Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (112)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Excellent science demo!

  • Thanks for giving such a clear demonstration. I'd never heard of this before. I'm really sorry that you must deal with this... and again possibly, after today's quake.

  • That's incredible.

  • WOW!!

  • Many thanks for posting this video.

    Wishes for a safe and speedy recovery.

  • 日本人ならyahoo! のニュースのとこから来たんじゃぁないか!? by日本人

  • I,m japanese.

    How to make this.

    I want to do this demo at school for children.

  • これはすっごく分かりやすい!なるほど!

  • 水が想像以上過ぎる〜

    分かり易く理解できました

  • 私は日本人です

    とてもわかりやすかったです。

    ありがとう^^

  • Same situation have happened at Urayasu city in Japan.

  • とても解り易いです。

  • A perfect example of what was once only a theory,but of course proven science now.Prayers for all in you're area,and the people of Japan from the state of ga.county of Haralson,USA.

  • wow. Such a great demo.

  • Perfect demonstration. good job. I never would have though to do it that way. Hats off to you!!

  • I've never seen something like this before. Thanks for the video. I wish you too all the best.

    greets from Switzerland

  • Good explanation though not only your ancestors wiped out the local indigenous from this lands but they also build your cities on quick sand...ayaha!

  • @seyoumeye Well, to be truthful we didn't wipe them out.... they were better than Her Majesty's troops so we entered into a 'treaty' with them to purchase/steal the land (delete as applicable depending upon your point of view) . That's a whole other story which we are still arguing about :-)

    We are contemplating asking for our money back as the land is 'faulty'. *drum and cymbals*

  • @ArgentumNZ

    No offenses, but have you heard of certain "Dragon Currents"?

    Sadly cathedrals builders (highly addicted to gold) and their cities are built on a so called "sacred sites" by the local indigenous people. These are not meant to be places of dwelling but an ideal place to hold a "sacrifice ceremony".

    Glad you are safe, but I assure more tremors will sunck many coastal cities.

  • @seyoumeye

    LOL.

  • @ArgentumNZ WoW Amazing demonstration

    thanks for sharing

  • this is an amazing video. I'm sorry for what's happened to your country. I wish you kiwi's all the best :)

  • Blimey...that was very interesting. It's great to understand how it works now, it was a mystery to us. Good job and all the best for you and your city. We're thinking of you all.

  • The two recent NZ earthquakes have certainly produced a lot of liquefaction.

    Since many/most of the earthquake videos we see on YouTube have come from California and Mexico, where it's far more dry, liquefaction looks bizarre as we rarely see it. Actually, it looks bizarre regardless. The vehicles trapped in thick grey sludge, sometimes almost immersed, are a kooky and unsettling sight.

  • Firstly can I thank all of you who have viewed this video and offered messages of support to the people of Christchurch and Canterbury. Thanks must also go to several media outlets that picked up the video and gave it national and, hopefully soon, international coverage. It was designed to be just a little informative video for some friends but has gone much wider than that. Regards ArgentumNZ

  • Great demonstration, thanks!

    

  • This is thixotropic in action, exactly the same as you can do with cornflour or avalanches. The molecules are (roughly) rectangular but stacked up at all angles until vibration occurs then they all shake down the same way and slide off one another.

  • Thank you for showing this video, i'm in canterbury and it's great to see what happens, i was totally fascinated by it, even if saddeed at the same time

  • Cool, for some reason this reminds me of hot ice - sodium acetate? One disturbed, it changes state? Informative vid!

  • Wow. Fascinating (if somewhat depressing for all you folks down there)

  • WIN!!

  • Thanks for the brilliant video, it's fascinating. You reminded me that I have been wondering what happens inside the soil during liquefaction.

    I've written about this. I can't add a link here but search for >> Mandeno Musings Christchurch earthquake liquefaction explained

  • Absolutely wonderful. Best wishes from the old empire.

  • What I want to know is - why does it always come out in people's back yards - as far away from the road as it can possibly get!

  • @abnunga That's very funny... but it does seem quite accurate too. The lot I was shifting was from down the back of the garden... I have a theory that revolves around getting the water into the ground sufficiently to saturate it. I think I'm going to suggest that it's run-off from the garages. Lets face it, they are down the back of the section by the lovely sunken garden/rose bed and the law of Murphy says if it can it will.... :-)

  • we saw you on the news. nice work!!!

  • @alone4u2be Thanks, my 2 minutes of stardom. I thought they wanted just a quick recorded interview but we ended up doing a live section.... and it's all thanks to the 60,000 people that thought watching a wheelbarrow of sand behave differently was as interesting as I did.

    Thanks to ALL of you.

  • @ArgentumNZ we really liked it gave me an insite im sure alot are glad you did. makes more sence now

  • Hope every things well !!!

