Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,633)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Pip...or Haley...can't pick:O

  • So....I don't like this. At all. Her voice is all over the place. Pips version is much much better.

  • @HannaChicka24 Pips version was a rip off of Haley you dumb twat. Go watch his version if you like it so much

  • @escaflowneil I know right not that Scotty's bad but all country music sounds the same :/ I missed Haley grrrrr I voted for her but I guess that didn't help :(

  • why haley didn't win God Damn america...... is far far far much better than scotty.........

  • Pip from The Voice sent me here..

  • Really, her voice gives me chills. She's sexy, she's talented... can't think about anything more to be an idol. The end of this season sucked.

  • Like if you are watching this in 2012 :D haley's a BEAST

  • this song still gives me chills one of the best Idol performances ever she def. should have won but at lestr she was top 3

  • She was in the Top 5 for a reason.She was amazing!She should have won!

  • I could see her with a burlesque show in Vegas, And i would totally go see it more than once

  • My very favorite!! She blows this away! At least the Judges gave her a good review this time. She should have won. I haven't bought any of the albums yet from the anyone. Waiting for Haley's! Coming in May! Yepee!

  • Well done!! Bravo!!

  • Haley is so freaking hot!!! I'm fucking jealous of Casey Abrams.

  • amazing !

  • She is AMAZING!!!!! I would buy her record over ANY artist now.

  • Oh my god, seriously? I never said Pip's name was masculine and I wasn't saying that Haley was a bad singer, I was just saying quit trolling around and stop the hate between the two different sounds. They are both amazing singers with TOTALLY different styles. Pip has a more strong theatrical voice whereas Haley has a jazzy smoothness about her voice so the two can't really be compared.

    Get over it.

  • @Iamonlymeee Why don't you just go to Pip's video and give him all the support he needs. Why come here and talk about Pip?.

  • I will single handedly get this video to 1M views

  • In my mind that should have been the winning deal signed sealed and delivered give her the prize cancel the rest of the show thank you for playing the game Scotty and Lauren your services are no longer need! Ladies and gentlemen your New American idol Haley Reinhardt!!!!.....seriously Scotty, Lauren really, wipe that confused dumb founded look off your faces and go hone.

  • One of the best performance of the year

  • one word Pip. From the voice

  • @tma12360 please go back to voice, we don't need to hear voice thing in here thanks bye.

  • @tma12360 lol I'm sorry sir but pip is a nobody. What a copy cut. And yes, I noticed how pip was so happy singing the song when the song was about a story of family suffering! No comparison. I rest my case! k BYE!

  • BEST PERFORMANCE EVER ON IDOL! SCOTTY WILL NEVER SING LIKE THIS!

  • I want her voice and her hair

  • @MrsJasper1 no you can't if you got it we lost Haley haha.

  • @MrsJasper1 Men take your sentence and use only the first three words.

    2011 was a great season with great singers: Haley, Casey, Pia, James ...

  • i love her version of this song soooooo much ~ so much better then anyone ive ever heard.. she is a beautiful girl

  • 2:00-2:02 Haley Orgasm.

  • muito bom! Amazing ^.^

  • GOOSEBUMPS.

  • Still watching this beautiful girls videos,can't seem to get enough of her!

  • still cant believe scotty won over her. shocking. do we really need another country singer? 

  • @Creeaura was the cinderella story with scotty , we cant forget is a tv show you know, give to the people they wanna see

    anyway for me the idol was and is haley

    march 1st her premier single

  • @kbrod90210 Her single come out at March 20....

  • @Creeaura it's shocking he won over anybody that season XD especially casey, haley, and james, and pia

  • why the fuck didn't she win???

  • @eyeslipsandface She did, Her destiny is the Stars she is going to the top!!!!

  • ditto she delivers it a way no one else has!!!

  • I saw pip sing this song on the voice! Their both really good!

  • You know shits bout to go down the moment she opened her mouth!

  • her voice is like glass....perfect

  • Absolute awesomeness!!!

  • Never heard this song till Pip performed in on the Voice- he totally blew me away. Haley had the best song choice hands down! I think she didn't use it as well as she could have if she performed it as an amazing powerhouse vocal. The soul r&b thing works with almost anything when done right but this had the potential to show off her vocals.

  • American idol robbed her from the title

    Haley you're the best of that season

    Lv

  • Oh my god this is amazing! The beginning gave me chills..

  • EXCELENTEEEEEEEEEEEE......ERA MI FAVORITA LASTIMA QUE NO GANO.

  • she shoulda won.. love scotty but she won in my heart

  • Found it: /watch?v=bletG_4cxR8

    WOW!  Definitely recommend that you listen.

