it never seems like during these "all star" wankfests, that anyone was put in charge of actually coordinated and arranging these so called tributes, which turn it out to be disasters usually....Lennon's been dead for some time now, so they cant say they didnt have time to get this shit together....had someone properly got these guys together and worked out harmonies, solos etc., it might have had a chance...instead slap em all together and you get a multi-millionaire soup of mediocrity..
no man deserves to be on that stage singing that song, none of them could even come close to dreaming to accomplish as much as john lennon & the beatles. If you can't do a song justice, you don't do it at all.
These people sang the song to Commemorate the Beatles. It's not that they sang it bad...it is REMEMBERING the Ones (The Beatles) who immortalized the song.
i agree they ruined it but at the same time it shows me how much respect people have for the beatles cuz instead of trying to say there better then the beatles they do a cover
aww....This totaly sux i dont like it.....they choose the wrong people to sing such a good song...i like alicias k.'s voice but i dont like it in this song...:(..it doesnt go ith it it SUX!!!! well compared to the real version
This is incredibly poor and the guy with red hair only wants to sound like Bowie....he certainly isnt him. Why the hell is there a cowboy on this stage???? Norah Jones is singing way too low...Bono is always lost without his band....Wilson is past it...Lennon is rolling in his freaking grave
No offense to any of these singers, but I've heard better group singing from my drunk co-workers at holiday parties... and trust me... they don't sing sober for a reason.
This was recorded at the Grammys a couple of years ago. It sounds badly underrehearsed by the singers, with the exception of Bono, Steve Tyler, and Tim McGraw. And the band really kicks it. Geez big singing stars--you know you're going on national TV to perform this song, couldn't you at least PRACTICE it so you don't look like idiots?
everyone should've just turned off their mics and left Bono alone on the stage, he owned this performance and made everyone look even worse, as usual....That opening was beautiful...aside from Bono, this is verging on terribad... I laugh at times...that first part with stevie was painful, the second woman sounded like a depressed, groaning goat, the greenday singer doesn't even belong, and it's just a total mess!!!
Hey brother, thats scott weiland, of STP and Velvet revolver, not David Bowie, though he does a version with john lennon on Young Americans, sounds alot like bowie in this though!
oh man, this pretty much sucks. THe only ones who aren't terrible are Bono and Steven Tyler. Whoever that is who sings third is amazingly terrible. And the fourth is almost as bad. I wish I knew who these people were though.
Billie Joe for president :)
Anarkkka666 3 months ago
why everybody not ready on that 5/4 beat part..? I mean this it not a first live cover where singers totally fuck ups... great skills..=/
Holms 3 months ago
it never seems like during these "all star" wankfests, that anyone was put in charge of actually coordinated and arranging these so called tributes, which turn it out to be disasters usually....Lennon's been dead for some time now, so they cant say they didnt have time to get this shit together....had someone properly got these guys together and worked out harmonies, solos etc., it might have had a chance...instead slap em all together and you get a multi-millionaire soup of mediocrity..
mherrenschmidt 3 months ago
fucksake bad karaoke
juljul67ify 4 months ago
Fucking alicia keys ruined this song
dnlvrlls 4 months ago
Is this a tribute to The Beatles or the people doing the tribute?
derek4ur 4 months ago
Whoa, I always knew these people sucked I just didn't know how much....until now
EndridCold 5 months ago
Making up their own vocalizations totally fucked up this song :/
Pinoyaznboii 6 months ago
If Roger Waters didn't make it almost near to John, Bobo & company will never do it...
vladvampire 8 months ago
no man deserves to be on that stage singing that song, none of them could even come close to dreaming to accomplish as much as john lennon & the beatles. If you can't do a song justice, you don't do it at all.
lees2oo8 9 months ago
@lees2oo8 BRAVO - Well said.
EndridCold 5 months ago
What happened to the one who was responsible for the sound? The sound is awful!!!
miggydscho 10 months ago
this is a terrible way to destroy a great song, retarded singers.
patdidis2 1 year ago
such a terrible boring, no annoying celeb-Bliblablu to a really terrific song
McGwinn 1 year ago
wtf why so many retarded singers lmfao
beatlefan9000 1 year ago
Woah Billie Joe didn't do half-bad
TheHendrixLegend 1 year ago
I don't like these celeb rock, Live Aid collabs...where everyone is trying to outdo each other. Soulless showing off. Embarassing tripe
BritFez 1 year ago
way way way way over done...to many cooks spoil the broth....
