Hola a todos, soy de Mexico city., despues de 45 años de vida y hasta hace apenas unos dias he comenzado a escuchar musica de cantantes Irlandeses y de verdad es hermosa, disculpen mi ignorancia si es asi, pero pregunto a la comunidad de youtube porque estos excelentes cantantes como Joe Dolan, Tommy Makem, Michael Flatley, etc., etc. y que me disculpen por omitir a varios mas, ¿porque su musica no se ha dado a conocer mucho mas en este mierda mundo material y homofobico?, no todo esta en EEUU.
@chacalday Disculpame mi Espanol. Algunos cantadores Irlandeses se ha dado a conocer en muchas paises como Enya, U2 y otros pero la musica tradicional se inclina quedar in paises ingleshablantes. Pero creo har muchas in Youtube. Busca The Dubliners, Clannad, Celtic Woman, Planxty, Horslips (Mas modernizado pero bueno) the pogues, the Bothy boys. Hay muchas para difrutar. Suerte.
This is quite the song, I don't know how to look at it..I just hapened to coe across it. It's obviously has something to do with fighting for your rights...it's long been history now by the sounds of it. Do you remember he "Deck of Card" by Wink Martindale? Take a listen.
I heared so much versions of this song, but I think this version is one of the best because there is the right feeling in the voice of Harrington for this great song!!! Thank you Paul!
@IRAprovos And ye were so Innocent gimmie a break. Your cause got lost years ago in drug running & protection rackets. From the revolution heroes came nothing more than common scumbag criminals,
Power corrupts no matter how noble the cause. Many kids also died in enniskilen and british bombings
@will00078@will00078 prove your FALSE allegations...then tell me with your intelligent brain why your new found british friends fought a WAR against China for the control of heroin...traitor to the Irish...by propagating...english...lies...Your no Irish than the sow pig that OWNS you...TAL
@will00078@will00078@will00078 prove your FALSE allegations...then tell me with your intelligent brain why your new found british friends fought a WAR against China for the control of heroin...traitor to the Irish...by propagating...english...lies...Your no Irish than the sow pig that OWNS you...T
@IRAprovos Love the way you completely sidestepped the issue. Your a dellusional republican tool answer me were the killings in omagh and enniskilleen right.
I suppose your also supporting Gadaffi since he ran funds for ye. So what if the british fought that war over drugs. Dont know the facts so wont comment. But I assure you my friend Im as much an Irishman as you claim to be. So go to your pityfull hatred.
Bet you never knew that churchhill commited 50000 to IR gov in case of Ger Invasion
@will00078 Churchhill was making sure the back door to britian was well and truly barracaded with that money. Omagh and Enniskilleen were acts of a minority who are cornered, and any cornered creature will fight tooth and nail to survive. Would save England a LOT of money to just give us back our land, and everything else you stole over the last 800 years and GFTO of OUR country.
This was a great version of Tommy's song. I cried to see the young people in awe as the proud words and lovely photos presented themselves to their youth and inexperience. Yes, this was a fine version.
that is the second best rendering of this song i have ever listened to, my favourite is from the late Kathleen Largey, great upload, was a pleasure to watch and listen to the song being sung from the heart.
hello IRAprovos , Yes, Kathleen was in the ,"Flying Column", and No, to the best of my knowledge, Kathleen Died of cancer after a long ilness, but i stand corrected if i am wrong.
Against the backdrop of an air view over Ireland and its graves Paul Harrington, former Eurovision winner 1994- and pianist at Lillies Bordello, treated us to an emotional version of "Four Green Fields".
This is what one would expect from Michael Flatley, but nothing matches Tommy singing this in the old days in his Irish Pavilion on 57th, located so conveniently by Doran's and so many other great Irish bars. God bless all, and R.I.P., Tommy Maken
Aggravating people seems to be something you are good at. Please refrain from this as it is tedious and people are going to be much more unpleasent towards you.
This is a friendly remark, as I, by no means, intend to try and threaten you, only inform you that you do seem to be trying to annoy people deliberatley.
I encourage you to stop this as it is frustrating and people get annoyed by behaviours such as these.
I believe that I would not try to deny anyone, no matter how annoying, their right to free expression. So I am sorry to say, my friend, that you have wrongly judged me in that court.
I am refraining from being exceptionally unpleasent for the sake of anyone else reading this argument. As I can write some very unpleasent things.
Yes you have the right to your opinion. And I have the right to think you are stupid.
I fail to see in any of my comments, me "descending into foul language, filth, and name-calling."
