Classically constructed song easily in the top 5 Oasis tracks. If they had recorded the album/single version with the backing of the Festival Chorus Choir it would have elevated this already great song to another level altogether and had the future airplay time it deserves rather than in effect being forgotten an 'album track' they missed the trick? Realistically they probably had never even considered this arrangement until the Electric proms, a shame but, "you can't always get what you want"
@sidbolero do sing in a choir asshole? no. i thought not, he keeps everyone in time and brings in and the various parts and controls the dynamics. Retard.
@sidbolero go fist yourself this is one of there best and had it been out earlier it probably would have been on their greatest hits album stop the clocks so in what way is a it a 'soulless plodder'
at 2:22 & 2:44 ...is jesus playing the keyboard :D? great concert....would loved to have be there...its a pitty that they split and that liams voice has changed that much..but who oasis still will LIVE FOREVER
Liam moves his head away from the mic before finishing the note I dose it quite a lot now he needs to work on that if you look back at oasis during the mid 90s they where better however new albums good its just Liam live hes lost something
....Btw.......... "SouthernDandy"... Nail & Head Spring To Mind... Hes A Raw Singer, He Gives It His All On Almost Every Concert Tour For What... 15 Years??? I Think He Sounds Great On Dig Out Yer Soul.
Theres something so ridiculously endearing about Liams performance on this song. This cat basically went out for a decade and just sang till his vocal chords burst. Everyone, including Liam im sure, know his voice will never be like it was when he was 19 . But man, there's something so "fuck you" about him still just gettin' up there in front of 20,000 people and givin it. You want a perfect voice, go to Pop Idol, you want a real person, then its Liam man.
couldn't have put it better myself! Oasis sum up rock n roll, they have the look, the attitude, the music and the talent!
No other band in my lifetime has come close to them (im 21) and i'm sure no other ever will! I can listen to Definately Maybe, WTSMG, Don't Believe the Truth, Dig out your sould and The Masterplan from start to finish!
look 5 years ago yeah oasis were rocknroll and rebellious
but now they are even more mature than ever oasis are a great band and they are talented
especially 2009 they show that they can and still do good rockmusic and they dont need to show this anymore by doing shit in the publictiy or making fights and behaving badly
no oasis are not anymore the stupid victims of press THEY ARE REAL ROCKSTARS now better than ever!!
5 years ago 2004? i dont think so. Not that liam has ever sounded horrible, but 2003-2006 liams voice wasnt as good as it normally was from 1994-2001. But recently liams voice has gotten better.
its oasis some times liam is shite but other times on top of his game..noel is always spot on. i fuking live,breath oasis till i die. live forever. good to see they are back with new tunes, enough said
i think his voice is a lot weaker now but dont tell me that he can't hold those notes anymore, i think its just laziness. His song was the best that night by a fucking mile and he tried harder on it
Fucking immense! I don't care who slags off Liam Gallagher, all he needs to do is play them this hauntingly, breathtaking, masterpiece. Who'd have thought the cocky front man from Oasis could write such a song!
samburf your one of these fans who cant admit his voice has gone, your in denial, listen to cast no shadow from maine rd, and then listen to 'im outta time' live from wembley arena. compare the 2
WELLL WELL SAID!! as a "true" Oasis fan,,,i hate to see liams sound getting slated these days,,,,but you hit the nail on the head there!!I was at the Maine road gig of '96,,,and yep,,,Liam was sure Nightingale sounding,,,compared to these days!
But,,,,what else would peeps expect after his rock 'n' roll lifestyle!
fuck everyone taking the piss from his voice...still fucking brilliant as ever...FACT. it was alot smoother back in the day and that was awesome, now its rougher and dryer and personally i prefer it...i'd like to see any of these people who think they're fuckin experts, leavin comments "oh he's not as good any more" do any better. MADFERIT
So, I don't know how he does it in the studio, but it's become pretty clear that Liam cannot sing anymore, at least at shows. If I paid for a ticket to a show and he sung like that the whole way through, I'd want my money back.
