"feel the music" is replaced by "sing the music" as a musician grows. I've hear Barrueco say this and many others. It's the same thing, so no reason to belittle someone else for saying your preferred version.
I'll line up with those that prefer this interpretation over Williams, mostly because of the more serene dynamics and expressiveness, that convey much more mystery, in a sense. Still it's not ideal, for me, I would like the dissonant and forte parts much more extreme, it's a romantic piece after all. I feel -as controversial as it might sound- that a lot of these "by the book" classical performers would do well to listen to some heavy metal music, or other contemporary genres as daring as that.
Yes, but first than all I want to be clear that this is just my opinion. FOR ME... Williams is one of the best players, I can't deny that, but sometimes I feel he forget to feel the music and just play everything "perfect" I like better this INTERPRETATION (not necesarly the execution) because this guy projects the idea of the song, you know... the Poe's tale... that's why I said it's better =) I will record it later soon and you let me know what you think about it ok?
"feeling the music" is a meaningless expression that amateurs who don't know what they're talking about use. If anything, this guy does about the same amount expressively as Williams, just in a different way.
well, that's your opinion.. I have been studying classical guitar for 10 years with very good professors, including David Mozqueda, "feel the music" is something that I use because that's what I think.. but whatever, you be upset about what I said of JW, either that, or you have a big ego...
While I still feel this is the best live performance of this piece, and his studio take is outstanding as well, but does this seem a bit fast to anyone?
Most amazing about this interpretation is the sound. The guitar remains musical, not percussive even when most percussive effects are played. Could someone, preferably a professional guitar player explain how could it achieved?
no no nooooo!!!! stronger stronger, not faster, but stronger... doesnt matter if you fail in some parts, maybe is part of the euforia of the song, break the guitar... jump from the yang to the ying, dont take care of the center, you have to feel mad mad MAD...
I agree, it's a wonderful piece, but, please, let people say "how amazing is the power of music!!" is better doing some imprecison than playing steadly! I think this piece this piece needs to be played by a brave man...
Comment removed
arr4gtr 5 months ago
molto molto bravo giusta interpretazione
GianculaT 1 year ago
excellent technique as clear as JW
simples244 1 year ago
@what567
"feel the music" is replaced by "sing the music" as a musician grows. I've hear Barrueco say this and many others. It's the same thing, so no reason to belittle someone else for saying your preferred version.
petruvai 1 year ago
Really enjoyable performance. You get a nice sound. And what kind of guitar?
Rogeetar 1 year ago
I'll line up with those that prefer this interpretation over Williams, mostly because of the more serene dynamics and expressiveness, that convey much more mystery, in a sense. Still it's not ideal, for me, I would like the dissonant and forte parts much more extreme, it's a romantic piece after all. I feel -as controversial as it might sound- that a lot of these "by the book" classical performers would do well to listen to some heavy metal music, or other contemporary genres as daring as that.
Phthgn 2 years ago 6
@Phthgn Yes, i definitely agree with what you said and that this is a way better interpretation than that of Williams.
tranzenic 1 year ago
i still like JW's interpretation :P
njevren 2 years ago
I think this is the best interpretation I've seen in youtube, I'm agree that it's a little fast, but defentetly better than Williams...
I really love this song...
to Favorites!
Krakheit 2 years ago 2
In which aspects is it better? Can you explain?
supermanalexk 2 years ago
Yes, but first than all I want to be clear that this is just my opinion. FOR ME... Williams is one of the best players, I can't deny that, but sometimes I feel he forget to feel the music and just play everything "perfect" I like better this INTERPRETATION (not necesarly the execution) because this guy projects the idea of the song, you know... the Poe's tale... that's why I said it's better =) I will record it later soon and you let me know what you think about it ok?
Krakheit 2 years ago 2
fair enough. I hate how people try and say how someone is better than the other, with out being able to explain.
supermanalexk 2 years ago
don't worry, I hate that too, it's called being a sheep xD =P what do you think about all this?
Krakheit 2 years ago
"feeling the music" is a meaningless expression that amateurs who don't know what they're talking about use. If anything, this guy does about the same amount expressively as Williams, just in a different way.
what567 2 years ago 2
well, that's your opinion.. I have been studying classical guitar for 10 years with very good professors, including David Mozqueda, "feel the music" is something that I use because that's what I think.. but whatever, you be upset about what I said of JW, either that, or you have a big ego...
Krakheit 2 years ago
While I still feel this is the best live performance of this piece, and his studio take is outstanding as well, but does this seem a bit fast to anyone?
clearlynotstefan 2 years ago
Fantastic performance, with many colours; not than John Williams in "Seville Concert", more mechanic!!
To my favourites!
Grretings from Spain
Marcos
mom17565 2 years ago
I don't think Williams understands the terms rall, rit, meno mosso when playing Usher Waltz!
JoeSnakes 2 years ago
Excellent!
Curatica 2 years ago
Very musical and inspiring. Very well done. Great sound and dynamics!
bzeliotis 2 years ago
Most amazing about this interpretation is the sound. The guitar remains musical, not percussive even when most percussive effects are played. Could someone, preferably a professional guitar player explain how could it achieved?
DonAnzalone 2 years ago
Sorry to ask, but , Could anyone hand me the partiture for this beatiful piece?
, i would love to play it
Cancinico 2 years ago
Comment removed
glassandglass 2 years ago
YES! BIG ONE!
king3rnie 2 years ago
I love this!
I'm working on this piece right now... you definitely have given me some direction and inspiration.
Thank you!!
steffanii 2 years ago
The best performance for this piece
pirki72
pirki72 3 years ago
Bravo!
psutak 3 years ago
THIS IS MY MAESTRO!!! U ROCK!!
estebanstevo930 3 years ago
Bravo This is much more better than Mr John Willims Pirki72
pirki72 3 years ago
Very expressiv bravo pirki72
pirki72 3 years ago
Great！
Gloverlee 3 years ago
Bravissimo !!!
Great playing!
Thanks for sharing,
wolfgang
Vreci 3 years ago
very nice...I am thinking about working up this piece for my senior recital.
csdavis12 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I wish I was as cool as you so I could play a great song like shit.
basscadet4 4 years ago
no no nooooo!!!! stronger stronger, not faster, but stronger... doesnt matter if you fail in some parts, maybe is part of the euforia of the song, break the guitar... jump from the yang to the ying, dont take care of the center, you have to feel mad mad MAD...
ajeleandro 4 years ago 13
I agree, it's a wonderful piece, but, please, let people say "how amazing is the power of music!!" is better doing some imprecison than playing steadly! I think this piece this piece needs to be played by a brave man...
eriksatie9 3 years ago
Love the harmonics. Eerie.
Very cool.
mackayde 4 years ago
THIS RULES
SteveFeces 4 years ago 2
Studying with Mr. Partington has been the most beneficial musical experience of my life. He's a national treasure.
bachrock86 4 years ago
ownage
Utubesuxmycock 4 years ago
well do it
ivanguitarro 5 years ago
muy bien logrado
ivanguitarro 5 years ago
very nice!!!!
phalopalo 5 years ago
Bravo!
Abs0lutGuitar 5 years ago