A whole lot of good the Revolution did, the Communists took control of the mainland and the Kuomintang was forced to retreat to the island of Taiwan. But all of China is increasingly coming under the influence of the American Empire...so what good was it to rebel? I know a Manchu, she laughs at this sometimes...
@TheShadowParliament Do you believe America and it's leaders learned from these thousand yr old systems? And is now implementing a better solution. Do you think there will be another civil war in the united states? I'm sure they have taken precautions to subdue an uprising right?
Is this movie any good? I am wary of films that deal with political themes that come from mainland china. You know how the CCP tends to tamper with those movies or ban them outright.
@ramboman88 I know where I can download it but I am hesitating because of this supposed political interference. I don't know what happened to hong kong films they used to be considered the hollywood of the east.
no offence to Jackie Chan, but I actually think someone else should play the role of Huang Keqiang(the greatest of all revolutionaries). And the "kungfu" scenes from 1911 should be cut. This would make 1911 a perfect movie.
I like Jackie Chan movies because their super interesting with all Kung Fu stuff, but I don't see that in the trailer. Is there any kungfu in the movie?
Han had annexed Mongolia and Xinjiang. Tang was the most Imperialist. They annexed Dongbei, Mongolia, Xinjiang, Tibet. They were finally overstretched at the battle of Talas. Somewhere between Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. Ming had conquered Manchuria.
gotta love chinese affinity with numbers cross referencing. 100th jackie chan film, 100th anniversary! PROVIDENCE! (or whatever the chinese equivalant to that word is...)
@victorhng: If you're talking about the Kuomingtang fighting Communist forces, then yes, I agree. I'm Chinese too (American Born) but I do know my history.
@joshcooldudeyeah yes. xinhai was nothing i mean qing was rotting from the core thru wars, internal struggles, foreign powers etc. After the revolution it seems to lead to even more fighting and bloodshed. Warlords carving their own turfs, Japs coming in, and ideology rivalry. xinhai was only the beginning. Wouldnt end until a few years after WWII finished.
@victorhng: Unfortunately, yes, that is all true. But every time I look back and begin to contemplate the scars of China's past (within the last century), the wounds run very deep and have divided our people across every political and socio-economic line possible at the time.
@victorhng But here's one of those bizarre paradoxes in modern Chinese history: if we were to remove all political boundaries (and hypothetically speaking, tearing down the wall that divides Kuomingtang and Communist), then maybe the Chinese people could unite again. I wouldn't know under what system, but from a cultural perspective, we Chinese are still Chinese no matter what. That's all I want to say about the topic.
@gotentk4 I know but for the better part of China, the KMT tried to maintain their control of the Chinese mainland, but ultimately failed to do so since they experienced intense political corruption, a right-wing and left-wing split, fighting the Japanese (and later on, the growing Communist forces) during WWII and so on and so forth. There was so much rivalry and corruption it was hard for the KMT to continue maintaining their grasp of the mainland, which is precisely why they fled.
@PenileFracture thanks!, but yea, i know... what i was trying to say was that Jackie Chan always says that ROC in Taiwan is not a country, and he is so proud of People's Republic of China
@tn00777479 Taiwan may not be an official country (at least not yet), but I agree it's NOT a part of mainland China. It should be the other way around. The ROC flew the flag over the mainland but we can only and pray the PRC doesn't fly their flag over Taiwan.
I'm Taiwanese with mainland Chinese roots so I do stand strongly on this issue. :)
我們應該要檢討的是: 辛亥革命推翻滿清已經100年了, 為何中國的問題依然存在? 然地制已被推翻, 但專制卻以共和國的外衣繼續存在著. We must think: The Revolution had been passed for 100 years(a century) but an autocratic government remains.
@Killer211314 we chinese are known as Han People, because the peak of Chinese known to historian are Han(汉人) and Tang dynasty(唐人). Song is one of the most corrupted dynasty, an imperial court full of official made up of corrupted officials (文武百官,贪污受贿,官官相护). Qing dynasty are tribal people, more incline to horse riding and fighting. Earlier emperor are strong because they know who to use, and what to do. . Qing fell weak when CiXi that take over whole court and mistreat whole of China population.
@Killer211314 Dear friend, I must disagree. Only the Qing Dynasty end, especially under empress Cixi was bad. You forget that Emepror Kangxi legitimately annexed Tibet, Taiwan, Mongolia, and Xingjiang areas under his rule. (Recognized by Western powers) Han, Tang, and Song never accomplished that. Yuan briefly did, but then were pushed North. Just my opinion.
