Its the first time I've heard of "We are the Fallen" but this chick can sing! I was searching through bilboard.com's covers because I was finding such awesome covers, and I found this... She did such a good job! I don't ever comment, but had to say she kicked ass on this one!
I think they are good, but they should do something to try not to look so much like EV, not that im hating, but loooking like a copy cat usually is kinda bad lol
Damn, i've heard a few covers of this amazing song. but this one and the one with kurt nilsen and his 3 buddy's just are the most beautiful. Her voice damn it gives me Chickenskin ( goosbumbs?) not that great in writing in english in the world!!!! Dutch.
@djenorman I know that is a troll. But does that mean I can't reply to them if I want to? Anyways, there's nothing bad about it. I don't feel angry or anything about it, anyway.
Amazing how just because We Are The Fallen have a female singer that almost sounds like Amy Lee they critisize the amazing band. Either way the music is much different if you listen to it closely there are a bunch of stylistic differences.
This is the direction you should go in. Drop the feud. Change your name and you will get re-signed. This cover was 100X more amazing than your first record.
People are not aware about Ben's solo career.... he released 3 albums after he left evanescence... the songs are so fuckin soulful... if people stop hating, buy the albums and listen to the music.. they'll realize what an amazing artist he is..
in my eyes watf is like velvet revolver.. a bunch of established people coming together to form a band...
Carly o vocal esta perfeito.Não bastaria você ter apenas um timbre lindo mas a afinação e a interpretação para uma musica tão conhecida, esta invejável, parabéns. "A sua musica chegou ao Brasil"
Great Cover! Ben Moody creating good music as always and Carly Smithson sounds wonderful! We could just enjoy this good performance and leave the comparison to Evanescence! They are two bands differents of the same gender the end!
@poseidon8180 u so wrong m8 looks like u r stuck with evanescence , is just the same genre and unfortunately she used to dress like that before she joined the band if u dont believe me try carly smithson american idol and see it with ur own eyes
I don't see why people can't enjoy both Amy's and Carly's talent.Both are truly amazing singers. There is no real need to compare them. Amy is Amy (my rock goddess) and Carly is Carly (who is breath taking as well). I kind of wish they would sing a duet one day (think of how beautiful that would sound.. maybe?). Still, I love me my Evanescence, that doesn't mean I can't appreciate the music this band makes as well.. Give them both a try and learn to love.
the vocal is so much the like with amy lee's style but with more grip on throat and nose its a cheat to reach high notes. in addition they weren't able to give much better twist on the song that could separate them from U2's version. its an acoustic though but they weren't able to take advantage of the twelve strings, its could have been cooler if they did. its good though but it lacks signature which most of the successful bands had. Peace you all I am a U2 fan. ur welcome to response.
Ok guys!...I'm not gonna lie.I absolutely love Amy Lee and Evanescence.I used to compare them by the past but I stopped.I realized that they may sound the same but they are very different.Let them live their lives!!...We Are The Fallen is a great band with a great music and has so much to offer to their fans.So stop comparing and appreciate and support them in what they are doing and help them to break through to much more success!
Always these shit comparing with Evanescence and Amy Lee -.-
We are the Fallen is a very good band I think, even if Evanescence is still my favourite. We are the Fallen and Evanescence are two different Bands that make both good music. And if you don't like WATF don't watch their videos...
this is a awesome cover of a great song ......this her really feeling and singing this song ....I would by this !...if WATF wants to stop being compared 2 EV and Amy Lee stop covering her songs ........ write your own on get some good writers in .......because I'd rather get to know this band then hearing them trying 2 touch something that can't ever be touch! jmho
people shut the fuck up we are the fallen are we are the fallen not evanescence and their vocalist is not a bootleg amy lee she may not be better then amy lee she may not be worse then amy lee she can sing though and this is a new band just shut the fuck up and pretend like you know no one in the band and enjoy the music they are a good band ben moody help make the goth metal sound that evanescence brought to the forefront and is keeping it alive with this band so shut your face and enjoy
@startingabandsoon Dude - punctuation is everyone's friend. When I read your comment, I read it in one long string, breathlessly, because my mind uses things like commas and periods to build the natural rhythm of speech. Don't neglect those little dots, and they'll treat you kindly in return.
147 are still stuck in their prepubescent music taste...two different brands of peanut butter is still peanut butter. We Are The Fallen and Evanescence are two different bands same genre, get over it and appreciate the music.
