Adam Lambert Starlight American Idol Season 8 San Jose

[5h401]

i think he did quite well ! ...even though no one can do better than matt ;)

[Cexar123321]

Terrible, esta canción fue destruída!!! o.o

Es buen cantante Adam, pero Matt es un genio.

Muse es el mejor grupo! : )

[MetalLee00]

@Cexar123321 Es como querer crear el universo de nuevo, dos como el primero nunca habrá.

[LewisTee08]

Why complain? its the only muse song ive ever heard on a show like this

[joojooflop122]

i think the guy has an awesome voice i mean iv seen worse his version of Soaked i really liked

but i still just dont like the dude

[globin3]

@joojooflop122 how could anyone "don't like the dude"? I mean, why? seriously? This guy is pbbly the nicest, more generous singer out there.. I don't get it. He's funny, nice, has stage presence like no one.. Sad that you don't think so..

[MICHAELB0LT0N]

wow the falsetto sounds terrible. way to ruin a great song

[m3ly1992]

I think he sounds good for a live performance.... unless you've done it you wouldent know how hard it is to do a live performance... no offence to anyone it has been my experience

[Nickmorama]

SO SO GAY!

[2039marl]

An incredible performance - it's live and with an amateur recording it - and people here compare it with one of Muse with professional recording? Ridiculous. Like to hear the two sing it side by side live and see who sounds better. Don't think Matt would come out best in that performance.

[YOmama30255]

@2039marl And that my friend is a load of bullshit. It does not matter if its a amateur recording it it sound bad... it sound bad. 

[2039marl]

@YOmama30255 I heard him sing it live in Washington, D.C., in 2009 on the American Idol Tour - absolutely incredible. Blew Matt away.

[YOmama30255]

@2039marl Your opinion. Adams voice is just not for my taste i guess, too... screechy.

[YOmama30255]

@2039marl MUSE's version feels more lush, this version makes me feel like ive been cut with a rusty ass blade.

[2039marl]

@YOmama30255 I suggest you wait till you've heard him live - incredible. (Or even try a better audio youtube - there are dozens of them.)

[2039marl]

Lambert rules.

[reniisgod]

Fucking terrible

[EeroVT]

Do not EVER try to sing like matt! Aww. He sounds like woman xD

[LilyTheAnnoyance]

Oh geez! I'm sorry Adam, I've been searching the Internet for you singing a Muse song (preferably one with some good screams in it, such as Micro Cuts: /watch?v=MdOHxh9-1Yo you can't tell me Adam cuts wouldn't be epic), but this is a fail...I'm sorry...try again....

[LilyTheAnnoyance]

He needs to sing Micro Cuts or Showbiz :(

Thumbs up if you like cookies. :D

[Wiru77]

GAY!

[jasmintee27]

Ouch. Epic fail. Trololol.

[sonjaspaan]

@MsSharon1031, so are you going to send everyone who disagrees with you a messages that they are the dumbest person on earth? You even stated it as a fact and not as an opinion! Now thats what I call dumb,! get over the fact that some people dont 'agree with you, it will happen a lot more often in your life, maybe you should prepare for that!

[oObrotkarstenOo]

is he gay?

[Yay248]

This isn't his song, but it's still great, I think.

[BangForBucks]

I was here and this is how I found out about Muse. Both are great

[Xch40zX]

lambert ruined a masterpiece!!!!

[dragoninja000]

Bellamy > Lambert

Bellamy is God

[Spedo09]

@MsSharon1031 actually it was written by Matt but not in time to put it on Muse's new album 'The Resistance' when someone from warner *suggested* Matt give it to Adam to let him put it on his album that hadn't yet been released. I mean.. believe what you want though, Matt would never belittle himself by saying someone who has barely had a career in music for a year (at the time) can out-perform him on his own song.

[m1r1t1n1]

@Spedo09 Well erh... Starlight is on the Muse record called Black holes and revelations. Which was released prior to The Resistance. So quite possitive that Muse released even before Adam had a chance to release an album of his own. Whether or not it is on his album I don't know.

[Spedo09]

@m1r1t1n1 what's your point? I'm talking about the unreleased MUSE song 'Soaked' that MUSE ever so kindly allowed Adam to sing b/c their album had already been produced and Not because they think Adam can out perform Matt, don't bother unless you read all.

[ninjaness1992]

he sings like an angel n_n but starlight is way better when matt sings it :D

[Hellblazer344]

wow we both have the same taste in music

[daydreaminmylif]

Are you kidding? No one comes even close to Adam Lambert's cover of this.

