the closest malay language to thai is the dialect of the malaysian malay mainly kelantanese dialect , or northern malaysia peninsular state perlis . the people of Satun , Thailand do speak in malay northern dialect , or loghat utagha , like the word canggung which has a meaning of "dancing??" , and the perlisian or kedahan malay would say " ala canggung makcik la masih canggung " : the ladies ( older ladies : aunt ) is still dancing
@destroyxeverything Just like the current Indonesian script is based on Roman letters even though Indonesian isn't a romance language, the Javanese and Balinese scripts are based on the Indic / Brahmi letters. Just like Thai is not an Indic language, because of religion / trade history etc, their are a lot of Sanskrit loan words in there.
I like the way you pronounce English words with Indonesian accent. That's exactly how we would actually pronounce them in Indonesian. The sad thing is that many young Indonesians nowadays would always *try* to pronounce English words using English accents just to make them sound/look smarter, especially the ones who study overseas. I would always cringe every time they do that, especially when they use the "English R" when they speak Indonesian. Oh, for God's sake, please at least roll them Rs!
Having been dabbling in mandarin on and off for almost a year i've never really taken it as seriously as I should to become fluent, so i type in multilingual into youtube and find you! Quite simply i'm blown away! I'd love your advise in learning how to read and write mandarin especially as thats the part i think will be most most difficult for me. I also noticed you mentioned your wife, being mixed race yourself and speaking so many languages, im curious to know what nationality your wife is!
@khanjutsu Learning to read Chinese, the first thing is to dive into it straight away. Make sure that you get your pin yin down really well from the beginning. It will make life easier for yourself in the long run. Although there are thousands of characters, there are only about 300 that make up 85% of what you read from day to day. Don't just learn individual characters - learn them as bi-syllabic words. Also - get a copy of Cracking the Chinese Puzzles by T.K. Ann!
most of Javanese youth cant read the Hanacaraka well.... but there's a bule who can read it fluently.... oasm... saiki sampeyan tinggal neng endhi mas Jay?
hi! we also have the same situation in the philippines. people are interested in polishing their english skills and in learning other foreign languages like japanese, spanish, korean, french, german, mandarin etc., but neglect local languages like cebuano, ilokano, ibanag, pangasinan, etc.
but i'm interested in learning javanese and buginese language. are you planning to upload videos on basic javanese and buginese?
Hello Stu, piye kabare? I'm with you on the keeping alive 'bahasa daerah Indonesia'. Saya tahu beberapa...basa Jawa, Sunda, Batak, Bali. I ask my Indonesian friends about their local languages. But its hard to find books on bahasa daerah. I do have a book for basa Jawa. Oh and I just learning Thai, phom kau jai pasa Thai nit noi khrab. I have Pimsleur Thai. Excellent videos btw. How long have you been studying Thai and Indonesian?
@MrJoem18 There are books out there if you look, but not as many as I'd like. The most I've found are for Balinese. All the main Javanese books I have teach it with only the Roman script - not Hanacaraka which is sad. Maybe this clip can inspire more ppl to get into it!
@stujaystujay Hee Mas Stu....I am still able to read and write the "Ha Na Ca Ra Ka". of the Javanese alphabet. I am living in Campbell, OHIO, USA. It is interesting that the Javanese scripts with the Wayang Kulit pictures that you display is actually Christian Prayer (the "Our Father" = Romo Kahulo) taken from gthe Gospel of Matthew 6: 9-13. Keep up the good work. Mugo tansah pinayungan ing basuki yo Mas.
@MrJoem18 It's been really sad watching them die out of popular use. In Malaysia, I have seen a resurgence in publications in tulisan Jawi aimed at all levels - kids, students, adults. Maybe that would be a good solution in Indonesia.
@stujaystujay I'd hate to see any of them die out. There so interesting. You can connect even more with the Indonesian people if you speak their bahasa daerah and better understand their culture. Tulisan Jawi is still taught in schools ya, why don't they just use it throughout up until college ?
@112ddd211 Thanks. Just doing things by trial and error trying to find a good match between quality snd content. Want to make something that people will want to watch.
@stujaystujay cool, as far as new video ideas go - besides the 2 I already gave you, I've got plenty more, but most are grammar related topics regarding some of the languages you've studied - i.e. indonesian pronouns and transitive verbs - but also tips on learning chinese characters, ...
