Gary Granada Vs GMA 7(kopyang Kanta!!!)Part2

[sonnynunag]

I agree with Mr. Gary Granada coz I'm also a composer I understand his sentiments

[neneborja]

in my opinion ay sinamantala ang study effort ni mr Gary Granada ng GMA pra dyan sa jingle na yan.. tama talaga na i-boycott ang GMA!!!

[composerjmtolentino]

WOW... GINAYA KA TALAGA SIR GARRY... IM A COMPOSER ALSO... PINAGBATAYAN BA NAMAN ANG GINAWA MO... GRABE.... 

[bongduqueza]

go go go MR. Granada....fight for your rights.... BOYCOTT GMA7

[ulapwatcher]

Correct, this is not about the money.

This is about showing respect and decency to artists like Gary Granada.

BOYCOTT GMA7.

[tazphel23]

galit na galit sa opinyon ng iba, pero sya ang daming nasabi, baka idemanda ka din ng tinutukoy mong "KABILA", paninirang puri din yung sinabi mo na binayaran nila si Mr. Granada... haist...

[tazphel23]

bakit pag may nakakaaway ang gma 7, abs-cbn ang sinisisi? sino ba ang nanloko kanino?

[tazphel23]

Kawawa naman gma 7... try nyo po kaya gumawa ng maganda naman sa kapwa para lang maiba. Promise magaan sa pakiramdam nyo. Have a HEART mga KAPUSO! Mabuhay po kayo sir Gary...

[ihp0ts]

Dear Mr Gary Granada,

Ang husay nyo po talagang gumawa ng kanta. Pero ask ko lang, anu pong masasabi nyo sa songwriting style ni Rico Blanco? Pansin ko lang po kasi na nireretoke lang nya ang mga MELODY ng mga banyagang kanta. Yung overall feel ng mga kanta nya, hind mapapapagkaila na nadinig ko na sa iba.

Si Rico Blanco lang po ang ganitong lumikha ng kanta. Si ELy Buendia, Dong Abay at Tanya Markova, hindi naman,.

Salamat po. KAyo po ang TUNAY na henyo

Masugid na taga-pakinig,

Iph0ts.

[APHESIS928]

Kasama mo ako sa iyong mga likhang awitin, Bro. Gary, maging sa iyong mga ipinaglalaban.- Isang pang-aapi sa taong henyo sa musikang Pilipino!

[islandfisher1]

fuck u gma7..ang kapal nyo

[chrislucasphoto]

malinaw na pinagnakawan si ginoong gary granada sa sitwasyong ito. ang di ko matanggap, isang malaki at multi-awarded (locally at internaionally) na tv station ang salarin. kahiya-hiya. nagkataon lang ba na pareho sila ng inisyal ni gloria? marami silang talents na kung tawagin nila ay 'artists',pero walasilang respeto at pagkilala s aisnag tunay, batikan, bihasa at maginoong artist na gaya ni ggg. ngawa nila kay ggg, kaya at uulitin pa nilang gawin ito sa iba pang artist.

[putiatasul]

naging interesado ako sa sining nung nakilala ko yung dalawang fine art student na naninindigan sa mga paniniwala nila na ipaglaban ang karapatan ng mga artists, ganto na ang nangyayari.

[udiokero333]

ano n po nangyari sa kaso yan

[rockgod1771]

May kasabihan tayo,"trabaho lang, walang personalan". Ang sa GMA ay, PERA-PERA LANG, WALA KAYONG PAKIALAM.

Laban Sir Gary!!!

(Pasencya sa tagalog ko po, Ilonggo po kasi)

[rockgod1771]

kung kredibilidad ang pag usapan, parang palagi na lang ang GMA ang nangunguna sa paninira sa mga ka kumpetensya nila. Lahat ng butas na pwedeng ikasira ng mga kalaban nila sa negosyo ay palalakihin. Typical na masamang ugali ng pinoy "crab mentality". Ang istasyon na ito ay ipinundar para sa pera at pera lamang. Kailan ma'y walang puso ang taong sumasamba sa pera.

[Restlesshiker]

I'm may be out of sync with the time, but I wanted to let you know, Brod, that we're with you in your struggle.

[MenciAng100]

SHAME ON YOU, GMA Kapuso Foundation!

Sir Gary, saludo ako sa iyo. All these years you have done much to raise our awareness of issues. More power to you, Sir!

[jonrellimac]

kapuso nga ba? walang kwenta naonod pa naman ako ng mga program ng 7. as support to gary, hindi na ako manonood sa inyo.