@Killer211314 there are quite a lot of idiots like cixi in past dynasties like cixi that caused the empire to collapse.
well gotta credit that b!tch for holding the crumbling empire up to 1912 lol. as i know in cixi's time, qing dynasty was already in deep shit!
well if wanna blame qing dynasty you should blame wanli emperor of ming dynasty(1572-1620) for not attending to his duty for 20yrs, and being more corrupted than cixi ever was that brought down ming dynasty in 1640.
LOL! Jackie Chan carrying a Maxim
McMeevin 1 week ago
and what do you call the gun in the police story series for instance? a kung fu modified chop sitck? wtf
findelkind99 3 weeks ago
Why Why Why -.-
If the Revolution doesn't started China would still have a Emperor -.-
kayn731 4 weeks ago
It was the Qing dynasty, not Ming.
nicck 1 month ago
the movie look good but make it English
jade379676 1 month ago
stadt der gewalt - bester jackie chan film
asozialamt 2 months ago
When i saw Jackie Chan holding that revolver, i said to myself "Dis shit aint real"
IWant2BASpartun 2 months ago
Description is wrong. Overthrew Qing dynasty (manchurians) not the Ming. Ming dynasty was overthrew by Manchurians 350 years ago
06lanevomr 2 months ago
@06lanevomr And here I was expecting to see Dr. Sun Yat-Sen operating a time machine.
AmericanNudist 2 days ago
You mena overthrew the Qing dynasty.
1Hard2Ass 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jackie with gunz LOL !
PayToDieFucker 2 months ago
A whole lot of good the Revolution did, the Communists took control of the mainland and the Kuomintang was forced to retreat to the island of Taiwan. But all of China is increasingly coming under the influence of the American Empire...so what good was it to rebel? I know a Manchu, she laughs at this sometimes...
TheShadowParliament 2 months ago
@TheShadowParliament Do you believe America and it's leaders learned from these thousand yr old systems? And is now implementing a better solution. Do you think there will be another civil war in the united states? I'm sure they have taken precautions to subdue an uprising right?
SuperOuJin 1 month ago
i remember jackie said he wishes to act in a movie where he do not have to use kung fu. im glad his wish may have fullfilled.
blackwolf9525 3 months ago
cool jackie have machine guns
marty72162 3 months ago
da hell?!?!? where's the Kung-Fu?!?!?!
amoo2007 3 months ago
Is this movie any good? I am wary of films that deal with political themes that come from mainland china. You know how the CCP tends to tamper with those movies or ban them outright.
redwhitedude 3 months ago
@redwhitedude
The movie can still be good. At least movie/TV censorship in China isn't as bad as it used to be in the US.
In any case, it would be very interesting to see Jackie Chan playing a role as this.
ramboman88 3 months ago
@ramboman88 I know where I can download it but I am hesitating because of this supposed political interference. I don't know what happened to hong kong films they used to be considered the hollywood of the east.
redwhitedude 3 months ago
@redwhitedude Well, there is no other way to know for sure than to see it. Taiwan also makes films but their industry isn't very big.
ramboman88 3 months ago
Jackie Chan movie without Kung Fu and Comedy is like Censored porn...
krsforever 3 months ago
no offence to Jackie Chan, but I actually think someone else should play the role of Huang Keqiang(the greatest of all revolutionaries). And the "kungfu" scenes from 1911 should be cut. This would make 1911 a perfect movie.
MingDynasty700 3 months ago
Where is Jakie's kung fu ???
farafeshow 3 months ago 16
@farafeshow because hes getting older...
ferrynator15 2 months ago
@farafeshow thats the reason i bought this movie!
Ichigo1423jfk 1 month ago
CHING CHONG DYNASTY!!
BITCHESSS :D
ielvisthegreat 3 months ago
Jackie Chan doesn't use guns D:
ImAweirdKid 3 months ago 27
@ImAweirdKid its a war movie... and he is a police officer...using gun is inevitable..
karthiksa2 2 months ago
did he just say: Faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaart ?!
arramad 3 months ago
不是大陸拍的還能看
SoutheGarden 3 months ago
I like Jackie Chan movies because their super interesting with all Kung Fu stuff, but I don't see that in the trailer. Is there any kungfu in the movie?
codergames 3 months ago
@codergames No, this is like a documentary film to learn about their history. There will be no kungfu scene. :)
xander9xx 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
jesus, our master is getting old. I beg you, please give jackie chan a sip from the cup of christ !!!
janquino 3 months ago
this movies releasing big in india cause its jackie's 100th film hope its good
itnsk 4 months ago
这部电影虽然是100年前的时代背景,但有头脑的人会看懂它的真正含义。是对当代中共独裁腐败的最恰当的讽刺电影。
Donghui0705 4 months ago
Is the actual movie fully in Chinese?
linkin1995 4 months ago
@linkin1995 Yes
TheBuddhaChannel 3 months ago
Fuck Qing Dynasty !! Why must shave the Fucking HEADS !!
megablood02 4 months ago
Japan should conquer China once again!
ngocquang19877 4 months ago
2:04 FFFUUUUUUUUU-
charlywarlyman 4 months ago
Comment removed
charlywarlyman 4 months ago
Is it just me or is Jackie dubbed? How good is his Mandarin anyway?