@tastyUdon thats hardly true. Ive been a fan of ev since 2003, and they've gotten me through some of the worst times in my life. I like Amy's voice, I like her lyrics, I like what she stands for. Most of all, I like that she gave me a musical output. We are the fallen is different. Different sounding vocals, different lyrics, just completly different.
@tastyUdon Im not saying I hate them because they're hardly original with band names/band members...in fact i could care less. I just really dont like her vocals as much as amy. The instruments sound the same (as you said-same genre) and its clearly because its the same band members from ev. That hardly makes me in a prebescent stage....it makes me know what I enjoy and know what I do not. simple as that
@VayuPurana To clarify further, it said WATF features alums (i.e former members) of Evanescence, because WATF members Ben Moody, Rocky Gray and John LeCompt were all in Evanescence.
Wow.. Its like being in a Nightwish video. Everytime a band gets a new singer.. the idiotic older fans get all butthurt n post useless, "that person sucks compared to so-n-so". Honestly, WATF is better than New Ev. New Ev is boring as fuck now n just has a good singer. WATF has an amazing band with a good singer. and she dont sound or look shit like Amy Lee. Idiots.
I just uploaded Carly's vocal range for this album. CHECK IT OUT!
I love Evanescene and I just found about We are the Fallen both of them have beautiful voices! Personally, I like Amy lee's better, but I also love this girls voice!
To all the people who keep dissing these guys for sounding like Evanescence... do your freaking research. three out of the five members of the band WERE in Evanescence so of course there are going to be so similarities
@GiraffesAreAWESOMEEE You mean who covered it first? Because I thought U2 wrote this song... It does say "U2 Mashup Monday Cover" in the title... Which would mean U2 did it first... But I don't know what you're asking, so sorry if I'm not answering your question lol. Plus I don't even know who Breathe Carolina are/is. Sorry xD I should shut up now!
at first when i seen this video all i could think was amy lee could so kill this better you guys can not replace amy lee and her new cd is awesome but carly does have a voice but she needs to stop commin off as if shes amy lee find a way to sing that suits you not trying to hate but noone will ever replace amy lee
who cares if she's better than amy lee or not,, this is the first time i have heard this woman sing and i am a fan of evanescence but be grown up enough to appreaciate good music and why bother arguing about who is better?? life is too short for all that jazz.. just enjoy good music people..
@falakalak Because maybe they want to listen to both? I love certain bands better than others, but I need variety personally. If there is anyone that truly doesn't prefer Amy Lee over We Are The Fallen I would be amazed. To say I don't want to listen to both wouldn't be true though.
@heroineadict I prefer WATF to Amy Lee, because Evanesence without Ben is just that, Amy Lee, WATF are a band, AMy Lee has become a solo artist in my eyes, I will never consider her a band from 3rd album onwards
@OASBDGR You mean they are a band till Ben gets his panties in a bunch and abandons the band again because they realize how worthless he is? They got a singer with very little talent and they can manipulate her for now, but Amy Lee said "you're fired" instead. But that's just my opinion, I prefer no bull****, people that aren't in it for just the money, and original stuff personally.
By the sounds of Ben I'm glad that douche is gone.
@falakalak-Carly really doesn't have the range nor the purity of tone Amy has. She also doesn't have the ability to hold notes (heavy smoker maybe?) nor the timing that Amy has (Carly breaks up her notes in weird places to take a breath all. the. time.). IMO This has to be one of her best performances. I will admit that Carly is improving, but she still can't hold a candle to Amy yet. For most Evanescence fans, it's like this: Amy's voice=Gothic angel; Carly's=scratchy, rougher version of Amy.
@falakalak The entirely guilt is for Ben Moody... Look at the band! Ex members of Evanescence and she looks like A. Lee too, her voice is similar, etc, etc... Well...
@kennycrackedskulls They left Evanescence for a reason. They were tired of Amy Lee acting like she was the only important member of the band. Well, she got her wish, without them.
@Rawk4Life No. Rocky left in his own Terms. John got Sacked. Ben Left cause he had creative difficulties and will boyd left cause of family reasons. Amy is the important person anyways. with her Rocky, john and Ben wouldn't be Performing at local Pubs right now while if they were still with EV they would be headlining tours all over the world.