JoeFisher12String 1 year ago
fucking blasphemous cunts.
dirtballjohnny 1 year ago
fucking blasphemous cunts.
dirtballjohnny 1 year ago
Have you seen Stevie's new shoes?...neither has he
TPATRICKT 1 year ago
not just buno!!
yoyogenerTION 1 year ago
These people sang the song to Commemorate the Beatles. It's not that they sang it bad...it is REMEMBERING the Ones (The Beatles) who immortalized the song.
elisehanslirod 1 year ago
I prefer Fiona Apple's version...
eqie99 1 year ago
I like it very much but I prefer original version.
martilook 2 years ago
yeah I don't like it...beatles were,are and will be the best singers!
hereg2007 2 years ago
This is what I call ¨let´s try and ruin one of the best songs ever written¨
violetavalery 2 years ago
i agree they ruined it but at the same time it shows me how much respect people have for the beatles cuz instead of trying to say there better then the beatles they do a cover
paulandjohnrdead 2 years ago
He is still blind as you might know so he had to find the position of the mic first so no mistakes there.
ginoh007 2 years ago
Did Stevie forget the words?
SirDrexl 2 years ago
@SirDrexl yeah hahaha
lynottlives 1 year ago
Bono is the best!
BoNoYzIdAnE 2 years ago 2
Ahhh filthy... its forced prostitution.
And was that the prick from Green Day? Arsehole can't sing...
rickygaler 2 years ago
shut up with your stupid critic
it's obviously that the ebst song is the beatles
but others can sing this song!
Dakimaho89 2 years ago
omg... it's ugly, i prefer the original Beatles song...
liveandletdie95 2 years ago
The Red Haired Guy is Scott Weiland
gdog49 3 years ago
Horrible
bluemeany 3 years ago
Great cover. The best performers (to me ): S Tyler, guy with red hair, B Wilson and Bono. The rest isn't that good (even Stevie !)
Laurent75017 3 years ago
slash+bono+gerard+many other awesome people= epic win
SLAARG 3 years ago
butchered.
aussiefirestorm 3 years ago
...did keys say 'break it down' at 3:30? cuz that would be totally corny.
TriggerHappyD 3 years ago 7
Great tribute to the beatles.
bono22albarn 3 years ago
It should have been just Slash, Bono, and Steven Tyler.
Fixer1911 3 years ago 9
Yeah ha... that isn't Bowie.... Keep Bono and Slash. Everyone else can leave.
Voodoochil111111 4 years ago 3
And Johnny Rotten, Steven Tyler, and Stevie Wonder
suchingwankdouche 3 years ago
i really like the choice of slash on guitar...it would have been good if it was just bono
Joesus1991 4 years ago
aww....This totaly sux i dont like it.....they choose the wrong people to sing such a good song...i like alicias k.'s voice but i dont like it in this song...:(..it doesnt go ith it it SUX!!!! well compared to the real version
mackpunky 4 years ago
This probably would have been a lot better with just the people actually playing instruments onstage with only Bono singing.
Sanguimaru 4 years ago
This is incredibly poor and the guy with red hair only wants to sound like Bowie....he certainly isnt him. Why the hell is there a cowboy on this stage???? Norah Jones is singing way too low...Bono is always lost without his band....Wilson is past it...Lennon is rolling in his freaking grave
kootenayman 4 years ago
Your a fool
Theplaymaker712 3 years ago
How the fuck did Ravi Shankar's daughter...oops...I mean "Norah Jones" get up there??
revolutionday1 4 years ago
It's Brian Wilson
billybill29 4 years ago
is that old guy paul
jmaxx112714 4 years ago
I think you mean Brian Wilson from the Beach Boys
billybill29 4 years ago
Somebody needs to wheel ol' Brain back to his room.
revolutionday1 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bono sucks ass.
erikrief 4 years ago
Agreed, he thinks he's the messiah
AdamShanklyUK 4 years ago
its scott weiland from stone temple pilots
cbratch512 4 years ago
He's a parody of himself in this clip.
revolutionday1 4 years ago
i just got 2 thing to say, I`m a gunner and it`s good to see duff, matt & slash playing on stage again!! lol
aerogunsrb 4 years ago
Awe comeon - it's not that bad!
arbinator 4 years ago
that velvet underground singer sounded like he was trying to copy david bowie wayy to much
comfortablynumb12345 4 years ago
or whoever had the pink hair
comfortablynumb12345 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Or whoever had the pink hair? you have to be kidding me. That is David Bowie...go back to school
flowgo11 4 years ago
go back to school?
i think you should man
thats not bowie man
david bowie is tallented.
the guy with the pink hair is Scott Weiland from velvet revolver
hes 20 years younger then david bowie
dont try and act all smart unless you know your facts.
comfortablynumb12345 4 years ago
damn man, he told you off good.
uwereverythin2me 4 years ago
Velvet Revolver you mean... Velvet Underground is a TOTALLY different band.