I am sorry to say, Oliver, that I do have a point to prove. It is the point that you make wars where none need to be made and seem to find some pleasure in aggrivating someones comment to mean something you find offensive.
This is a tedious way to live, Oliver and I suggest you refrain from it. It will only hurt you in the long run.
fantastic song! Great message about the harsh history as well! I have seen the show love and got goosebumps of this song (and ofcourse of Michael since I've been a fan for 11 years lol)
oliver you sick little coword,next time you see an irishman i bet you wont say the things your saying to one of our faces,cause if i heard some english fella talking like that id jump all over there face.and id make sure they never talk bullshit again
tell me, oliver, why shouldnt the 6 ulster counties currently under british sovereignity return to Ireland? afterall, it is my opinion that the british have no business in Ireland. imagine the french conquering England and when it became free once again theyd still have control over Northumberland, for instance. im serious here, so dont answer with bullcrap, if you please.
the example you are giving does not reflect the northern irish condition. along the course of history many peoples move here and there. in the case of the normans, afterwards normans and saxons alike formed part of what became the kingdom of england. the irish have always had their own culture, different from british culture, and the irish natives did not willingly become part of the uk. the fact is that the majority of the people in NI consider themselves to be british.
If so, if the majority of the people regard themselves as british what are they doing in irish soil? because that land is irish, but the government that holds sovereignity over it isnt. of course that the people want to remain under british sovereignity if they were born there, lived there, sons and daughters of people who were british themselves. but, again, that was the result of discriminative policies and colonisation of Ireland in the 1700s
of course not. and the north is in fact regarded as british territory. that is the official situation. but, once again, that territory was taken from ireland and the irish nation comprises all the island of ireland. if people in NI are irish, they may stay, british can stay, protestant, catholic can stay there. but the british government cannot. it has had no legitimacy to take the north to begin and as such as no legitmacy to keep the north.
I am sorry, I was Very angry at the last few statements I have read! I believe the UK should completley end all conection`s it has with IRELAND, The island of EIRE is Our land, Our Home, the Home of Our Ancestor`s , Our People. Fuck with Us ,Mess with Us All!!!
The North American 'indians' had and still have their own separate 'culture'.
I tell you what....if you can convince every single United States resident of non-indigenous origin to get back on the Mayflower and sail back to England, then you might be taken more seriously.
thats a nice point! in fact the american settlers(i.e. british, dutch, french, etc) they completely smashed amerindian culture. do you think they had the right to do that? do you think they should have taken the natives out of their homelands and put them in reservations and deprived them of their cultural habits? i dont. but nowadays it isnt possible to make american as it once was. theres no solution now, but the northern irish problem Does have a solution. give ireland back to the irish.
You are not making alot of friends are you Oliver. Opinions can be voiced, but shouldn't alwyas be.
"Yes you have the right to your opinion. And I have the right to think your stupid."
Why don't you just stop picking fights and enjoy the videos? It would be so much easier and alot less hassle. Or maybe you like picking fights and having a go at totally inoccent comments...?
You are going to annoy completely the wrong people if you keep this up.
I knew some-what what the song was about, I do listen to lyrics, unlike most people.
And all I can say for your comments are that they are interesting to read, if you must make a point, make it silently, because though I am not one of the people you are liable to annoy, I am going to warn you that others may not appreciate your opiions as much as me.
If you took my words of warning as a threat, then I beseach you to actually READ what was written.
It seems that this is something you do not often do, READ. If perhaps you read all the comments you argued with, you might actually see that there is nothing wrong with them and that you, my friend, are starting wars where none needs to be started.
We have ebough wars carrying on in life, we do not need your bad tempered arguments filling the comment boxes.
georgepaul15 is a prime example of the people you are liable to piss off.
Please, I do ask that you retire fropm this tedious argumentative stage of your life. I have warned you because people are likely to get you blocked from youtube.
I am now tired of this conversation and ask that you refrain from getting into arguments that are likely to end with someone getting hurt, either menatlly or physically.
Because you have started to annoy me greatly and agree with georgepaul15's comment.
@Oliver1649 This song was written prior to the beginning of the Troubles. The words spoken by the female character in the song are taken directly from a play by W.B. Yeats written decades vefore the song was written.
that problem concerns not the territorial issue, but the national issue. the people of northern ireland, the majority of it, are british, as a result of the plantations of ireland. they want to be british, they want to remain in the UK. i completely understand that. they were born there. but that doesnt mean that NI should be under british sovereignity. just because the majority of the people there want to remain part of the UK doesnt mean the UK has any right there.
