for manchurians I am sorry because we lost,but anyway China did selfindependence from inside China, so purpose was the same as our wishes.
Mao Tse-tung said without Japan, we could not be independence.you dont need say sorry.
I hope we can eat food without any provety if below comments is right.it is great Qing Dynasty will always. China will consider if it is so.let them eat pal thanks.
The Qing invoked the mandate of Heaven which is a Chinese tradition. The legitimate rulers of China do not need to come from a particular race or clan, so long as they govern well. This is the superior nature of the Chinese political system.
what is interesting is when the Qing Dynasty fell, the Manchus assimilated theirselves into the Chinese population to avoid persecution and wiped out their own ethnicity in the process, leaving little trace of the Mancu race in China today
You say the Tang were Xianbei? Possibly, but who cares? In fact, the first unified Chinese dynasty, the Qin, had barbarian roots. But (then) again, who cares?
Ein typisches Chinesisches Lied, was auch mit Gesang unterlegt sich sehr gut anhört, wird heutzutage oft auf Folklore CD`s angeboten, was so schlecht nicht ist, weil es dadurch auch der breiten Masse zugänglich wird.
western history books document the chinese rush to manchuria- called "闖關東", which was made legal by the QING government, AFTER russian encroachment on manchuria.
strange how the russians evicted manchus and flooded outer manchuria with russian people, but people only complain about the chinese side, which was made possible by the manchus themselves.
and puyi himself had a han chinese grandmother, who was adopted into a manchu clan.
China was at it's political, military and cultural pinnacle during the realm of the greatest Manchu emperor Aisin Girio Kangxi. Chinese scholars and historians popularly refer that period of time as " The Golden Era of Chinese civilisation"
very true monarchist. the thing is the Qing continued what the earlier han dyansties began and refined, they just added a little more vigor to the administration in the first half of the dynasty. unfortunately China was powerful long before the Manchus and they basically are taking back what they think is old Chinese territory from "barbarians". hence the great wall... that's just my opinion anyway
Tang is more related to the Xianbei, and when Ming was built, there pure Chinese didn't existed. Untill they revive ethinc Han Chinese (actually fabricated one for the purpose of political rule), Han Chinese were one of dead minorities.
@Cheon1Son Tang is more related to XianBei?? I doubt how much XianBei blood is in Tang emperors.... pure Chin didn't exist? Does pure Kor exist? Han Chinese were one of dead minorities? evidence?
Someone can tell you a color is black when it's black, but if your Communist government wants your people to say it's white, then all of you will say it's white. I just told you moron. Stop being lazy and go to the Beijing Library. It's the biggest library in BEIJING. Look up the founders of the JIN DYNASTY. This is why no one believes in your history. You kids don't make any sense.
@joeangtong ---------->Asking for preferrencial treatment smacks of racism. That's what nazis say. Everyone contributed in some way or another 2 the development of the world, China included.
there is no doubt that chinese civilisation and culture reached its pinnacle during manchu rule in china. The present chinese was mouided by the geart manchu people.
What constitutes the pinnacle of culture is debatable -others have said that was in the Ming era. However, China reached its peak in size, power and tributary states during the Qing era -that is a fact.
@joeangtong I thought the Manchus greatly admired Chinese culture and literature. Hence, the emperors themselves had to learn Mandarin etc. And Mandarin is not a Manchurian language! Each dynasty started as great and then go down the hill. And other dynasty would start.
@phoenixjade1955 The Manchurians *created* Mandarin. The evidence is in Matteo Ricci's (Italian court official of the Ming Dynasty) dictionary and romanization of Chinese words. All the words that were supposed to have stop consonants such as -p, -t, -k, and -m were still evident in his book, not to mention pronunciation simillar to older Chinese languages like Cantonese and Shanghainese, amongst others. It takes centuries for languages to evolve, but only a couple decades needed to butcher it.
@TaiGekTou well I made a mistake,actually Tang Dynasty official language was closer to Fujian dialects rather than Cantonese dialect,Cantonese dialect was actually closest to Song Dynasty official language.
But they always try to protect their people from assimilation they were sucessfull in early days of the empire and little by little failed to achieve a compelte separation even so nothing compare to what Communists aftewards as anny "Praisefull" Communists. The Communists creat the myth of a Single China a Single Chineses as oposed to the Multi Cultural and Multi National realm that was under the Quing and so all other minorities that werent "Chinese" had to go including many times even Han!