Checkout Carrion by Fall Through iris, on itunes or amazon.com track features Phil Taylor of Future leaders of the world, Rocky Gray & John LeCompt formerly of Evanescence
I liked how they played this song, very good playing. Carly is very good singer, realy good technic she proved it in American Idol. Only one objection is her tone of voice, I heard better, but still I'm impressed. Good work, thaks :)
@hobbitpotatoe it doesn't matter darling,evanescence is evanescence,or you didnt get this band's biography,i ask you to read it very well..and even as a hlf-decent fan of evan. doesnt matter for me the rest,i support the original stuffs..but i see you do to the copies...and it's not my business you mediocry taste,as i can see you are all mediocre
wait a minute i watched this for 2 minutes that's not Amy Lee..WTF!! this isnt Evanescence JK!!! Carley and Amy are both hot and amazing now if only Kate Beckinsale could sing like this in Underworld i would be on cloud 9!!!! anyone with me..i heat goth girls i wont lie....or vamps lol
anyone caught up in the controversy over we are the fallen and evanescence is missing the point and that is PAY ATTENTION TO THE MUSIC!!! not the fact that carley resembles amy lee. i love amy lees voice and carleys vioce bc their beautiful singers and i distinguish their bands as two different bands that i love amy lee i love you carly i love you keep making beautiful music.
I've been a huge Evanescence fan since I was 11, but these guys are good. She can sing great, the band makes good music. I don't understand why people think they have to hate one or the other. Like them both--it makes life easier.
She has a amazing voice! When she sings there is a tone which is comparable with so many successful ladies in music. I will not compare names on the account that she deserves her own spot in music history as a great singer!!!
beautiful remake...
KostasCataclysm 1 day ago
BATMAN !!! XD
SuperPavel178 2 days ago
Its the first time I've heard of "We are the Fallen" but this chick can sing! I was searching through bilboard.com's covers because I was finding such awesome covers, and I found this... She did such a good job! I don't ever comment, but had to say she kicked ass on this one!
scotttras15 2 days ago
different genre but their play has sincereness and respect, i felt.
haru19730318 3 days ago
I think they are good, but they should do something to try not to look so much like EV, not that im hating, but loooking like a copy cat usually is kinda bad lol
Jesuschick22 4 days ago
Yeah, she's Irish too!!! <3
keniapowa 5 days ago
Damn, i've heard a few covers of this amazing song. but this one and the one with kurt nilsen and his 3 buddy's just are the most beautiful. Her voice damn it gives me Chickenskin ( goosbumbs?) not that great in writing in english in the world!!!! Dutch.
TheZax17 6 days ago
I've only just discovered this band and they're fantastic
HoorayForVampirates 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check FallenOne.nl
jasonlife 1 week ago
I've gotta say great cover of a U2 Classic. Carly has got a fantastic voice who wouldn't want to listen to it.
EvilBarmyArmy 2 weeks ago in playlist More videos from BillboardMagazine
Listen to drew rynewiez's cover too, just as awesome. But this is slightly better
solehinzs 2 weeks ago
WATF Fans are easy to troll
probem?
EvanescentSoul31 2 weeks ago
@EvanescentSoul31 WATF haters are pathetic.
Problem?
colourdeyes 1 week ago 3
@colourdeyes ... you actually replied to a troll? lrn2internet
djenorman 1 week ago
@djenorman I know that is a troll. But does that mean I can't reply to them if I want to? Anyways, there's nothing bad about it. I don't feel angry or anything about it, anyway.
colourdeyes 1 week ago
Who the hell doesn't know where Ireland is?
yosho700 2 weeks ago
love accoustic versions of this song, this is one of the best ive heard!!
TheSiobhanmac 2 weeks ago
I love her accent and she is a wonderful singer and so beautiful! I think if her and Amy Lee did a song together, it would sound beautiful!
13lonelyheart 3 weeks ago
they are really good and people should shut up about evanescence even though they are good they are not the same ok get that in your mind
nefadora1016 3 weeks ago
I love this and how they did this, but I would've liked to see them give it a new twist.
QweenElle513 3 weeks ago in playlist Mashup Mondays
just because ben moodys there doesnt make them evanescence and i agree carly has a very beautiful voice
lilith6661985 3 weeks ago
@lilith6661985 Yes she has a great voice but you are mistaken it is not just Ben. John and Rocky are also former bandmates of Evanescence
Tierneyslover518 3 weeks ago
Amazing how just because We Are The Fallen have a female singer that almost sounds like Amy Lee they critisize the amazing band. Either way the music is much different if you listen to it closely there are a bunch of stylistic differences.
trappedbymusic 4 weeks ago
This is the direction you should go in. Drop the feud. Change your name and you will get re-signed. This cover was 100X more amazing than your first record.
ritam 1 month ago
hey she was from American Idol :D
MuncksSittingOnDucks 1 month ago
What a breath-taking cover. Amazing, amazing amazing.