@Oliver1649 The rights and culture of Unionists must be protected. The former Prime Minister of Ireland said that if a united Ireland is to be achieved Unionists need to fell that they belong to a united Ireland. Nationalists and Unionists share a common island and history. That's my position also.
@YoungIrishGuy If you think songs like this will make Unionists feel that they somehow belong in a "united Ireland" then you are very naive indeed. To turn things around, my hope is that Nationalists will feel more at home in the United Kingdom. This, I believe, is already happening.
@Oliver1649 I never even suggested that this song would change the opinions of Unionists nor would I expect it to do so. I simply stated that there are misconceptions about the intent of the song. I would never feel at home in the U.K. I respect the U.K. and deplore the actions of terrorists but I'm not British.
The Irish people have their own history, culture, and objectives. By culture, I mean much more than music, etc. We form a nation in other words.
In the era of the anti-christ and the war against Christ's church, the anti-christ landed first against the land in which Patrick worked (Ulaidh) to claim it for himself, and his lieutenants were Queen Elizabeth and Oliver Cromwell.
paisley said that he would never share power with nationalists, would never work with sinn fein and would never tolerate southern influence into 'northern ireland's' affairs.....look at whats happening now!!
Whoever this guy is he's bringing more emotion to the song than anyone previous has EVER done! Sorrowful, yet sung with such a passion! Brings a tear to my eye...
Ireland is the best Country in the World
johnstamosgirl90 2 months ago in playlist Michael Flatley's celtic tiger
I pray that in my lifetime our four green fields will bloom..
brokenglassesshaner 4 months ago
This brought a lump to my throat and tear to my eye. Humbled.
Twonks 5 months ago
Shit for all the comments! It´s a fine melody and a fine rendition, that´s all that matters.
prince2000ful 7 months ago
What did I have, said the fine old woman
What did I have, this proud old woman did say
I had four green fields, each one was a jewel
But strangers came and tried to take them from me
I had fine strong sons, who fought to save my jewels
They fought and they died, and that was my grief said she
kingfishertw 7 months ago
I wonder how many people at this concert understood what this song was really about?
catholicrik 9 months ago
Now i know who flogged the celtic Tiger it was Flatley. Knew hed bring the country down !!!
will00078 11 months ago
bravo...Well done. Kudo's to the late Tomy Makem for writing this piece. up the Republic !
mayotom 1 year ago
this is certainly a good song in a calming and strong way. great number
WildDancer101 1 year ago
@WildDancer101 Well said. :)
Dreamflower6 8 months ago
I used to sing this in the pubs/clubs in the north of England - I wish I'd have had this kick ass orchestra instead of a guitar!!
Actually...while I'm wishing - how about this audience too?? - Lol!!
Tobytrim 1 year ago
gives me goosepimples
tadhgodalaigh 1 year ago
<3 Ireland
MrBunnes 1 year ago
Hola a todos, soy de Mexico city., despues de 45 años de vida y hasta hace apenas unos dias he comenzado a escuchar musica de cantantes Irlandeses y de verdad es hermosa, disculpen mi ignorancia si es asi, pero pregunto a la comunidad de youtube porque estos excelentes cantantes como Joe Dolan, Tommy Makem, Michael Flatley, etc., etc. y que me disculpen por omitir a varios mas, ¿porque su musica no se ha dado a conocer mucho mas en este mierda mundo material y homofobico?, no todo esta en EEUU.
chacalday 1 year ago
@chacalday Disculpame mi Espanol. Algunos cantadores Irlandeses se ha dado a conocer en muchas paises como Enya, U2 y otros pero la musica tradicional se inclina quedar in paises ingleshablantes. Pero creo har muchas in Youtube. Busca The Dubliners, Clannad, Celtic Woman, Planxty, Horslips (Mas modernizado pero bueno) the pogues, the Bothy boys. Hay muchas para difrutar. Suerte.
Taiwanlight 1 year ago
This is quite the song, I don't know how to look at it..I just hapened to coe across it. It's obviously has something to do with fighting for your rights...it's long been history now by the sounds of it. Do you remember he "Deck of Card" by Wink Martindale? Take a listen.
cafe9802 1 year ago
Sung as though it was part opf an opera and perhaps it should be. That would be something to see.
josephonwhidbey 1 year ago
@josephonwhidbey It was.. Trust me. I've seen the show. This song was performed in the perfect way..
Witchbtch 1 year ago
Gets me every time...love it!!!!!!
