Added: 3 years ago
From: TulZi
Views: 1,011,652
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (3,386)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i got goose bumps when he wisperd"im the one blowing throo your haaaair" and "whos theere?"lol..p.s(the best part is i had headphones so it was in MY ear!!!!)

  • thanks a lot, now i pooped my pants infront of my parents

  • Brendon makes this song...sexy?

  • I love this song!!!!

  • I mean better

  • Marylon mansons was 2,000,000 times netyer

  • @OchioChan1325 you lie

  • you lied.... it says + lyrics

  • @boppa1082 I would appreciate if you would take a look at the orange box where Jack says where the lyrics are... Long live hasty decisions calling people liars, huh?

  • What exactly is a tender lumpling? xD

    Anyway, love this song(: It's always been my favorite. All my friends call me a creep and yell at me because it's not halloween.

  • @BelieveinmeLexxi I think it's a small, fat child :)

  • @ThEcAtScAmEbAcK OMG I DIED OF LAUGHTER WHEN I READ THIS LOLOLOLOL

  • @ThEcAtScAmEbAcK

    LMAO! Thanks..xD

  • I love this song!!! :D it's my favorite... But my friends think I'm crazy...

  • OMG I LOVE THIS SO MUCH I TINK I JUST DIED!!!!!!!!!

  • *Q*

  • ugh... Marilyn Manson's version is wayyyy better.

  • @Airlocke77 you wish!

  • @Airlocke77 well than go watch that instead of this! XD

  • FREAKING LOVE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS.. and Panic! At the Disco.. Omfg. I just died. <3

  • @TheReidNation rest in peace <3

  • Yeah, it's too calm and passive. This probably won't scare any little kids anytime soon.

  • Is this on a cd?? And if it is can someone tell me??!! I really LOVE this song!

  • @YoFreakyMother Don't hate on Panic!. Just don't.

  • @Emma498 dude chill some people actually like this so no need to bash on it so hardly

  • Can't wait until next Halloween(: haha

  • Omg no matter how many times I replay this song I can't stop loving it <3

  • wow this shit sucks way more than I expected.

  • Eh, the original and Manson's version are better.

  • *sigh* brandon is amazing!

    

  • Hey all! I just wanted to say thanks for all the views! YOU ARE AMAZING! Lots of love from TulZi <3

  • YEAH! 1 million views!

  • is this really be panic at the disco!!?? its so cool though and it does sound like them

  • Ohhhh, how I wish I was Jack in this songg...-_-

  • @Alexrocks8499 I agree with you xD

  • @bajs006 Lol

  • @AlternativeProject3 Yup I agree

  • Chills

  • K so here's what I think! I think panic!'s version is more eery and creepy, meant To haunt while MM's version is crazy psycho kill you with a rusty spoon kind of scary. So both are pretty damn awesome. There end of conversation!

  • heh why the h*ll am i listening to this? its January!

    than again it's never to late for Danny Elfman's music

  • I like this one, too, but I'm addicted to Marilyn Manson's version, even though this one is more true to the original :)

  • I check under my bed every night. Not for monsters

    For Brendon.

  • @Koopa368 bredon frazier?!?!

  • i love the movie and i love the songs

  • An awesome band and an amzing as hell movie !!!!! <3

  • Love the 'Woo' at the end :D

  • darnit, Brendon! you lie! you are NOT under my bed! I CHECKED!!! >:O

  • Two of ,y favorite things: Tim Burton movies and Panic! At The Disco

  • Panic at the Disco is perfect for this song. :D

  • I like the way Panic! sings it. However, I do prefer Marilyn Manson's version. With Panic!, they keep the mystical 'kiddish' charm to the song (not that it's bad) but with MM, it's like he transformed the entire song into something hardcore and awsome (in other words... kick ass).

  • I like them both! Of course, I prefer this one because it's Panic! but they are both amazing.

  • Oh no you don't! no more posting your opinions if you think Marylin did it better or PATD did it better. OR if you like one better than the other. Have you seen the previous comments? They're ridiculous, MM did it better, No PATD is better, who bloody cares?! Just say if it was good or if you prefer MM better. Not all blunt, because people take it the wrong way and *poof* You have a war.