TimmothyA 1 month ago
People are not aware about Ben's solo career.... he released 3 albums after he left evanescence... the songs are so fuckin soulful... if people stop hating, buy the albums and listen to the music.. they'll realize what an amazing artist he is..
in my eyes watf is like velvet revolver.. a bunch of established people coming together to form a band...
1011sid 1 month ago
Now, sit and learn Bono Vox !
lavachequirit02 1 month ago
this song she sounds nothink like amy lee x
lolageppl 1 month ago 3
Carly o vocal esta perfeito.Não bastaria você ter apenas um timbre lindo mas a afinação e a interpretação para uma musica tão conhecida, esta invejável, parabéns. "A sua musica chegou ao Brasil"
roluiz27 1 month ago in playlist Mais vídeos de BillboardMagazine
....yuck. WTF suck.
cuzRYsaid 1 month ago
@cuzRYsaid you suck:) you would wish you could sing the same way she does:)
MichaelJacksonDiana 1 month ago
Great Cover! Ben Moody creating good music as always and Carly Smithson sounds wonderful! We could just enjoy this good performance and leave the comparison to Evanescence! They are two bands differents of the same gender the end!
anncad 1 month ago 2
this band is nothing more than a big ass bootleg of evanescence
poseidon8180 1 month ago
@poseidon8180 u so wrong m8 looks like u r stuck with evanescence , is just the same genre and unfortunately she used to dress like that before she joined the band if u dont believe me try carly smithson american idol and see it with ur own eyes
karithmey 1 month ago
Comment removed
anajoyceescorcio 1 month ago
Comment removed
anajoyceescorcio 1 month ago
Is this the Carly from American Idol?
tkdmmalover 1 month ago
@tkdmmalover Yes it is :D
DWSMusic93 1 month ago
I don't see why people can't enjoy both Amy's and Carly's talent.Both are truly amazing singers. There is no real need to compare them. Amy is Amy (my rock goddess) and Carly is Carly (who is breath taking as well). I kind of wish they would sing a duet one day (think of how beautiful that would sound.. maybe?). Still, I love me my Evanescence, that doesn't mean I can't appreciate the music this band makes as well.. Give them both a try and learn to love.
TheMissingMo 1 month ago 3
idk y ppl r comparing her to amy lee all rock girls have dark hair makeup like that and tattoos soo shut the hell up ppl and enjoy the music .... :)
godlandera 1 month ago
the vocal is so much the like with amy lee's style but with more grip on throat and nose its a cheat to reach high notes. in addition they weren't able to give much better twist on the song that could separate them from U2's version. its an acoustic though but they weren't able to take advantage of the twelve strings, its could have been cooler if they did. its good though but it lacks signature which most of the successful bands had. Peace you all I am a U2 fan. ur welcome to response.
davanth777 1 month ago
Ok guys!...I'm not gonna lie.I absolutely love Amy Lee and Evanescence.I used to compare them by the past but I stopped.I realized that they may sound the same but they are very different.Let them live their lives!!...We Are The Fallen is a great band with a great music and has so much to offer to their fans.So stop comparing and appreciate and support them in what they are doing and help them to break through to much more success!
Kaelajin96 1 month ago
Somebody get Bono on the phone, time to set up one hell of a duet. Gotta have some kind of percussion this time.
lancasterdrummer 1 month ago
psI love her voice.)
lius612 1 month ago in playlist Mashup Mondays
omg i love it!
lius612 1 month ago in playlist Mashup Mondays
Always these shit comparing with Evanescence and Amy Lee -.-
We are the Fallen is a very good band I think, even if Evanescence is still my favourite. We are the Fallen and Evanescence are two different Bands that make both good music. And if you don't like WATF don't watch their videos...