Dreamflower6 1 year ago
LOVE this song.
janelb888 1 year ago
Ireland, I'm with you....
karahan246 1 year ago
Brilliant song, so patriotic and sad at the same time, real pathos here for Ireland !
josparkes1 1 year ago
I heared so much versions of this song, but I think this version is one of the best because there is the right feeling in the voice of Harrington for this great song!!! Thank you Paul!
GermanVegas 1 year ago 2
This man has the voice of an angel...
Dreamflower6 2 years ago 3
@ Mr grumpy...kid killing is an art of the british...google 'plastic bullet deaths' ...deliberate murder of children by you....
IRAprovos 2 years ago 13
@IRAprovos And ye were so Innocent gimmie a break. Your cause got lost years ago in drug running & protection rackets. From the revolution heroes came nothing more than common scumbag criminals,
Power corrupts no matter how noble the cause. Many kids also died in enniskilen and british bombings
will00078 11 months ago
@will00078@will00078 prove your FALSE allegations...then tell me with your intelligent brain why your new found british friends fought a WAR against China for the control of heroin...traitor to the Irish...by propagating...english...lies...Your no Irish than the sow pig that OWNS you...TAL
IRAprovos 11 months ago
@will00078 @will00078@will00078 prove your FALSE allegations...then tell me with your intelligent brain why your new found british friends fought a WAR against China for the control of heroin...traitor to the Irish...by propagating...english...lies...Your no Irish than the sow pig that OWNS you...T
IRAprovos 11 months ago
@IRAprovos Love the way you completely sidestepped the issue. Your a dellusional republican tool answer me were the killings in omagh and enniskilleen right.
I suppose your also supporting Gadaffi since he ran funds for ye. So what if the british fought that war over drugs. Dont know the facts so wont comment. But I assure you my friend Im as much an Irishman as you claim to be. So go to your pityfull hatred.
Bet you never knew that churchhill commited 50000 to IR gov in case of Ger Invasion
will00078 11 months ago
@will00078 Churchill was not defending the Irish, he was defending the gain and wealth of the british empire..
brokenglassesshaner 5 months ago
@will00078 Churchhill was making sure the back door to britian was well and truly barracaded with that money. Omagh and Enniskilleen were acts of a minority who are cornered, and any cornered creature will fight tooth and nail to survive. Would save England a LOT of money to just give us back our land, and everything else you stole over the last 800 years and GFTO of OUR country.
IrishSecretSquirrel 4 months ago
MISE EIRE!!!
rasm3390 2 years ago
I wonder how the traitors who bargained and sold feel when they hear this wonderful song
55august 2 years ago 2
This was a great version of Tommy's song. I cried to see the young people in awe as the proud words and lovely photos presented themselves to their youth and inexperience. Yes, this was a fine version.
batourey 2 years ago
so was wunderbares! wir haben celtic tiger in stuttgart gesehn
kleinananas 2 years ago
My best friend wrote this song. The late tommy makem.
irishpride9999 2 years ago 14
The best rebel song ever...Respect to your mate Tommy Makem...a legend.
IRAprovos 2 years ago 2
Oh you bet i do. I miss him every day of my life. There isnt a day that im not sure if hs watching over me from heaven.
irishpride9999 2 years ago
That's wonderful, this is so beautiful, it's magic !
Norfolk UK
(Female 59)
josparkes 2 years ago
@irishpride9999 Tommy was my best friend too..........though I never met him.
1diesel1 1 year ago
that is the second best rendering of this song i have ever listened to, my favourite is from the late Kathleen Largey, great upload, was a pleasure to watch and listen to the song being sung from the heart.
itsjustmacker 2 years ago
Kathleen Largey..wasn't she shot dead by the british army???...WAS she in the group 'The Flynig Column'...the best version of this song ever sung.
IRAprovos 2 years ago
hello IRAprovos , Yes, Kathleen was in the ,"Flying Column", and No, to the best of my knowledge, Kathleen Died of cancer after a long ilness, but i stand corrected if i am wrong.
Tiocfaidh ar la
itsjustmacker 2 years ago
No you stand true she did unfortunelatey died of cancer...a woman who inspired a nation of oppressed people to rise...Fear Bas
IRAprovos 2 years ago
Comment removed
IRAprovos 2 years ago
@IRAprovos You are thinking of 14 year old Kathleen Feeney who was shot in the back by an IRA sniper!
MrGrumpybugger 2 years ago
So beautiful, I love it !