[Bottleofsunshine13]

adam is actually quite good... Just not at this song. His voice is too dramatic for it.

[vipsu95]

My opinion: This is an terrible failure. I LOVE Muse and I respect Adam but this is just wrong. Adam shouldn't choose songs to cover that just don't fit to him. He can leave awesomeness to Muse. Adam, you ruined this song -.-

(Sorry for my bad english) :3

[otany83]

some people should stick to what they do best and not mess around with great songs for which their voices are not at all suited. This is the most important thing an artist should remember - find their strongest point and work only on that...

[ezgi5118]

it's not Adam's fault.. I think Muse's music is too good to be covered; after hearing them from Matt's epic voice, no one sounds good.

[AlphonseAdv]

@ezgi5118 THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!11111111111111­1111111111111111oneoneoneoneon­e

[AlphaMUSER]

this is just wrong

[LiveAndDieWithMusic]

No offense towards Adam Lambert, but yeah, he did killed Starlight. His voice simply doesn't suit it. And no, i'm not an Adam hater, but simply a Muse lover (:

[Bullen150]

@LiveAndDieWithMusic he reaped it first. :(

[b4nnz]

omfg stop this shit.

adam lambert will never be as good as bellamy.

This sounds horrible.

[Tromben120]

If Matt Bellamy were dead, he'd be rolling over in his grave. Honestly though, Muse has to be the original. Or else it isn't Muse. To put it delicately, it's crap.

[prittyh8machine]

@Tromben120 don't say such morbid things. no muser wants to think of matt ever dying. D:

anyway, about the video... this cover is okay, but i agree with another commenter, adam's voice is too dramatic for this song.

[undericesinger]

Wow, she was being a jerk asking if I was a music expert. I was saying a diff take would be neat. SORRY for not commenting on the video. I think Adam is talented I just was not a fan of the cover.

[MsSharon1031]

So many of Matt's fans have so much free time to scan the YT site just to find a Muse song that was written for Adam by Matt or a cover by Adam. Are Matt's fans this mentally ill. Do they sit in the dark basements 24/7 hating on Adam to make Matt seem better to them. What sick people in this world.

[shell150675]

@MsSharon1031 lmao @ this comment. Sweetheart, you're the one who is trolling YouTube replying to everyones comments because they dare say someone has sung something badly. Deal with it, this is not a good version.

[MsSharon1031]

@XschwabX Why are u even listening to it and what brought you here? Oh yes ur following Adam from video to video becaue you hate him. Sicko

[lucytheweepingangel]

@MsSharon1031 Btw stop jumping down people's throat's, they are entitled to an opinion, afterall where would the world be without anyone's opinions.

[MsSharon1031]

It's amazing all of the haters that follow Adam. Why would a Muse fan even bother spending hours hating on another singer. Get a life people.

[LenandRinlove113]

yay, where Iwas born! <3

I like it x3

[TheLambertFan123]

I don't get why people have to compare. Grow up. Adam isn't forcing you to like his version. His fans like it, so get over it. Muse is amazing. Just chill.

[Reneesme109]

Matthew Bellamy sing a lot better!!!!!! ♥♥♥MUSE♥♥♥



[MsSharon1031]

@Reneesme109 First of all your grammer is terrible. If u don't like it don't listen

[undericesinger]

grammar* I believe your grammar is terrible.

[yngv1]

This ain't such a bad cover! :D It's different from the original, but I guess that's what a cover is meant to be. And it ain't bad different, rather interesting/good different. :)

[strutlady]

@recklessythinking

 I totaly agree with you !!

[allriseblue]

i knew it would go wrong as soon as he said the name Muse (he pronounced it like muuzzzeeeeeee)

[clutzyshell]

Matt Bellamy does NOT approve. Douche... he was wrong to even try to cover a Muse song, but to disgrace by making it into a crap Broadway song UGH lol

[MsSharon1031]

@clutzyshell Oh boy does your user name fit you "clutzy" perfect I guess your brain malfunctions too. Potty mouth you are.

[recklessythinking]

Dear People. If You Hate It. Please Don't Comment. Adam Isn't Paying You To Like Him. Just Leave Him Be. If He Wanted To Cover The Song Let Him Cover It. I Think It's Awesome. And I Don't Give A Fuck About What You Think.

[MrRage2112]

Someone should sue this guy for making this song sound so bad. He thinks he's in a movie or some shit. Muse is awesome!

