Added: 5 years ago
From: 23Daves
Views: 122,009
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (178)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is the song featured on Fossil Fuel, not Black Sea.

    Still, this and No Thugs In Our House are some of my favorites for the great instrumentals.

  • @Core11953 Yes, this is the single version (a remix), not the album version from Black Sea.

  • This was what started it all for me and a lifelong love of this group.

  • To be fair to Andy P., me and the wife talk about absorption all the time, and we often enjoy an invigorating stretch over our garden fence.

  • As ripped off by Aerosmith/Run DMC for "Walk This Way" video

  • this is the cleaned up version - not the one on the album!

  • I agree with PATAGONIALOOP. What ever they said is bound to be true. That and I live in Wales!"

  • XTC 4ever greats!!!!!

  • God, how big they would have been if Andy hadn't come down with stage fright, glad i got to see them before they stopped touring

  • It's ridiculous how many non dirty words were changed for this video. It's a completely different vocal track.

  • we were so naive back in the 80s, when "abortion" and "sex position" and "retching" and "contraception" were dirty words.

  • So sad to think that when someone could challenge the social order with verve and intellect, that the BBC would edit them -- still great

  • La raja weon la rajaaaa!!!!!

  • lol, what's with the LITERAL blue hair at 2:30 with the collar? this video is pretty quirky & funny! & 5 people have no sense of humor :)

  • What a great band.

    epic song too.

  • Brilliant!!!!!!!!

  • xtc = sexy road ! gengster indonesia ! hahaha lol xD

  • good aint it, listening to XTC since about 76 i think and they just get better

  • their best track for me. best lyric. this and no thugs.

  • absorption. wtf :/

  • Well this idea pre-dates Aerosmith and Run-DMC by a good 6 years or so.

    .

    XTC, always on the leading edge.

  • One of the best dates in my life was taking my then g/f to see XTC at the Palladium in NY in 1981. They did this number. "Living through another Cuba" was surpisingly the highlight of the show IMO--it was awesome. The girl was so exictied she savaged me in the car as soon as we got in after the show. I turned her on o the real deal. XTC.

  • @RareBird0 was there, too, and remember Andy spinning during Helicopter. GREAT live band.

  • They changed the lyrics from "which sex position pleases best her old man" to "which proposition pleases..." Why?! lol

  • @LovingSeattle to get it played on UK radio. they had to change a few other lyrics, too. "abortion" -> "absorption", "contraception" -> "child prevention", "wretching" -> "stretching".

    all the while, lou reed's transvestites were giving each other blowjobs on the wild side and nobody noticed. ;]

  • @nightdriver That was bugg'in me.... here I was singing along, an all a sudden I notice they're singing the wrong lyrics!

  • I think Damon Albarn was listening to this when he wrote Tracy Jacks.

  • @gazerman65

    for sure! an online friend recommended i listen to more of them about 6 years ago because i like Blur so much (as did he). I wasn't really old enough to know of these guys in their heyday. The 1st song i heard was "The Ballad of Peter Pumpkinhead" in '92, & slowly got into them from there... but yah, i've since seen the XTC influences in some Blur songs :)

  • Hoidy-toidy folks beware!! They're on to you!

    It's about THE KIND OF LOOK THAT SAYS YOU'RE PERFECT.

  • I love them sweeping up the beer cans. Black Sea was a defining album for my teen years. We used to sing this song about a place called Drake Street in Sault Ste, Marie, Ontario, Canada. Great memories. Thanks to the Dinsmore brothers for introducing me to this song!

  • Probably the most underrated band from that era.

  • Well the neighbour slamed his car door....

  • Rodney Mayo , decendant of one of the first Irish families to establish themselves on the island of Palm Beach opened a progressive bar Downtown WPB named it after this track ....still there 34 yrs later !

  • Love the Sex Pistol poster in the quick scene...about 2:13...

    Great album and great band...brings me back to a kid of 14 listening to Black Sea.

  • this song needs its original album version lyrics, though.

  • Black Sea was the first of their albums I got before I got the rest back in the 80's, was lucky enough to get the British pressing of English Settlement a the time which was a double album with extra tracks. Great Band ! I wish bands today had this much humor, energy, talent, and songwriting ability. The music scene today is populated by the untalented unless you dig for indie stuff or check out your local scene or listen to reunion tours. Now punks sit around and play 'guitar hero'. Sigh.

