@MovieMaker484 actually you can see john playing guitar on the chorus, 1:53. And he does a quick harmony on 2:35. Although most of the time he is just standing there.
@MovieMaker484 Ok... so nobody was gonna have John jumping around and helping out when they knew Yoko would be coming to oversee these animations. So to keep the peace I guess they have John there singing harmonies he didn't sing and half heartedly hanging out with the guitar knowing that the reality wouldn't go over to well with the estates. LOL.. if it'd been me doing the animation I'd have LOVED to show McCartney noodling with the synthesizer using the slide control!!!
@KoolKorey1011 I guess a song about a murderer fits under the category of english folk song. Sort of like Steve Winwood doing John Barleycorn Must Die ... though it's uncomfortable amidst the Peace & Love mythology of John & Yoko and The later Beatles. What's with George playing the fender six string bass though? Is he on this and Golden Slumbers?
@John37816 that's true also in the dreamscape of Here comes the sun, John isn't supposed to be there, or Back in the USSR, where Ringo din't play the drums, but I think it could be worst if they took out some beatle in a dreamscape
@SgtLennonRocker@John37816 Harmonix mainly crafted The Beatles: Rock Band as a tribute to them, as well as a fictionalized version which is why all four members are always there even if in actuality they weren't; they made it as if they never had their troubles.
I agree with the people that say this game is not realistic. According to The Beatles, John hated Maxwell's Silver Hammer. So he had to be moved to the audio studio. So when they recorded this song John wasn't there. He was in the room. Yet in the game, here he is. And if you wonder why Paul laughs when he says "writing 50 times..", guess who was showing his ass from the audioroom when Paul said "behind". XD Well it don't matter. I don't think people want to see John's hairy ass in the scape. :P
@Pollandtheawesome Then, if George is on a regular electric guitar, John is on an acoustic, Paul is on the piano, and Ringo is on the drums... who's playing bass guitar? Ah, it's a Beatless song... anything's possible!
@TheRockWings Yeah they show George playing guitar during the chorus and then have him holding the bass during the verse. I didn't think he was playing bass on this one though.
John hated this song and did not participate in it, yet he's in the dreamscape. Minor flaw, but I like how the animators seemed to incorporate John's hatred for this song in the dreamscape, you'll notice John keeps tilting his head up and looking annoyed at 44 seconds, at 1:09, and he looks bored at 2:22, that being said I have no idea why he looks so happy at 18 seconds and at 1:57. I love this song though as well as this game.
I like Paul's Beatles songs (most of them anyway), but what a terrible song to follow "Something". Almost as bad as "Martha My Dear" following "Happiness is a Warm Gun".
@TheSuperGamefreak not sure this is fact, but I remember reading somewhere (could have been in the beatles anthology) that john mooned him from the booth. hahahaa. though, that may be in the anthology version, where paul really starts laughing, not just a little chuckle.
@USERNAMEESES it's actually a Fender VI six string bass that George is holding.. hey I didn't know George played bass on this one and I'm surprised that's him on Golden Slumbers and I guess Carry That Weight.
i have a beatles book with the words its realy "clang clang" in the words but they changed it (idk y they would tho) but in fact they didnot realy mess up. (paul just changed the words around)
@darkhoarse820 Yeah he does, (judging from the video around :45) and I know for a fact John hated this song so he may as well have. According to Wikipedia (who may or not be reliable in this case) says he plays the acoustic guitar on the song and George plays lead guitar and bass.
@RevolverKat Well, George hated the song, too, but he was too gracious not to play on it. After all, he was in a band and bandmates normally don't do what John did on many occasions. He always found an excuse to not play on a George song. John's initial absence had more to do with the car accident he had been in and he was busy getting healthy while the other three started recording it.
@Doorknob069 one guitar is a FENDER VI six string bass and the other is the Gibson Les Paul to show he was playing guitar on it too. Was he using the Les Paul on the whole album? What about "Rocky" the stratocaster or the rosewood tele?