He's clearly trying to sound as normal as he can, but it's not enough. Look back at what he sounded like even in 2002, at least that was in tune, even if it was an octave lower.
absolutely. they were outstanding in belfast! this song was my fave but supersonic was unbeleivable to. hang on i just remembered they were all class! pity about the wankers who through coins though.
The reason is that you're a geek that only see them by you tube. And you're sitted in your chair and can't feel a shit of what's happening. His voice is great like it is now, it has more passion. Like whine, gets better. Obviusly it's different from the begginig of his career.
simply fuckin epic. Despite sounding pretty much like an A-list beatles covers band for the last few years, every episode has a few impeccable moments and this is one of them.
although i think liam performs well here, i think this song is liam telling us that he knows he's had it and that he's out of time now. and after this record he will be gone.i hope iam wrong, but listen to the words...
everyone says that it took him 10 years to write, and why? because he said it in tongue and cheek during a 1.10 sec clip thats here on you tube? Come off it, behave yourself. Of course its not taken him 10 years to write. He also said that he started that when bring it on down came out 'which wernt even a single and was more than 10 years ago' . gullible gullible people! TONGUE AND CHEEK!!! for fuck sake. JOKES!! get em?
hes maybe shouting at his kids to much lol lol na i dont think his voice is gone he sometimes has an of day every singer does .when they did this at wembley he was terrible and he knew it but at least he didnt throw the speakers of the stage like ian brown when i was at tinthe park and he cant sing .OASIS are still class best band by a mile 4 me
From what i heard at their NIA concert this tour, he sang rather well. A bit like he used to in the nineties. Much better than this. Fingers crossed its just an off night
I just can't fathom how liam can sound so damn good on the album and yet every live performance he sounds horrible. I guess becasue he's always shouted rather than sung Live all that strain he's put on his voice has taken it's toll. The sound crew should turn his mike up so he doesn't have to shout and strain so much into the mike. He has to sing rather than shout!!!
Hearing the rock and roll voice of a generation like this is really depressing.
I know what you mean mate, he's hacking his way through a lot of live shows going for sheer force of power instead of a melodic approach, however, don't forget the processing on the vocal tracks, multi-tracking etc and the other studio trickery that can make anyone sound several times better, have look at some youtube video's for products such as melodyne then imagine what a skilled producer and some decent booth engieerng can do with this.
Noel or someone close to Liam needs to tell him to sort out his voice! He is damaging his voice singing in this horrible stretched throaty growl. If he's this bad at 35 imagine how bad he wills ound in10 years time? He just won't physically be able to sing. He'ill sound like how Rod Sewart does now and that would be a fucking travesty!
fact is that forcing the air out through your throat damages your vocal chords.
Liam's technique has become his undoing. Its a real shame because I love his voice.
Anybody that has affection for this group needs to watch the performance of Champagne Supernova at Earls Court 1995 and ask themselves whether they're doing Oasis any favours by continually brushing this aside.
Tough love, but his voice is on the way out for good if he doesn't sort it out.
Sorry Liam I love the sound of your voice on the new album but I have yet to hear you sing live on this tour and sound anywhere near good. He's isn't holding the notes for long enough and keeps pulling back from the mic, I imagine this is because he knows he's not hitting the notes right and sounds bad. Better to sing a crap note and pull away from the mic than hold the same shit note for longer.
liam sounds great. he's not 21 anymore. it's got to be one of the most demanding vocal roles in any band...he proper has top belt them out, year after year, show after show. legend - great performance, well done liam
I always find Liams voice sounds better when they are in North America. Watch the canadian videos on You tube he sounds great singing shock of the lightning,
Man, I don't think any other band can get this good. Man, after 15 years they do such a great, sublime, intense music. Epic. The version on the album would be great with the choir. Noel is a genius, I know the song is written by Liam, but the idea of the choir belongs to Noel.