LoveAmyLeeEv 1 month ago 3
canta bem...mas é um pouco forçada....
fernandaesmigolpreci 2 months ago
we are the fallen FTW
no more.
jelc1293 2 months ago in playlist L O L
She has a nice voice But dam shes so damn ugly
3aboodzin 2 months ago
@3aboodzin Are you blind? Carly is so beautiful.
anajoyceescorcio 2 months ago 2
this is a awesome cover of a great song ......this her really feeling and singing this song ....I would by this !...if WATF wants to stop being compared 2 EV and Amy Lee stop covering her songs ........ write your own on get some good writers in .......because I'd rather get to know this band then hearing them trying 2 touch something that can't ever be touch! jmho
solarfiredancer 2 months ago
I love it.
missjuana707 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
Perfect *__-
markimloukim 2 months ago
This performance is perfect!
jessicadawnpena 2 months ago
I like this song!
jessicadawnpena 2 months ago
ha ha stop hating !!she still sings good
gabriellah02 2 months ago
people shut the fuck up we are the fallen are we are the fallen not evanescence and their vocalist is not a bootleg amy lee she may not be better then amy lee she may not be worse then amy lee she can sing though and this is a new band just shut the fuck up and pretend like you know no one in the band and enjoy the music they are a good band ben moody help make the goth metal sound that evanescence brought to the forefront and is keeping it alive with this band so shut your face and enjoy
startingabandsoon 2 months ago 26
@startingabandsoon Dude - punctuation is everyone's friend. When I read your comment, I read it in one long string, breathlessly, because my mind uses things like commas and periods to build the natural rhythm of speech. Don't neglect those little dots, and they'll treat you kindly in return.
walpoly 2 days ago
147 are still stuck in their prepubescent music taste...two different brands of peanut butter is still peanut butter. We Are The Fallen and Evanescence are two different bands same genre, get over it and appreciate the music.
tastyUdon 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 44
@tastyUdon exactly
trappedbymusic 4 weeks ago
@tastyUdon thats hardly true. Ive been a fan of ev since 2003, and they've gotten me through some of the worst times in my life. I like Amy's voice, I like her lyrics, I like what she stands for. Most of all, I like that she gave me a musical output. We are the fallen is different. Different sounding vocals, different lyrics, just completly different.
musiclovingchick6 1 week ago
@tastyUdon Im not saying I hate them because they're hardly original with band names/band members...in fact i could care less. I just really dont like her vocals as much as amy. The instruments sound the same (as you said-same genre) and its clearly because its the same band members from ev. That hardly makes me in a prebescent stage....it makes me know what I enjoy and know what I do not. simple as that
musiclovingchick6 1 week ago
liz gillies xd
usuario91ful 2 months ago
TRAITORS!!! but she can still can sing...
stanstan009 2 months ago
i can't say enough that the dude with a batman symbol shirt is friggin hot and badass
VayuPurana 2 months ago
@VayuPurana well I've had my derp moment, that "dude with a batman symbol" is BEN MOODY!!!....i feel so stupid now .________.
I've heard of ben naturally, just never knew what he looked like before lol
VayuPurana 2 months ago
@VayuPurana To clarify further, it said WATF features alums (i.e former members) of Evanescence, because WATF members Ben Moody, Rocky Gray and John LeCompt were all in Evanescence.
TheMCGaming 2 months ago
Nah, too white bread, too clean. Doesn't work.
tunkul59 2 months ago
shit
BandaBanheiroQuimico 2 months ago
Brilliant version......this is so good...
MrRockmanRockman 2 months ago 2
aimee proal is better lighters/supperbass MASH UP by kurthugo schneider!
SuperSuperaman 2 months ago
Wow! She is amazing. I loved her on Idol but she just rocked this song. She is amazing
ScrabbleGirl74 2 months ago
2:05 it even says evanescence. lol!
keepit 2 months ago 3
2:05 so even the billboard people mistaked them for evanesence XDDDDDD
VayuPurana 2 months ago
@VayuPurana oh snap! haha.!!!
yourrfacehere 2 months ago
ya right??
OftheAllince 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow.. Its like being in a Nightwish video. Everytime a band gets a new singer.. the idiotic older fans get all butthurt n post useless, "that person sucks compared to so-n-so". Honestly, WATF is better than New Ev. New Ev is boring as fuck now n just has a good singer. WATF has an amazing band with a good singer. and she dont sound or look shit like Amy Lee. Idiots.
I just uploaded Carly's vocal range for this album. CHECK IT OUT!
Sevrion 3 months ago
Can everyone shut the fuck up about Amy lee and just enjoy the song.. If you don't like it. Turn it off!!
agirlnamedcharlie2 3 months ago
SHE WAS ONLY COOL IN "BRING ME BACK TO LIFE" AND THATS IT!
