Added: 3 years ago
From: revaholic
Views: 35,560
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (91)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • diana has the nice voice than fantasia diana can reach the high notes

  • *song

  • honestly, i didnt even know tht diana did this sone with her.

  • Fantasia is tha onli 1 that sings this song tha best hence why she won idol that year..... veri1 has their opinions and mine is "this is Fantasias song hands down"!!!!!

  • Considering how different these ladies voices are, this is an INCREDIBLE mashup job. Kudos.

  • WOW WHY IS DIANA SCREAMING. . .PLEASE JUST LET FANTASIA HAVE THIS SONG. . .I STILL LOVE YOU THOUGH DIANA. . .

  • If not my favourite song of all times, then definately one of my favourite songs ever .. Tamyra Gray is a genius ;)) Love the lyrics and the music..and the choir :***

    You should make a quartett out of this - With Syesha and LaKisha ;))

  • this was a hot mess

  • Fantasia owned this!! Diana was good i give her that but Fantasia just had "IT" that season....this was an excellent job on the video if i must say

  • Comment removed

  • @fbgrad07 thats not true......fantasia has better vocals than diana and doesn't sound screaming at all....its a shame you dont know a powerful voice when u hear one

  • the end was really spectacular........

  • These two sound great together and are the best Top 2 of American Idol history thus far. Season 3 was a great year for both, but Fantasia was more of an entertainer while Diana was a performer. It's true. Diana was only 16 here and Fantasia 19. I still think it's messed up that Fantasia won over Diana, but it's fair I guess because American Idol needed a soul singer that year and Fantasia was it. Diana was a vocal powerhouse, she didn't really have the whole package, They sound great together!!

  • i cant hear dianas voice well

  • @chiisuchiananderesu yeah, they should have turned down fantasia's part.. her voice is so powerful.

  • Why don't you put the Diana's Encore Version? That's sounds much better!

  • This reminded me of a Whitney and Mariah. ;) Haha!

  • Loved the video. I dont care what anyone else has to say cause they did their thing. Fantasia grew up singing this type of music and she rocked it. there was no surprise that she was gonna do her thing. their voices did go good together. people should quit tryna criticize one or the other and just say both did their thing! these were two different types of artists takin a song and doin it their own way together. i loved the performance. and thanks revaholic for the video.

  • Fantasia's voice is so loud that you can't even hear diana's voice in the chorus

  • fantasia kills, shes better than diana, dianas good too

  • It's been six years since these two competed in the Season 3 Idol Finale (Fantasia was 19 and Diana was only 16. Fantasia is now 25, and Diana 22). Their voices compliment eachother well, but I have to be honest. Diana struggled the most. Her voice was so buried underneath the heavy beat of the chorus and the powerhouse choir, that Diana strained and lost complete control. I heard she sick, the night she sang this too...whereas Fantasia, growled powerfully and was flawless. Great, overall!!

  • I appreciate both singers.  I do believe if Diana had gone up against another finalist she would have probably won. Fantasia gave a performance that demanded attention. She has much better stage presence. So after it is all said and done, Fantasia wins because she out performed Diana.

  • @jesmom NO SHE OUT SANG HER ALSO

  • @Jameela2890 I agree, Fantasia did out sing her. Her performance includes her singing. I was simply mentioning how Fantasia's complete performance made her the obvious winner. The judges were impressed with her from day one.  Fantasia is an excellent performer with an outstanding voice.

  • Was it just me, or was Diana's last note out of tune. I mean both of them had some pitch issues, but the last note....mmh mmh mmh. I felt bad for her she was so cute.

  • No it was on tune but she make her a longer note than fantasias because she had the voice and can hold a longer note too.

  • i love dianas voice but fantasia has a good voice oo but she hasnt come out with anything since season 3..diana shouldve won!!!

  • @jdogdiez8 wat are u talkin about? fantasia done SO much since then

  • ok, ok, at first I'm like, "Oh, dear GOD, whyi n the HECK did this joker mesh these two performances together??" But after listening a little further into it, I guess the two voices had the POTENTIAL to sound decent-maybe even recordable(?) Ok, that's a stretch, but I learned a valuable lesson here: Listen, then critique. You might end up putting your foot in your mouth, but that's why God made mouthwash, isn't it? :)

  • Whoa, the verse wasn't too good, but the harmony on the chorus, DIVINE!!!!!!!

  • @ fbgrad07.Fantasia has other jobs Color purple is of them she is still making her own money. Secondly Diana has a new cd? I never heard of it. Now don't get me wrong I think Diana did a great job but she did not do better than Fantasia, I know you are probably white, and I am just saying that every time a black goes up against a white some racist has to say the black was terrible, but come on Diana didnt do that song I believe the justice that Fantasia did.

  • Comment removed

  • well, that's because she's on broadway in "The Color Purple:

  • lol i can only hear fantasia,not diana

  • GREAT JOB!