Sigh why do people keep comparing Liam's voice to that of 95/96 IT'S NEVER GOING TO BE LIKE THAT AGAIN! ACCEPT IT. Sure his voice might not be as strong as it was back in the mid to late nineties but he can still bang it out.
His voice sounds weak because he's singing from his throat like he always did. He either has to learn a different technique or these 'pub rock' live performances are going to carry on forever,and it drags the rest of the band down.
interpretazione "magica"!!!! grande liam,decisamente meglio ke a wembley!!!Oasis the best!!!! nn ce musica senza di loro!!!!! OASISSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS: THE SOUND OF MY LIFE!!!!
bad boy tune up for liam
azzy508 3 months ago
a fuckin great version!!!
AndreijKomaskij 4 months ago
liam is awesome
MrTrevormctrevor 4 months ago
i love this version~
frankrose111 6 months ago
Amazing underrated tune.
The greatest tune Liam ever wrote (this and The Morning Son)
RamonMadFerIt 10 months ago
this is the best and first time a heard this song live
jamie9916 1 year ago
The intro of this sounds like a james bond theme ;)
tomppawalker 1 year ago 5
this song is about god. an ex oasis bandmate
zoomckng 1 year ago
Great song, shame that so much of there recent crap songs overshadowed ones like this
MsBlueboy79 1 year ago
the chorus in this video is absolutely EPIC!
AngelChildxxx 1 year ago
Classically constructed song easily in the top 5 Oasis tracks. If they had recorded the album/single version with the backing of the Festival Chorus Choir it would have elevated this already great song to another level altogether and had the future airplay time it deserves rather than in effect being forgotten an 'album track' they missed the trick? Realistically they probably had never even considered this arrangement until the Electric proms, a shame but, "you can't always get what you want"
bonnriley 1 year ago 2
Maybe Liam's voice isn't at his best here but I really got shivers and I love it, it sounds amazing!
Bengalen88 1 year ago
the 5 people who dislike this. if you dont like it my advice to you is simple. go suck on lady gaga's fat cock you cocksuckers
gimiausername 1 year ago 3
I absolutely love playing this on my guitar
tomhughestrainz 1 year ago
,ALL MOST GHOSTLY LIKE! BRILLANCE DONE SO EASY, IF U CLOSED UR EYE,S ITS LIKE LISTENING 2 AN ANGEL WITH A LITTLE BIT OF A RAW VOICE RICHIE
RICHIE69841 1 year ago
5 assholes
skizobatz 1 year ago
a great performance of a great band
konheeed 1 year ago
Q: Why does a choir need a conductor when there is a rock band providing the music?
A: It doesn't. pretensious bastards.
sidbolero 1 year ago
@sidbolero idiot
Pabloleblanc 1 year ago
@Pabloleblanc you're welcome, lamebrain.
sidbolero 1 year ago
@sidbolero do sing in a choir asshole? no. i thought not, he keeps everyone in time and brings in and the various parts and controls the dynamics. Retard.
Pabloleblanc 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
another soulless plodder from a band who should have split up years ago
sidbolero 1 year ago
@sidbolero twat
jimilmilm 1 year ago
Comment removed
CFCRM23OASIS 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sidbolero go fist yourself this is one of there best and had it been out earlier it probably would have been on their greatest hits album stop the clocks so in what way is a it a 'soulless plodder'
@southerndandy89 FUCKING AMEN
CFCRM23OASIS 1 year ago
@CFCRM23OASIS Learn to punctuate and learn to spell. It's their best not "there best". Idiot.
sidbolero 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sidbolero do you think i give a flying fuck?