  • Marilyn Manson wins no questions asked

  • Marilyn Manson would sing this for his kids lulllaby.

  • gay marilyn manson wins hands down

  • i love this panic at the disco and Marilyn Manson =D

  • any body else hear the clock?

  • ill be the one hiding under your bed

  • No. Its freaking girlie. And I love Panic! At the Disco.

  • Brendon is the wind blowing through my hair ;)

  • Sudden craving for The Nightmare Before Christmas.... and Brendon Urie

  • @Girsawasquirrel1 me to very weird! HAHA!!

  • Nice, but I prefer Marilyn Manson version better. Sounds more psycho.

  • this is better than the original.

  • Small pumpkins that have just sprouted and are ripe

  • What are tender lumplings?

  • What are tender lumplings?

  • @MsSilverBubbles

    Question

    What is a tender lumpling anyway?

    Answer

    Good question. I'm still trying to figure that one out. It comes from an old Mystic Knights of the Oingo Boingo poem.... And so my tender lumplings, let my welcome hear you now... Into our flesh-pink home of hearts we greet you with a bow... So entertain you must we may our pleasure from within. The Oingo Boingo treasure chest of lust and mortal sin.

  • Wow but i like falloutboys still the best On this cd but still like this

  • BRENDON IS HOT!

    

  • Brendon sounds so hot in this song!

  • Its cool their voices are so lullibic :)

  • I agree with u completely love it but the original is better

  • "I think that both are awesome but the other original is better paucity at the disco band is better though

  • this version of the song is BAD ASS !!! ^,,^

  • good but never gonna beat marlyn mansons version sorry people

  • ryan's "lala"s at the end <3

  • brendon did a better job than the original<3

  • Good lord..he could be the wind blowing through my hair... ;)

  • cool

  • My new favorite song..

  • MWAHAHAHAHA!!!

  • +1'd???????

  • anyone else notice how unbarably sexy his voice is when he says im the who in the call whos there?

  • Ehh Marylin Manson's version is better..

  • Comment removed

  • Eargasm-3

  • Marilyn Mansons is horrible. And yet again I have to post why. The MM's version didn't get the point through and 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' wasn't made to frighten everyone. Its telling a story about a person who lost hold of who he really was, and he embarked on a journey to find himself again. This version understood that, and showed us that its a beloved fairytale, not a horror movie. So all you people who dislike this version: Hide before the 'Other Mother' gets you. :p

  • @IceyCat134 ok you may be right about the fact that it wasnt meant to scare people, but that doesnt mean marilyn manson is horrible. He/she made a version of the song that would appeal to someone who would prefer a more awesome sounding song. it may have altered its message, but marilyn's goal wasnt to keep the message, his/her goal was to make the song a lot cooler for those who would like the song to have a hard rock beat. so its not right to say he/she is horrible. just saying.

  • @gumba1033 Go ahead and think what you want but you mainly said that they twisted the song to get money out of it and didn't get the point across at all, yet again ruining more people's minds and pushing people farther and farther away from thinking for themselves and having sanity. Thanks for putting up a decent fight but the marilyn mansons version is horrible. and I think they would even take that as a compliment. So this war is over. :p

  • @IceyCat134 ok you have your opinion and i have mine. i wasnt even trying to participate in a"war" lol geez all im saying is a lot of people think the song made by marilyn is an improvement over the original as far as sound goes. maybe its horrible in its "message" and its fine for you to think that. and youre probably right. but it doesnt make the whole song complete crap, you know what i mean? i personally like that song thats just why i felt like i had to say this, im not trying to argue.

  • @gumba1033 I'm just sick of people posting that MM's version is better when Its not. I'd prefer if people who enjoy their types of music wouldn't go and make rude comments on a genre they probably don't even listen to or something. Ya know?

  • @IceyCat134 I agree with Gumba1033, sure Manson has some bad songs, but Halloween is by far his greatest achievement. It doesn't suck, you just don't like that kind of music and there is no reason for you to push that opinion on others and be a dick about it. And if i wanted to here what i can only describe as a boy band singing it, i'd go somewhere else, because for a boy band, these guys SUCK.