  • Someone posted a link to video of Haley singing Wild Horses with Slash and Kennedy, and now I can't find the comment. Thought it was here!

  • @HalienNation1 it is on the EJ 's Banny n jets video go check it out.

  • @HalienNation1 If your want to see them sing on the video I'm waiting too, They sung awesome on the M Ali 70 b/day at LV few day ago.The note I said from EJ video was wrong hope you forgive me ,if you find out please me know.Thanks.

  • @fung2011ny No problem -- thanks! Did you locate the video yet? If not, then search youtube for: mjsbigblog haley-ali. That should do it, but let me know if you have trouble. It is a beautiful rendition of Wild Horses!

  • @HalienNation1 Thanks you I got there and watch many time it's awesome thanks again that why we are halien.

  • @fung2011ny by the way her single come out at March 20.

  • One of the best performances in Idol history.

    (Also, her hair and make up look really nice.)

  • Pip defiantly based his performance off haley's arrangement here and on tour, which was smart cuz its beautiful. Just too bad he couldn't deliver as good as haley. I think he did a good job...it's just no where near Haley performance.

  • @15hoski soo truee well at least we gotta give him props 4 being a halien

  • So much better than Pip. :DD LOVE.

  • Again. this will hit 1M for the 3rd time.

  • So...... Sexy...

  • I love haley but pip rock it!

  • @LuceroD9 you like rock it good for you thanks you love Haley.

  • This was my favorite she done! She is an amazing singer! ONE OF A KIND

  • ok, so why is everyone saying that Pip copied her version??! They both sang this DIFFERENTLY and "uniquely". I bet most of you saying this haven't even heard the ORIGINAL version. So hush! And BTW Pip's version was better. js.

    bring on the hate.

  • @IwasDiana No need to hate any body you like PIP better OK good for you thanks come by here, Haley fan please go to the 104.3MYFM to see and hear Haley perform this song again a little different. Haley fan will like it.

  • @fung2011ny Let's get one thing clear. NO ONE'S hatingg (but you). If you read carefully, you'll see that i didn't say anything NEGATIVE about Haley, in fact she was one of my favorite contestants that season. So get that straight. Anyone can see/hear she has talent. I said on this PARTICULAR SONG, i preferred Pips. So chill.

  • @IwasDiana It's great that Pip has many fans like you and all those who came here to trumpet him. Your attention and energy is bettter served supporting him at his videos, the Voice show. etc. Haley has raised the ante again and she has shown the world that SHE now OWNS this song. All your teenaged, hormone-induced adulation and clamor for that Justin-Bieber copy and wishful thinking will not change that. Go support Pip at his videos, he REALLY needs it!!

  • @realfinnatic yes love what you said she OWNS this song.

  • @realfinnatic I can support anybody i WANT on ANY video. Who are you to tell me otherwise? Haley is probably one of the most talented contestants on american idol. Did i doubt that fact? no. Your statement is an opinion. Haley killed this song, BUT so did Pip! I just PREFER his version more. Ok?. And who said anything about justin bieber?? Or an obsession for that matter. Why would you compare the two. You don't know much about Pip, &neither do i. Accept that ppl will have their own opinions.thx

  • @IwasDiana This is my OPINION: It's great that Pip has many fans like you and all those who came here to trumpet him. Your attention and energy is bettter served supporting him at his videos, the Voice show. etc. Haley has raised the ante again and she has shown the world that SHE now OWNS this song. All your teenaged, hormone-induced adulation and clamor for that Justin-Bieber copy and wishful thinking will not change that. Go support Pip at his videos, he REALLY needs it!!. Thanks : )

  • @IwasDiana I'm just curious how you prefer his version better when he's singing HALEY'S VERSION? Hmm...very curious indeed.

  • The thing is this Pip guy copied Haley's version

    I guess copying is the best form of flattery

  • Check out a live version of Haley's new single "Free" on the 104.3 MYFM New Music Night Youtube channel. There's also an acoustic version of HOTRS. The video quality is excellent.

  • They should have cancelled the show right there and awarded her first place for this performance alone and told everyone else to go home. This was more than a show-stopper. Why this girl is not already ultra famous is beyond me. She's a genuine once-in-a-lifetime icon.

  • @xlucim agreed :o)

  • Forget THE ANIMALS, SIOBHAN, PIP OR WHOEVER. There is only ONE version that can beat this and it's Haley's latest (and possibly the best) rendition of HOTRS: 104.3 MYFM New Music Night - Haley Reinhart "House of the Rising Sun Cover".

    Be warned - YOU WILL BE BLOWN AWAY!!