  • ECTACY~

  • This song head has been stuck in my head for days. Much prefer XTC's earlier stuff than the late eighties stuff

  • Reminds me of Joe Jackson and that's not a bad thing

  • These guys had an amazing, and I'm assuming underrated, rythym section! Tight!

  • I envy anyone who has just discovered the mighty XTC, what a treat you are in for with all the back catalogue brilliance, I grew up listening to them and was never disapointed when an album came out and I ran to buy it.

  • "which sex position pleases her old man" was over the top even for Andy P, Come back to us XTC 'cause there's nothing that comes close..it's almost embarrasing

  • some of the best poetry ever written.

  • reminds me of the northside of chicago! I got almost thrown out of the improv olympic theatre well for being spontaneous! Please boycott the io on my behalf!

  • Classic stuff!

  • Hell, YEAH!!!!!!!!

  • i love singing this at school to annoy the teachers lmao

  • I think this is the clean version.

  • Never heard this version before, but I figured that they would have had to make a "sanitized" version, especially for the BBC. I couldn't imagine that "Abortion","Contraception","Se­x Position", and "Retching" would have made it onto the network that had banned "I Am the Walrus" for its "Knickers" reference. This song was awesome, though. It was a witty tribute to the falseness and hypocrisy of the pretentious upper-middle class which is still relevant today.

  • you read politics at YALE (lock) UNIVERSITY ?maybe ya should try writing some new(er) tunes...where are they know? in a country cottage in the west country...battered by high winds (flatulence?) No doubt their juicy royalties keep em afloat at a time when English OAPs survive on Heinz beans and NO toast...but MAN what bass lines...this guy has six fingers...

  • ...i don't know,...i've been around for about 48 years or so...

    .....grew up with them in the 80's...etc .. X.T.C.are more novelists,and poets, than mere pop

    artists!

  • It's the version that's on Rag and Bone Buffet, with the re-done vocals; the 'choir' backing vocals at 2.16 have been mixed higher then on the Black Sea version too.

    Fucking hell, I'm such a geek.

  • Nowt wrong with being a geek mate! I'm a nerd and proud of it. I always quote producers, lyrics etc to my mates and they look at me as if I have landed from Mars! I thought I was alone in this world!!

  • Heh heh! You are not alone!

    I too am met with the same blank stares and 'resistance', but usually wear my friends down until they willingly concede that XTC are, in fact, a genius group ;-)

  • Of course they are! I grew up with them - along with Squeeze, Blondie, Talking Heads,and many many others. So much music, so little time. And why is music SO crap these days, with a few exceptions? (I sound like an old git now!)

  • I agree with you, and I feel privileged that my musical taste was crystallised during the late 1970s/early 1980s New Wave period.

    There is some good new music coming through from young bands though, which is heartening. If you're a fan of Drums and Wires-period XTC, check out 'Photoshop Handsome' by a band called Everything Everything, here on YouTube.

    They've been compared to XTC, and I was impressed!!

  • 素敵な曲。

    it is goooooooooooooood!

  • How come XTC sold so few records while those pretentious, stuck-up, tuneless posers Duran Duran sold millions?

  • In a word: makeup.

  • @YoungPike Hey! Leave Duran out of this. They were great too. But yes, XTC deserved the same kind of success.

  • Great song, This seems to be a different edit from the album version though. Is it the same as on my copy of Rag & Bone Buffet? Oh and Sex Pistols poster at 2:14.

  • I haven't done a side by side comparison, but I'm 99% sure it's the same as R&BB.

  • Yeah, it is the same edit as on Rag & Bone Buffet.

  • Teveh, I agree with you. It really sounds like a little more effort in the last verse. Backing synth and vox helps it as well. What a great great under-appreciated song it is. Too bad the BBC, forced them to chage some lyrics but in the day I am sure some would have been offended. Thanx for the years of enjoyment XTC...

  • Why does the last verse sound better the ones before? It may be just me but vocals just sound better on the "heard the neighbours..." bit. i duno

  • Serve the Servants ?

  • Wow this song makes me crazy - it's a fuckin good tune

  • just red uncut article on andy partridge,it said that he is a uncommon genius.