CFCRM23OASIS 1 year ago
@sidbolero do you think i give a fuck? this is youtube not a fucking lesson in proper english
CFCRM23OASIS 1 year ago
really awesome!!!
lacys1886 1 year ago
What a voice! He's got a really, really GOOD voice! :D
nhadz16 2 years ago 5
@nhadz16 better than thom yorke :D
gerdiristyo1 1 year ago
fucking biblical man, i got the shivers
Famehater 2 years ago 21
love that solo
19911995 2 years ago
epic
jwalford90 2 years ago 4
go on my son awsum
MrSos28 2 years ago
This is fantastic...
maestro288 2 years ago 3
great song
marceloscoelho 2 years ago
At Wembley Noel introduced him as "Mr Jesus Christ" ha
flagga 2 years ago 6
TUNE
baguhmeister 2 years ago
at 2:22 & 2:44 ...is jesus playing the keyboard :D? great concert....would loved to have be there...its a pitty that they split and that liams voice has changed that much..but who oasis still will LIVE FOREVER
paulteutuljunior88 2 years ago 4
Haha noo,
Noel cald him the guy from Lord Of The Rings during the concert they gave in Netherlands
nickverbakel23 2 years ago
is george harrison hahahah!?...jaja
Linchudo 2 years ago
this is fuckin awesome, sounds so good whit the chorus, this is music
maurolinga 2 years ago
i love liams voice as it is now, it isnt what it was, but its different and in some ways i prefer it.
cowelly2006 2 years ago 4
TEMAZO
TEMAZO
TEMAZO
bdrcrewzas 2 years ago 4
cavolo, qui era proprio messo male con la voce, il pezzo arrangiato con i cori invece è da paura
GliAlveoli 2 years ago
I saw them at wembley the other day, and his voice sounds so much better than it does here, he hasn't lost anything i can assure you.
harryb925 2 years ago 7
what is the type of guitar gem is playing??? been buggin me for aaaaaaaaaaaaages
oves21 2 years ago
Gibson Firebird !
Samuelohehe 2 years ago
legend cheers
oves21 2 years ago
me like =)
flenost 2 years ago
gibson firebird 1975
edubalian 2 years ago
Liam moves his head away from the mic before finishing the note I dose it quite a lot now he needs to work on that if you look back at oasis during the mid 90s they where better however new albums good its just Liam live hes lost something
MsAlex101 2 years ago
....Btw.......... "SouthernDandy"... Nail & Head Spring To Mind... Hes A Raw Singer, He Gives It His All On Almost Every Concert Tour For What... 15 Years??? I Think He Sounds Great On Dig Out Yer Soul.
0Kian0 2 years ago
fucking amazing!
Jonophonics 2 years ago
Liam sounds bad !! voice is sometimes gone
but the song is great
luciferion2000 2 years ago
this song is great live, Liam sounds awesome
porterdinho08 2 years ago
Mejor imposible
Perfecto
Gran Performance
Lennon esta vivo
Gracias Liam
Gracias Oasis
hardrock251183 2 years ago 4
oye donde puedo descargar este concierto en mp3?????
en limewire no lo encuentro
ROOBERTOO1984 2 years ago
Theres something so ridiculously endearing about Liams performance on this song. This cat basically went out for a decade and just sang till his vocal chords burst. Everyone, including Liam im sure, know his voice will never be like it was when he was 19 . But man, there's something so "fuck you" about him still just gettin' up there in front of 20,000 people and givin it. You want a perfect voice, go to Pop Idol, you want a real person, then its Liam man.
southerndandy89 2 years ago 66
couldn't have put it better myself! Oasis sum up rock n roll, they have the look, the attitude, the music and the talent!
No other band in my lifetime has come close to them (im 21) and i'm sure no other ever will! I can listen to Definately Maybe, WTSMG, Don't Believe the Truth, Dig out your sould and The Masterplan from start to finish!
stey2k 2 years ago 6
yeah man. no other band will ever do that to me... i hope to god their will be.. but i dont think their will.
adam4592 2 years ago
@southerndandy89 Fuck yeah!!! what and epic comment!!!!