  • PIP'S VERSION IS MUCH BETTER. SUPPORT PIP AND TEAM ADAM ALL THE WAY!!!

  • @lymle1orfatihahmk Totally :D Pip :D Team Adam :D

  • @lymle1orfatihahmk this statement is invalid beacuse his performance was based on her version of the song anyway

  • Hear Haley's new single!!

    104.3 MYFM New Music Night - Haley Reinhart "Free"

    Copy the line above and paste into the You-tube search box! You wont be sorry!!

    I'm still Hooked!!

  • My GOD! Shut your traps you trolls, this sounds nothing like Pip's audition. Haley might have been the best voice of that season but her stage prensence sucks.

    Two different voices, two different styles. Personally I liked Pip's better because 1) I'm a girl and 2) He has a cool name and 3) I'm a girl.

  • @Iamonlymeee It appears that you, my dear, are the troll you are referring to. If you would like to express your teenage girl admiration for Pip, then you should do it on his page. Most of Haley's fans are doubtfully even aware of who Pip is, and that name has sparked ZERO attention or discussion here, so we are not the ones trolling. Hopefully your favorite will win the Voice, but for now, go listen to your Pip squeak somewhere else... (Pip - a mouse name; the least masculine name ever?)

  • SEXY

  • 2:20 chills everytime.

  • @TheRDM20 curious,I clicked 2:20 and I got chills instantly..............

  • Wait, is Haley's album coming out next month or is it just a single coming out?

  • @MorganGayle8 Its a single next month, and the album in May!

  • I can't wait for her album to come out next month. :3

  • Into season 11, and I still have Haley fever!!

  • @Lilphil3920 Well you should see a doctor right away cuz it seems that you're deaf...

  • instant goosebumps O.o

  • You know this is a good performance when you realize that you're so enthralled that you've nearly stopped breathing. I had to remind myself to inhale while watching this.

    It's also a great performance when it makes you want to put down your laptop and give a standing ovation, even though this was taped months ago and you're alone in your living room so there's no way she'll possibly hear your applause. Yet you can't stop clapping b/c it was that good!

  • @ariesunique yes you have to see her perform this song at 104.3myfm with a little different. she perform live.

  • You want to know why..just watch the(earth song video with 4:59 min) they put her down so much it ticks off steven tyler..but i think MJ would have lovsd her version of his song!!

  • If you want to know why everyone says that..watch the( earth song video) all the way to the end where they put down her singing so much it ticks off steven tyler...I mean come on MJ would have loved her version!!

  • idk y everyone says randy and jlo are against haley they never did anything

  • I so miss watching and listening to new performances of Haley. It is painful waiting for her to perform something new again.

  • @dajohn12345

    Search Twitter or HaleyFans for something new that was performed tonight. It is slow, bluesy and accompanied only by a piano.

  • Her voice gives me an eargasm all the time

  • Just found this in my favorites folder and what a treat to re-discover. This was, I think, my favorite performance from all of last season, just amazing then, and now.

  • @beast1022 Check your inbox for info on the little misfit who wrote the nasty poem about this song and Haley.

  • @realfinnatic @Thespringishere Havnt yet read the comment by this ritchie2225 character... been dammed busy w/inventory job... thought I'd check out Haleys vids B4 I gadda work 2nite... when I get bac l8ter ppl I'm gonna check out this character... wonder IF it's worth it hmmm ? good to c some of our regulars like Me r still hangin in there 4 Haley... whens her CD comin grrrr I WANT IT PRONTO dam gadda go arrrrghh

  • @beast1022 Her c/d come out on May and single at March.

  • @ritchie2225 I did not go to your post you little misfit. I am hoping your Daddy shoots your computer. I am always happy for others when they succeed in what they aspire to do. That is what a well adjusted, happy, normal person does. I have zero tolerance for people who hide behind the computer keys. Come on out in public you little creep.

  • @realfinnatic I never went to his/her site. I knew it would be something idiotic. Trolls like Ritchie are all pathetic people that use the internet for their hatred because they do not have the guts to say these things to peoples' faces. I have never had tolerance for mean spirit people. There is enough terrible things in this world that none of us can do anything about. So I have a real problem with out and out nastiness. All Haley wants to do is sing and give joy to the world.

  • I didn't watch this season but reviewing the videos afterwards, Haley is the obvious winner, at least she would have been in my country. Come on America, Daughtry, Adam and now Haley...

  • @PeterV1009 Your are right, Haley should have won, but she is happy with 3rd because she is not tied to an Idol contract, and we can all support her career by subscribing to her channel: HaleyReinhartVEVO, and can buy her single FREE (in March) and album (in May).