[MsSharon1031]

@MrRage2112 If you don't like it just go away and listen to Matt's version. Noone made u come here. Hater.

[XxAgAmAiVexX]

that damn bitch!!! stupid Adam Lambert......he ruined a really good song.....oh and he is gay....

no one can sing Starlight as Matt Bellamy :)

<3 MUSE!!!

[MsSharon1031]

@XxAgAmAiVexX First of all men arent' bitches like you. What has sexual orientation to do with singiong. I never would have believed that Matt has so many sicko fans. I guess it says something about him.

[BigRedRRP]

Let a queer from american idol fuck up a wonderful MUSE song..... go fuck something else up fag......

[SophomoricHumor]

@BigRedRRP too far man. i dont like his version at all, and he grosses me out with his whole pop star attitude, but there is no appropriate time to call someone a fag or queer in a negative way.

[MsSharon1031]

@SophomoricHumor U really have no idea what you saying it just shows your ignorance abt Adam's background. He is classically trained singer and has performed all over the world. He's not a pop singer unless you call singing what's popular "pop." Btw so is Matt's music. Do some research b4 u comment.

[SophomoricHumor]

@MsSharon1031 See, I would take your comment seriously but your spelling, or lack there of, completely voids your point. Terribly sorry I offended you.

[lunatsuoO]

holy shit

[Georgikinz]

err.

wtf. I hate this guy, always have, and he just ruined an epic song.

Its so hard to cover a Muse song because theyre so legendary and so unique.

[MsSharon1031]

@Georgikinz U hate this guy you always have? How long have u known him? I didn't know you knew him personally. But to say u hate him w/o knowing him is more than sick it's stupid. Adam can outsing anyone anyway anytime. Deal with it.

[Georgikinz]

@MsSharon1031 hahah okay then. Calm yo farm.

[shell150675]

I love Adam to bits... but this is terrible. It's almost impossible to do a good cover a Muse song as they are so unique to the bands own style.

[MsSharon1031]

@shell150675 U are a liar. You don't love Adam to bits or you wouldn't say it's terrible. It's the aoustics in the venue dumby.

[shell150675]

@MsSharon1031 lmao, are you kidding me with your pathetic comments to people? Do not go around calling people liars when you don't know them. We're all entitiled to our opinions, if you don't like them, too bad. There is no need for your illiterate & childish attempts at insults.

[JoaoPedroo25]

Muse is so much better ;o

[PetterMyhr]

this cover made my brother kill him self. no shit.

[McFLYVidzFan]

FU !! ADAM LAMBERT U MESSED UP

[dreamsihateyou]

He's making this song so gay. Look at that hand moving. ew

[deepinthought23]

this is f-ing disgusting

[Hyperguy2000]

Good god...........fuking awful

[iluvgeorgeh]

oh whats that i hear? its just the faint screaming of terror coming from muse when they heard this

[SORSELR]

not even close muse.

[kyu300]

... #FAIL

[fuder11]

x_x

[steverzilly]

id sure like to rip out his still beating heart for this massacre

[SophomoricHumor]

he just likes it because its high.

[JogreRush]

Firstly, learn the song properly, then fire the damn keyboardist.

[MsSharon1031]

@JogreRush Go on Matt's site and leave Adam alone.

[JogreRush]

@MsSharon1031 Pitch all over the place, wrong melody, timing issues (need i go on?) that means more practice required...... and if the keyboardist doesn't learn the right bit, he should be fired after that.... after all, poor performances give even cover artists A BAD REP. its called constructive criticism, i didn't even say anything about Mr Bellamy.

[obsculum]

hell no, dont try this at home

[GLPCHB1960]

Try singing a Hanna Montana song that might work a little better for you, Adam. 

[MsSharon1031]

@GLPCHB1960 Hater or just jealous moron

[GLPCHB1960]

@MsSharon1031 Im not jealous or a hater. There is just no excuse for butchering a good song.

[anastasiavanite]

@GLPCHB1960 What is wrong with you?

Muse looks stupid compared to how adam sang it!

[GLPCHB1960]

@anastasiavanite Sorry to inform you that you are one of the only people on the planet that holds that opinion. So, perhaps I should be the one asking whats wrong with you.

[zugg48]

MURDER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[MsSharon1031]

@zugg48 STFU

[SophomoricHumor]

@MsSharon1031 You've gotta stop bashing people for having different opinions than you.

[lolpmsl1]

U certainly puffed it up love!!!