CristianoEduardo07 1 year ago
@southerndandy89 probably the best summing up on a video i have ever read, something so "fuck you" about him still :)
beatlebum1000 1 year ago
nice voice liam today last 2001
pamnaldo24 2 years ago
you are totally right man how i said before oasis are real rockstars now than ever
22 I am I first saw them live 2002
konheeed 2 years ago
@kozzy 06 oasis were also excellent 5 years ago
look 5 years ago yeah oasis were rocknroll and rebellious
but now they are even more mature than ever oasis are a great band and they are talented
especially 2009 they show that they can and still do good rockmusic and they dont need to show this anymore by doing shit in the publictiy or making fights and behaving badly
no oasis are not anymore the stupid victims of press THEY ARE REAL ROCKSTARS now better than ever!!
konheeed 2 years ago 3
i've grown up with Oasis i'm now 33 and followed them from the early 90s
this is their most impressive performance worked really well with choir added a errie atmosphere 1st class
monkeymagic33 2 years ago 3
gods of music
aaron18467 3 years ago 4
the last great british band ever.LIVE FOREVER people.
mods75 3 years ago 4
absolutly amazing, another great oasis song, however its clearall these years of drugs,smoking etc have fatigued liams voice
adamsx01x 3 years ago
no doubt about it matey but just listen to bob dylan these days and compare him to the way he sounded 30 years ago voices change dont they
ste1366 2 years ago
Yer but oasis arent that old, and Noel still sounds quite good.
MsAlex101 2 years ago
liam must of felt like a god here with the choir behind him backing his preaching and a large crowd infront of him eating out his hand.!
tojam22 3 years ago
oasis is better than ever today wow liam looks better than he did in 2000
they will release more great songs
konheeed 3 years ago
better than ever? How old are you pal? I assure you liam sounded alot better 5 or more years ago.
Kozzy06 2 years ago
5 years ago 2004? i dont think so. Not that liam has ever sounded horrible, but 2003-2006 liams voice wasnt as good as it normally was from 1994-2001. But recently liams voice has gotten better.
def671 2 years ago
The Years Of Drugs And Alcohol Hav Taken Its Toll On Liams Voice
Jamesol203 3 years ago 3
Indeed they have. Indeed, they have.
Cuoin 2 years ago
great song but not his best vocal
bryanwest3 3 years ago
its oasis some times liam is shite but other times on top of his game..noel is always spot on. i fuking live,breath oasis till i die. live forever. good to see they are back with new tunes, enough said
martodawg 3 years ago 3
I think he should go to a vocal coach to get things back on track. But Liam being Liam, he would never do that.
daithifleming 3 years ago 4
hahaha i bet so..
oasisforever00 3 years ago 2
hel never sound bad... :S
samiproskater 3 years ago
i think his voice is a lot weaker now but dont tell me that he can't hold those notes anymore, i think its just laziness. His song was the best that night by a fucking mile and he tried harder on it
keflar5 3 years ago 3
despite Liam's voice not being what it used to be, obviously, he still sounds amazing!
bcfctilldeath 3 years ago 2
I think that kidda its not denial coz he aint brill any more but this voice grows on you and sounds class on this song bt still prefer the older liam
1everton2 3 years ago 2
Would love to see them live with that Choir.
All the songs from the Electric Proms with that choir just add somthing to it.
Not that Oasis need them though!
dickie3110 3 years ago 2
This has to be the best Oasis track since the Morning Glory days - immense.
dcl848 3 years ago 2
amazing, see them July 9th Wembley Stadium
baxxynufc 3 years ago
WOW !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
wadihfrancis 3 years ago
Fucking immense! I don't care who slags off Liam Gallagher, all he needs to do is play them this hauntingly, breathtaking, masterpiece. Who'd have thought the cocky front man from Oasis could write such a song!
