It would be nice if Barry would go on tour with Robin. He is missing an opportunity to be with his brother. I feel like Barry deserted Robin when he needs him the most.
WOW, I've never heard him so off key and so are the backup singers. They need to fire the producer & for sure fire the Audio Engineer. This is the worst mix I've heard from any band in a long time.
sadly to say, its really a disservice for him to perform these songs without Barry...there are some clips of him on here on some British show and he mangles everything song he tries to sing...they'll always be one of my all time favorites...
Robin is great on his lead songs and Barry's ballads, these ones are just slipped in to liven the crowd up. His live solo performing has matured quite a lot since this and before anyway.
@chriscrimson98 Oh god i have to agree they both have awesome voices but some songs don't sound good in Robyn voice and visa versa .... miss that 3 part harmony ...please stick to the songs that suit them or better still write new ones just love these guys but this doesn't seem right
To be honest Robins Falsetto is a little weaker than Barry's but he can reach a higher pitch. You can hear them together on Stayin Alive with Robin bouncing around over the top of Barry's lead.
pero que temaso, nunca le habia puesto atencion, los cantantes y los musicos excelentes, ojala yo pudiera participar en algo parecido asi ... snif me emociono
Or maybe not according to this audience watch?v=ZQoNV8eQShw , pretty sure Robin wasn't particularly enthusiastic about this performance here but when a audience is up he can work miracles, as you can see by the audience reaction on the video I linked of Tradegy at the end.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
man you are pathetic to believe he can work miracles lol... this performance just proved every thing i said about robin being a back up singer to barry and maurice lol.....
The atmosphere is dead, he is playing with this orchestra for the first time, the event is free entry,and he is of course singing this song simply to please the audience, but since there isn't really one, I'd be a bit miserable, here is a orcehstra concert with a massive crowd in a gig that came after this one, the crowd love it, standing ovations all over the place even for fever songs, have a watch of this, I don't want you to think he is pathetic.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Robin is really pathetic. I feel sorry for his backing singers having to try and save him from complete embarrassment. His performances are terrible. He doesn't even seem to enjoy singing, it's painful to watch.
Sorry, forgot to hit reply, but also check the performance in Germany this January, his voice has never failed this year, I think you'll like Jive Talkin.
Just don't let that obscure bandless Miss World thing or some selected fever songs from this marr you're view of Robin, I think he's allowed 2 non gigs, one of which being free, one of which not being a gig, in his 40 year career, and my watching of his performances is almost stalkerish, he enjoys it when its right, which it normally is.:)
Yeah, if you want an example of a perfect Robin Gibb performance, with good backers, I point you to the Dubai March 08 performance, and the January 08 and December 07 performances in Germany, Robin's website has the sound files.
Whats this for a kind of concert?? Seems like nobody´s there... And Robin normally can sing, but this version is not nice, think he had to sing alone without background-singers...
@tweeny7935 I couldn't do it better, but it wouldn't change the fact that this is a weak performance. I love the Bee Gees, and I've long felt that Robin has a stunning voice. Of course anyone can have an off day, but the man is a seasoned pro. He should be held to a higher standard.
ya, a tragedy. However, I think they just wanted to have fun traveling around. They really did not care what the audiences felt or how the viewers like us would comment on their performance. Robin has already achieved too much. He deserves to have a break once or twice in a while. Have fun Robin.
I think the backups were being kinda silly cause the crowd was dead and theyw ere trying to get them back into it. Robin has a look on his face at 2:00 like he's just there becuase he has to be. too bad, cause the orchestra sounded great.
I'm a huge fan, but Robin sounds like some amateur doing karaoke singing alone. No comparison to Barry's voice, and he needs to lose the back-up singers. That blondie acts like Blondie.
Oh my God!!!! What a horrible version of tragedy. Please Robin stop trying to be Barry. You just cant sing falsetto. How embarrassing for such a great group.
No, Barry is not gone. Currently he is working on a country album with his sons and one song "Drown on the River" has already been released. He and Robin said several months ago that they may reunite later this year or next year for an album or possible tour. I'm counting on it! :)
Robin is actually an excellent falsetto singer. His falsetto on "Living Together" from the Spirits Having Flown album is just as good as any Barry falsetto lead. I'm not sure why Robin doesn't do falsetto on these Bee Gees songs when he does solo concerts.