[jolas691]

hahaha kahit compose n lng ninanakaw pa,,gma 7 wala kng kwenta yung puso mo gma din magnanakaw gloria macapagal arroyo kya pla gma kapuso daw?go gary naiintindihan ko sentimyento mo...idol kita,,,

[adrianmer666]

mga kasama, may mga videos ako about pinoy plagiarisms, panoorin nio and observe,

go kuya gary, kasama mo kami

[adrianmer666]

nagcocompose ako, alam ko ang pakiramdam pag ako ginawan ng plagiarism

hindi nila kayang lokohin c gary granada kc edukado siya pagdating sa music

[owengonzales29]

kaya nagkakagulo sa pinas e. ginaganyan ung mga obra ng mga tao.

[rennica08]

how could GMA do this to a national artist..? -_-"

Sir Gary Granada, we fully support you..

[springblueivan]

bakit yung abc composer di nagreklamo sa twinkle twinkle...

[marloncomia]

hehe pasaway ka pareng Ivan h

[adrianmer666]

nursery rhyme un tol

[scribe2468]

I know a little bit of music and had written a few songs myself. As an observation, let me just say that some of my songs, several bars anyway, in fact, follow the same chord progression as the songs that inspired me into writing my own songs. I'm probably not alone in that experience. Take "Ako Ay Pilipino" and "To God Be The Glory." Their similarities do extend beyond a few bars. Ditto with many of our Filipino folk songs (I-V-II-VII pattern mostly). Yoyoy Villame's songs too. Just a thought.

[pogsiters]

Tama lang yan Sir Gary, ipaglaban mo ang nasa "Puso" mo n wla sa PUSO ng programa ng KaPuso...

[mangmundo]

A Flash of Genius...see the movie!

[Androgenies]

Hindi naman pera pera ang habol dito ni Mr. Granada. Makikitid lang siguro mag-isip ang iba para sabihin na pera ang habol niya dito.

Karapatan din ni Mr. Granada na ihain at imungkahi ito sa publiko para na rin sa kapakanan ng paghahanap niya ng hustisya kesa manahimik na lamang.

Alam naman natin na hawak ng mayayaman ang batas. Ang ganitong mga kaso ang madalas isinasantabi ng hukuman, o kung hindi man, mas pinapaboran nila ang mas may pera at impluwensya.

[toggnid33]

tandaan mo manalo ka man dito pwede ka balikan ng paninira at [pananabutahe ng isang istasyon.

sana mag isisp muna tayo, o kaya naman madami free ligal advice dyan ask muna.

[toggnid33]

isa pang kaso na nakikita ko dito ay copy pirata, pinirata mo ang commercial ng GMA, sabi mo nga hinde sayo yun kinopya mo lamang sa TV. kaso parin sayo yun kapatid

[toggnid33]

yun sa kasunduan ninyo na lahat ng gagawin mo ay kailangan aprobado ng clients ng GMA na proctor & gamble phil, malinaw na hinde ang GMA ang may kagustuhan na yun ang gamitin nila, maliwanag na hinde ang GMA ang mag pipinal na magdidisisyon sa awitin ng commercial na ngayon ay nerereklamo mo.

hinde GMA ang makikinabang sa awitin mo kapatid.

[toggnid33]

di ko malaman bakit dinala mo kaagad ito sa youtube ganung may mga korte naman ang pilipinas.

hinde ba parang nabayaran ka ng kabila dahil sa hinde pag kakabayad sayo?

lumalabas na PERA ANG KAHULUGAN NG LAHAT NG ITO.

[toggnid33]

alam mo ba na pwede maibalik sayo ang mga ginawa mo na ito. pwede ka balikan ng paninirang puri, sabotahe.

baka kung magkano hinahabol mo sa GMA kulang pa pambayad mo sa kaso na isasampa sayo.

[toggnid33]

hinde ba dapat sa tamang lugar dalahin ang ganito kasilan na kaso?

[repacol]

Kahit saan talaga ang G-ME... este GMA... tsk tsk tsk... nasaan nga ba ang puso? Aist!

[grimnight]

ang gma talga oh.. karumal dumal.. tsk tsk..

[ruthy090192]

Only truth can set us all free. Man can hinder for the truth to be revealed but it is Gos who will show the world the wickedness of this ruthless evil doers. Let us pray for this two people.Gary G and Gma Kapuso

[prettynspiffy]

Nakkainis ang ginawa ng GMA! Klarung-klaro na they just "collectively" copied Mr. Granada's work. TINI-TRIPID DIN si Mr Granada. I just hope Ms. Tiangco could at least share her view re: this. Kung di sya expert (Ms. Tiangco)o, she could ask her son who is a singer/composer. Baka they can "collectively" persuade GMA bigwigs to say sorry to Mr. Granada . Pabayarin mo sila ng Damyos, Mr. Granada!