The founder of the Jin Dynasty are Koreans. Written in Chinese history and also in Japanese history. We Koreans don't have to do anything to prove, it's just there all around us
pray tell, what history records are you talking about? show me the records? show me the historians who say that? or are they some crap from wikipedia LOL!
the greatest empire in china 5000 years of history is manchu empire. The Manchu people rule over china for more than 250 years. It is a golden era of chinese civilisation.
for manchurians I am sorry because we lost,but anyway China did selfindependence from inside China, so purpose was the same as our wishes.
Mao Tse-tung said without Japan, we could not be independence.you dont need say sorry.
I hope we can eat food without any provety if below comments is right.it is great Qing Dynasty will always. China will consider if it is so.let them eat pal thanks.
God bless you all.
hebrews11jp 6 months ago
how sad, many manchurians are living in poverty today :/
nangdoninja 8 months ago
what is a name of music a like China !
Bonsay3 11 months ago
应该注明一下谁是谁
xiongsyc 1 year ago
DEATH TO COMMUNISM!
May the butchers Lenin and Mao burn in the depths of Hell!
PaulieRomanov 1 year ago 11
The Qing invoked the mandate of Heaven which is a Chinese tradition. The legitimate rulers of China do not need to come from a particular race or clan, so long as they govern well. This is the superior nature of the Chinese political system.
Bloodlovefreak 1 year ago
what is interesting is when the Qing Dynasty fell, the Manchus assimilated theirselves into the Chinese population to avoid persecution and wiped out their own ethnicity in the process, leaving little trace of the Mancu race in China today
aIteredbeast 1 year ago
ooh! i like the instrumental song you used! what is it called?
shadowalchemist24 1 year ago
lol looks like a couple people here studied out of different text books.
chemicalsweet13 1 year ago
You say the Tang were Xianbei? Possibly, but who cares? In fact, the first unified Chinese dynasty, the Qin, had barbarian roots. But (then) again, who cares?
DifangDuana 1 year ago
Ein typisches Chinesisches Lied, was auch mit Gesang unterlegt sich sehr gut anhört, wird heutzutage oft auf Folklore CD`s angeboten, was so schlecht nicht ist, weil es dadurch auch der breiten Masse zugänglich wird.
MrTsingtau 1 year ago
western history books document the chinese rush to manchuria- called "闖關東", which was made legal by the QING government, AFTER russian encroachment on manchuria.
strange how the russians evicted manchus and flooded outer manchuria with russian people, but people only complain about the chinese side, which was made possible by the manchus themselves.
and puyi himself had a han chinese grandmother, who was adopted into a manchu clan.
64654634243 1 year ago
Korean=Jurchens=Manchus=same people just different tribes of Altaic peoples.
stirrednotshaken7 1 year ago
@stirrednotshaken7 That is so not true. Manchu ruled Qing China, Koreans were a vassal state of Qing.
WuTangtst 1 year ago
China was at it's political, military and cultural pinnacle during the realm of the greatest Manchu emperor Aisin Girio Kangxi. Chinese scholars and historians popularly refer that period of time as " The Golden Era of Chinese civilisation"
in 5000 years of chinese histrory.
Perdakim1 1 year ago
May China returns to it's imperial roots. Long live the Son of Heaven, the Lord of Ten Thousand Years..!!!
Aryasna 1 year ago
manchu people are aristocrats, during the realm of the greatest chinese emperor Aisin Girio Kang xi. Han people are just defeated war slave.
joeangtong 1 year ago
very true monarchist. the thing is the Qing continued what the earlier han dyansties began and refined, they just added a little more vigor to the administration in the first half of the dynasty. unfortunately China was powerful long before the Manchus and they basically are taking back what they think is old Chinese territory from "barbarians". hence the great wall... that's just my opinion anyway
Alusnovalotus 2 years ago
the greatest dynasty in china is the qing dynasty.
The qing dynasty was founded by the great manchu people.
joeangtong 2 years ago
@joeangtong
Can't really say the greatest as China has a lot of great dynasties such as the Tang, and Ming.