  • Comment removed

  • Syesha Mercado sang it well. The best version in my opinion is Diana's Encore version! 2nd is Syesha 3rd is Rachelle then only Fantasia... You guys love Fantasia's version maybe because of the HIGH NOTE at the songs That "Higher,HIgher,higher, Higher,HIGHER"...Rachelle Ann can Do the same thing.

  • Fantasia was better :)

  • i think they wrote this song cause she was a fantasia fan. this song is kinda for her voice i love diana degarmo in my heart i believe she should of won

  • idk fantasia kinda sounds like donald duck to me n diana is just loud, the best was Latoya London

  • I will admit it was quite a shock when Latoya lost in the Top 3. If I recall there was just absolute shock for everyone.

  • she was eliminated 4th which is worse lol, she was robbed lol, but yea totally shocking, dint see that coming

  • Oh right...sorry, season 3 was so long ago I kinda forgot sorry....but yeah no way should Latoya have gone before Jasmine, that's what was even worse.

  • Latoya wasn't that awesome. I thnk J Hud and Fantasia were better.

  • honestly, I do NOT like Fantasia her voice is weird... idk its your opinion but i love love love Diana!!!!

  • I agree, HOWEVER, Fantasia's voice I think perfectly fit this song & unfortunately Diana's was just OK... But I really like Diana a whole lot.

  • they both have great voices but fantasia has a more powerful voiceee.

  • no fantasias recording is just louder then dianas because if you play them seperatly diana has more power, but they were both great

  • diana is way better than fan

  • And LaToya and Jennifer Hudson are a way better than Diana. I think Diana has no personality.

  • you can find any Gospel singer just like them LaToya and Jennifer Hudson

  • point is all 3 of them were better then fantasia, lol

  • It would have been better if it was an actual duet and not two videos that had been spliced together!

  • Fantasia's vocals are more powerful. Diana was relegated to the background towards the end. It was as if she knew it and was trying to compete with Fantasia to prove otherwise.

  • Not exactly. Because they were not singing with each other(if you look carefully you'll see that the lighting during the shots of Diana is red while the lighting throughout the shots of Fantasia is blue)

  • They were not in sync when singing and Diana sounded echo-y, as if she was singing background vocals.

  • well, duh! That's because they were not actually singing this together this video is actually two videos spliced together!

  • Fantasia owned this song...Diana just sang another song. Fantasia was the best in this competition and she proved it by winning.

  • fantasia better than diana de garmo !

    50,40% fantasia and 49,60 % for diana..\

  • Well that happened in real life too, didn't it?

  • That's cause they weren't actually singing together, the lighting is different for the two girls (it was red for diana and blue for fantasia)

  • @fbgrad07 WELL SMART KID ITS NOT A REAL DUET THEY JUST PLAYED THE SONGS AT THE SAME TIME!

  • they sound so good together!

    go fantasia!

    go diana!

    go God!

    go me!

    go everybody!

  • that was fantastic revaholic,

    great job!!

  • thanks :)

  • Fantasia is on another level. Diana was too young and immature.

  • Diana should have put on a choir robe and sang with the choir because ummm...Fantasia STOLE the show!! I'm sure Diana would've sounded great by herself..but she sounded like somebody trying to do karaoke with the full version, lol. I was like What is that noise? smh AI knew better. Kudos tho'!

  • awesome! loved it!

  • Wow, nice job mixing this! When you hear them side by side Diana's range really stands out as the song builds.

  • Fantasia the best idol ever.....special special, special

  • somebody sounds like a frog in here.

  • LMFAO

  • they sound great together

  • This duet is amazing. this was done very well. i love it.

  • They sound really good together! However I know for a fact that a duet of them with Diana's encore performance from the Grand Finale nite would be better. Diana and Fantasia both sang better the Grand Finale night when the winner was announced, and they both performed this song that night as well. Could you possibly do a duet version of their performances from that night?

  • Wow, the chorus on this is awesome! :O

  • WOW GOOD JOB

  • wow this is good. kudos to the one who made it.

  • Wow, it sounds like a real duet. I like it!

  • Still one of the best performances of all time.

  • fantasias voice really compliments diana's in this, sounds really good, like a main singer and the strong background :)

  • thanks :)

  • The ending is amazing. The different styles they use to sing the songs form so well there. It seems as if it were a real duet. I love the both of them. That was a hard final for me to pick a favorite. All in all though man props for this video. You did a very very good job.

  • thanks :)

  • is this just dianas voice being mixed up into one of fantasias videos and fantasias voice mixed into dianas video??? becaude there is no point in the video where they are both together

  • Their voices are overlapped throughout the entire video.

  • ohh so you edited it that way?

  • yup, to make it seem like they are singing together.

  • oh ok...well great job!! it really looks eal

  • fantasia' version 1000 times better than Diana's

  • yr comment TOTALLY defeat the purpose of posting this video by the user!

  • thank u some 1 wit some sense im addin u as a friend

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more