Norfolk UK
female 59
josparkes 2 years ago
can someone please tell me who is singing this beautiful song,is it tommy fleming?
rathkeilter 2 years ago
Against the backdrop of an air view over Ireland and its graves Paul Harrington, former Eurovision winner 1994- and pianist at Lillies Bordello, treated us to an emotional version of "Four Green Fields".
1956louise 2 years ago
Tiochfaidh Ar La
goldnzgrl88 3 years ago
Beautiful song and great video!
I love to see the girls' faces... they seem raptured!
Love to Tommy Makem, as well.
Micheliu71 3 years ago
Super song....cuts deep to think the 4th green field is still in bondage....Tiochfaidh Ar La !!
jnott83 3 years ago
What was the name of the song from celtic tiger that went something like this.
"So sing me an old fashion song, to raise my spirit high" ?
Mekurion 3 years ago
War touches the real life!! There is no pretending that history does not tread on our heels!!
Morrianna08 3 years ago
Is that Michael singing? Great voice
leoniderna 3 years ago
No, it's Paul Harrington. I love his voice.
dorym85 3 years ago
Four Green Fields Beautifully done my Michael Flatley Gives me goose bumps Totally awesome
Marina Hoskins
St.John's NL
Bluebelle50 3 years ago
Please excuse the typo - Rest in Peace, Tommy Makem.
lpooltom 3 years ago
This is what one would expect from Michael Flatley, but nothing matches Tommy singing this in the old days in his Irish Pavilion on 57th, located so conveniently by Doran's and so many other great Irish bars. God bless all, and R.I.P., Tommy Maken
lpooltom 3 years ago
OlIVER im drunk and im pissed now you cunt
im guessing your a 30yr old living in ur mum house and shages her now and then u insead cunt
georgepaul15 3 years ago
georgepaul15,
I'm curious, are you really any more lucid when sober?
Thought not....chuckle.
Oliver1649 3 years ago
Aggravating people seems to be something you are good at. Please refrain from this as it is tedious and people are going to be much more unpleasent towards you.
This is a friendly remark, as I, by no means, intend to try and threaten you, only inform you that you do seem to be trying to annoy people deliberatley.
I encourage you to stop this as it is frustrating and people get annoyed by behaviours such as these.
Emikero 3 years ago
Emikero,
I do not agree my friend.
If you are annoyed or aggravated - that is your problem.
I suggest you ask yourself why that might be.
I also believe you would deny me the right to free expression if you could; however you cannot.
If you choose to link yourself with an exponent of foul language, filth, and name-calling like georgepaul15 - that is up to you.
Birds of a feather and all that....
Oliver1649 3 years ago
Oliver,
I am sorry to hear that you do not agree with me.
I believe that I would not try to deny anyone, no matter how annoying, their right to free expression. So I am sorry to say, my friend, that you have wrongly judged me in that court.
I am refraining from being exceptionally unpleasent for the sake of anyone else reading this argument. As I can write some very unpleasent things.
Yes you have the right to your opinion. And I have the right to think you are stupid.
Which I do, Oliver.
Emikero 3 years ago
Emikero,
Well at least you managed to compose a response without descending into foul language, filth, and name-calling this time.
Other than that you have no point to make except perhaps that you do not like the fact that I do and have the 'temerity' to express it.
Oliver1649 3 years ago
Oliver,
I fail to see in any of my comments, me "descending into foul language, filth, and name-calling."
I am sorry to say, Oliver, that I do have a point to prove. It is the point that you make wars where none need to be made and seem to find some pleasure in aggrivating someones comment to mean something you find offensive.
This is a tedious way to live, Oliver and I suggest you refrain from it. It will only hurt you in the long run.
Emikero 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
OLIVER FUK OFF U WANK
why dont u stick ur 2 finger up ur arss
why do u lissing to thiss song if ur a prosistiont
just do ever one a fave and just lissing to the qwin u cunt and to Emikero
safe Emikero
Tiocfaidh ar la
thiss songs is amizsing
used 2 lissing to the old man up the pub affer mass he sang thiss song well x
georgepaul15 3 years ago
OLIVER FUK OFF U WANK
why dont u stick ur 2 finger up ur ass
why do u lissing to thiss song it ur a prosistiont well it migth ass well be
just do ever one a fave and just lissing to the qwin u cunt
lissing to Emikero
safe Emikero Tiocfaidh ar la
thiss songs amizsing
used 2 lissing to the old man up the pub affer mass he sang well x
georgepaul15 3 years ago
georgepaul15,
I'm guessing you are either drunk or English is not your first language.
Either way, I don't much care.