[benchwishmaster]

they are so bad, in any way na tignan natin. tama si Sir Gary, sila pa itong nagsusulong ng anti piracy campaign, sila pa itong gumagawa ng piracy subliminally. pero hindi na ito subliminal kundi lantaran na. halatang halata naman eh..

[ubetterthink]

Go Gary Granada...ipaglaban mo karapatan mo sa arogante at un propesyunal na istasyon...

[ubetterthink]

the true color of GMA is now revealed.

[blueknight22]

if incase at the end the "one" really commit the mistake...the "one" should compensate the "other one" what is duly due for him...if not then the "one" should suffer the lashes of our law or the law of the people w/c is "viewership". but i believe the "one" will do what is just and humane thing to do and had the ability to admit mistakes and correct it unlike the one i know that was...is still then (2) "second".

[thewisestofthemall]

d battle is not btwn 2 & 7, just 2 remind u that it's btwn gary & gma kapuso foundation. also, contrary 2 what u'r sayng 2 is actually d #1 undisputed leader & d pioneer of Phil. TV, not 2 mention d fact that it's d Asia's & d world's most admired Phil. Media Co., so what's d sense of dragging ABS n d issue? d verdict of d law & d ppol is 2 punish d dishonest, corrupt, arrogant, pretentious, & assuming 2 b d #1 network(7), bcoz d acts of plunder of ths station r obviously visible 4 so many x

[blueknight22]

we can not and should not pass quick judgement without thinking first all the angles of the story....

[Dibyong]

We alredi herd da story bhnd it... and we are not

judging anyone we are just posting our comments and opinions rgardng this godfosken issue......

ofcors if gma will hav da chance to say anyting on der side

ovyusly dey will say things dat will put dem on a safe place.......

[blueknight22]

its really nice to have a lot of EXPERTS in this world..they tend to MEGA BURSTS things as if it will be a matter of losin' d world....granted the "one" committed the mistake to the "other one" does it amount for you to tell that it will be the downfall of the "one"... all things should come on procedures...

[Dibyong]

musikero rin ako at kompositor npakaskit nman ng gnawa nio!!!!!! GMA!!!!!! sa tuno ng pnanalita ni Idol prang gs2 nia ng magmura.....

ramdam n ramdam ung glit, sma ng loob,

sakit at lhat ng msa2mang bagay

na pwdeng mramdaman.....

G- anid

M- agnanakaw

A- rogante

Putang ina nyo GMA!!!!!!!!

Bsta GMA salot

mpaTao o Network

[lourdjack]

nakakahiya ang GMA 7... tsk tsk

[c4rl3rik]

This kind of plagiarism also happened before on print ads. LOL GMA, even a 10 year old kid would know the difference between an original or a modified piece.

[lonewolfsdesire]

si chaosguy69 kung hindio ka expert sa music wag ka na munang magsalita.

only people who are adepts in music can fully understand and confirm or deny what Mr. Granada is claiming.

wag mong i-limit ang calim ni Mr. Granada sa lyrics ng kanta lang dahil hindi lang yan ang bumubuo sa isang awitin.

[wacks08]

Iba na talaga ang panahon ngayon... wala ng respeto sa mga matatanda ang mga tao ngayon tapos wala pang respeto sa mga musikero... bakit?? kung wala namang musikero walang buhay sa mundo... GMA sucks... tripid talaga sila parati... babalik na ako sa ABS... o kaya mag HHBO na lang ako... kainis!!!!

[chanemswil]

sa madaling salita.Kung gusto mong maging pirata eh dapat may malaki kang barko. this is not different from piracy, eh kahit kantahin mo ng wala sa tono malalaman mo na ung harmony at structure ng kanta came from Mr. Gary's study tape and not frm GMA 7.

I'm a sound forge software expert. I've been editing and organizing music using sound forge and I tried to compare the musical pattern coming from your study tape and the one broadcasted by GMA 7. preho sila ng signature

[sheggzpoohbear]

That's how I analyze it. Whether there is an applicable law for this and the above-stated analysis can support any violation on anything, then it should be applied.

[sheggzpoohbear]

As I noticed, there are very minimal and super slight deviation from the music made by Gary Granada.

The revised lyrics and music could have been given to the second composer and have it enhanced only.

Because if the instruction is to write a song, it would definitely be a "apply music start from scratch" approach.

It's as if the second composer heard it and applied minimal changes to it and re-arranged so it won't appear a "carbon copy" of the original.

[sheggzpoohbear]

Analysis on b:

Try to give that same lyrics to two composers and allow them to put music into it.

No two composers think alike or super close to "alike" even if you give them ample time to think and re-think.

The second composer could have done other beat or other musical approach but never "almost the same".