THEN SHE FEATURED WITH K0RN? WTF?! THAT WAS TOO MUCH FOR HER. STAY AT HOME BITCH
theuncanspan 3 months ago
@theuncanspan you can't even get the title right...you dumb! You're the one who should stay at home and study with your nanny or whatever.
johnastrid 2 months ago
FUCK Amy Lee
theuncanspan 3 months ago
Best singer in the world. Period.
platinainfernal 3 months ago in playlist we are the fallen playlist
@carlysmithson You sing really well this song
ShaggyMedina 3 months ago
*jaw drops*
hit the replay button
Best female version of this song !!
test123ok 3 months ago
I love Evanescene and I just found about We are the Fallen both of them have beautiful voices! Personally, I like Amy lee's better, but I also love this girls voice!
TheOutLook989 3 months ago
To all the people who keep dissing these guys for sounding like Evanescence... do your freaking research. three out of the five members of the band WERE in Evanescence so of course there are going to be so similarities
TheRockerrwl 3 months ago
who did this song first? we are the fallen or breathe carolina?
GiraffesAreAWESOMEEE 3 months ago
@GiraffesAreAWESOMEEE Neither, ...it's by U2. Finish watching the video, they talk about it... or read the title or the description.
GyroTheTitan 3 months ago
@GiraffesAreAWESOMEEE You mean who covered it first? Because I thought U2 wrote this song... It does say "U2 Mashup Monday Cover" in the title... Which would mean U2 did it first... But I don't know what you're asking, so sorry if I'm not answering your question lol. Plus I don't even know who Breathe Carolina are/is. Sorry xD I should shut up now!
Kagomai15 2 months ago
@Kagomai15 lol im an idiot that didnt read the title, breathe calorina did a cover of this song so thats how i had first heard about it xD
GiraffesAreAWESOMEEE 2 months ago
Love the intensity!
0hprettywoman 3 months ago
She's perfect. <3
ArcticusWH 3 months ago
There's no mushup here!
dwintzeh 3 months ago
she tries 2much 2b like amy lee, she changed her voice, and her looks so that she looks + sounds like amy..... @ least i made that connection.
DEMY160 3 months ago
at first when i seen this video all i could think was amy lee could so kill this better you guys can not replace amy lee and her new cd is awesome but carly does have a voice but she needs to stop commin off as if shes amy lee find a way to sing that suits you not trying to hate but noone will ever replace amy lee
mamifromda301 3 months ago
who cares if she's better than amy lee or not,, this is the first time i have heard this woman sing and i am a fan of evanescence but be grown up enough to appreaciate good music and why bother arguing about who is better?? life is too short for all that jazz.. just enjoy good music people..
TheBeccaCee 3 months ago in playlist Mashup Mondays 2
Stop comparing her with Amy Lee, geeze.
This is amazing, if you prefer Amy Lee, why are you even here? ...
falakalak 3 months ago 62
@falakalak Because maybe they want to listen to both? I love certain bands better than others, but I need variety personally. If there is anyone that truly doesn't prefer Amy Lee over We Are The Fallen I would be amazed. To say I don't want to listen to both wouldn't be true though.
heroineadict 3 months ago
@heroineadict I prefer WATF to Amy Lee, because Evanesence without Ben is just that, Amy Lee, WATF are a band, AMy Lee has become a solo artist in my eyes, I will never consider her a band from 3rd album onwards
OASBDGR 3 months ago
@OASBDGR You mean they are a band till Ben gets his panties in a bunch and abandons the band again because they realize how worthless he is? They got a singer with very little talent and they can manipulate her for now, but Amy Lee said "you're fired" instead. But that's just my opinion, I prefer no bull****, people that aren't in it for just the money, and original stuff personally.
By the sounds of Ben I'm glad that douche is gone.
heroineadict 3 months ago
@falakalak-Carly really doesn't have the range nor the purity of tone Amy has. She also doesn't have the ability to hold notes (heavy smoker maybe?) nor the timing that Amy has (Carly breaks up her notes in weird places to take a breath all. the. time.). IMO This has to be one of her best performances. I will admit that Carly is improving, but she still can't hold a candle to Amy yet. For most Evanescence fans, it's like this: Amy's voice=Gothic angel; Carly's=scratchy, rougher version of Amy.
