*sniff sniff* very beautifully tragic...my spirits were lifted for a moment when i thought the papa actually came home...wahhhh...karina you did wonderful, and so did the rest that worked on it :D
Really beautiful Karina ! Very good editing, acting and animation. The scotch tapes on the windows reminded me of the wartime in Teheran. :( . I don't talk about the scenario which is really moving. In terms of animation I really appreciated the snowflakes invading the house in the end. Bravo !!! Arash (Gobelins)
Thank you for your great words 8))) It makes me very happy to see people's comments and debates, I like when stories make audience think and try to figure out different ways the plot went 8))) Thank you guys!
Saw this in a festival two days ago. It's amazing. The first comments made me smile, because my mom and me had the same debate about whether the boy dreamed of the family being reunited before he died, or if he died and they were reunited in the afterlife. To me, a dream makes more sense chronologically: dream comes first, then he dies (scarf falls to the ground). Fits better with the overall piece, too (it's about the tragedies of war, not the joys of heaven). Regardless, brava Karina!
Karina Gazizova you are one of the best animators i have ever seen please tell me how much time did it take you to do this film from the studies to the very end :)
грустное кино
therinatgazizov 4 months ago
Karina, thank you very much for making and sharing such a touching film.
StudioLadyBugByKids 5 months ago
Thank you Yann 8))) you made me very happy 8))) kisses
karinagaz 6 months ago
*sniff sniff* very beautifully tragic...my spirits were lifted for a moment when i thought the papa actually came home...wahhhh...karina you did wonderful, and so did the rest that worked on it :D
weiyann 6 months ago
Thank you Arash, i'm glad you liked it 8)))
karinagaz 6 months ago
Really beautiful Karina ! Very good editing, acting and animation. The scotch tapes on the windows reminded me of the wartime in Teheran. :( . I don't talk about the scenario which is really moving. In terms of animation I really appreciated the snowflakes invading the house in the end. Bravo !!! Arash (Gobelins)
mljah 6 months ago
thanks Joe!!!
karinagaz 6 months ago
Great work dude! Very thought provoking film!
truendymion 6 months ago
Thank you for your great words 8))) It makes me very happy to see people's comments and debates, I like when stories make audience think and try to figure out different ways the plot went 8))) Thank you guys!
karinagaz 7 months ago
Saw this in a festival two days ago. It's amazing. The first comments made me smile, because my mom and me had the same debate about whether the boy dreamed of the family being reunited before he died, or if he died and they were reunited in the afterlife. To me, a dream makes more sense chronologically: dream comes first, then he dies (scarf falls to the ground). Fits better with the overall piece, too (it's about the tragedies of war, not the joys of heaven). Regardless, brava Karina!
jedm81 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is it world war I
Tigrebb 7 months ago
thank you 8)
karinagaz 8 months ago
Very good :)
lRedWingl 8 months ago
it took me about 2 years 8))) thank you for your great word!
karinagaz 8 months ago
Karina Gazizova you are one of the best animators i have ever seen please tell me how much time did it take you to do this film from the studies to the very end :)
fnongamela 9 months ago
they were reunited in after life... 8)
xscarlet07x 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
karinagaz.blogspot.com
xscarlet07x 10 months ago
they did all die 8))) I know, Karina
xscarlet07x 10 months ago
@xscarlet07x yeah me too :)
mashalovesyou 10 months ago
Such a sad story :'(
I'm just glad they were reunited in the end. Great animation!
MsAnimeLover18 10 months ago
@MsAnimeLover18 they wern't... it was a dream of his.
mashalovesyou 10 months ago
@mashalovesyou I thought they all died.
MsAnimeLover18 10 months ago
@MsAnimeLover18
oh i thought you meant like they were reunited when the dad came back home.
yeah, they died
mashalovesyou 10 months ago
@mashalovesyou lol sorry, I should have explained myself.
MsAnimeLover18 10 months ago