Philosophy w/Sushi: The Chinese Room

[TheEminem430]

which is that hack u have?

[LCGdude]

i'm so confused x(

[hlvs44]

Great video. I don't think Searle intended to disprove AI, he just wanted to point out how misleading/pointless it is to say that a non-human "understands" something without knowing the physical basis for understanding in humans.

[ayoopdog]

thank you! you helped me with my in-class essay :D

[SkyrimCube]

Great video!

[MultiMegakevin]

after watching this i feel stupid rewatch

[Anthonychua1982]

wtf is ancient mandarin? In any case, I think was not trying to tell which scenario is true or false. Based on the first conclusion that "oh the machine understands chinese", he swaps the "machine" for a person in a box with a manual. Thus the person in a box/room is like the machine and produces the same results. However, looking at it this way, we know that the person inside the room doesnt actually understand Chinese, but rather follows the manual religiously to come up with the output.

[SinCitySpartanHD]

You should do a Commentary of were you see yourself in five years because your actually intellectual with your subs in your videos.

[alecazam3567]

i love quantum physics. More please. Do more Sushi! O.o

[ayoopdog]

@alecazam3567 this isn't quantum physics! it's cognitive science.

[alecazam3567]

@ayoopdog lol well i posted this comment when he mentioned quantum physics and i immediately wanted more hahaha

[pelares666]

in my opinion you can make something clear of the experiment, in fact now i believe that strong AI is impossible. Because the person in the room will eventuelly learn chinese while the computer will just repeat the process without a ''deeper understanding'' of it. This lack of deeper understandig is provided by the fact that the computer it's not a concious being, becuase concious beings like us tend to fail, so a strong AI will also fail at the end

[CanadianSinna]

You're honestly my new favourite youtube commentator, you're not just another stupid ass CoD player wanting subs, you actually talk about interesting stuff, and listen to good music. Well done!

[alekzander2010]

you speak Mandarin?

Awesome but do you speak Ancient Mandarin or the Short simple version of mandarin

(Random fact:the name Mandarin came from portugal the Manda means order in portguese and it ahde something to do with the chinese nobles)

[Dustinj15]

Well considering that the human in the room is exactly how our brains work we need to figure out what "learning" and "understanding" actualy is.

[MihaiViteazul100]

Hey SushiRush, can you explain the Chinese room for me. I read the things in the description but I didn't understand well. Please help, I'm just a dumb ghetto kid :(

[rubberbumm]

I feel so dum know

[becool365]

I heard of the problem before. It seems BF3 running on a GeForce 560 Ti, tends to have a lot of problems of that kind. I would update drivers and try again.

[redsoxloverjeff]

I was following you until around 4:40, then you lost me.

[Ean2796]

That's some crazy stuff

[Nodd93]

Why would we need to google it? It's right there on the right hand side......

[TheHCZI42]

So after watching this I looked up Schrödinger's cat, since you mentioned it. I don't even understand that!

So the cat is alive AND dead until you look at it?

And why would the cat be dead?

Oh and I totally see your logic on the Chinese room thing. I think although the computer is weak (does not understand Chinese) this idea cannot be extrapolated without further study.

[chunkymilk]

You need to watch Ghost in the Shell.

[redsoxloverjeff]

If you play GTA IV regularly, you should get the LCPD:FR mod. I have videos of it.

[GeneralBlackNorway]

Sounds cool but it's a bit hard 4 me to understand this cause it sounds like a lot like brain fuck an English is not my native language.

[Drenizer]

I'm not sure if I should respond, because it'll be more than 500 characters and I don't know if beginning a discussion was part of your intention.

[FalloutNVand3Rock]

I have lots of spare averagegameplay how can I send it to you do u want me.to upload it so.u.can download it and use it as ur own

[heuykiller]

Great philosophical video, I would love to see more of these.

[t3hslowpoke]

@heuykiller It is great, not your regular retarded commentary with zero efforts, but i dont see how it is philosophical, just logical.

[RajandTajProductions]

SCREW YOU I"M TOO STEWPID AND I CAN"T TAKE ANY INTELLECTUALITY IN VIDEO GAME COMMENTARIES. !UNSUBSCRIBE!

[xSushiRush]

@RajandTajProductions aidsmonkey

[RajandTajProductions]

@xSushiRush "month of may...transition to summa"

[JMiguelDS4]

@xSushiRush do a commentary with ur thoughts about ACTA and SOPA.

let us know more about it, with some intelligent comments.

i only say, "sopa is stupid bla bla " im tired of those comments without any point of cryticism.

thanks

Apreciate ur videos man.

[Berserkism]

@xSushiRush Maybe your not conscious? Maybe your just simulating it?

[terssi12]

@RajandTajProductions stupid cunt. Just watch the "real" gameplay commentaries.

[xSushiRush]

@terssi12 He was being sarcastic. 

[MrGman543]

@xSushiRush i am more into politics but that was very interesting haha. i have never even heard the chinese room thing.

[RajandTajProductions]

@terssi12 lol tard

[MrWeescottyab1]

@terssi12 shut down lol

[TheShreddster]

@terssi12 lol. idiot

[IAmAPeanut96]

Fantastic, this is genuinley my favorite video by you, for the plain fact that it's original.

Great work Sushi, been here since 300 subs and i'm still loving it.

[Dinozords]

And yes im saying this because i didnt understand what you said the entire time. And i did watch the entire 6 minute and 43 second video

[c2fan22]

@Dinozords yea i kinda didnt get it because it was just him sitting there bitching about an expiriment that he thinks and prolly alot of other ppl dont agree with

[Dinozords]

@c2fan22 Seems like most of his videos nowadays are him complaining about something or someone, when i subbed to him it was because he was a good gameplay commentator trying to hep me get better at pc and what not but now hes just a pecimest and i dont enjoy his videos anymore

[xSushiRush]

@Dinozords @c2fan22

Wait, what? I wasn't bitching about anything, I was explaining how Searle's thought experiment does nothing to disprove strong AI. If you don't get what I was talking about, further reading is in the description. If you don't feel like doing some research that's totally fine, just don't call me out for "complaining". It makes no sense. I made this video with the intention of providing you guys with an interesting and thought provoking watch. Thanks for the feedback.

[MatthewNJDavis]

Interesting

[PuRpLeXkoBrA]

How could we send you some gameplay? I have HD gameplay for BF3, which I recorded with Bandicam Pro! I would love to help you out but how can I send it to you?

[xSushiRush]

@PuRpLeXkoBrA Dropbox, or any another file sharing service.

[PuRpLeXkoBrA]

@xSushiRush Alright I will upload some, do you want me to PM you the link to the file?

[PuRpLeXkoBrA]

@xSushiRush What settings would you recommend I use that I use, cause the footage I have is more or less just testing settings... For months now I have been trying to get good settings for bandicam, but I just can't get it.

[JMiguelDS4]

@PuRpLeXkoBrA i mean (i only ear * "sopa is stupid bla bla ")**

[PuRpLeXkoBrA]

@JMiguelDS4 What? You lost me...

[DeRealDealOneill]

awesome :D