2021Timbales 3 years ago 2
15 fevereiro -----------»» PORTUGAL!!!!! :D :D
WhiskasSaketas 3 years ago
oh my god!I love them!
delpierosjq 3 years ago
amazing!
delpierosjq 3 years ago
thats pretty great
thegreatestgooner 3 years ago
he gets every fuckin note here
awesome performance probibly the best of outta time
noelwannabe 3 years ago 6
genius !
buckyberger 3 years ago
his voice is better now. it's rock n roll, and he's singing his heart out
dave790 3 years ago 4
u fucking wankers, if u ever take the piss out of his voice ever again i will personally come to your house and ring your mums pussy
samburf 3 years ago
samburf your one of these fans who cant admit his voice has gone, your in denial, listen to cast no shadow from maine rd, and then listen to 'im outta time' live from wembley arena. compare the 2
CraicCocaine 3 years ago 2
WELLL WELL SAID!! as a "true" Oasis fan,,,i hate to see liams sound getting slated these days,,,,but you hit the nail on the head there!!I was at the Maine road gig of '96,,,and yep,,,Liam was sure Nightingale sounding,,,compared to these days!
But,,,,what else would peeps expect after his rock 'n' roll lifestyle!
alty567 3 years ago 2
fuck everyone taking the piss from his voice...still fucking brilliant as ever...FACT. it was alot smoother back in the day and that was awesome, now its rougher and dryer and personally i prefer it...i'd like to see any of these people who think they're fuckin experts, leavin comments "oh he's not as good any more" do any better. MADFERIT
jamesye11 3 years ago
top preformance, stop whinging about his voice and just apprecate the genius that is oasis
foxyfoxy06 3 years ago
So, I don't know how he does it in the studio, but it's become pretty clear that Liam cannot sing anymore, at least at shows. If I paid for a ticket to a show and he sung like that the whole way through, I'd want my money back.
He's clearly trying to sound as normal as he can, but it's not enough. Look back at what he sounded like even in 2002, at least that was in tune, even if it was an octave lower.
thegreatscp 3 years ago
I agree he didn't sound very good here but to be fair I was in belfast for the next show and he sounded excellent all the way through.
liam1one1 3 years ago
absolutely. they were outstanding in belfast! this song was my fave but supersonic was unbeleivable to. hang on i just remembered they were all class! pity about the wankers who through coins though.
johnterrylegend 3 years ago
The reason is that you're a geek that only see them by you tube. And you're sitted in your chair and can't feel a shit of what's happening. His voice is great like it is now, it has more passion. Like whine, gets better. Obviusly it's different from the begginig of his career.
Ivanovich18 3 years ago
You've got to love the solo! Its magnificent in its simplicity (when compared to song like Live Forever). Simply stunning!
jalisciense88 3 years ago
great performance, the chorus its amazing
Hooba1900 3 years ago
Great performance, best song off the new album.
dcl848 3 years ago 4
I have followed Oasis from the begining and Paul Arthurs(Bonehead) used to be a customer where I worked.
These guys are the Ballocks and so was this show
primal510 3 years ago
simply fuckin epic. Despite sounding pretty much like an A-list beatles covers band for the last few years, every episode has a few impeccable moments and this is one of them.
durtyz 3 years ago
One of the best songs of the new album i think, and like all the others it sounded great at the proms
chris3boro 3 years ago
although i think liam performs well here, i think this song is liam telling us that he knows he's had it and that he's out of time now. and after this record he will be gone.i hope iam wrong, but listen to the words...
tojam22 3 years ago
He's been writing this song since the late 90's, so I doubt that he's going anywhere anytime soon.
theboiwonder 3 years ago
everyone says that it took him 10 years to write, and why? because he said it in tongue and cheek during a 1.10 sec clip thats here on you tube? Come off it, behave yourself. Of course its not taken him 10 years to write. He also said that he started that when bring it on down came out 'which wernt even a single and was more than 10 years ago' . gullible gullible people! TONGUE AND CHEEK!!! for fuck sake. JOKES!! get em?