Zergcerebrates 1 year ago
@Zergcerebrates
Tang is more related to the Xianbei, and when Ming was built, there pure Chinese didn't existed. Untill they revive ethinc Han Chinese (actually fabricated one for the purpose of political rule), Han Chinese were one of dead minorities.
Cheon1Son 1 year ago
@Cheon1Son Tang is more related to XianBei?? I doubt how much XianBei blood is in Tang emperors.... pure Chin didn't exist? Does pure Kor exist? Han Chinese were one of dead minorities? evidence?
canadianfirzen 1 year ago
Someone can tell you a color is black when it's black, but if your Communist government wants your people to say it's white, then all of you will say it's white. I just told you moron. Stop being lazy and go to the Beijing Library. It's the biggest library in BEIJING. Look up the founders of the JIN DYNASTY. This is why no one believes in your history. You kids don't make any sense.
ryunbaik 2 years ago
the great manchu people should be given special right and preference in china . Their contribution to modern china is so great.
joeangtong 2 years ago
@joeangtong ---------->Asking for preferrencial treatment smacks of racism. That's what nazis say. Everyone contributed in some way or another 2 the development of the world, China included.
xxxdieselyyy2 6 months ago
there is no doubt that chinese civilisation and culture reached its pinnacle during manchu rule in china. The present chinese was mouided by the geart manchu people.
joeangtong 2 years ago
Chinese civilisation and culture reached its pinnacle during the Tang Dynasty, not the Qing.
Deuszxable 2 years ago 2
What constitutes the pinnacle of culture is debatable -others have said that was in the Ming era. However, China reached its peak in size, power and tributary states during the Qing era -that is a fact.
MadMonarchist 2 years ago
Yes, that's true.
Deuszxable 2 years ago
that's right. but the physical size of china reached it's zenith under the qing...or was it under the yuan?
it's science was best under the song.
for sheer imperial despotism and extravagance ming was even more absolute than qing.
vsovereign2 2 years ago
@Deuszxable Tang was Altaic Kingdom as majorith of Tang ruling class were of Altiac.
klee4 1 year ago
@joeangtong I thought the Manchus greatly admired Chinese culture and literature. Hence, the emperors themselves had to learn Mandarin etc. And Mandarin is not a Manchurian language! Each dynasty started as great and then go down the hill. And other dynasty would start.
phoenixjade1955 1 year ago
@phoenixjade1955 The Manchurians *created* Mandarin. The evidence is in Matteo Ricci's (Italian court official of the Ming Dynasty) dictionary and romanization of Chinese words. All the words that were supposed to have stop consonants such as -p, -t, -k, and -m were still evident in his book, not to mention pronunciation simillar to older Chinese languages like Cantonese and Shanghainese, amongst others. It takes centuries for languages to evolve, but only a couple decades needed to butcher it.
TaiGekTou 1 year ago
@TaiGekTou well I made a mistake,actually Tang Dynasty official language was closer to Fujian dialects rather than Cantonese dialect,Cantonese dialect was actually closest to Song Dynasty official language.
BATURUSHA 6 months ago
@BATURUSHA you can go Youtube now call (CONVERSATIONAL MANCHURIAN LESSON 1) i m learning manchu language over there.
samquan123 4 months ago
But they always try to protect their people from assimilation they were sucessfull in early days of the empire and little by little failed to achieve a compelte separation even so nothing compare to what Communists aftewards as anny "Praisefull" Communists. The Communists creat the myth of a Single China a Single Chineses as oposed to the Multi Cultural and Multi National realm that was under the Quing and so all other minorities that werent "Chinese" had to go including many times even Han!
ImperialGuard9001 11 months ago
The founder of the Jin Dynasty are Koreans. Written in Chinese history and also in Japanese history. We Koreans don't have to do anything to prove, it's just there all around us
ryunbaik 2 years ago
You mean the Jianzhou Jurchens?
Deuszxable 2 years ago
pray tell, what history records are you talking about? show me the records? show me the historians who say that? or are they some crap from wikipedia LOL!
realgookhistory 2 years ago 3
the greatest empire in china 5000 years of history is manchu empire. The Manchu people rule over china for more than 250 years. It is a golden era of chinese civilisation.
perdakim 2 years ago
@perdakim
Tang Dynasty was actually the golden era of China!
codeagent47 2 years ago 5
Thank you for sharing this wonderful video on YouTube!
artbabee 2 years ago