  • watch 'complicated game xtc' if you like early xtc

  • It was the BBC that forced them to clean up the lyrics - or they wouldn't play the song on the radio.

    But still a damn shame...

  • Shame they had to change the original lyrics to get played on TV....damn shame..

  • I love XTC

    It's in the order!

  • is that david gregory sporting that beautiful beard?

  • im 16 and i love 80's music.

  • great song great album,the youngsters of today have no idea what good music is.i pity them cus the crap they have to listen to just does not compare or am i being a grumpy forty something?

  • I am 19 and i agree with you, the music today is absolutely terrible, to be honest i absolutely hate this indie thing at the moment. XTC kick ass, thank god i have parents who let me listen to good music.

  • glad to hear some good stuff is getting through.wot u think of the jam,buzzcocks,skids,squeeze and big country? happy listening

  • if you look hard enough there is always some good music being produced somewhere- personally i think the XTC sound is really dated, though i did enjoy seeing them live, it now sounds chugg

  • Hey truthorfibs, Im a forty somthing and I agree with you 100%. Whats nice for me is that I have a 19yo and a 13yo and they love 80s music. Only cause of me tho Im sure.Otherwise they would not have been exsposed to it. 80s was the best decade for music period. Does anyone remember Urgh! a Music war?? An HBO special released in 81 ? there was an excelant live version of this cut on there, with the original lyircs. Along with many other great 80s bands. Look for cuts from it here on youtube.

  • I am 45, cotey, and Urgh! is one of my favorite movies EVER!!!

  • I'm forty something too (but not for too much longer... and I'm not quite sure how that happened...) I appreciate that you pass the baton of incredible music to your kids - and that they're bright enough and receptive enough to appreciate lots of different kinds of wonderful music! XTC is up there with David Byrne and Bowie...

  • ah the good old days when mtv played videos

  • wall-to-wall grins upon listening to this (yet another) great tune from XTC, and more fabulous bass playing from Colin

  • I hear this, and am still gobsmacked and skull-cracked that XTC didn't become as sickeningly famous as some of their contemporaries. I hear this and I'm transported back to the clubs I lived in, hearing the local favorite band kick the living' crap out of a cover version of this song, and wishing I could go back to those days. Hi to my friends from the Harrisburg PA area who remember The Pikers, and Li'l Joe's and all the fun we had. I've been thinking of you all!

  • steve lillywhite produced this, what an amazing drum sound he seemed to get.

  • i totally agree. even when you listen to generals and majors, from black sea too, it sounds a bit like girls and boys. today´s british pop musicians are standing over the shoulders of the beatles, xtc and david bowie...

  • i remember this song from 1984...love it still.

  • Sterotypes(Blur)has almost the same intro as this one! Blur was in many ways XTC over again. Love both bands off course!

  • Such a thumping start,i love this tune.Its a wonder Oasis havent ripped some of it ...

  • Hmm, I thought more Blur "Tracy Jacks" but yeah the simlarities are there! Both amazing bands!!

  • fantastic group..some of the most true lyrics out there

  • like how the song make a 360 degree turn and it all fits.

  • I always found the "edited for radio" version of the lyric to be the height of irony, considering it's a song lashing out at hypocritically conformist society.

    Great song though.

  • Even more sad than the fact that they aren't touring is that they aren't a band anymore!!!!

  • Awesome song! I never seen this video before, and I can't help but notice --it's got some different lyrics, and also when he goes "Sunday church and they look fetching", right as he says that, some kind of instrument(s) come on soaring.

    Thanks for posting!

  • I think the instruments over that line are just vocal harmony and a bit of keyboard, might be wrong. But it's a great effect!

    Simply adore this band!

  • these days, 70s Punks actually LOOK like that!

  • the best !!!!!!!!!!!!!! from bcn

  • This sucks ass....destroy it...I LOVE XTC, but this VERSION sucks.

  • XTC is better then any fucking thing you know of bitch

  • @alexsarus No way, you idiot!!!

  • Great song, I just wish it weren't the watered down version.

  • Simply brilliant!!

  • This song rocks so hard

  • puta el grupo culiao bueno, por las re chucha!!!

    La cagaron los huevones grossos...onofre?