lsdarcy 3 years ago 2
YOUTUBE IS SERIOUS BUSINESS!
theboiwonder 3 years ago
DAM RIGHT!!!!!!!!!
lsdarcy 3 years ago
:L:L:L
foxyfoxy06 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
bullshit
lsdarcy 3 years ago
Gotta agree with kill83,love oasis to death but hes right!!
bentheled 3 years ago
excelente
panamacecoro4 3 years ago 2
hes maybe shouting at his kids to much lol lol na i dont think his voice is gone he sometimes has an of day every singer does .when they did this at wembley he was terrible and he knew it but at least he didnt throw the speakers of the stage like ian brown when i was at tinthe park and he cant sing .OASIS are still class best band by a mile 4 me
scumerfielder 3 years ago 2
his voice is shot, he sounds beautiful on this song though. and what a song it brings a tear to my eye
Sheldo022 3 years ago
in my experience the stage proformanes dont match up to the album acts, methinks they take the piss when they preform live
inobamawetrust08 3 years ago
You lot are talking sh*t!! I was there and his voice sounded awesome.
He doesn't need vocal lessons, he's a rock n roll singer not Charlotte effing Church!
MattGOODE1978 3 years ago 4
he sang it brilliantly at the secc sounded very much like the album version
Gemarcheroasis 3 years ago
killwill83 hit the nail rite on the head
caseylfc 3 years ago
From what i heard at their NIA concert this tour, he sang rather well. A bit like he used to in the nineties. Much better than this. Fingers crossed its just an off night
SouthBankOwen 3 years ago
in this perfomance the voice of Our Kid is very good, not like other perfomance of this tour
TeLeInDiE 3 years ago 2
absolutly perfect
Damon83 3 years ago
killwill ur right about everything you said
but noel is not a very close person to liam
i mean they love each other for sure but they're not close ..
it should someone like his missus
or john lennon tells him in a dream while he's sleeping or something =p
wthallnamestaken 3 years ago
I just can't fathom how liam can sound so damn good on the album and yet every live performance he sounds horrible. I guess becasue he's always shouted rather than sung Live all that strain he's put on his voice has taken it's toll. The sound crew should turn his mike up so he doesn't have to shout and strain so much into the mike. He has to sing rather than shout!!!
Hearing the rock and roll voice of a generation like this is really depressing.
killwill83 3 years ago
I know what you mean mate, he's hacking his way through a lot of live shows going for sheer force of power instead of a melodic approach, however, don't forget the processing on the vocal tracks, multi-tracking etc and the other studio trickery that can make anyone sound several times better, have look at some youtube video's for products such as melodyne then imagine what a skilled producer and some decent booth engieerng can do with this.
durtyz 3 years ago
Noel or someone close to Liam needs to tell him to sort out his voice! He is damaging his voice singing in this horrible stretched throaty growl. If he's this bad at 35 imagine how bad he wills ound in10 years time? He just won't physically be able to sing. He'ill sound like how Rod Sewart does now and that would be a fucking travesty!
killwill83 3 years ago
fact is that forcing the air out through your throat damages your vocal chords.
Liam's technique has become his undoing. Its a real shame because I love his voice.
Anybody that has affection for this group needs to watch the performance of Champagne Supernova at Earls Court 1995 and ask themselves whether they're doing Oasis any favours by continually brushing this aside.