Lucu,Aksara Jawa itu yang di ucapkan oleh stuart jay itu ngawur. hanacaraka dibaca dengan honocoroko,ini baru benar.....
MyGamelan 1 week ago in playlist Uploaded videos
wah, hebat!!! senang saya bisa nonton video anda :D
inikitaphoto 2 months ago
good indonesian accent sir..
wjo92 3 months ago
the closest malay language to thai is the dialect of the malaysian malay mainly kelantanese dialect , or northern malaysia peninsular state perlis . the people of Satun , Thailand do speak in malay northern dialect , or loghat utagha , like the word canggung which has a meaning of "dancing??" , and the perlisian or kedahan malay would say " ala canggung makcik la masih canggung " : the ladies ( older ladies : aunt ) is still dancing
syedfaez 5 months ago
THUMBS UP !!!
RajkoMuzika 6 months ago
Yes I agree there are "loan words". But other than that, we are part of the Austronesian family.
destroyxeverything 7 months ago
Bahasa daerah is NOT indic or sanskrit related. Get ur facts straight! Its malayo-polynesian.
I hate how Indonesians think they are related to the Thais, burmese or any other SEAsian when in fact, we have our OWN distic language family!
destroyxeverything 7 months ago
@destroyxeverything Just like the current Indonesian script is based on Roman letters even though Indonesian isn't a romance language, the Javanese and Balinese scripts are based on the Indic / Brahmi letters. Just like Thai is not an Indic language, because of religion / trade history etc, their are a lot of Sanskrit loan words in there.
stujaystujay 7 months ago 3
I like the way you pronounce English words with Indonesian accent. That's exactly how we would actually pronounce them in Indonesian. The sad thing is that many young Indonesians nowadays would always *try* to pronounce English words using English accents just to make them sound/look smarter, especially the ones who study overseas. I would always cringe every time they do that, especially when they use the "English R" when they speak Indonesian. Oh, for God's sake, please at least roll them Rs!
topaztrex 9 months ago
some of subliminal effect hope not make my love u hahaha...
ujivan87 11 months ago
@ujivan87 subliminal??
stujaystujay 10 months ago
what it's that ? This video have "something",
ujivan87 11 months ago
Wouldn't happen to have a transcript for this video in Bhs would you? Makasih banyak, harian, saya dengan video ini untuk berlatih.
BobtheMoneythedbr 1 year ago
Having been dabbling in mandarin on and off for almost a year i've never really taken it as seriously as I should to become fluent, so i type in multilingual into youtube and find you! Quite simply i'm blown away! I'd love your advise in learning how to read and write mandarin especially as thats the part i think will be most most difficult for me. I also noticed you mentioned your wife, being mixed race yourself and speaking so many languages, im curious to know what nationality your wife is!
khanjutsu 1 year ago
@khanjutsu OK having watched all your videos my last question is answered! looking forward to your tips and wisdom in mandarin,
khanjutsu 1 year ago
@khanjutsu Thai :)
stujaystujay 1 year ago
@khanjutsu Learning to read Chinese, the first thing is to dive into it straight away. Make sure that you get your pin yin down really well from the beginning. It will make life easier for yourself in the long run. Although there are thousands of characters, there are only about 300 that make up 85% of what you read from day to day. Don't just learn individual characters - learn them as bi-syllabic words. Also - get a copy of Cracking the Chinese Puzzles by T.K. Ann!
stujaystujay 1 year ago
well.. I recalled something.. it's taught when I still at elementary
the reason why they ordered like this :
Ha Na Ca Ra Ka
Da Ta Sa Wa La
Pa DHa Ja Ya NYa
Ma Ga Ba THa NGa
it's actually a poem.., and every part has its own meaning,
each part teach how javanese people's way of thinking..
sorry for my bad english.. thanks..
piyonigma1 1 year ago
@Uranggokil BKK THL + Gold coast Aust
stujaystujay 1 year ago
most of Javanese youth cant read the Hanacaraka well.... but there's a bule who can read it fluently.... oasm... saiki sampeyan tinggal neng endhi mas Jay?