  • i love her. :)

  • Ugghh, stop mentioning scotty or pia. They fucking suck, they can't sing or perform like this, not even remotely close. The world will come to sense once again when Haley releases her single and then her album. The real music will win. Really there, none of those two other idol singers have anything on Haley musically or quality wise.

  • And it's running to 1M again and again....

  • who won that season?

  • What the heck? she didn't win? that was amazing... i guess that's why american idol sucks

  • Wait, who won? Didn't she win?

  • @ChristineHaha089 Scotty won, but Haley should have won by a land slide

  • @SweenyTodd98 American Idol has a HUGE 12 year old girl following, the first half of the season is good, but best to tune out at that point.

  • @Gagafan26 - Thank you for the information!

  • wowwwww. what an amazing and unique voice. she is super talented and beautiful.

  • it's you who vote for these contestants. Ur favs didnt win cuz u didnt REALLY vote for her!! Why blamed for the show? If you had really voted for her, maybe she'd have won!! Be fair people!

  • @TheFanoFan I voted for her every week thank you very much. It's not my fault that there are so many little girls liking Scotty's face

  • those 80 ppl must all be stephanos...

  • Jordin sparks was the last winner to actually amount to any memerable mucic career, OVER HALF A DECADE AGO!!! this is a dead show officialy. the tenth season was the shows peak in talent and diversity, and the top two end up being the flattest, least unique of them all. ahahaha why i don't watch it anymore, tweenage girls, enjoy voting for the cute guys, we all know you can't even afford their music. (lee,kris,scotty,ect.)

  • Haley won this competition but the voting system did not produce the correct result. No more AI for me :(

  • this is why i stopped watching this show; the best dont win.

  • @0Lloyddusktuner0 Uhm I think the third position maybe the best for her. If she went second or first she will belung to American Idol for like 2 years

  • @0Lloyddusktuner0 haley really does deserved to win. most talented finalist of season 10. i was kinda looking for another haley from the new batch, can't find any.

  • Haley is the most hated on person on American idol she does great every time she opens her mouth

  • dayuuum.

  • @ If you reimember we lost so many of her videos and have had to start practically over. Those videos would all be around a million now, had that not happen. Oh yes, that video with Irvin Mayfield is a classic. There is talk that she could join him in October at Carnegie Hall. I would love to see that. Lord, have mercy, I so want her single "Free" to be a hit.

  • @TheSpringishere I hope it's true so I can buy the ticket...

  • THIS VERSION IS SO MUCH BETTER THAN PIP's FROM THE VOICE....

  • i love haley<3 but i love her live! her voice is sooo amazing, it's not that same when they record it and change it :/

  • Oh brother!!!! Here we go again.

  • @TheSpringishere does youtube offer side notes like video views were reset to zero after the intial 500k views......i loved loved loved when she did God bless the child with Ivin Mayfield....now thats art

  • @TheSpringishere i just watched HALEY House of the rising sun NYUCK NYUCK nyuck

  • o shitttttttttttttttttt

  • Now how many people can sing acapella nowadays and sound THIS GOOD??! GO HAILEY!!! :)

  • FREEEEEEEEEEEEEE sorry had to express that. But seriously Is it March yet? I'm so ready to hear Free already!

  • @frenziedmalady Siobhan's voice is amazing. Haley tries to be like a bear and growls. The growling annoys me. I can tolerate some in one song. But not growling the whole song out.

  • @eric10375 You are entitled to your opinion of course; but, I can't stand Siobhan's screaming.

  • @ everybody, I never liked Hayley. Never will. I'm glad she didn't win. I actually think Pia should have won. SHE was the best of the season.

  • @eric10375 I am sorry... Did anyone ask? NO!Because we could care less what you think. People are here to listen to Haley and would rather you not be a troll.

  • @eric10375 you should go back to Pia's place, this is Haley place. Bye...

  • @eric10375 @ you: GROW A PAIR

  • @eric10375 well Haley and Pia should have been in the final....any other match up Not including both was Bogus and teeny bopper induced

  • Best. Song. Ever.

  • Haliens, Pip a guy from the voice ripped Haley off. He sang the same rendition. Unacceptable! Haley's performance is still the best.

  • @frenziedmalady Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery! (I didn't see it though)

  • chills...chills..chills..!!!

  • giving her credit for being very cute haha but scotty blows her out of the water.

  • @bigmatt72sreyns lol in your opinion! Haley's fart would sound 100x better than Scotty's voice. Sorry, true story!

  • <333

    

  • Ummmm.... Siobhan Magnus did this EXACT arrangement season 9. Why didn't anybody point this out? Siobhan is amazing and puts this version to shame!!!! GO check out Siobhan's version.