    "Todo el mundo se limpia los pies en cualquier cosa que diga Bienvenido" (A. Partridge)...

  • One of my favorite XTC songs :D

  • "Rag & Bone Buffet," their Bsides and leftovers has the original, much more "retching" version of the song. A lot was edited out in this version. "And which sex position pleases her old man..."

  • Andy's typically brilliant insights.

  • love this song, saw it in a movie called "Ugh! a music war"

  • Actually, the movie was called "Urgh:A Music War."

  • Just a thought: is drumstick twirling an obligatory part of a drummer's repertoire?

  • Yes. It is much like a Mason's secret handshake.

  • Fantastic Song! The song sticks in my head for days every time I listen to it!

  • Great song..

  • pixies copied it. many *new* bands copied it. a shame.

  • ....Yeah, it's interesting (though not in a good way, i mean) how radio stations often have no problem playing a (often much worse) cover of a tune, but refuse to play the original....go figure....

  • love it! Beautifully, thrashy song, with a great melody. Love the juxtaposition of the band playing strings and wearing tuxes.

  • I hate to say this, but this is painful to watch (and I love XTC).

  • Cleaned up radio play version!

  • what old time

  • Thanx for all the XTC! Highlights for me are the clips from English Settlement which remains an all-time favorite.

  • "Absortion?"  I doubt it.

  • I worshippped this band, especially with hyper funky beats like this

  • Rock and Roll...... garage quirky rock

  • I remember living in an apartment in Reseda, California, 4th of July, 1981. Watched Wimbledon, took some acid, put my speakers on the balcony and blew out the neighbors windows with "Respectable Street" and the rest of "Black Sea." That was when KROQ was at its finest, too.

  • rocket from a bottle!yes!

  • farflungfarcry

  • interesting. just realized they changed 'sex position' to proposition in the video. i think they changed it on one of the compilation cd's too.

  • Classic Power Pop Anthum.

  • One of their best songs, imho

  • o.k. you have to stop ingesting anything remotely drug like, although i do agree we have to be a lot nicer to each other, and generally ignore things that get in the way of everyday life, especially any lind of religion, or fake philosophical system. are you listening america?

  • Kicks your butt.

  • Ummm, donuts, when this song came out, there WAS no hiphop. Not in the sense that you and I know it today, anyway.

    Fuckamericanidiot: yes, it is as dark as it sounds. XTC have always had a dark sarcasm about them, despite the sweet perfect pop sounds of their later albums. They rock. Full stop.

  • yes, espeically here with our "conspicuous consumerism" and the hypocracy of "keeping up with the jones". This is a very strong social commentary as we watch the various neighbors buy the newest biggest fanciest more expensive SUV or sony plasma tv or other gizmos

  • wow is that supposed to be as dark as it sounds to me? that was awesome. good as sgt rock. fuck yeah

  • Thanks!  If forced to pick just one XTC song, this is it.

  • def damn near impossible to pick just one, but this is right up there. I always liked rocket from a bottle too. it just always put a smile on my face while leaping about singing along.

  • does anyone happen to have jason & the argonauts from english settlement???? love XTC!

  • luv this band..saddest day when they stopped touring.

  • One of my favorite bands ever...this still sounds better than half the shit that comes out today!

  • Shame that the "company" forced them to censor the lyrics. By today's standards (esp with hip hop), the words "abortion", "wretching", "sex position" etc are pretty tame.

  • Unnecessary dig at Hip Hop.

  • Thanks to the gilmore girls, i'm now a big fan of XTC!

  • This came out in what? 1980? Yet the drum sounds kick the shit out of pretty much all modern drum sounds.

  • the drums

  • XTC..the drums always sound great!

  • Would someone tell me what those people are doing? Slamming the walls and kicking their legs up as if in a tantrum doesn't seem to have much connection with the Song lyrics. I'd love to know if they ever did the uncensored version of this, my favorite XTC song, in a video.

  • better than the Beatles! Easily!

  • The censored words are hilarious - "retching" turned into "stretching" - really? It totally corroborates the meaning of the song - I guess retching isn't respectable.

  • neither is (ahem) "stretching" --VULGAR! ;p

  • Arguably one of the best and certainly most consistent bands of recent times. Have loved them since statue of liberty. Still going strong, check out their website.