Uranggokil 1 year ago
lo orang mana mas ?
s290709ws 1 year ago
@s290709ws asli Australia ... campur Bule / India
stujaystujay 1 year ago
@stujaystujay saya kira wong madiun hahaha
s290709ws 1 year ago
I love your videos, but your intros are way too long, my friend.
dude3390 1 year ago
hi! we also have the same situation in the philippines. people are interested in polishing their english skills and in learning other foreign languages like japanese, spanish, korean, french, german, mandarin etc., but neglect local languages like cebuano, ilokano, ibanag, pangasinan, etc.
but i'm interested in learning javanese and buginese language. are you planning to upload videos on basic javanese and buginese?
july071992 1 year ago
andaikan bahasa indonesia menggunakan honocoroko (hanacaraka)
aryowailangitoyo97 1 year ago
orang ini bisa berbahasa 25 bahasa
aryowailangitoyo97 1 year ago
i'm indonesian
aryowailangitoyo97 1 year ago
Wow Bahassa Indonesia is such an easy language (I can speak it also). Also how come that ancient alphabet died out?
Chezrocksall 1 year ago
สวัสดี, ผมสนุกวิดีโอของคุณมากและอยากทราบถ้าคุณมีSkypeหรือไม่ ภาษาไทยของคุณดีมาก คุณมีความชำนาญในภาษาไทยไหม? ถ้าคุณมีSkype, กรุณาให้ผมชื่อของคุณ ขอบคุณมาก
Chezrocksall 1 year ago
Hello Stu, piye kabare? I'm with you on the keeping alive 'bahasa daerah Indonesia'. Saya tahu beberapa...basa Jawa, Sunda, Batak, Bali. I ask my Indonesian friends about their local languages. But its hard to find books on bahasa daerah. I do have a book for basa Jawa. Oh and I just learning Thai, phom kau jai pasa Thai nit noi khrab. I have Pimsleur Thai. Excellent videos btw. How long have you been studying Thai and Indonesian?
Thanks,
MrJoem18 1 year ago
@MrJoem18 There are books out there if you look, but not as many as I'd like. The most I've found are for Balinese. All the main Javanese books I have teach it with only the Roman script - not Hanacaraka which is sad. Maybe this clip can inspire more ppl to get into it!
stujaystujay 1 year ago
@stujaystujay Hee Mas Stu....I am still able to read and write the "Ha Na Ca Ra Ka". of the Javanese alphabet. I am living in Campbell, OHIO, USA. It is interesting that the Javanese scripts with the Wayang Kulit pictures that you display is actually Christian Prayer (the "Our Father" = Romo Kahulo) taken from gthe Gospel of Matthew 6: 9-13. Keep up the good work. Mugo tansah pinayungan ing basuki yo Mas.
masyanto 1 year ago
@MrJoem18 It's been really sad watching them die out of popular use. In Malaysia, I have seen a resurgence in publications in tulisan Jawi aimed at all levels - kids, students, adults. Maybe that would be a good solution in Indonesia.
stujaystujay 1 year ago
@stujaystujay I'd hate to see any of them die out. There so interesting. You can connect even more with the Indonesian people if you speak their bahasa daerah and better understand their culture. Tulisan Jawi is still taught in schools ya, why don't they just use it throughout up until college ?
MrJoem18 1 year ago
your videos are really top notch!
the editing and imaging alone is outstanding, combine that with the one-of-a-kind content and you've got something here un-matched on youtube.
112ddd211 1 year ago
@112ddd211 Thanks. Just doing things by trial and error trying to find a good match between quality snd content. Want to make something that people will want to watch.
stujaystujay 1 year ago
Comment removed
112ddd211 1 year ago
Comment removed
112ddd211 1 year ago
@stujaystujay cool, as far as new video ideas go - besides the 2 I already gave you, I've got plenty more, but most are grammar related topics regarding some of the languages you've studied - i.e. indonesian pronouns and transitive verbs - but also tips on learning chinese characters, ...
but really looking forward to your next videos
112ddd211 1 year ago
I love that Bahasa Indonesia!
5Language 1 year ago
@5Language I love it too!
stujaystujay 1 year ago
@5Language Can you read this script?
stujaystujay 1 year ago
@stujaystujay Nope, but I'd like to.
5Language 1 year ago
@5Language So u need this chart then ;p
stujaystujay 1 year ago