Mikeman29 4 years ago
yeah i skrewed up there
i love velvet underground,
i was baked im sorry
but yeah the singer from velvet REVOLVER sounds like hes trying to copy bowie, ahha not lou reed
capundrah123 4 years ago
yeah i skrewed up there
i love velvet underground,
i was baked im sorry
but yeah the singer from velvet REVOLVER sounds like hes trying to copy bowie, ahha not lou reed
ahah i sent that comment on the wrong account
comfortablynumb12345 4 years ago
bono and steven tyler were amazing.
and billie joe could have done better.
but everyone else just did not belong there.
who was the red hair guy though.
i know i know who he is,
i just fucking forget his name and its bothering me.
he wasnt too bad either...
bonokicksbutt 4 years ago
No offense to any of these singers, but I've heard better group singing from my drunk co-workers at holiday parties... and trust me... they don't sing sober for a reason.
Ladoons 4 years ago 3
This version sucks, The Beatles version is so much better!!!!!!!!!!
43angus43 4 years ago
I agree, these people fucked it up, Stevie Wonder is great, but he forgot the lyrics... they tried too hard
JSantiago0 4 years ago
This was recorded at the Grammys a couple of years ago. It sounds badly underrehearsed by the singers, with the exception of Bono, Steve Tyler, and Tim McGraw. And the band really kicks it. Geez big singing stars--you know you're going on national TV to perform this song, couldn't you at least PRACTICE it so you don't look like idiots?
soulcornflake 4 years ago
everyone should've just turned off their mics and left Bono alone on the stage, he owned this performance and made everyone look even worse, as usual....That opening was beautiful...aside from Bono, this is verging on terribad... I laugh at times...that first part with stevie was painful, the second woman sounded like a depressed, groaning goat, the greenday singer doesn't even belong, and it's just a total mess!!!
hazyskyline 4 years ago
Hey brother, thats scott weiland, of STP and Velvet revolver, not David Bowie, though he does a version with john lennon on Young Americans, sounds alot like bowie in this though!
UnderTheBridge96 4 years ago
Oh my god! i love this!
Bono,Billie,Steven tyler,Bowie and slash!
Fucking cool!
theonecalldwhats 4 years ago
when was this recorded??
orangehasrhymes 4 years ago
Bono and steven tyler are amazing.
i love them.
id have been happy if it was just them singing the whole song.
summerytime 4 years ago
Johnny rotten? I can't see him there.
redfacedpresident 4 years ago
oh man, this pretty much sucks. THe only ones who aren't terrible are Bono and Steven Tyler. Whoever that is who sings third is amazingly terrible. And the fourth is almost as bad. I wish I knew who these people were though.
eissirk 4 years ago
LOL I didn't know at first that Alicia Keys was in it, and I thought you were just making fun of stevie.
eissirk 4 years ago
Hey, Alicia Keys! You have a great voice but this isn't your song.
Tone down the vibrato, thanks.
Passionate4QAF 4 years ago
She was "blacking it up" just like they all do with the National Anthem. Makes me want to vomit.
revolutionday1 4 years ago
Bono rules but Johnny Rotten and Stevie Wonder are killer too. David Bowie does a kick ass version with John Lennon on Young Americans
nshvnancy 4 years ago
Steven Tyler did the best job here
gorooo 4 years ago
Actually now that I think about it, I like it with everyone singing it
MasterDesertPhoenix 4 years ago
I think if Bono sang it the whole time it woulda sounded better
MasterDesertPhoenix 4 years ago
when was this? i just want to know
BeatlesLiveOn 4 years ago
Rufus did this song the best
randomlettersand5 4 years ago
You some sort of wizard Mszczupak? Thanks.
zogabongs 4 years ago
all of them sound horrible...
suneyedgrrl 4 years ago 2
yeah this is a pretty awesome group of people. damn!
but you have to admit that this "pass the mic" tribute songs with celebrities are SOOOO corny.
haha
but this is too good
langlim 4 years ago
Bloody Brilliant!!
jstully 5 years ago