ThePoisonousTiger74 3 months ago
@falakalak The entirely guilt is for Ben Moody... Look at the band! Ex members of Evanescence and she looks like A. Lee too, her voice is similar, etc, etc... Well...
ccsdna 2 months ago
@falakalak its amy lees band members
kennycrackedskulls 2 months ago
@kennycrackedskulls They left Evanescence for a reason. They were tired of Amy Lee acting like she was the only important member of the band. Well, she got her wish, without them.
Rawk4Life 2 months ago
@Rawk4Life No. Rocky left in his own Terms. John got Sacked. Ben Left cause he had creative difficulties and will boyd left cause of family reasons. Amy is the important person anyways. with her Rocky, john and Ben wouldn't be Performing at local Pubs right now while if they were still with EV they would be headlining tours all over the world.
kaarankin69 2 months ago in playlist WATF
@falakalak to vote down haha
EvanescentSoul31 2 months ago
@falakalak Im hating got a problem? then do something about it..
kaarankin69 2 months ago in playlist WATF
This has been flagged as spam show
Checkout Carrion by Fall Through iris, on itunes or amazon.com track features Phil Taylor of Future leaders of the world, Rocky Gray & John LeCompt formerly of Evanescence
wearethefallenfan 4 months ago
BATMAN T-SHIRT!!
Hell yeah! :D
Pattartar 4 months ago in playlist Mashup Mondays 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Checkout Carrion by Fall through iris, on itunes or amazon.com track features Phil Taylor & Rocky Gray
6969tattoogirl 4 months ago
Amy lee say to they ... YOU GOING UNDER
lolo4276 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SPREAD THE WORD!! Checkout Carrion by Fall through iris, on itunes or amazon.com. Track features Phil Taylor & Rocky GRAY!!
punkrockprincess221 4 months ago
Embarrassing.
Gottfrequenz 4 months ago
I swear shes frm American Idol's past contestant! god wats her name again? arghh!
smudgeink 4 months ago
@smudgeink She is. Her name is Carly Smithson.
AnMwDe88 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Checkout Rocky Gray on "Carrion" by Fall through iris, on itunes or
MsBigbigboobs 4 months ago
THAT BITCH WEARS TOO MUCH BLUSH AND AMY LEE IS PRETTIER AND A BETTER SINGER THAN HER WANNABE ASS
infamousmetalmaiden 4 months ago
@infamousmetalmaiden you are fucking dumb! She is better than Amy Lee because she is from Ireland! SO ha! suck on my Irish BALLS!
angieg3072 4 months ago in playlist AG's FAv
@angieg3072 hey...amy lee is the best.. ok.. she gift the best and she sing from her heart. AND AMY LEE THE BEST
lolo4276 4 months ago
@lolo4276 umm well for one use proper launguage! but yes Amy lee is good but this girl is amazing! mabye better than Amy!
angieg3072 4 months ago in playlist AG's FAv 2
@angieg3072 nah she is just a wannabe who will never be better than amy
infamousmetalmaiden 3 months ago
Rock on...
frankmaiello 4 months ago
@kaarankin69 that awkward moment when you are blinded by favouritism
Crys5736 4 months ago
fantastic music ..thumbs up ..lovly greetings Dear ann
Lichtfee004 4 months ago
My GODS this woman's got lungs! LOVE LOVE LOVE HER!
Jurek009 4 months ago 3
I liked how they played this song, very good playing. Carly is very good singer, realy good technic she proved it in American Idol. Only one objection is her tone of voice, I heard better, but still I'm impressed. Good work, thaks :)
WulfgardWOT 4 months ago
Dont be a n asshole fan boys... that is sad.... dont divide cause that way metal)general) its not going anywhere
Bally878 4 months ago
126 people are hardcore fans of Amy Lee !! LoL
Annatelles 4 months ago
@Annatelles the awkward moment when Amy Lee is better.
kaarankin69 4 months ago 16
@kaarankin69 AMY BETTER? LOL three times =p
mikinhalingeron 2 months ago
@kaarankin69 lol well said :D LUV YA AMY 4EVA!!!!! this womans still good too though :)
Crazi4Budgies 2 months ago
Beautiful, but wtf is she doing with her hands?! Lmao.
BombWarning 4 months ago
Carly was my favorite contestant on American Idol the year she was on the show, and I'm happy she's gotten where she is! :) She's beautiful!