Oliver1649 3 years ago
OLIVER FUK OFF U WANK
why dont u stick ur 2 finger up ur ass
why do u lissing to thiss song it ur a prosistiont well it migth ass well be
just do ever one a fave and just lissing to the qwin u cunt
lissing to Emikero
safe Emikero Tiocfaidh ar la
thiss songs amizsing
used 2 lissing to the old man up the pub affer mass he sang well x
georgepaul15 3 years ago
OLIVER FUK OFF U WANK
why dont u stick ur 2 finger up ur ass
why do u lissing to thiss song it ur a prosistiont well it migth ass well be
just do ever one a fave and just lissing to the qwin u cunt
lissing to Emikero
safe Emikero Tiocfaidh ar la
thiss songs amizsing
used 2 lissing to the old man up the pub affer mass he sang well x
georgepaul15 3 years ago
as an irish lass this song brings a lump to my throat,very sad .he sings it well.we look to the future but never forget the past
charlieangel78 3 years ago
Oliver1649
is a wanker lol
well done fanstick song m8
up the ra
and fuk u Oliver1649
georgepaul15 3 years ago
Amazing. Fair play to Flatley for doing what no one else would.
Dublinjon12 3 years ago
fantastic song! Great message about the harsh history as well! I have seen the show love and got goosebumps of this song (and ofcourse of Michael since I've been a fan for 11 years lol)
DutchLoyal 3 years ago
Magic,
Brings a tear to the eye!
Saoirse Na hEireann.
AbMucker 3 years ago 4
Paul Harrington is the best singer in the world. After Gyula Vikidal.!!! :D:D:D :P:P:P
halmayg23 3 years ago 10
:DDDD Are you idiot? By the way...you said it well.
Spritofearth 3 years ago
@halmayg23 that`s right, dude
xebe1 1 year ago
and you certainly sound like a cunt
berrier123 3 years ago
oliver you sick little coword,next time you see an irishman i bet you wont say the things your saying to one of our faces,cause if i heard some english fella talking like that id jump all over there face.and id make sure they never talk bullshit again
berrier123 3 years ago 2
berrier123,
Interesting....
I take it you've done time in the past then?
You certainly sound like a criminal.
I stand by my comments, every word.
Oliver1649 3 years ago
tell me, oliver, why shouldnt the 6 ulster counties currently under british sovereignity return to Ireland? afterall, it is my opinion that the british have no business in Ireland. imagine the french conquering England and when it became free once again theyd still have control over Northumberland, for instance. im serious here, so dont answer with bullcrap, if you please.
Chapels 3 years ago
Chapels,
The Normans invaded England in 1066.
Should their descendents now be sent packing back to France with their heads bowed?
Come, come now....
Are you seriously advocating that the British Unionist majority of Northern Ireland get out?
Perhaps you deny that they are British?
For the life of me, I really don't think you've thought this one through.
Oliver1649 3 years ago
the example you are giving does not reflect the northern irish condition. along the course of history many peoples move here and there. in the case of the normans, afterwards normans and saxons alike formed part of what became the kingdom of england. the irish have always had their own culture, different from british culture, and the irish natives did not willingly become part of the uk. the fact is that the majority of the people in NI consider themselves to be british.
Chapels 3 years ago
(sorry, but these things are too short)
If so, if the majority of the people regard themselves as british what are they doing in irish soil? because that land is irish, but the government that holds sovereignity over it isnt. of course that the people want to remain under british sovereignity if they were born there, lived there, sons and daughters of people who were british themselves. but, again, that was the result of discriminative policies and colonisation of Ireland in the 1700s
Chapels 3 years ago
Chapels,
I suggest you consult the UN, EU, or the US.
Northern Ireland is internationally recognized as British and part of the United Kingdom.
That is what the last 30+ years of the 'troubles' were about.
A settlement is now in place under the St Andrew's Agreement.
Would you have them go back to violence?
Oliver1649 3 years ago
of course not. and the north is in fact regarded as british territory. that is the official situation. but, once again, that territory was taken from ireland and the irish nation comprises all the island of ireland. if people in NI are irish, they may stay, british can stay, protestant, catholic can stay there. but the british government cannot. it has had no legitimacy to take the north to begin and as such as no legitmacy to keep the north.
Chapels 3 years ago
I am sorry, I was Very angry at the last few statements I have read! I believe the UK should completley end all conection`s it has with IRELAND, The island of EIRE is Our land, Our Home, the Home of Our Ancestor`s , Our People. Fuck with Us ,Mess with Us All!!!
jiggyturbojim 3 years ago
you tell em ,What sort of english fool would even speak such rubbish(sorry I am aware of the language I use for FEAR OF BEING EDITED OUT)
jiggyturbojim 3 years ago
Chapels,
The North American 'indians' had and still have their own separate 'culture'.