  • @XxDrRainfallxX You can shush up. Your saying this version sucks? Can't a boy band try a new genre of music? This version does not suck. And I'm not a boy FWI. And if you don't even like this song, why are you even listening to this music?

  • @IceyCat134 I'd say the same about the Manson version, if you didn't like it, why did you listen to it? Lol and no, boy bands are boy bands, but if you like them, I won't challenge that. I'll I am trying to say is don't hate on other people for being different >:D

  • @IceyCat134 really! a coraline reference! (no joke she scares the crap out of me)

  • Marilyn Manson's song originally, Danny Elfman (who voices Jack Skeleton who is EPIC) did a cover of it for the movie, and Panic! At the Disco did THIS epic cover.

    Any way you look at it, all the versions are insanly AWESOME. =D

  • This is my math teachers favorite movie :$ he let us watch it just before break, haha me and him could sing along to all the songs :)

  • Ok.. all im gonna say is.. i.. freaking.. love.. this.. song.

  • Danny Elfman > Manson's cover > Panic! At the Disco's cover

  • lmao, i was in italian class and my teacher played this song (the italian version, not P!ATD) and she was singing along.... towards the end she says "i remember a nice band did a remake of this song" i Yell " PANIC! AT THE DISCO" i got detention for calling out, but so worth it for giving credit where it is given

  • Hearing dis in Christmas :D

  • I'm listening to this on christmas day. My family thinks I'm insane. :D

  • Jack is like my favorite character ever! I'm about to see The Nightmare Before Christmas in a minute. I could listen to this song all day! Love Panic! At The Disco!

  • I hate when people ask for thumbs up but... Thumb this up if you love Panic! At The Disco and your family/freinds think you're nuts for listening to this on Christmas/eve!

  • i kinda like it to be honest, but i think the marylin manson version is better than this one

  • @TheFireman4903 Fudge you. Stop spamming us with dirty lies

  • Brandon how bout you come from under my bed and be on top ;D

    Love this song! Love the movie! And love this flipping band!!

  • @egc0929 Ight word.

  • @egc0929 Sorry to correct you but his name is Brendon. And I second that.

  • @Draculaura321 its ok im glad you corrected me :)

  • I love the way he says "Surprise" at 2:31!

  • hows come this was not on nightmare revisited!?

  • oh thats why my dreams are soo creepy! (if u new wat i dream u would think im nuts, goth, emo and lots of other stuff!)

  • @Creatureofthenight16 Illiterate, maybe?

  • jack is soooooooo cute! he<s my favorit character! i have like 3 posters from the movie!

  • i love this song! i love the movie "the nightmare before christmas" i mean is it a christmas or halloween movie.... wait i can anwser that....... both!

  • my school band played this for the winter concert the band director could not get the name of the "young band that made the song for the movie" so i yelled "PANIC! AT THE DISCO"

    i believe i educated my school community into knowing that their beloved movie has my beloved band's music as the best song on the soundtrack

  • @xxultrahappyxx It sounds really awesome - but I have to tell you that Panic! didn't make this song - they just covered it :/ The original music from the film is made by John Carpenter :)

  • @TulZi Danny Elfman actually did the music..

  • @TulZi What? I thought that was Danny Elfman. Hmmm...

  • @2002tiif You are right - I found the wrong name :)

  • @TulZi Alright. :)

  • @TulZi I know it's by Danny Elfman but the director asked for the teenage band and P!ATD came to my mind but I know it's by D. Elfman. ;D

  • @2002tiif yeash it is Danny Elfman  :D xx <3 <3

  • @xxultrahappyxx ours played it as well, how weird. Are you talking about A nightmare before Christmas That began with overture/Whats this/Sally's song, and This is Halloween

  • @xxultrahappyxx i love nightmare before Christmas i told my principal that we play this for the winter thing we were having and he said no it inappropriate and im like wtf is wrong with u

  • @xxultrahappyxx Manson made it better.

  • @xxultrahappyxx patd did a great job at remaking this song

  • @xxultrahappyxx ya actually yelled that!?