[rmtdrums]

WTF!! This so rough. If your gonna cover a song you better deliver but this shocking. Why do something by a band (muse) that are far superior than you Adam? Real poor karaoke. His pitching is all over the place too, ouch.

[MsSharon1031]

@rmtdrums You are a hater.

[rmtdrums]

@MsSharon1031 OMG, We have a first class stalker here!! Seriously, you need help. This is what happens if you listen to Adam Lambert and Justin Bieber all the time. Please don't enter into a debate about music when you clearly haven't got a clue. He murders this song-FACT. Just look at all the negative comments on here. Let me know where you live so I can drive you to the nearest bridge so you can jump off it. That's where your stalking is taking you my dear. Sad, So Sad.

[vicedgaralvarez]

wtf?????

who's this guy???

sucks

[zombieland555]

When he sings he sounds like he's been kicked in the balls really really hard like a chuck Norris roundhouse

[savy99]

I think Adam sing's this song better then muse doe's

[StingPT]

ladies and gentleman the new Bill Kaulitz

[nichonr95]

@MsSharon1031 hahahahaha youre funny. btw you cant blame that lambert missed som e tones because of the accoustic. ;) :P well well

[Spedo09]

what a wana-be... First Feeling Good (I know this is not an original Muse song), then Starlight... Now he's getting Matt Bellamy to write songs for him (Soaked, which is clearly a Matt song)... come up with your own crap

[MsSharon1031]

@Spedo09 Matt personally gave Soaked to Adam because he thought Adam could sing it better. It was a demo.

[okloipon]

i was prepared to say something like "ok,he is fine too..." but. . . it hurts!this cover actually physically hurts!!!

[Iibuli]

Is it just me or is he making the song a bit porny? xDD

No one can do it better than Muse! <3

[ShaNyEvaNs]

It's terrible... O_O Adam's voice is fine, but this song does not suits it... like screaming :O MUSE RULEZ

[LuLu4Twilight]

Love it!!!!!

I like this guy, he's singing Muse..Yeah \m/

[araliciousfamous]

matt's voice is unique so this song is meant for MATT ONLY! I love adam lambert but man he spoiled everything!

[Manneilbonoso]

Did he have a rat rolling over in his throat? what a shame,no feelings in that.

[iamxray1256]

why the FUCK would he do this. Only Matt Ballamy can pull this off EVER. Period.... >.>

[MsSharon1031]

@iamxray1256 Go the hell away if you don't like Adam's version hater. Oh stop using profanity. You are blocked.

[questrelm]

The Muse version is amazing. But I can't help favoring Adam's more, I think it's amazing.

[thephantomsflutist]

Ugh. Just NO! Adam Lambert can NEVER live up Matt Bellamy's standards. He sounds like a woman... Oh my God... this is terrible!!

[AngieEnz84]

That was...interesting... It sounded like...Broadway pop...or something. Could've done without the exaggerated hand gestures, too.

The Muse version is definitely a trillion times better. But it's cool that Adam's a fan of the band regardless. Can't fault him for having good taste in bands.

[GENEZ619]

Phuck this cover

Your version suck.

[kgraham15]

if Matt Bellamy was dead, he'd roll over in his grave....god his voice is winey!!!

[presidentcharlie14]

i just wish adam wouldn't cover this song.

i'm glad he's a fan though. i mean hey, he's better than stephanie meyer.

[RoarSirRoar]

matt says this this version is hammy XD

[LoqBuster]

Homo starlight version

God, this shit sucks balls

[ShRiZzEL]

No.

[IloveMuseic68]

leave this song to Muse please :)

[bl0wy0urbrain]

some adam haters? u guys can suck balls for having a bad taste

[Jaggijughurtti]

His just fucks up the song if u have heard muse version before this one.

[SheryP96]

Hey guys stop! haha well Matts voice is WAYYY BETTER but still it was umm good..

i guess

haha I <3MattBellamy&&MUSE! soo effin much!!

[sparkish808]

I love Adam Lambert. Like.. I LEGIT love him... but I have to agree with everyone else... Only Matt should sing this song. XD

[MsSharon1031]

@sparkish808 Ur a liar you don't like Adam I know who u are. What a joke.

[sparkish808]

@MsSharon1031

Yup. I'm lying. The 80 bucks I spent on his show doesn't exist. Neither do the tickets I bought. I didn't get his autograph on my FYE album booklet. I don't have any of his songs memorized at all and I didn't watch him cannibalize every other singer on American Idol. And I certainly DO NOT have an album on photobucket dedicated to him. NOPE.