Sanzo84 4 months ago
@Sanzo84 It seemed like half the movie he was dubbed and then all of a sudden HEY Jackies real voice
???
Lmulraine 4 months ago
cant find subs for this movie anywhere
pkidro 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
when is this movie coming to America
suskaisan 4 months ago
WHERE ARE the POWER ARMORS!!!!
Anarchizer 4 months ago
jackie with guns...EPIC
richardfps123 4 months ago
A SUB IN ENGLISH PLZ???
norazlinc 5 months ago 2
Thumbs up if piratepedia brought you here :D
abhi5205 5 months ago
@abhi5205 why not just tell the whole fucking world?! I bet people don't trust you with secrets lol.
Kamakazi7000 4 months ago
Han had annexed Mongolia and Xinjiang. Tang was the most Imperialist. They annexed Dongbei, Mongolia, Xinjiang, Tibet. They were finally overstretched at the battle of Talas. Somewhere between Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. Ming had conquered Manchuria.
Lordofthenipplerings 5 months ago
@Lordofthenipplerings the Ming lost to Manchuria.
gotentk4 4 months ago
@gotentk4 Ming had also controlled Manchuria. Nurhachi himself was a soldier in the Ming empire before declaring his own state.
Lordofthenipplerings 4 months ago
who have watched this movie before?? and how was it??^^
peeyachu 5 months ago
civil war is the nastiest kind of war you can imagine.
MrHoppers002 5 months ago
this is like the continoueing of assassin and bodygaurds
EmperorGeass 5 months ago
gotta love chinese affinity with numbers cross referencing. 100th jackie chan film, 100th anniversary! PROVIDENCE! (or whatever the chinese equivalant to that word is...)
thegoodlifeonlybettr 5 months ago
Long live the Republic of China! :D
joshcooldudeyeah 5 months ago
the civil wars that came after this revolution were even more brutal
victorhng 5 months ago
@victorhng: If you're talking about the Kuomingtang fighting Communist forces, then yes, I agree. I'm Chinese too (American Born) but I do know my history.
joshcooldudeyeah 5 months ago
@joshcooldudeyeah yes. xinhai was nothing i mean qing was rotting from the core thru wars, internal struggles, foreign powers etc. After the revolution it seems to lead to even more fighting and bloodshed. Warlords carving their own turfs, Japs coming in, and ideology rivalry. xinhai was only the beginning. Wouldnt end until a few years after WWII finished.
victorhng 5 months ago
@victorhng: Unfortunately, yes, that is all true. But every time I look back and begin to contemplate the scars of China's past (within the last century), the wounds run very deep and have divided our people across every political and socio-economic line possible at the time.
joshcooldudeyeah 5 months ago
@victorhng But here's one of those bizarre paradoxes in modern Chinese history: if we were to remove all political boundaries (and hypothetically speaking, tearing down the wall that divides Kuomingtang and Communist), then maybe the Chinese people could unite again. I wouldn't know under what system, but from a cultural perspective, we Chinese are still Chinese no matter what. That's all I want to say about the topic.
What are your thoughts about it?
joshcooldudeyeah 5 months ago
since China is so rich in military history they should make more movies about war but use more reputable actors from Hong Kong
spike378 5 months ago
Chinese take over Manchu rule?