  • <3 should of been the orginal.

    it's okay brandon you can be under my bed. (;

  • Where did u pick that pic tell me plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz !! :)

  • Jacks Soooooooooooooooo cute!

  • this jack looks like he has an eye patch on

    

  • It was seen on MCR... Its by P@TD... and its THIS IS HALLOWEEN. IM in LOVE with THIS

  • if Brendon Urie is..

    .. the one hiding under my bed and stairs, my house is awesome

    .. the one with the tear away face, then his tear away face is HAWT!!!

    ..the wind that blows threw my hair, then thank you because you make it look amazing

    .. the ''who'' to my ''who's there'' then he must be around me alot :D

  • @maddiegal89 no it would b my house that is awesome my friend!

  • i'm sorry boys, i love u to death, but Marilyn Manson is just too beast at this song to compete. props for trying though! XD

  • Brendon can be hiding under my stairs anytime he feels like it!

  • Brendon's under my bed? He must be hungry,I'll get him a biscuit ^.^

  • Marilyn Manson owns this xddd

  • like if u raped the replay button

  • im more concerned wit the wind in my hair!! it took me 2 hours to get it this way so stay out of it!!!!!!

  • Brendon you can hide under my bed! Lmao XD

  • Soul Eater in the suggestion bar!! :DDD

  • Umm... I think I killed the replay button :(

  • <3 fucking amazing

  • ...i bet liam andrew is TulZi...

  • Brendon Uriel hiding under my bed? Yes please :)

  • I love how lots of my favorite artists cover songs from one of my favorite movies! :D

  • Great film even better song love you Panic!

  • who's singing this?

  • @ErynLuvzCatz brendon urie, the lead singer of Panic! at the Disco

  • Oh Brendon, feel free to hide under my bed. Or better yet, IN it.

  • I LOVE THIS SOOOOO MUCH!!!!!!!! I have basically raped the replay button;)

  • No im srry to say it....it's Brendon Urnie....i should know i know him

  • @TheCheese258 If you knew him, you would also know that his last name is Urie not Urnie...

  • :3

  • this song makes me cold. the part about the wind blowing through your hair i got chills and also i fell more in love with panic at the disco when i heard this

  • i am in love with nightmare before xmas always hav been and biggest fan

  • .....i think this is ...-shrug- i love both marilyn manson and Panic! at the disco's versions <3

  • I can't figure out which cover is creepier/best.... Marylin Manson or PATD........ I'll flip a lion!!(if you've ever watched the gradualreport, you know what I mean ;))hmmm....... I say both.(it landed sideways!)

  • never has lalala sounded so sexii

  • If you think this sounds a bit weak / not the right atmosphere, listen to the remix where someone blended this version with Marilyn Manson's. It sounds excellent.

  • I love bothh(:

  • Manson did the creepier version.His was actually kinda scary.

    This has a more fun tone to it.Both are very good.

  • Marilyn mansions version is SOOOOO much better

  • No offense but i like Marilyn Manson's version better...

  • Music Video Idea: A little girl is in her play room, winding up a Jack-In-The-Box (beginning of the song), when the song ends, the box pops open but there is no doll. The girl peeks inside and is sucked into the toy. She hears these voices talking to her, but cannot see who is speaking. Only when she lights a match can see the demons. *song continues till the toy music starts again* Then the toy starts to wind itself up again. This time a doll pops up, but it looks like the little girl.

  • ah.....i think i like the one with Marilyn Manson better....sounds way creepier...

  • @xXxdaultimatesemexXx Yes. Excellent.

  • My Fav song by a great band WHO COULD ASK FOR MORE??!!

  • Brendan I wouldnt mind if you were under my bed

  • @XxBriBeeMistalShowxX I'm sorry to correct you, but his name is Brendon :) And I wouldn't mind either ;)

  • @XxBriBeeMistalShowxX I wouldn't mind if he was under my covers.

  • @XxBriBeeMistalShowxX hahahaha that sounds weird to me cuz my boyfriends name is brendan

  • Comment removed

  • love this vid, the pic is well cute!

  • When he said i'm under your bed i got up and looked and so fuckin' pissed when he wasn't there