Paul wrote this song as a reference to his past. He wrote a poem during his childhood that he thought was one of the best he ever wrote. And his English teacher rejected it and disliked it. So he wrote a song on it, and sort of as revenge against his teacher.
@wonderman800 means that things that are going so good can just get so fucked up out of nowhere gettign ready for a date beign all happy to spend tiem with your man then all of a sudden he beats the shit out of you with a silver hammer
@wonderman800 I'm not sure if someone already told you this, or if you found out, but it's not really about a murderous boy. Rather, it's about the ups and downs of life. Paul said so himself.
ha ha ha ha
MovieMaker484 1 week ago
George's Bass randomly changes into a Les Paul.
IanEduardoMeneses 1 month ago
@IanEduardoMeneses like a boss!!
jarredgamarra28 1 month ago
hahaha paul is laughing in 1:23
thewillrocks1 3 months ago
Comment removed
thewillrocks1 3 months ago
I see that John is in the video. He's holding an acoustic guitar. But he doesn't play it. Nor does he sing. So basically he is just standing there...
MovieMaker484 4 months ago
@MovieMaker484 actually you can see john playing guitar on the chorus, 1:53. And he does a quick harmony on 2:35. Although most of the time he is just standing there.
grossmushroom1581 3 months ago
@grossmushroom1581 Thank You
MovieMaker484 3 months ago
@MovieMaker484 Ok... so nobody was gonna have John jumping around and helping out when they knew Yoko would be coming to oversee these animations. So to keep the peace I guess they have John there singing harmonies he didn't sing and half heartedly hanging out with the guitar knowing that the reality wouldn't go over to well with the estates. LOL.. if it'd been me doing the animation I'd have LOVED to show McCartney noodling with the synthesizer using the slide control!!!
LBrilliante 1 week ago
@wonderman800 They were prob high on drugs or something
KoolKorey1011 4 months ago
Bang Bang Maxwell's silver hammer!Weird what this song is about ,Still such a GREAT SONG
KoolKorey1011 4 months ago
@KoolKorey1011 I guess a song about a murderer fits under the category of english folk song. Sort of like Steve Winwood doing John Barleycorn Must Die ... though it's uncomfortable amidst the Peace & Love mythology of John & Yoko and The later Beatles. What's with George playing the fender six string bass though? Is he on this and Golden Slumbers?
LBrilliante 1 week ago
i can never understand why the video doesn't work right whenever i do this on multiplayer
TheSuperGamefreak 4 months ago
kolkolkol~
Dearhunter43 4 months ago
ehhhhhhh Paul doesnt look to bright
arceus775 5 months ago
i LOVE Paul :D
Abram556 5 months ago
best scenes 0:55 0:56 0:57 0:58 1:01
emorockero95 6 months ago
jaja i love 0:52
wereverfan17 6 months ago
I love the Anthology version where Paul laughs! xDD
Chibimorry 7 months ago
@John37816 that's true also in the dreamscape of Here comes the sun, John isn't supposed to be there, or Back in the USSR, where Ringo din't play the drums, but I think it could be worst if they took out some beatle in a dreamscape
SgtLennonRocker 7 months ago in playlist The Beatles Rock Band Dreamscape ( Wii )
@SgtLennonRocker @John37816 Harmonix mainly crafted The Beatles: Rock Band as a tribute to them, as well as a fictionalized version which is why all four members are always there even if in actuality they weren't; they made it as if they never had their troubles.
TheOverachiever7 4 months ago
I agree with the people that say this game is not realistic. According to The Beatles, John hated Maxwell's Silver Hammer. So he had to be moved to the audio studio. So when they recorded this song John wasn't there. He was in the room. Yet in the game, here he is. And if you wonder why Paul laughs when he says "writing 50 times..", guess who was showing his ass from the audioroom when Paul said "behind". XD Well it don't matter. I don't think people want to see John's hairy ass in the scape. :P
John37816 7 months ago
i wonder, does Maxwell represent Thor?