I tell you what....if you can convince every single United States resident of non-indigenous origin to get back on the Mayflower and sail back to England, then you might be taken more seriously.
Oliver1649 3 years ago
thats a nice point! in fact the american settlers(i.e. british, dutch, french, etc) they completely smashed amerindian culture. do you think they had the right to do that? do you think they should have taken the natives out of their homelands and put them in reservations and deprived them of their cultural habits? i dont. but nowadays it isnt possible to make american as it once was. theres no solution now, but the northern irish problem Does have a solution. give ireland back to the irish.
Chapels 3 years ago
You are not making alot of friends are you Oliver. Opinions can be voiced, but shouldn't alwyas be.
"Yes you have the right to your opinion. And I have the right to think your stupid."
Why don't you just stop picking fights and enjoy the videos? It would be so much easier and alot less hassle. Or maybe you like picking fights and having a go at totally inoccent comments...?
Emikero 3 years ago
Emikero,
Do you have a point to make on the subject matter?
By the way, I love the "totally innocent comments" line.
This song is an endorsement of the Republican terrorist campaign in Northern Ireland my friend.
Your protestations, however, are hilarious.
Oliver1649 3 years ago
Oliver,
You are going to annoy completely the wrong people if you keep this up.
I knew some-what what the song was about, I do listen to lyrics, unlike most people.
And all I can say for your comments are that they are interesting to read, if you must make a point, make it silently, because though I am not one of the people you are liable to annoy, I am going to warn you that others may not appreciate your opiions as much as me.
Emikero 3 years ago
Emikero,
Please explain.
If you're going to issue threats then why not stop beating around the bush?
Who exactly are "the people you are liable to annoy"?
Oliver1649 3 years ago
Oliver,
If you took my words of warning as a threat, then I beseach you to actually READ what was written.
It seems that this is something you do not often do, READ. If perhaps you read all the comments you argued with, you might actually see that there is nothing wrong with them and that you, my friend, are starting wars where none needs to be started.
We have ebough wars carrying on in life, we do not need your bad tempered arguments filling the comment boxes.
Emikero 3 years ago
Emikero,
Please explain why I would need a "warning".
Also, you have not answered my question, perhaps you did not read it?
Therefore, I'll ask again, who exactly are "the people you are liable to annoy"?
What might they do?
Do tell....
Oliver1649 3 years ago
georgepaul15 is a prime example of the people you are liable to piss off.
Please, I do ask that you retire fropm this tedious argumentative stage of your life. I have warned you because people are likely to get you blocked from youtube.
I am now tired of this conversation and ask that you refrain from getting into arguments that are likely to end with someone getting hurt, either menatlly or physically.
Because you have started to annoy me greatly and agree with georgepaul15's comment.
Emikero 3 years ago
@Oliver1649 This song was written prior to the beginning of the Troubles. The words spoken by the female character in the song are taken directly from a play by W.B. Yeats written decades vefore the song was written.
YoungIrishGuy 1 year ago
Chapels,
Are the British of Northern Ireland not part of the United Kingdom? It is not just remiss to ignore this, but insulting.
Northern Ireland is British and will so remain as long as the majority want it.
I, for one, cannot ever see that changing.
Oliver1649 3 years ago
that problem concerns not the territorial issue, but the national issue. the people of northern ireland, the majority of it, are british, as a result of the plantations of ireland. they want to be british, they want to remain in the UK. i completely understand that. they were born there. but that doesnt mean that NI should be under british sovereignity. just because the majority of the people there want to remain part of the UK doesnt mean the UK has any right there.
Chapels 3 years ago
F off you twat,I would ring your neck you sad english royalist!
jiggyturbojim 3 years ago
@Oliver1649 The rights and culture of Unionists must be protected. The former Prime Minister of Ireland said that if a united Ireland is to be achieved Unionists need to fell that they belong to a united Ireland. Nationalists and Unionists share a common island and history. That's my position also.
YoungIrishGuy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@YoungIrishGuy If you think songs like this will make Unionists feel that they somehow belong in a "united Ireland" then you are very naive indeed. To turn things around, my hope is that Nationalists will feel more at home in the United Kingdom. This, I believe, is already happening.
Oliver1649 1 year ago
@Oliver1649 I never even suggested that this song would change the opinions of Unionists nor would I expect it to do so. I simply stated that there are misconceptions about the intent of the song. I would never feel at home in the U.K. I respect the U.K. and deplore the actions of terrorists but I'm not British.