What the heck was that?
craigs1001 6 months ago
LOS BEE GEES JUNTOS SIIII SEPARADOS JAMAS !!! RECUERDEN QUE SON LEYENDA Y TODO EL MUNDO LOS QUIERE VER JUNTOS!!!
metallicagosh 9 months ago
It would be nice if Barry would go on tour with Robin. He is missing an opportunity to be with his brother. I feel like Barry deserted Robin when he needs him the most.
Ekaran37 1 year ago
WOW, I've never heard him so off key and so are the backup singers. They need to fire the producer & for sure fire the Audio Engineer. This is the worst mix I've heard from any band in a long time.
WulfBand 1 year ago
barry gibb sonuds better!!!
jackassmex1 1 year ago
...a great tragedy :-o
enkilmio 1 year ago
this performance is a real! tragedy....
piksieben 1 year ago 3
sorry there are just some songs that don't suit Robyn's voice stick to those that do
annettelane 1 year ago
The backup singers sounded better. Thats sad!!!! Let your older bro handle it.
MegaBabygirl30 1 year ago
Nice try but no.
cyndym2001 1 year ago
How sad. It totally doesn't remind me of the glory days of the Bee Gees,
DhrHH 1 year ago
que merda!!!! cagaram a musica toda, cadê o Barry???
que tragediaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!
wellissone 1 year ago
WOW! (and not in a good way)
supercrossdog 2 years ago
Exatamente como diz o título da canção...Trajédia...Que trajédia sem a voz do Barry...literalmente falando...que trajédia!!!
Nicautomation 2 years ago
sadly to say, its really a disservice for him to perform these songs without Barry...there are some clips of him on here on some British show and he mangles everything song he tries to sing...they'll always be one of my all time favorites...
chriscrimson98 2 years ago
Robin is great on his lead songs and Barry's ballads, these ones are just slipped in to liven the crowd up. His live solo performing has matured quite a lot since this and before anyway.
LukeShoveller 2 years ago
@chriscrimson98 Oh god i have to agree they both have awesome voices but some songs don't sound good in Robyn voice and visa versa .... miss that 3 part harmony ...please stick to the songs that suit them or better still write new ones just love these guys but this doesn't seem right
annettelane 1 year ago
Se oye y se ve como el puto culo, menuda mierda.
666aceofbase 2 years ago
FALTA LA VOZ DE BARRY
elfrausto1 2 years ago
To be honest Robins Falsetto is a little weaker than Barry's but he can reach a higher pitch. You can hear them together on Stayin Alive with Robin bouncing around over the top of Barry's lead.
Robin should do the songs in Falsetto I think.
tesstink 2 years ago 3
You are so right. I saw him yesterday in Roskilde (Denmark), and i also think that his falcetto was way to weak. Good show anuway.
1heavycheavy 2 years ago
This is bad the bee gees are superb but this is very bad especially with those god awful backing singers.
snoozingphil 2 years ago
this is a tragedy
iceaxe56 2 years ago
Hunters, you say that on every single Bee Gees video, you are just an idiot.
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
kill the croaking chicken lol... back up singer is sing much better then robin lol...
hunters11111 3 years ago
The croaking chicken was the backup singers. I think Robin could do well on his own with just a bit of change on the music. To much backgroud noise.
robinisfun 3 years ago
How moronic. If u don't like the Bee Gees STOP WATCHING THEM lol goshhhh ha!
ilsy74 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Don't read this
PauloNessaBosta 3 years ago
I have to agree, this song was written for Barry's falsetto (spelling?) but thank you for sharing
Brianna32571 3 years ago 2
pero que temaso, nunca le habia puesto atencion, los cantantes y los musicos excelentes, ojala yo pudiera participar en algo parecido asi ... snif me emociono
bobbyconvideos 3 years ago
Robin should have left this song to Barry, I think...
Emmalala123 3 years ago
Or maybe not according to this audience watch?v=ZQoNV8eQShw , pretty sure Robin wasn't particularly enthusiastic about this performance here but when a audience is up he can work miracles, as you can see by the audience reaction on the video I linked of Tradegy at the end.