Pollandtheawesome 9 months ago
Anyone notice how George has a bass guitar, John has an acoustic, and yet there is an electric guitar in the background?
TheRockWings 9 months ago
@TheRockWings thats actually an 6-string george has. it's actually a fender jaguar (one of my personal favs.)
Pollandtheawesome 9 months ago
@Pollandtheawesome Then, if George is on a regular electric guitar, John is on an acoustic, Paul is on the piano, and Ringo is on the drums... who's playing bass guitar? Ah, it's a Beatless song... anything's possible!
TheRockWings 9 months ago
@TheRockWings Yeah they show George playing guitar during the chorus and then have him holding the bass during the verse. I didn't think he was playing bass on this one though.
LBrilliante 1 week ago
John hated this song and did not participate in it, yet he's in the dreamscape. Minor flaw, but I like how the animators seemed to incorporate John's hatred for this song in the dreamscape, you'll notice John keeps tilting his head up and looking annoyed at 44 seconds, at 1:09, and he looks bored at 2:22, that being said I have no idea why he looks so happy at 18 seconds and at 1:57. I love this song though as well as this game.
caflagel 10 months ago
I like Paul's Beatles songs (most of them anyway), but what a terrible song to follow "Something". Almost as bad as "Martha My Dear" following "Happiness is a Warm Gun".
Logan912 1 year ago
why did paul chuckle?
TheSuperGamefreak 1 year ago
@TheSuperGamefreak not sure this is fact, but I remember reading somewhere (could have been in the beatles anthology) that john mooned him from the booth. hahahaa. though, that may be in the anthology version, where paul really starts laughing, not just a little chuckle.
dhruvluke 11 months ago
Wow.. this is song is disturbing but.. I like it ^.^
shannon7123 1 year ago
paul laugh at 1:24
craigbeavers24 1 year ago
one person needs to get hit by Maxwell's silver hammer
MarkDAretard 1 year ago
TE AMO CAMILA ARDILA I LOVE YOUUUUU
difer1999 1 year ago
i love that Paul laughs while singing this song.
finalfantasybrawl 1 year ago
mmm why george have a fender jaguar and at 1:45 he have a les paul ?
USERNAMEESES 1 year ago
@USERNAMEESES it's actually a Fender VI six string bass that George is holding.. hey I didn't know George played bass on this one and I'm surprised that's him on Golden Slumbers and I guess Carry That Weight.
LBrilliante 1 week ago
fender jaguar! yay :D
glassyzero 1 year ago
Glowing Paul!
MysticKirby64 1 year ago
why was george playin his guitar at the very begining i didnt hear it i hate when that happens
TheBobohj 1 year ago
@TheBobohj George was playing the bass in the beginning you idiot... If you watch carefully, George switches from bass to guitar during the song.
ThatEpicAsian 1 year ago
at the beginning the drum set is playing by it's own lol
IanEduardoMeneses 1 year ago
i love how in some songs George plays bass
98lakai 1 year ago
0:47
They messed up
Paul says "Bang Bang," as it says "clang clang" in the background
GuitarHeroIIIRocker 1 year ago
@GuitarHeroIIIRocker
i have a beatles book with the words its realy "clang clang" in the words but they changed it (idk y they would tho) but in fact they didnot realy mess up. (paul just changed the words around)
JamNJohnN 1 year ago
George swithes guitar through the song. thats how awesome the beatles are
glassyzero 1 year ago
Comment removed
glassyzero 1 year ago
I know the some is about a boy killing people with a hammer but is the boy a kid, or a teen?
usnlp100 1 year ago
...how is george playing bass with a regular guitar?
GarsinX 1 year ago
@GarsinX It's a 6 stringed bass.
RevolverKat 1 year ago
@RevolverKat I think George played both the Fender VI and the lead guitars, too. I believe Lennon was absent from the initial recording of this song.
darkhoarse820 1 year ago
@darkhoarse820 Yeah he does, (judging from the video around :45) and I know for a fact John hated this song so he may as well have. According to Wikipedia (who may or not be reliable in this case) says he plays the acoustic guitar on the song and George plays lead guitar and bass.