  • I am shocked that for this video they would overdub some of the lyrics and Andy Partridge let them. Oh well..interesting and my favourite band of all time!

    Can I get an AMEN!

  • I love XTC too... COLIN AND ANDY AND TERRY ARE SO FUCKING HOT AND SO FUNNY!!!!

  • Interesting concept for the video. Having never seen it until now, I always assumed the song was from the point of view of someone complaining about upper class busybodies. I guess ignorance knows no class distinctions, eh? LOL. XTC rules.

  • they always make great videos.

  • They cut the music hall intro.

  • This song brings a tear to my eye from it's awesomeness. Too bad this is the censored version. "Child prevention"? LOL, gimme a break!

  • i saw them live back in 1980 opening for The Cars. i think Black Sea was their best album.

  • "Now they talk about absorption" eh? Blimey, I bet that was an interesting conversation.

  • Has the best drum sound this side of "When the Levee Breaks" and "Moonlight Mile".

  • "Black Sea" was one of the XTC albums that was produced by Steve Lillywhite and engineered by Hugh Padgham (they also did "Drums and Wires", but Padgham produced and engineered "English Settlement"). Padgham went on to produce Phil Collins in that same era with that same huge, gated drum sound. Great songs, always. Bless Andy Partridge! "Travels in Nihilon" was always my favorite from this album, but ALL the songs have a special place in my heart and Terry Chambers really pounded them out.

  • Thanks for the info. Yes, yes I can hear it now. "In the Air Tonight" and "Respectable Street" are first cousins for sure (at least with the drum sound. End of comparison).

  • yeah, they were really at the top of their game, but if you look at their careers, Padgham and Lillywhite want on to produce some real blockbusters....and XTC never broke through to that gigantic worldwide audience like their other productions, it's a shame. But XTC has that core of rabid, devoted fans. If you can find it, get Andy's solo album from 1980 " Take Away", now collected into the CD "Explode Together" with the "Go+" EP.

  • Didn't even know Andy did a solo trip. Must have been b/w Black Sea and English Settlement. Thanks. Have you checked out Andy stumbling off stage in '82? I couldn't resist a pithy Spinal Tap comparison. And who cares that XTC weren't huge. To us, they are up with the Fab Four for non-stop quality album after album.

  • Yeah I saw that clip of Andy just yesterday...it's a sad reality of the history of the band that they stopped touring. I would have LOVED to have seen them live. The quality of their recorded output is right up there with the Beatles, for sure, I've been a big fan of them since '83. Even albums I didn't like at first, I grew to love. Even so, seeing these videos is a first for me--so been checking them all out. Very amazing band.

  • So true about the strange 'growing power' of XTCs albums. I bought 3-D EP (their first recording) and found it AMAZING. Ever since I have bought their albums and ALWAYS was deluded at first... only to capiyulate after a few spins. As a singer I LOVE to sing all the parts witha nother XTC fan called Davide (from Italy). We used to stay upo all night (he was a Night Porter in a Rome Hotel) singing Album after Album!!!

  • Yeah, I'm foaming at the mouth. Someone pass the salt please.

  • Very, very British, all of them. Yeah, they were at the top of their game. Padgham and Lillywhite produced some HUGE records, and XTC just never broke out to a huge audience...a shame. But they have rabid, rabit fans. A great, tough to find album was Andy's "Take Away" from this same era, which has been collected with the "GO+" EP into the compilation called "Explode Together"--pretty interesting stuff.

  • OOPS, I thought I lost it, and it don't post! sorry for the double comments, replying to my own comment, a metacommentary.

  • Interesting. Also, Lillywhite did extensive work with Peter Gabriel and Genesis. The Groove noise on "Respectable Street" is a copy from the Peter Gabriel song 'Intruder' on "III". Funny how they all intertwine like that.

  • or it could be the other way round as Dave Gregory played on that Peter Gabriel album - who's to say Gabriel didn't rip off XTC, when they were in the Townhouse studios at the same time?

  • 'In The Air Tonight' ripped off the drum sound of XTC. I'm glad you entered the info for Youtube fans of XTC. Thanks from Argentina!

  • yeaahhhhh!!!! this song rules!

  • god, i always loved XTC!

Loading...