[sheggzpoohbear]

Analysis on a:

Given that GMA didn't like what Gary Granada has composed and opted to have another composer to do it, GMA could have given that composer "the original lyrics" which was presented earlier to Gary. But clearly, they used the "edited" lyrics suggested by Gary Granada to GMA. Suggested, not collaborated because the edited (not the entire lyrics) came from Gary.

[sheggzpoohbear]

I tried to rewind it a couple of times and have it played on my keyboard. There I noticed, very slight/minimal changes on the notes... instead of using lower note, they opted to choose a higher note to make it appear "a lil different" from that of Gary Granada....

I went back to his claims:

a. Ginamit ang edited lyrics batay sa pagkasukat ko. - EXACTLY

b. Ginamit na tungtungan ang musical structure na ginawa. - EXACTLY

[tudjeg]

para sa akin iyan ay malawakang (collective) Pamumusong. Grabeng pangiinsulto sa pinakamagaling na artist sa larangan ng pagsusulat. Buti na lang di ako nagsasubmit sa mga songwriting contest nila kundi baka ninakawan na rin ako ng ideas.( di naman kaya may history na rin sila sa mga naunang mas mahihina?)

[dpsyndic4t3]

ok...im convinced...i-BOYKOT na ang procter and gamble products at GMA...

[chaosguy69]

Certainly, Mr. Granada cannot claim sole authorship of the lyrics because he himself admits that GMA provided the lyrics and that he rewrote portions of it, which means that he admits as well the authorship of the lyrics by GMA Marketing.

[chaosguy69]

Mr. Granada claims that the lyrics used for the plug is his version. We dispute that. GMA Marketing provided Mr. Granada the complete lyrics for the music he was supposed to compose. He changed a word in these lyrics. With due respect to Mr. Granda, that does not make the lyrics, under copyright law, his version or his work.

[chaosguy69]

malinaw naman kasi sa sinabi ni gary na hindi sa kanya ang lyrics..

[thewisestofthemall]

nililigaw mo ang usapan, hindi lang naman lyrics ang argumento d2

1. edited lyrics na kinopya ng GMA (ipagpalagay natin na sa kanila ang lyrics, bakit nila kinopya ang edited version ni gary-dapat gumawa cla ng sarili nilang editing kc sobrang halata na xerox ang final product mula sa pinaghirapan ng iba)

2. musical structure na ginaya rin ng GMA (intensyon ng GMA ang manlapastangan ng isang artista, dapat hindi nila ginamit na batayan ang musical structure na ginawa ni gary)

[chaosguy69]

sa pagkakaalam ko bago ma approve or mai copyryt mo ang composition,it will take tym sa dami ng kaeklatan..kaya u cannot claim that it was yours unless copyryted na,pero kung sinubmit mo na and it was rejected,,and then rearrange etc..di mo ma nga siya ma claim na sayo kasi ni revise na......

[groovyman77]

Now, what does "Kapuso" really stand for? It is not even a legitimate Filipino word. Lumalabas na ang totoo na ang GMA e puro kasinungalingan sa kanilang mga sinasabi tungkol sa mga iba't-ibang kampanya nila. "Walang pinoprotektahan"? E karapatan nga ng isang beteranong kompositor e hindi nila marespeto. Ang pinoprotektahan nila ay walang iba kundi ang sarili nilang kapakanan. This is a vulgar display of arrogance and deceit. Simula na talaga ng pagbagsak ng GMA.

[rockerbanger]

suportahan natin si gary granada! let this be heard, let everybody know of what GMA Kapuso Foundation did to a very talented composer.

[gilalicious3]

sobra.. kapuso b tlga sila o walang pus0? hndi man ako musician pero obious naman na kinopya lang gawa ni gary.. haizz..

[sitiongco]

gary... as a sign of support i posted both videos on my facebook... just email if i can some more help online.... at mabuhay ka kapatid at kaalagad!

[sitiongco]

Hi gary,,,, i posted both videos in my facebook account as a sign of support.... kung meon pa akong pwedeng maisuporta online just email...

[grimnight]

grabe talga gma oh.. tsk tsk.. karumal dumal..

[darknightwing1]

kapal naman ng mukha ng GMA

[toorkone]

boses ba talaga ni gary granada yan?

[gawanigawa]

pahabol: sir gary, collectively kang ninakawan

[gawanigawa]

hindi yata maganda ginawa ng GMA 7 dito kay sir GG.... i guess basta may initials na GMA e nanakawan ka lang yata lolz.... seriously, lets support sir Gary on this one.

[iahn13]

ay!..sobra nman ata un...kakabigat isipin na may ganto kalaking company d2 sa Pilipinas ganun ganun nlang mang trato ng kapwa nila Pilipino... we support you Gary Granada on your complaint against the Kapuso's. Mabuhay ka!