RevolverKat 1 year ago
@RevolverKat Well, George hated the song, too, but he was too gracious not to play on it. After all, he was in a band and bandmates normally don't do what John did on many occasions. He always found an excuse to not play on a George song. John's initial absence had more to do with the car accident he had been in and he was busy getting healthy while the other three started recording it.
darkhoarse820 1 year ago
Why does Harrison play with two different guitars in this song???
Doorknob069 1 year ago
@Doorknob069 one guitar is a FENDER VI six string bass and the other is the Gibson Les Paul to show he was playing guitar on it too. Was he using the Les Paul on the whole album? What about "Rocky" the stratocaster or the rosewood tele?
LBrilliante 1 week ago
I really like this sooong oh oh oh.... LOL
krismagix 1 year ago
Comment removed
krismagix 1 year ago
1:09 John's hair looks really shiny like lego hair shiny
Beaverfest101 1 year ago
paul had a beard during this period though
IamAsi94 1 year ago
Thumbs up for an angry James Paul McCartney!
trainchugger53 1 year ago 61
BANG¡¡ BANG¡¡...CLANG¡¡ CLANG¡¡ :D
jairyoung 1 year ago
Only The Beatles can write a song about a murderer and still make it up-beat hahaha this song is crazy as hell! But it's one of me favourite songs =]
RickyGervaisFreak 1 year ago
thanks for sharing
poussyledzep 1 year ago
I. WANT. THIS. GAME. SO. BAD. D:> It's not FAIR!!! jk its totally fair. I need to save mah moneh... : ( But still... :'(
Beatles7373 2 years ago
Why did the beatles write a song about someone who kills people with a hammer? Awesome song, though.
wonderman800 2 years ago 28
Paul wrote this song as a reference to his past. He wrote a poem during his childhood that he thought was one of the best he ever wrote. And his English teacher rejected it and disliked it. So he wrote a song on it, and sort of as revenge against his teacher.
Intrdmnsion 2 years ago
@Intrdmnsion where did you hear that??
kmylo4 1 year ago
@Intrdmnsion Google and Wikipedia.
Intrdmnsion 1 year ago
@wonderman800 probobly from all the cannabis they were on, lol
Eloo2u 1 year ago
@wonderman800 they wrote this when they were in their Death Metal faze.
Themightyblunghole 1 year ago
@wonderman800 Paul got dared by a friend...
tubrutolity 1 year ago
@wonderman800 paul saidahappy song about aserial killer
countryandpivot 1 year ago
@wonderman800 If that was a legit question: I'm guessing it would be a metaphor.
KingdomofConnor 1 year ago
@wonderman800 Because they were high as F.ck lol
j4k3tele 1 year ago
@wonderman800 means that things that are going so good can just get so fucked up out of nowhere gettign ready for a date beign all happy to spend tiem with your man then all of a sudden he beats the shit out of you with a silver hammer
halloweenfan92 1 year ago
@wonderman800 I'm not sure if someone already told you this, or if you found out, but it's not really about a murderous boy. Rather, it's about the ups and downs of life. Paul said so himself.
THATKIDSProductions 10 months ago
@THATKIDSProductions did you even listen to the song?
TheMrcrazy711 9 months ago
@TheMrcrazy711 Ouch.
THATKIDSProductions 9 months ago
@THATKIDSProductions sorry to sound mean, i was in a pissy mood and thought that sounded wrong
TheMrcrazy711 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@TheMrcrazy711 Nah, it's alright.
THATKIDSProductions 9 months ago
@wonderman800 For maxwell the fucking badass of m-I5 THE KILLER
Huxkysh 7 months ago
gracias for all these uploads :D
btw what do you use to record these videos?
Triple7Hack 2 years ago
It's in the video description. I use the Pinnacle Video Transfer
granmacco 2 years ago
oh cool thanks bro lol
Triple7Hack 2 years ago