Insouciantly 4 months ago
I just think she is a very average singer!
clemarochies 4 months ago
she even dresses up like Amy Lee!
gabisumaia 4 months ago
@gabisumaia she is amy lee you tool... its the remainders of evanescence... oh god, even a half-decent fan would know that.
hobbitpotatoe 4 months ago
@hobbitpotatoe actually it's carly smithson from american idol, you tool.
elizabethknies 4 months ago
@elizabethknies yes well. im just passing on a message given to me, so not really mate... that was a copy+pasted message.
hobbitpotatoe 4 months ago
@hobbitpotatoe it doesn't matter darling,evanescence is evanescence,or you didnt get this band's biography,i ask you to read it very well..and even as a hlf-decent fan of evan. doesnt matter for me the rest,i support the original stuffs..but i see you do to the copies...and it's not my business you mediocry taste,as i can see you are all mediocre
gabisumaia 3 months ago
@gabisumaia bit late replying arnt you? couldn't just leave mistakes?
or "not feed the troll" as its said nowadays ;)
hobbitpotatoe 3 months ago
i'm so proud of Carly. I'm a fan since A.I.
joyusu 4 months ago
i'm so proud of Carly. I'm a fan since A.I.
joyusu 4 months ago
wait a minute i watched this for 2 minutes that's not Amy Lee..WTF!! this isnt Evanescence JK!!! Carley and Amy are both hot and amazing now if only Kate Beckinsale could sing like this in Underworld i would be on cloud 9!!!! anyone with me..i heat goth girls i wont lie....or vamps lol
DarkJosh99 4 months ago
@DarkJosh99 exactly!!!! this guy knows what im talking about. if a womans hot and has a beautiful voice im in heaven!!!!
aaronbenkle 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DarkJosh99 exactly!!!! this guy knows what im talking about. if a womans hot and has a beautiful voice im in heaven!!!!
aaronbenkle 4 months ago
@DarkJosh99 LOL, this is your idea of "goth chicks"?
D3c1m8th30pp0s1t10n 4 months ago
@D3c1m8th30pp0s1t10n i won't lie i don't know shit about gothic man so I assume lol don't quote me on it you probably know way more then me
DarkJosh99 4 months ago
anyone caught up in the controversy over we are the fallen and evanescence is missing the point and that is PAY ATTENTION TO THE MUSIC!!! not the fact that carley resembles amy lee. i love amy lees voice and carleys vioce bc their beautiful singers and i distinguish their bands as two different bands that i love amy lee i love you carly i love you keep making beautiful music.
aaronbenkle 4 months ago
Soooo fucking good!
Chr0nicMasterbater 4 months ago
the 2 bands are very cool
Kimico80kimico 4 months ago
absolutely brilliant
anna26396 5 months ago
Rachel and Ross 4ever!
blumac81 5 months ago
wanna be Amy
eilonamram14 5 months ago
She looks like amy lee!!! Ben missed so much maybe!
She has to find her way, her style!! she sing well i like it !!
But i prefer amy of course
lukaspiojo 5 months ago
Not bad, missing harmony though.
driftingeric2k4 5 months ago
She has an absolutely amazing voice. I love it. She was my favorite Idol contestant during her season. I'm glad she's found a home in this band.
Did I say this was great?!
HasbeenTuna 5 months ago in playlist Mashup Mondays 2
well I loved it..
shotzer 5 months ago
I've been a huge Evanescence fan since I was 11, but these guys are good. She can sing great, the band makes good music. I don't understand why people think they have to hate one or the other. Like them both--it makes life easier.
darkseaofempathy 5 months ago 75
@darkseaofempathy i'm with you 100%
EleanorRigby212 3 months ago
@darkseaofempathy seriously. I love them both
NonaMuskratLuv 2 months ago
Excellent.
blewers 5 months ago in playlist More videos from BillboardMagazine
I like it.... :)
LadyLightningEv 5 months ago
I don't like it. Her voice is really average and the cover is not balanced. Strong voice and really sweet riffs.
TheRomaniia 5 months ago
bitch gets an entire quartet of guitars.
Kippeneuker69 5 months ago in playlist Mashup Mondays
I like the way she sing.
espiralify 6 months ago
Great cover!!!! WOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOW!
StairClimbCanada 6 months ago
love it.
LaMelina90 6 months ago
This song is a classic ...!! Wonderful singer @CarlySmithson
ShaggyMedina 6 months ago
she wishes....
EmmaWismyhero 6 months ago
She has a amazing voice! When she sings there is a tone which is comparable with so many successful ladies in music. I will not compare names on the account that she deserves her own spot in music history as a great singer!!!
phillieb30 6 months ago