The Irish people have their own history, culture, and objectives. By culture, I mean much more than music, etc. We form a nation in other words.
YoungIrishGuy 1 year ago
I'll join you! (and I've only a little Irish blood)
LannerFalcon 3 years ago
A true real great Song...
musikuslive 3 years ago 3
cunt
berrier123 3 years ago
This song as sung in this video takes my breath away it does.
goldenfriendstwo 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You'll still have to make do with three green fields folks.
The other one will always have the Union Flag flying over it.
Keep singing.
Keep dreaming.
Oliver1649 4 years ago
My sons have sons, as brave as were their fathers and my four green fields will bloom once again said she..
teachill 4 years ago 4
In the era of the anti-christ and the war against Christ's church, the anti-christ landed first against the land in which Patrick worked (Ulaidh) to claim it for himself, and his lieutenants were Queen Elizabeth and Oliver Cromwell.
Cionaodh
Monroe, LA USA
Cionaodh57 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Cionaodh57,
Is that an extract from the "ballad of sour grapes"?
What a schoolboy Mickey Mouse thing to write.
Hilarious.
Oliver1649 3 years ago
Laugh if you will. The truth affects those who mock like that.
Cionaodh57 3 years ago
do u feel the need to keep repeatin urself oliver! it won't be long until the fourth is reunited with the other 3!!!!!!
mjswa 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
mjswa,
Do let me know the date so I can mark it in my calendar.
The Twelfth of Never?
Chuckle....
Oliver1649 3 years ago
paisley said that he would never share power with nationalists, would never work with sinn fein and would never tolerate southern influence into 'northern ireland's' affairs.....look at whats happening now!!
mjswa 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You'll just have to make do with three green fields.
The other one will always have the Union Flag flying over it.
Keep singing.
Keep dreaming.
Oliver1649 4 years ago
And my four green fields WILL bloom once again said she..
Éire go Bráth.
teachill 4 years ago
my grandmother listened to this song over and over and tink ya done her proud singing the way you did wel done son :)
joeyjojowonka007 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You'll just have to make do with three green fields.
The other one will always have the Union Flag flying over it.
Keep singing.
Keep dreaming.
Oliver1649 4 years ago
Hey Dutch guy !! You are the one who is dreaming if you think th union flag will always be there , you're a fool !!!
Our Country will be United !!
Slainte !
breffnipark 4 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
breffnipark,
Please feel free to hold your breath waiting for a 'united Ireland' my friend.
Why not tell me the date so I can mark it in my calendar?
The 12th of Never perhaps?
I like the Union Flag on your home page, by the way.
Oliver1649 4 years ago
Oliver1649 ,
Thanks for the reply ! Yeah I live in London.
Well the date won't be the 12th of July .. lol !
You should have 1690 after your name !
Are you Dutch ?
Maybe we should both stick to singing ..ha ha
Definately Ireland will be united one day!
Regards.
breffnipark 4 years ago
great song. you should put in a searh for buncrana 1975, theres another great singer on that
rhdoc74 4 years ago
BRILLIANT song...
Whoever this guy is he's bringing more emotion to the song than anyone previous has EVER done! Sorrowful, yet sung with such a passion! Brings a tear to my eye...
Tiocfaidh ár lá.
GlasgowCeltic88 4 years ago
the singer is called Paul Harrington
cat13woman 4 years ago
This song was shown in Budapest as seen on teh celtic tiger dvd! I love this song. The singer was a Grand Prix winner.
GermanVegas 4 years ago
does anybody have any info about this man please
jobling51 4 years ago
does anybody have any info about this man
jobling51 4 years ago
...But my sons have sons... as brave as were thier father's... and my fourth green field, will bloom once again.... Oooh yeah!
tomgreaney 4 years ago 7
I like this version too. I think its very elegant.
gete1972 4 years ago 2
beautiful rendition but no one can beat the writer himself tommy makem
HaulAwayJoe 4 years ago
Thanks for the info
lreland1 4 years ago
yes it is irish dance concert
muffles12 4 years ago
Absolutely fantastic!!! Where was this concert?
lreland1 4 years ago
i think it was in Budapest, Hungary.
gete1972 4 years ago
it was in dublin ireland! omg! idoit
GothicKnightsInc 4 years ago
It was in England. It was the preview.
scottasbj 4 years ago
IRELAND UNFREE SHALL NEVER BE AT PEACE
sniperatwork81 4 years ago 4