    In chch

  • Just saw you on TV3, Thanks for sharing :P

  • Thats fantastic I'm sending it to my daughter who is a science teacher

  • nifty

  • Thanks for this video, very educational. My best wishes go to those in NZ who have been affected by the recent big earthquake.

  • @peshwengi Thank you for watching and your wishes to us all here. It's going to be a long recovery.

  • For those who don't seem to understand the term "liquefaction"

    liquefaction (lkw-fkshn)

    The process by which sediment that is very wet starts to behave like a liquid. Liquefaction occurs because of the increased pore pressure and reduced effective stress between solid particles generated by the presence of liquid. It is often caused by severe shaking, especially that associated with earthquakes

    It is not about the sediment becoming a liquid OK?

  • The NZ Herald hav ripped your vid......

  • Saw this on TV3 this morning, good stuff.

  • Top guy! I had to see it to believe it.

  • I think it's quite sad that a simple vid of a guy trying to bring a bit of education to the world out of his misfortune brings out the conspiracy theorists, the racists and skeptics ("it's photoshopped" ). I really think that Youtube should turn comments off full-time since the 10% of wackos spoil it for everyone else.

    @ArgentumNZ thanks for an informative vid and hope you get over your disaster soon.

  • thanks for posting such an informative video!

  • That is immense!

  • ignore jd55000 everyone, he ruins NZ with his annoying attitude and bigotry. he makes NZ look like a miserable, gloomy, depressing, and moronic country which I assure you it is - for the most part - not.

  • Thank you! I just showed this to my almost 7 yr old, and he now has a better understanding of what happens in a quake. Kind of hard to explain to kids without some sort of visual aspect.

  • @bikkies78

    Thank you. That's why I put it there (in educational) so people might get a grasp of the process.  It's easy to understand when you see it happening but for people outside CHCH it's hard to describe or comprehend..

  • Nice Video - I was amazed when I saw the liquefaction happening - So sharing this video around

  • Has this hit the TV screens yet? Excellent depiction of liquefaction before your very eyes, albeit in wheelbarrow. Superb if just a little frightening

  • @HaudMiBackPal Well funnily enough it was on TVONE (and again on 7)..... but they voiced over my dulcet (aka gasping) tones.

    At least the NZHerald asked for permission to link/rebroadcast it on their homepage.

  • @ArgentumNZ it was on again on 'News Tonight' on TV1. So i decided to look up your vid for myself.. :)

    All the best.

  • Has this hit the TV screens yet? Excellent depiction of liquefaction before your very eyes, albeit in wheelbarrow. Superb!

  • its not liquefying, the sand is just settling to the bottom and the water present in it is coming up on top.

  • @wmsilvia That separation is exactly what Liquefaction is that I'm demonstrating. But when I stop did you notice it returns to the 'solid' state and I can empty the barrow in 1 piece - the water doesn't remain on top.. I'm not saying it's liquifying (the sand turning to liquid). Perhaps I'll change the title (if I can) to say Liquefaction since it's obviously causing confusion (3 similar comments out of 35,000 views). Thank you for your comment.

  • @wmsilvia Although it's called LIQUIfaction, you're right, it is not a liquid. But is does have FLUID properties. Gasses, liquids, and solids can all have fluid properties. For example flowing air in gas or a debris flow of solids. Water saturated sand that gets shaken will have fluid properties until the shaking stops as the video shows.

    Great video. I'll be showing it in my class tomorrow.

  • @wmsilvia Although it's called LIQUIfaction, you're right, it is not a liquid. But is does have FLUID properties. Gasses, liquids, and solids can all have fluid properties. For example flowing air in gas or a debris flow of solids. Water saturated sand that gets shaken will have fluid properties until the shaking stops as the video shows.

    Great video. I'll be showing it in my class tomorrow.

  • British people just want attention on the earthquake and their not even KIWIS,INFACT they ruin everything to do with new zealand with their annoying attitude and accents..they make nz look miserable,cold ,gloomy and depressing just like their own country Britian is

  • @JD55000 you're outlandishness disgusts me! Thanks soo much for this video mate, for explaining what liquefaction is and what its like, LOVE FROM A FELLOW KIWI xx

  • @ArgentumNZ

    Thanks for the vid mate, it's so hard to explain this effect to people who have never driven a wheelbarrow full of the stuff! Lets hope we all finish removing it soon. Make sure you get a breathing filter - St Johns have been handing them out, and I think they are supposed to be handing them out at the water collection points as well.

  • This video is both amazing to see it happen and educational.I think they should show this in all science classes across the world!

  • /watch?v=hLydC_J81gM

  • Very good demonstration. This is one of the main problems with the new madrid fault line as well. Arkansas has had over 800 earthquakes in the last six months. I send my prayers and well wishes out to New Zealand.