He does one song wrong in my eyes, but I don't really give a fuck. I still love him.

[lucytheweepingangel]

Hes ruined one of my favourite songs :(

[MsSharon1031]

@lucytheweepingangel Then go away from here. Why bother listening moron.

[lucytheweepingangel]

@MsSharon1031 Well excuse me for listening to it, i thought he'd be good covering a song but he's not he's just ruined the whole song.

[Alvarezie89]

Hahaha omg this Made laugh hahaha this is terrible

[ohmygoshy552]

MUSE > ADAM.

Adam, you make my ears go deaf.

[Raqualad]

RAPED THE SONG. What a fricking asshole. 'Whattaya want from me' is awesome, but this was just... bad.

[Ellyanei]

he raped that song, starlight.

[ZelenaBananaa]

retarded emo usa shit.

[Fabrunno]

Love u Adam but this song ya did so bad and I hated it

[MsSharon1031]

@Fabrunno U are a liar. You don't love Adam phony.

[rmtdrums]

@MsSharon1031 Stalker.

[ScarTissue222]

WTF?

[OfficialNickNakama]

You know you can't expect a cover to sound exactly like Matt -__- I think it's great

[shawty151994]

It's not even that his voice is horrible! It's just that he oversings it so horribly! It's obvious that he has no clue how to sing the actual song! I'm betting all he did was look up the lyrics!

[YmnBmy]

@shawty151994

You're right. People are blinded aren't they?

[shawty151994]

@YmnBmy Yes, yes they are. It's not even that he bothers me that much. He just needs to pick his songs better. When you're not careful to choose a song that works with your voice you end up destroying it and pissing a lot of people off in the process.

[sonjaspaan]

my comment dissapeared, so1 more time. This guy sings well indeed, but people should realise that Muse are where they are now not only by being very talented musicians with Matt as an excellent songwriter with a unique voice, but also by working VERY hard during years when they played in crappy venues with crappy sidejobs. They have my deepest respect for that They accomplished everything by themselves and this guy practically has his bed made for him.

[MsSharon1031]

@sonjaspaan U have to be the dumbest most ignorant person to have ever walked this earth. Adam started singing at 10 and was classically trained. Opera stars rave about his talent and wish they could do what Adam can do with his voice. He also struggle in LA since age 18 writing songs, appearing in musicals and starred in Hair in Germany. So next time do a little research before bashing him.

[sonjaspaan]

This is indeed a good singer and all, but people should realize that this guy has his bed ready made for him. Where Muse are nowdays is something they accomplished by themselves, by being very talented musicians, with Matt as an excellent songwriter with a unique voice, but also by working truly very hard for years, starting by playing in crappy venues with jobs at the side. They have my very deep respect for that.

[mike912899]

total crap, NOONE can ever do a song better then muse

[mortred009]

Muse is my favorite band so of COURSE I like their rendition better, but you have to give credit to Adam. ANYONE WITH AN EAR FOR MUSIC can tell that Adam has a much higher and probably better natural voice than Bellamy. Yes, I like Matt Bellamy's version better but Adam and his AMAZING voice did a very fine job.

[MoonInHerEyesx]

@mortred009 I was gonna post a comment but I don't now because it would have been an exact repeat of this.

[ReB161616]

@mortred009 having a higher voice is grand, but the notes this guy is hitting naturally just dont sound the same as when matt uses falsetto.. if he covered showbiz and hit the note at the end of that naturally.. id be immensely impresses. good singer. but i just doesnt have the eerie sound matt can make.. too common, to much of a pop voice

[MsSharon1031]

@ReB161616 It's the aoustics in the venue that are affecting the sound and if you understood music u would have known that.

[rmtdrums]

@MsSharon1031 Stalker.

[MsSharon1031]

@ReB161616 You just don't get it. Adam has been acclaimed as the #2 tenor in the world with a range higher than Matt, Freddie and all but one other person that ever lived. So please don't show your ignorance.

[ReB161616]

@MsSharon1031 says the person who went trolling to a comment that wasnt actually offensive, i said he's a good singer BUT, matts songs are written for falsetto, it just sounds weird, so dont lecture me on music, adam doesnt actually hav as high a range as matt, with falsetto matt can reach G#5

[rmtdrums]

@MsSharon1031 Stalker.

[ROCKSAIAS]

eso si es mierda

[alecgwapo]

gay version

[temptingsweety]

how can people even think that muse is better then adam. Adam is a much better singer and sings this song way better/more beautiful