocks 2 years ago