Tough love, but his voice is on the way out for good if he doesn't sort it out.
oswego22 3 years ago
yeh mate i agree 100% that earls court performance is unbelievable
Sheldo022 3 years ago
Sorry Liam I love the sound of your voice on the new album but I have yet to hear you sing live on this tour and sound anywhere near good. He's isn't holding the notes for long enough and keeps pulling back from the mic, I imagine this is because he knows he's not hitting the notes right and sounds bad. Better to sing a crap note and pull away from the mic than hold the same shit note for longer.
killwill83 3 years ago
EXCELENTE
panamacecoro4 3 years ago
amazing performance!:D
laurencelake007 3 years ago
afroman hot, hot as fck, love fckn afroman, also love this tune, 9 years writing this song,deadly buzz
stauntondeclan 3 years ago
u know what i mean MJ everyone loves to critisise liam but at the end of the day hes a fukin ledgend and this tune is a fukin belter @nt
ant20coventry 3 years ago
He bottles the high notes though!
Cunners82 3 years ago
liam sounds great. he's not 21 anymore. it's got to be one of the most demanding vocal roles in any band...he proper has top belt them out, year after year, show after show. legend - great performance, well done liam
dave790 3 years ago 2
I always find Liams voice sounds better when they are in North America. Watch the canadian videos on You tube he sounds great singing shock of the lightning,
geordie0525 3 years ago
I agree. I was second row on the floor for their Edmonton gig and Liam sounded absolutely awesome!
andycap523 3 years ago
for any one who's slagged off Oasis over the years....eat this!!
chriscurwen 3 years ago
Man, I don't think any other band can get this good. Man, after 15 years they do such a great, sublime, intense music. Epic. The version on the album would be great with the choir. Noel is a genius, I know the song is written by Liam, but the idea of the choir belongs to Noel.
Ivanovich18 3 years ago
Sigh why do people keep comparing Liam's voice to that of 95/96 IT'S NEVER GOING TO BE LIKE THAT AGAIN! ACCEPT IT. Sure his voice might not be as strong as it was back in the mid to late nineties but he can still bang it out.
andycap523 3 years ago
I'm happy to accept it.
Fact is,he can't bang it out anymore.
His voice sounds weak because he's singing from his throat like he always did. He either has to learn a different technique or these 'pub rock' live performances are going to carry on forever,and it drags the rest of the band down.
oswego22 3 years ago
great! he didnt go out of tune! best live verison
laurencelake007 3 years ago
nice to see they got some singers in, as Oasis don't seem to have one anymore.
Compare this to Liam 95/96 and it's such a shame, because it's a beautiful song.
oswego22 3 years ago
who the fuck are u to comment?! would like to here you bang out this tune pitch perfect!
MJBELB10 3 years ago
you've got me down as a hater and that's not the case.
he ia pitch perfect, birdbrain. but his voice is shot.
oswego22 3 years ago
Agreed, Liam take vocal lessons or quit. Reality is that you sound like absolute shit.
SEModena 3 years ago
The choir gave even more soul to the song :)
ManuZombie 3 years ago
does anyone else thinks the start sounds like a james bond theme?
oasismonkeyslfc 3 years ago 2
interpretazione "magica"!!!! grande liam,decisamente meglio ke a wembley!!!Oasis the best!!!! nn ce musica senza di loro!!!!! OASISSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS: THE SOUND OF MY LIFE!!!!
OASISpzthebest 3 years ago
liam gets a new haircut isn't he?!
khiqie 3 years ago
the coda is amazing
thefadedline 3 years ago
OMG, this sound's Beautiful
TSERSR 3 years ago
This is absolutley sublime.
Sweentodd 3 years ago
absolutely mesmerising
the choir, liams vocals
stunning
bigjokk 3 years ago
Absolutely brilliant!!!!!!!!!!!!!
skins19816 3 years ago
AMAZING!!!!!!1
neiltilley 3 years ago
liam's vocals seem a bit strained here...but work of genius, this.
electrequiem 3 years ago
where's the rest? PLZ!!!
faver87 3 years ago
Now I understand the magnitud and greatness of this song.Classic sure.The guitar solo is the same style of slash aha.I'm from Argentina.SALUDOS
jorlr89 3 years ago