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
man you are pathetic to believe he can work miracles lol... this performance just proved every thing i said about robin being a back up singer to barry and maurice lol.....
hunters11111 3 years ago
xvr el tema ah! mi banda del cole va a tocar! px este tema!
alexanderSC789123 3 years ago
Robin Gibb: siempre tan genial.
Es uno de los mejores artístas que existen.
The BeeGees 4ever!
MariadeElSol 3 years ago
The atmosphere is dead, he is playing with this orchestra for the first time, the event is free entry,and he is of course singing this song simply to please the audience, but since there isn't really one, I'd be a bit miserable, here is a orcehstra concert with a massive crowd in a gig that came after this one, the crowd love it, standing ovations all over the place even for fever songs, have a watch of this, I don't want you to think he is pathetic.
watch?v=5xARvsoYhXo&
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Robin is really pathetic. I feel sorry for his backing singers having to try and save him from complete embarrassment. His performances are terrible. He doesn't even seem to enjoy singing, it's painful to watch.
beautifulbitterns 3 years ago
Sorry, forgot to hit reply, but also check the performance in Germany this January, his voice has never failed this year, I think you'll like Jive Talkin.
Just don't let that obscure bandless Miss World thing or some selected fever songs from this marr you're view of Robin, I think he's allowed 2 non gigs, one of which being free, one of which not being a gig, in his 40 year career, and my watching of his performances is almost stalkerish, he enjoys it when its right, which it normally is.:)
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
Yeah, if you want an example of a perfect Robin Gibb performance, with good backers, I point you to the Dubai March 08 performance, and the January 08 and December 07 performances in Germany, Robin's website has the sound files.
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
Whats this for a kind of concert?? Seems like nobody´s there... And Robin normally can sing, but this version is not nice, think he had to sing alone without background-singers...
Steve167de 3 years ago
hahaha:D nice crowd :DD
GlamAegnor 3 years ago
Pathetic
jasondenbakker 3 years ago 2
upload yourself singing this song if you think that you can sing it better than Robin. Please do share your voice with us.
tweeny7935 3 years ago 2
@tweeny7935 I couldn't do it better, but it wouldn't change the fact that this is a weak performance. I love the Bee Gees, and I've long felt that Robin has a stunning voice. Of course anyone can have an off day, but the man is a seasoned pro. He should be held to a higher standard.
jonthom11702 2 years ago
Barry is the greatest
cbmsv 3 years ago 2
ya, a tragedy. However, I think they just wanted to have fun traveling around. They really did not care what the audiences felt or how the viewers like us would comment on their performance. Robin has already achieved too much. He deserves to have a break once or twice in a while. Have fun Robin.
jess0060 3 years ago
I think the backups were being kinda silly cause the crowd was dead and theyw ere trying to get them back into it. Robin has a look on his face at 2:00 like he's just there becuase he has to be. too bad, cause the orchestra sounded great.
gameshowfreak2007 4 years ago
I'm a huge fan, but Robin sounds like some amateur doing karaoke singing alone. No comparison to Barry's voice, and he needs to lose the back-up singers. That blondie acts like Blondie.
curlysue6 4 years ago
it´s really a tragedy...
freddie1818 4 years ago
VERY AGREED!
MOFANSHK 3 years ago
Oh my God!!!! What a horrible version of tragedy. Please Robin stop trying to be Barry. You just cant sing falsetto. How embarrassing for such a great group.
mzsunflower8175 4 years ago
Is Barry just gone completely or what. Does Robin really need to keep working at this point?
dmnarc 4 years ago
No, Barry is not gone. Currently he is working on a country album with his sons and one song "Drown on the River" has already been released. He and Robin said several months ago that they may reunite later this year or next year for an album or possible tour. I'm counting on it! :)
dropjawbertone 4 years ago
Robin is actually an excellent falsetto singer. His falsetto on "Living Together" from the Spirits Having Flown album is just as good as any Barry falsetto lead. I'm not sure why Robin doesn't do falsetto on these Bee Gees songs when he does solo concerts.
dropjawbertone 4 years ago
If Robin cannot sing in falsetto, how the held you make this single, how you do 3 part harmony in falsetto?
yesilike101 4 years ago
I love the Bee Gees, Robin included, but that sounds like crap.
jonthom11702 4 years ago
Silly Backup singers.. Great performance on Robin Gibb.
YowR33 4 years ago
good job robin
kuuipo03 4 years ago