Shang, Zhou, Qin, Han, Song, Tang, Ming = Chinese states.
ghoststrider45 5 months ago
lol, Jackie acted the army of Republic of China but nor People's Republic of China?
tn00777479 5 months ago
@tn00777479 People's Republic was not established until 1949
PenileFracture 5 months ago 2
@PenileFracture That's correct. The Republic of China controlled the mainland from 1911 until the loss to the Communists in 1949.
joshcooldudeyeah 5 months ago
@joshcooldudeyeah it wasn't fully controlled
gotentk4 4 months ago
@gotentk4 I know but for the better part of China, the KMT tried to maintain their control of the Chinese mainland, but ultimately failed to do so since they experienced intense political corruption, a right-wing and left-wing split, fighting the Japanese (and later on, the growing Communist forces) during WWII and so on and so forth. There was so much rivalry and corruption it was hard for the KMT to continue maintaining their grasp of the mainland, which is precisely why they fled.
joshcooldudeyeah 4 months ago
@PenileFracture thanks!, but yea, i know... what i was trying to say was that Jackie Chan always says that ROC in Taiwan is not a country, and he is so proud of People's Republic of China
tn00777479 5 months ago
@tn00777479 Taiwan may not be an official country (at least not yet), but I agree it's NOT a part of mainland China. It should be the other way around. The ROC flew the flag over the mainland but we can only and pray the PRC doesn't fly their flag over Taiwan.
I'm Taiwanese with mainland Chinese roots so I do stand strongly on this issue. :)
joshcooldudeyeah 4 months ago
I think jackie chans son was going to appear in this movie too
AffieKnows 5 months ago
我們應該要檢討的是: 辛亥革命推翻滿清已經100年了, 為何中國的問題依然存在? 然地制已被推翻, 但專制卻以共和國的外衣繼續存在著. We must think: The Revolution had been passed for 100 years(a century) but an autocratic government remains.
wphr2101 5 months ago
Doesn't sound Jackie's voice...
mvang01 5 months ago
@mvang01 Japanese voice actor.
TriumphantLoser 5 months ago
Wow!!! Hopefully this will run in North America In it's original language subtitled of course!!!
GregoriousGregori9 5 months ago
not many people know this, but Sun Yat-sen was a Triad
39unknown93 5 months ago
Qing dynasty is ugliest dynasty!!! I hate Qing dynasty!!! Tang and Song are the best!!
Killer211314 5 months ago 26
@Killer211314 we chinese are known as Han People, because the peak of Chinese known to historian are Han(汉人) and Tang dynasty(唐人). Song is one of the most corrupted dynasty, an imperial court full of official made up of corrupted officials (文武百官,贪污受贿,官官相护). Qing dynasty are tribal people, more incline to horse riding and fighting. Earlier emperor are strong because they know who to use, and what to do. . Qing fell weak when CiXi that take over whole court and mistreat whole of China population.
edwinzang 5 months ago 2
@Killer211314 Han all the way :P
murkythreat 5 months ago
@Killer211314 FOR FUCKS SAKE THIS IS ABOUT A MOVIE
vikingskippen 5 months ago 2
@Killer211314
Don't forget Han Dynasty there champ.
bobo441 5 months ago
but they did acquire a majority of china's modern land?
MrHoppers002 5 months ago
@Killer211314 Dear friend, I must disagree. Only the Qing Dynasty end, especially under empress Cixi was bad. You forget that Emepror Kangxi legitimately annexed Tibet, Taiwan, Mongolia, and Xingjiang areas under his rule. (Recognized by Western powers) Han, Tang, and Song never accomplished that. Yuan briefly did, but then were pushed North. Just my opinion.
arodspecialist 5 months ago
@Killer211314 fucking manchus. china belongs to the han!
ervin920 5 months ago
@ervin920 china belongs to chinese. DUH
tdzheng 4 months ago
@Killer211314 Qing dynasty is not all that bad tho in their 2/3rd of their lifespan. if not they won't last till 200+ years.
tdzheng 4 months ago
@tdzheng every dynasty is good when they were built. But Qing dynasty rulers are so stupid, I can't stand them. especially the B!tch Cixi.
Killer211314 4 months ago
@Killer211314 there are quite a lot of idiots like cixi in past dynasties like cixi that caused the empire to collapse.
well gotta credit that b!tch for holding the crumbling empire up to 1912 lol. as i know in cixi's time, qing dynasty was already in deep shit!
well if wanna blame qing dynasty you should blame wanli emperor of ming dynasty(1572-1620) for not attending to his duty for 20yrs, and being more corrupted than cixi ever was that brought down ming dynasty in 1640.
tdzheng 4 months ago
@Killer211314 If not Tang Dynasty , They'll be no Japan and Korea .
megablood02 4 months ago
封建是没了, 专制还在
jazzny001 5 months ago 3
i don't like watching war movies/drama but because Hu Ge is in it i'll give it a try
anonymouslover96 5 months ago
GOOD LOGO!!
gimgim 6 months ago
Qing dynasty, not Ming dynasty.
linbj2008 6 months ago 22
@linbj2008 Yeah really. You would think they would know better than to make this kind of mistake.
redwhitedude 3 months ago