  • @Exposingthetruth41 that's 4.4 earthquakes a day.

  • @hoosierhiver Yep, on average, the problem is that in the last two weeks they have had over 100. I print out the quakes from the USGS, when I go back later and print a current read out, some quakes have either been removed completely or the strength lowered. Something isn't right. Now FEMA is having a drill this May for the New Madrid threat.

  • nice demonstration man

  • Good video. Don't know why our ancestors built on a swamp.

  • @midsta Ahh I think that was the first point at which creative real estate marketing raised it's head. Imagine if you will a land of milk and honey only 12,000 miles away in the sunny south pacific. Only 6 months journey by boat (if you got there). The boats arrived in Lyttelton (a sunken volcanic crater no less) and the new residents had to walk up and over the rim of the Port Hills (where these current quakes are predominantly originating) and saw their land.......a swamp.

  • @ArgentumNZ

    When you dissolve a fine particulate to saturation in water, you get a non-newtonian fluid

    Pretty sure that's what's going on

    Does it get hard when you hit it with something? It should react to pressure

  • @adrastea99 Ours certainly did when my partner was trying to dig a trench out of it! Ouch.

  • Wow, imagine that time 100... very sad watchingthe devastation for the last week, wish I could help. Have made a donation and keep hoping for the best, will be reflecting during 2 minute silence tomorrow. Love you Christchurch x

  • Why is it always BRITISH PEOPLE on these new zealand earthquake videos?

  • @JD55000

    hahaha... I've been in NZ for something like 38 years now... but the voice sets once one gets past about 14 yrs of age. The accent is softer... believe me. Thanks for your comment though. it added some humour to the day.

  • @JD55000 maybe because a lot of British people live in Christchurch.Its the most English city in NZ.

  • @JD55000 enjoy using OUR language

  • great vid thanks for sharing

  • Definitely shopped i can tell by the pixels and having seen a few photoshops in my day

  • @L33Tspartan No it hasn't been shopped. Pity you don't know what you are talking about - an armchair expert no doubt. Come over and grab a shovel and help out.

  • @ArgentumNZ haha i was just joking as were most everyone else that says its shopped sorry man. I will see i i can donate some money torward the relief effort

  • @L33Tspartan . Sorry also for my snapped response. I was tired and irritable and the blasted sand is so fine when it dries out it's like cement, or talc, and my eyes are itching.

  • COLLOIDS! How do they work!?

  • @RhinoSanderson - Unfortunately is is not photoshopped. It's very real.

  • @RhinoSanderson

    I wish it were shopped.. in fact I wish it hadn't happened ... But it did and it's real. I kept the whole raw video to do it in one take rather than making a pretty version (if I had the tools).

  • Non-Newtonian fluid is scary

  • It's not changing from a liquid to a solid or the other way around. The vibrations are pushing the water out of the sand. The water goes above the sand and the sand sinks down. They're just separating.

  • @Atheyst God you're a moron.

  • You live on a pick pile of anti-ublick!

  • I kind of thought he was going to push the wheelbarrow into traffic.

  • @HighwarlordJC, I guess you are technically correct in that the sand itself doesn't turn to liquid - but that is to liquify. *(that's Physics).

    This process we call Liquefaction is a geological term which refers to the process by which saturated, unconsolidated sediments are transformed into a substance that acts like a liquid. *thanks Wikipedia*

  • sand saturated with water.

    I suppose you spend a lot of money with special foundations that need to float on this stuff.

  • @saintpine : Christchurch is basically built upon reclaimed/drained swampland. In areas where they know the soil is 'loose' or on top of peat we are sometimes made to put piles down and concrete them into the base foundation to provide stability. ... but this is a more modern technique.

  • Build your house upon the rock!

  • SCIENCE!!!!

  • One video worth more than a thousand words. Great demo!

    So sorry about the earthquake. A very heavy blow. :-(

  • Science!

  • I actually work with raw materials that behave in a similar matter. It's usually caused by acicular particles high solids to water ratio.

  • Sort of the opposite of the classic corn starch in water non-newtonian fluid.

  • Wet sand, gravity says heavy stuff falls. The sand falls to the bottom, and the liquid floats on top. Don't see any sand liquifying here, but it certainly is interesting; I'm not saying sand doesn't liquify just that this video doesn't show it.

  • @HighWarlordJC Yes it does. The sand in the wheelbarrow is liquifying as he rolls over the cobbles.

  • @HighWarlordJC

    You are right, it's just the popular term used for this phenomena of fine sand saturated with water, sand liquefies at very high temperatures and solidifies when cooled.

  • @TeslaTechnologyRocks why on earth would they do this to NZ, causing death and billions of dollars of damage. when they can do it to north korea or something,

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more